Rather than supporting visual literacy and arts education, though, the ubiquity of the arts and visual forms can serve as a logical argument against it. If people are making art regardless of their education and economic stature then why should schools devote time and money teaching it? Why not just let art, design, and the understanding of it happen as it will? We are surrounded daily by pictures both informative and aesthetic in a vast number of forms, therefore visual literacy will come on its own, perhaps through experience or simply chance.
If this is considered a sound argument against teaching art, then it is equally logical to argue against teaching language. Kids can learn a language simply by growing up around people that speak it fluently. However, nobody has argued that we ought to let nature take its course and drop the study of English from our schools for the sake of saving money. We can appreciate how modern education improves the capability to read, write and speak effectively, yet schools do not give visual literacy the same consideration.
Skepticism concerning the feasibleness of art education is bound in the false notion that art cannot be taught. Talent is a gift, something that a number of people are simply born with, and art results from inspiration. Coinciding with these ideas is the concept that art appreciation is entirely subjective, a matter of however art makes the viewer feel. If these stereotypes were true, education could not do much for the development of creative people or their audience. Nor could it teach young minds how to make sense of the visual information they are subjected to on a near constant basis. The misconception lies in the idea that education consists exclusively in the transfer of information and ends there. Since art is not strictly propositional, it must not contain verifiable truths or facts, and since most art does not present any arguments, or at least in an easily recognizable fashion, it must not require justification. Works of art then have very little, if any, credible data to convey. “Construed as sources of information,” Mary Mothersill writes, “the arts create a poor showing; as a means of acquiring new truths about the world or the soul, they are in competition with science and with philosophy” (8).
While inspiration certainly figures in the creation of art, the idea that art is entirely a product of inspiration is unwarranted. Within the visual arts, students learn the powers and limitations of the various media available, as well as the effects of color, light, shade, shape, and form. Further, artists benefit greatly from studying art history. Even if creative talent is a genetic gift, education can foster and develop those creative skills and the level of critical thinking needed to use those skills effectively. Regardless of the fact that most people will never be artists in the traditional sense, and comparatively few people will even be serious amateur artists, we are all part of a greater audience. Audiences of the humanities do not consist entirely of cultural elite. They embody everyone who watches TV, goes to the movies, reads the news or uses the internet. Indeed we are bombarded with visual stimuli continuously. Information graphics are everywhere we look.
Visual literacy is worth it for its own sake, however it also provides a platform for understanding both of art and other matters as well. Through an education that includes visual literacy we can develop perspectives that allow us to raise questions that, without them, we might not have. It is also important to note that visual literacy and the arts in education can cultivate a demand for art that is economically essential. Data from the National Endowment for the Arts’ Survey of Public Participation in the Arts shows evidence of a chronic decline in the audience (Zakaras 27). Equally as worrying is the steady decline of young adult participation. As the authors of, Cultivating Demand for the Arts, Arts learning, Arts Engagement, and State Arts Policy declare, “declining demand leads to a loss of the public and private benefits derived from the arts” (27). While this trend may not be directly related to the attention given to visual literacy in the sphere of education it is interesting nonetheless that these downturns are seemingly simultaneous.
Works Cited
Dimitriadis, Greg, Emily Cole, and Adrienne Costello. "The Social Field(S) Of Arts Education Today: Living Vulnerability In Neo-Liberal Times." Discourse: Studies In The Cultural Politics Of Education30.4 (2009): 361-379. SocINDEX with Full Text. Web. 4 Apr. 2014.
Giorgis, Cyndi, and Nancy J. Johnson. "Children's Book: Visual Literacy." Reading Teacher 53.2 (1999): 146. Academic Search Complete. Web. 10 Apr. 2014.
Krauth, Kathy . "Visual Literacy: A Must for the 21st Century." Visual Literacy: A Must for the 21st Century. N.p., n.d. Web. 2 Apr. 2014. <http://ocw.mit.edu/ans7870/21f/21f.027/asia_rising/cur_teacher/ar_cur_intro.html>.
Mothersill, Mary. Beauty restored. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1984. Print
Washington, Booker T.. The Negro problem; a series of articles by representative American Negroes of to-day.. New York: AMS Press, 1970. Print.
Zakaras, Laura, and Julia Lowell. Cultivating Demand for the Arts, Arts learning, Arts engagement, and State Arts Policy. Santa Monica, CA: RAND Corp., 2008. Print.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
In this archive file of CGD 218 Entire Course you will find the next documents: CGD 218 Week 1 Assignment Why is Visual Literacy Important.doc…
- 427 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
This is a class in which we survey the history of Western art to chronicle the development of our mass media society. We will examine art monuments generally studied in art history classes (that is, paintings, sculptures, etc.), as well as photography, film, and video. The purpose of this class is to help you develop what is often called "visual literacy." This means the ability to "read" the images that surround you in our information society.…
- 2547 Words
- 11 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Distinctively visual images which can be seen, or perceived in the mind can shape the responder understanding of relationship with others plus the world around . The use of distinctively visual features has had a positive effect on my understanding of the novel Maestro by Peter Goldsworthy’s and the painting ‘starry starry night’ by Vincent van Gogh. This has been done through distinctively visual features such as descriptive and emotive language in Maestro and the use of colour, shading, lighting and placement in ‘starry starry night’.In saying this, this gives evidence as I do strongly agree with the statement ‘‘The visual image has a significant impact on the way the responder is positioned to react to a text’. This will be seen through…
- 1241 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Life without art is boring and dull. But often at times, art is a subject that is underestimated in schools. The art courses in many schools are being cut back across the country. Many classrooms now have little supplies, and some courses are being taken away entirely. There are many reasons to which students need the aspect of art education in their curriculum, whether it is because it is an outlet for them to explore their creativity, or to work in a way that is soothing and in a stress- free environment. Art should be a mandatory subject to be taught in elementary and middle school as a child is growing up, but cutting back on art programs in schools seems to be a common solution to budget cuts since the 1970s when budget cuts began. Fewer public schools are offering art classes, whether it is in drama, dance, or visual art. This decline is due to budget cuts and an increased focus on math, science, and reading. Unfortunately, art classes are the first to be cut from schools, because the arts aren’t taken as seriously as subjects such as math and science because the arts programs are the first to be cut. This is a major problem in education.…
- 1244 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
Throughout the world literacy and photography have inspired individuals by how they point their message across to the viewers. They have the power to attract and inspire others in how skillfully they write or in how they draw and take photos. In the article “Picture Imperfect” by Jed Perl, he explains photography is not one hundred percent accurate evidence for their spectators. Due to this, both literacy and photography connect to each other by depending on their audience for judgment. But in the other hand, the role of literacy exceeds the role of photography because it helps the audience target the final analysis in ways that pictures cannot as noted in the article “The New Literacy” by Clive Thompson. Before…
- 1196 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
· Under the Ch. 2 heading, click on Howling Wolf’s Treaty Signing at Medicine Creek Lodge…
- 173 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
In this article both ethical and logical appeal are used to explain why education should change and how there should be more liberal art education to advance student training to prepare them for the world they will face. Its understandable why colleges don’t offer liberal art courses; they can be very expensive to the school and kids these days are not attending these classes, however, there is plenty of evidence that shows the benefits…
- 913 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
My aim is for my learners to use non traditional methods to challenge preconceptions of drawing. This will be achieved by creating a paper cut-out that demonstrates drawing through new techniques, tools and processes to depict works of art from observation. The activity will create a fun environment, which will subsequently aid learning. This session will help me visually assess learner’s ability to work with equipment and to follow simple instructions. The outcome of this task and the ease in which learners approach the activity will enable me to gain an understanding of the learner’s practical skill capabilities. Equal opportunities are met by this activity and the method is not gender, ethical, moral or socially biased. The use of LSP’s will not be required for this task, though practical assistance will be offered to one learner to assist with her motor skills.…
- 298 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Literacy education primarily has been ruled by written language, which as a result has pushed the teaching of visual images and multimodal elements to the outskirts of the literacy curriculum. In today’s world it seems as though texts that focus primarily on written language are scarce in comparison to multimodal texts that include visual images and a variety of other design features. This is due to the rapid development in technology, which has impacted the way in which people communicate. Nowadays students are confronted with these sorts of texts more so than ever, which means that “continuing to view the world through linguistic and print-based sensibilities limits one’s experiences and narrows the forms of expression and interpretation…
- 1540 Words
- 7 Pages
Good Essays -
1. Although Howling Wolf’s drawing is seen as naively executed by the standards of Western art, why do we conclude that his record of the treaty signing event is more honest than the illustration rendered by the other artist?…
- 409 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
The most astonishing case of budget cuts is occuring in Boston where Thomas (2011) says, “the cuts are a part of a $171 million package that calls for eliminating the equivalent of 33.6 full time positions.”(p.1) These cuts amount to cutting out: 3rd grade recorder classes, 4th grade chorus classes, while changing the art classes from 60 minutes to 45 minutes. (Thomas, 2011, p.1) According to the Assistant Superintendent Joe Russo, this was “the only time all our students were exposed to a musical instrument, and some of them even learn to read music.”(Thomas, 2011,p.1) Patton (2011) brings to attention that this decline in art education in public schools has been happening for over a generation, (p.1) but…
- 1386 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
Hurley, Ryan. “Cuts in Art Programs Leave Sour Note in Schools.” Wisconsin Education Association Council. 24 Mar. 2013.…
- 1916 Words
- 8 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Although Howling Wolf’s drawing is seen as näively executed by the standards of Western art, why do we conclude that his record of the treaty signing event is more honest than the illustration rendered by John Taylor?…
- 361 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Smith, F. (2009). Why arts Education Is Crucial, and Who’s Doing It Best. www.edutopia.org. Retrieved from http://www.edutpoia.org/arts-music-curriculum-child-development.…
- 2759 Words
- 12 Pages
Powerful Essays -
In our book the definition of visual literacy is the competent creation and consumption of visual messages (Ryan, 2012). Which is a vague fairly vague definition compared to what Kennedy said. Kennedy really dives deep into the subject and drives home the importance of visual literacy. He has you close your eyes and then he asks you to name off some things that are in the room. I honestly couldn’t remember any of these things. It just goes to show you how important it is for us to see things. When we see things we generate assumptions about them, try to interpret them, and we add text to them. So visual literacy can go a long way for us.…
- 502 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays