Preview

Vouchers Vs Alternative Schools

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1061 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Vouchers Vs Alternative Schools
Why is there such a huge push and what does it mean for our education system? The revived debate over a vouchers and alternate schools of choice system has brought up old and some new questions. As before, rather than evidence both sides are making a lot of hyped up statements based on ideological or theoretical positions. There are several vouchers and alternate schools of choice systems up and running across the country. Although some of them have not been in place for long, we have enough data to gain an educated opinion. It is my opinion the use of vouchers and alternate schools of choice option can only lead to furthering the divide between the rich, and poor. The school of choice programs can leave gaps or shortages in enrollment and …show more content…
When competition is introduced into the market the players then preform at a higher level. The U.S. Secretary of Education, Betsy DeVos is the strongest advocate for the vouchers and alternate schools of choice system. She has given her own money in her home state before she became the secretary to help further the cause. (Maxwell) there is a strong belief that if given the freedom to choose the school a child attends, it will open educational opportunity never afforded to some of the children in our society. The voucher system works by giving each child a set amount to use towards tuition to any school they choose, opening the possibility for some children to attend private schools they would not have had the money to pay tuition on in the past. The other options would be; magnet, charter, …show more content…
Stated in a report from UCLA they found that charter schools have higher rates of racial segregation more often than traditional public schools, similar results were found in Minnesota and North Carolina . (www.the74million.org) There is also the argument these programs are unconstitutional by violating separation of church and state. “Per the U.S. Department of Education, 76 percent of private schools have a religious affiliation and 80 percent of students attending private schools are religious institutions.” Opponents often refer to some of media coming out on the success of these programs as a war on public education, sighting such works as “Waiting for Superman,” “The War on Kids,” “The Cartel” and “The Lottery.” (www.au.org) Teachers are concerned about the ability to protect their rights to organize as well, since most school of choice programs utilize non-union teachers. Often the opposition suggest, this may be part of the push, conservatives are not typically supportive to unionize. The opponents of the vouchers and alternate schools of choice systems are adamant in their opinion that the diversion of public education funds to private schools will not only detrimentally damage the public-school system, they strongly believe it is already creating

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    How were property owners reimbursed for properties that were cleared for urban renewal projects? Were the properties condemned and devalued or were they paid a fair market value? How much did these practices feed into white fears of living in integrated neighborhoods and the impact it would have on their housing values?…

    • 135 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Betsy Devos Summary

    • 259 Words
    • 2 Pages

    When asked whether or not schools which receive federal funding should be held equally accountable, DeVos stated that she “supported accountability” but ultimately said “no”. The appointment of Betsy DeVos to the position of secretary of education presents a threat to public schools and middle class families across the country. The rise of for-profit schools could put considerable economic strain on working and middle class families and could ultimately lead to a divide in quality education between those who can afford to send their children to for-profit schools and those who cannot. The lack of quality education for less wealthy students would potentially result in lower paying careers which would in turn prevent them from sending their children to higher quality, for-profit…

    • 259 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Betsy Devos Analysis

    • 267 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The anger that is shown towards this announcement is for the blatant disregard to learn our history and support national policy that will support and enhance our institutions. Evidence of this was shown in February when Betsy DeVos called HBCUs pioneers of “school choice”. She released a statement which said that HBCUs “started from the fact that there were too many students in America who did not have…

    • 267 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The income source for U.S. public schools came from taxpayers paying their property taxes and since a lot of the parents couldn’t afford this expense, public education was almost not available. Alabama also struggled to pay their teachers on top of the people unable to pay their property taxes. “Only 16 of 116 Alabama school systems paid teachers in full in 1932. In Winston County, teachers went an entire year without pay”. 5 The teachers had to choose to either loss their jobs completely or take a cut in their pay. Eventually, an agreement was made which led to “teachers receiving part of their pay in cash and the remainder in vouchers”.5 These vouchers were able to be used at local stores in their…

    • 1545 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    “Certain facets of a child’s outcome-- personality, for instance, or creativity-- are not easily measured by data. But school performance is”(158). The provided data in the chapter concern school choice, an issue that many people feel strongly about. Almost every parent believes that their children, if attending the right school, will thrive. With the Chicago Public School system, CPS for short, school choice came early. This is because it had a disproportionate number of minority students, like most urban school districts. Despite the ruling in Brown v. Board of Education of Topeka, “many black CPS students continued to attend schools that were nearly all-black”(158). In 1980, the Chicago Board of Education teamed up with the U.S Department of Justice to try to better integrate the schools in the city. “It was decreed that incoming freshmen could apply to virtually any high school in the district”(158). This act threatened to create bedlam. “The schools with good test scores and high graduation rates would be rapidly oversubscribed, making it impossible to satisfy every student’s request”(159). The CPS resorted to a lottery for fairness. It was a natural experiment on a grand scale. The data showed that school choice barely mattered at all. “It is true that the Chicago students who entered the school-choice lottery were more likely to graduate than the students who didn’t-- which seems to suggest that school choice…

    • 1237 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Charter schools are defined as an independent public school that operates independently of the district board of education. While traditional public schools are run by the school district. As the years have progressed charters have become more popular because people believe that they are more child-centered and provide more educational choices for the children. While people who oppose charter schools are against them because of various reasons such as: corrupt boards, segregation within the schools, etc.. Charter schools are said to give families opportunities to pick the school most suitable for their child the question. Families and the public are now more than ever expressing opinions on the education system and what they need for their…

    • 420 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The article “Charter Schools: How Charter Schools Can Hurt”, written by Lucinda Rosenfeld is an article about the negative impact of Charter Schools on the local public school institutions. Prior to No Child Left Behind (NCLB) there were public schools and private schools. Private schools included sectarian and non-sectarian institutions. Approximately twenty years ago, it was found that our public school system was failing drastically, and we were not servicing the children of this country to the best of our ability. Since that time, the idea of Charter Schools was created to facilitate parents who could choose to move their children from a failing public school to a thriving Charter School; which would be paid for with American tax dollars.…

    • 621 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Recently, attention has been given to plans for improving the public schools by allowing parents to choose where their children attend school through a school voucher system. The education voucher system exists when a government provides payment to families that allow their children to attend a private or public school of their choice. The payment is in the form of a voucher that can be given directly to the parents of the child, or indirectly to the school of choice. The purpose of the voucher systems is “to increase parental choice, promote competition and allow lower income families access to private education” (West 1997, p.83). The implementation of the voucher system would force poorly run schools and inadequate teachers to improve their…

    • 994 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Phi 105 Persuasive Essay

    • 1045 Words
    • 5 Pages

    You may be wondering what a charter schools is. According to The National Alliance for Public Charter Schools, charter schools are public schools that are independently operated and are given the ability to use innovative teaching in exchange for assured improved student achievement. A charter is formed by the work of a group of educators, parents, educational leaders, and others that come together and develop the school 's mission statement, guiding principles, governing body, and the measure for accountability. They then submit the proposal to the state for approval. If the charter is granted then there is an agreement made between the state and the school, and because of the charters autonomy there is a higher level of expectation imposed. Not only by the state, but also by themselves, and ultimately by the people as enrollment is based on their choice.…

    • 1045 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    On May 22, 2013 the largest closing of public schools, in history of the United States, occurred. The board of education of the Chicago Public Schools voted to close down 50 schools in the Chicago area (Bartlett). To no surprise, most of the schools if not all came from areas that had low-income neighborhoods consisting mainly of African Americans and Latinos on the south and west side of Chicago (Bartlett). Although the ex president George Bush said popular quote“ No child left behind”, what is happening in the Chicago Public schools is exactly the opposite. Even if every kid is given the opportunity to go to school some are being given a…

    • 2181 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The main issue with using this as an argument is, if you break down what a charter school is: a publicly funded, privately run school, is it doesn’t actually fit the description of what a neo-liberal program would be, specifically, the publicly funded part. Charter schools, as far as their present status is concerned, are an abomination that takes two separate ideologies and mixes them to form some sort of weird strawman to attack the new trend of neo-liberalization. Charter schools should not be considered neo-liberal the same way private schools are as a result of their inherent nature, and if someone were to seriously argue against neo-liberalization, they should argue against “absolute” private schools, as that has all the accoutrements of being neoliberal. Instead charter schools were chosen as a strawman to attack, when charter schools should not even be considered neo-liberal at…

    • 831 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Vouchers

    • 5245 Words
    • 21 Pages

    As of recently, much of the information and research regarding how voucher programs would affect urban school districts has been shrouded in the hyperbole and rhetoric of both the liberal union backed views, and the more radical free market conservative views such as those espoused by Milton Friedman. In truth, I believe there is ample room in the middle to find compromise on just how to make vouchers feasible for economically disadvantaged children. The recent results of numerous studies based on vouchers programs conducted in inner city school districts would tend to bear this notion out. However, there is more to the issue than simply deciding that vouchers are a good and positive step in the right direction. There is a need to understand why the inner city schools are faced with the problems they now have and what the reasons are for these problems.…

    • 5245 Words
    • 21 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    School Vouchers

    • 2012 Words
    • 9 Pages

    What exactly is the great debate behind a school voucher offer for the use of private education and the positive offerings for the students that are able to take advantage? Schools are designated by the district that one lives in. Everyone knows that there are various areas such as high income and low income areas that make up the population of a city. Because of the school designation by district, many in lower income communities feel that children are short changed on education due to the belief the lower income area schools are not of the same caliber as the other area schools. Add in the equation of private schools and there is another distinct difference perceived in regard to public education versus the private education establishment.…

    • 2012 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    This is a major problem because public schools are being run at the lowest budget possible and dividing the money for charter and traditional schools means everyone is strapped for money. Many educators argue that it is not ethical to take money away from schools that are in need of programs that will benefit student achievement; while others argue that it is not ethical to make students attend failing schools. The infrastructure of charter schools will be different based on state…

    • 996 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    School Vouchers

    • 1809 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Publicly-funded education vouchers allow families to make private decisions regarding how public taxpayer money should be spent. Therefore, a voucher program hopes to create an educational market where schools must compete for students. Supporters claim market benefits, such as choice and innovation, will improve education. Opponents, on the other hand, say that vouchers will lead to greater inequality and the loss of civic preparation. Current evidence concerning the impact of vouchers is disputed (IBID.).…

    • 1809 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays