Preview

Was Dunkirk ‘A Miracle’ or ‘A Disaster’?

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
496 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Was Dunkirk ‘A Miracle’ or ‘A Disaster’?
Was Dunkirk ‘A Miracle’ or ‘A Disaster’?

In this following essay I will be discussing the different views and military tactics used for evacuating both French and English soldiers from Dunkirk. I hope to show both positive and negative views using sources and other sorts of information such as, newspaper articles and speeches. By using these I can portray a comparison in which is fair for both opinions but also that each source is reliable so both sides of the argument will be compared reasonably. I will be explaining in tremendous detail and also adding a conclusion about my opinion on this World War 2 mystery.
Dunkirk was called an amazing military exploit by many people, in this paragraph I will be presenting the positive aspects of the evacuation at Dunkirk. Source A, Movietone news June 1940. This news film was shown in cinemas throughout Britain. It describes how British and French soldiers were rescued at Dunkirk. This source is very positive towards the evacuation; it uses phrases and information about Dunkirk to make the audience describe it as a positive military tactic. One of the phrases used was amazing military exploit; this phrase compliments the British’s military tactics and compliments the army as well as the Prime Minister. They also used refreshing this infers that they were all fed properly and the food was in fact quite pleasant. As well as that they also used epic this phrase enlarges the success of the evacuation from Dunkirk and how life changing it was to so many soldiers and there families. In addition to that they had also called the French and British troops gallant this showed how brave they were in a situation which put there lives in danger. The final phrase which I will explain is dramatic, this word was used to make the whole situation seem very large and also a occurrence that would stay in history forever. As well as phrases information of the day was also used to describe how great the evacuation was conducted. The first

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    A predilection for the high drama of war stories and an appreciation for history as narrative led me explore Barbara W. Tuchman’s The Guns of August , a dramatic, comprehensive and painstakingly detailed account of the beginnings of World War One. Having read her history of fourteenth century Europe, A Distant Mirror, I was eager to see how she would apply her style of taking important individuals of the period and showing how events unfolded through the prism of their experiences, to the subject of the First World War. Moreover, the period is one in which I have long been interested, having been introduced to it through the World War One poets, T. S. Elliot’s The Wasteland and All Quiet on the Western Front. The very individual tragedy of this war and the one it engendered a generation later was brought home to me when I lived in France and saw the village memorials and the plaques in Paris commemorating the spots where a civilian had been dragged out and “fusillé par les Allemands,” (shot by the Germans.) Finally, the fact that nearly a century later we are still grappling with war and the world that arose out of 1914 gave immediacy and poignancy to the reading of this book exactly ninety years since the events it records took place. The Guns of August is a military history of the first month of the First World War written by a self-taught scholar and physician’s wife who combined raising three daughters and writing her first books. The Guns of August, which received a Pulitzer Prize in 1962, cemented her reputation in the field of history. Tuchman was a traditional historian who depended on facts scoured painstakingly from a plethora of primary and secondary sources and who wove a gripping narrative from the interplay of these facts, an exploration of the role of individuals, and a consideration of the complex motivations which may have led them to take the actions they did. Rather than imposing her own loose…

    • 2668 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    • As this text is very over the top, with the dialogue used to get the soldiers in the mood for war, it is appropriate that a hyperbole is used, by the over the top sergeant.…

    • 1854 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    “All Quiet in the Western Front” is a social commentary on how soldiers are effected emotionally and socially throughout the war and are conflicted on how to readjust to their lives after the Great War. Soldiers are conflicted by their character and do not know whether to pick back life up as a youth or as adults who have endured hard circumstances. The book does not focus on battles and it does not focus on a specific time frame, it rather evaluates what goes through the minds of a soldier. These men are literally being bombarded in the war front by explosives and in the home front by misinformed public who want to know the extremity of the war. Bystanders set High expectations for soldiers to be tough and to know how to behave in order to survive, yet those who did not participate in the Great War could only speculate what was going on in the soldier’s minds. The Great War damaged these soldiers physically and mentally, however certain elements gave the survivors the ability to pull through the war. The youth shifted its mentality and lost its innocence in the Great War. Therefore, Remarque did not focus his book on the combat that took place during the Great War, rather he presents social issues, which does not belittle his experience rather it presents a different view of the…

    • 1709 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Battle of the Somme took place during 1916 to take pressure off the French at Verdun and the Russians on the Eastern Front. The French were under heavy fire at Verdun and had been since February, and the army itself was close to cracking. The Russians had fought gallantly on the Eastern Front to try and avert the German Forces away from the Western Front. After launching many small offensives the Russians had gained very little ground for the amount of lives lost. This essay is going to explore; 1st Day of the Battle of the Somme, the Pals Battalions used during the Battle and the tactics developed after the Battle of the Somme was over. Each of these key areas contribute because the first day of the Battle of the Somme had the highest casualty rate the British Army had ever suffered, Pals Battalions were inexperienced in the art of battle, and the tactic used before the battle were inconclusive in helping with the battle overall.…

    • 1160 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Pros And Cons Of Dunkirk

    • 428 Words
    • 2 Pages

    I agree with the quotation above that “Dunkirk was a miracle of deliverance” because of the overwhelming evidence of the pros of the operation (codenamed Operation Dynamo). The first pro of the evacuation was that 338,226 soldiers…

    • 428 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The allies even though they were surrounded by the German army still fought back and resisted even after the Belgian army surrendered (May 28). The Germans bombed and destroyed most of Dunkirk and its surrounding areas as they were kept a distance by the allies who had set a perimeter that slightly kept falling back until they got to Dunkirk where they were evacuated. Many allied troops died keeping the Germans out of Dunkirk but all these sacrifices helped save the life of approximately 338,000 men all these troops were saved in the span of 11 days, the Germans may have taken over Dunkirk but many allied troops were able to live another day and the evacuation also saved the British many soldiers who were able to fight another day. The battle of Dunkirk was important in WW2 because had the Germans sealed off and killed all those troops that were evacuated the whole momentum of the western front war would have gone to Germany. The Dunkirk evacuations moralized the British army as they didn’t suffer major defeat and were able to save the life’s of a lot of men. Had Germany killed all those men the outcome of the war on the…

    • 1010 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Erich Maria Remarque’s original 1928 novel, turned movie, All Quiet on The Western Front, is very useful in helping to understand the many social and cultural difficulties soldiers faced in WW1 during the period of 1914-1918. One could argue that the given film is reliable, but being a secondary source this is arguable. AQOTWF exhibits the saviour physical, and mental stress German soldiers of World War 1 encountered, and the raw emotional detachment from civilian life displayed by many on returning home from the front. The film has a strong connection and relation to many poems, letters and images received and taken right from the Western Front itself and is very useful in helping viewers to grasp unique insight of physically commencing in battle, living conditions, and rare friendships formed in such harsh, dreadful conditions.…

    • 1089 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Long Way Home Summary

    • 749 Words
    • 3 Pages

    These soldiers were considered “Americans”, even though they were immigrants at one point; they fought for their new home, and citizenship. Coming to America from a foreign country may be difficult, yet it was worth it, for these immigrants; because they can have a better life than their original hometown. These twelve men made it to America for one main reason, and they worked diligently in order to meet their desired needs. It is important to recognize these stories, about how these people sacrificed themselves through the difficulties they were facing, such as their journey to America and the Great War. In the end, their hard work was paid of, and it is considered a major key to success. A common enthusiast of the world wars, or more specifically, the first world war will take great interest in this monograph, because of the provided information over the soldiers who fought these battles and their experiences leading to…

    • 749 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout history, war has been constantly evolving. Over time, it has taken a new less glorious form. World War One was one of the most devastating and transformative events in human history. In Erich Maria Remarque’s book, All Quiet on the Western Front, he depicts the horrors of “the great war” by showing the complete disregard for human life in modern warfare. This war modeled the way that any future war would be fought. It would shape human history by completely changing the game of warfare and people’s opinions of it. Remarque shows, from his point of view, the terrors that happen on a daily basis on the front lines, and away from it, of World War One. World War One changed the perception of war in a big way and opened the eyes of so many people to the horrors of modern warfare.…

    • 484 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    "why did the Allies win?" For Overy, to ask such a question is to presuppose that there was nothing pre-ordained about Allied success (Overy pg 1). To understand the Allied victory, Overy asserts that we must realize that explanations of resources, technology, of fighting men, are not enough on their own to explain victory. The moral dimension to warfare, he asserts, is inseparable from any understanding of the outcome. The role of human agency is extensive. With this…

    • 933 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Fatigue. Explosions. Blood. Guts. Death. These are only a few of the horrid images that the World War I soldiers endeavoured. Serving in war is not for the faint of heart or those considered not able to stomach the sight of gore and dead bodies every step. In the story, All Quiet on the Western Front written by Erich Maria Remarque, this story depicts these exact horrors during Remarque’s time spent on the German battlefront. Deaths are of the norm. Soldiers become immune to the smell of rotting bodies and bits and pieces of flesh everywhere. Although comradery is a positive aspect of war, corruption and lost youth outweigh comradeship, therefore making war a negative circumstance.…

    • 1317 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In 1916 witnessed the commencement of the battle of the Somme. Through the course of that one battle, a million British men were slaughtered compared to the combined number of American casualties in both the first and Second World War. The Battle of the Somme was planned as a joint French and British operation, approved by Haig. However, the German attack on Verdun in February 1916 turned the Somme offensive into a large-scale British attack. Haig accepted responsibility for the action and with the help of Rawlinson who devised his own plan of attack. The vital part of Haig's strategy was an eight-day attack to destroy the German defenses. Soldiers were lined up according to battlefield strategies, and led by major officers. The blood of the nations was poured into conditions of such horror and violence. “Lions led by donkeys”, was how the German soldiers referred to their British counterpart. Ever since the end of WW1 in 1918 which was won by the British allies against the Germans it has been hugely debated whether the phrase 'Lions Led by Donkeys' is correct. In this essay I am going to talk about the extent of which the phrase was a fair description of what had happened at the battle of the Somme, by looking at different people’s point of view about General Haig.…

    • 1645 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    [8] H.R. Kedward, Occupied France: Collaboration and Resistance 1940-1944, (Oxford:Blackwell Publishers Ltd 1985), p. 34.…

    • 2547 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    history coursework

    • 3423 Words
    • 14 Pages

    The five sources that I have selected to help with my enquiry are photographs, an extract from a newspaper article and a soldier's diary. The reasons why I chose these five particular sources is because I believe that they are a wide variety of selections, dating back to many years, all ranging from the start of the war to the end of the war. However, one of my sources, the newspaper article, was published in 2008 so it is more of a recent source but still, very useful and effective.From my own knowledge I know the trenches were inhumane and were infected with diseases which led to 1.2 million men who were registered physically and/or mentally disabled.These sources are quite important because each source shows pictures and texts of what was like in the trenches and the difficulty of living in the trenches. I believe that the sources are useful as a historical; some more than others e.g.; a photograph is more reliable than a newspaper article. In my opinion one of the strengths of these sources are their reliability and the useful contexts and information that they include. One of the limitation were that they only included either a physical or mental view and did not include both perspectives and experiences.…

    • 3423 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    When reading a book it is very important to read between the lines, to catch the hidden meanings and metaphors that lie within its pages. " A Separate Peace " is no exception as it is filled with metaphors which give the novel a concealed meaning and teach the reader about many things including the immense impact of World War II on people of the era. This essay will identify and explore some of them in order to further understand John Knowles' novel and the message he wanted to get across. Finny's Clothes, The Winter Carnival, Blitzball, and The Tree are all adequate examples of metaphors in this tale as they all have double meanings that bring the reader into a whole new world, one filled with mystery and wonder. Metaphors play an amazingly important role in this novel as they transform it from a plain story into a complex one, where simple things represent a greater, intricate reality.…

    • 996 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays