Preview

Was The French Revolution Worth The American Revolution?

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
607 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Was The French Revolution Worth The American Revolution?
For decades people have asked are revolutions really worth all the trouble it cause sand there have been many arguments from both sides of it. On one side revolutions have brought about great new countries into the world that would have never existed if no one had spoken up. However on the other the situations that were dealt with during these revolts make a person question was it really worth all of that hardship. These revolutions can take a toll on the populations of countries with thousands of innocent citizens dying on both sides. During the Revolutionary War the conditions that the colonists suffered were almost intolerable for both the patriots and loyalists. In the beginning many who were loyal to the British were abused by the patriots having been tarred and feathered in extreme cases. However it was not just the British side that suffered greatly, after the colonists declared their independence they became miserable for troops especially during the winter at Valley Forge. During their time spent here they had an ill equipped and under fed army that was struggling to get be. The amount of deaths and casualties had way exceeded the amount especially of a smaller nation, which was a huge price to pay when it came to starting a uprising. …show more content…
Even though this revolution started in a similar fashion it was much more brutal from the start with all the ways the ways anti-revolutionists and aristocrats were tortured and murdered. Also many peasants revolted against the nobles and landlords of France. Lastly the revolution continued for such a long time because of the chaotic-ness of the situation and how for several years the new governments were so unstable that they fell or turned into what they revolted from in the first place. The state of how this war went about was almost

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Britain's taxation on the American colonists greatly affected the relationship between the two nations. Moreover, the colonists were not being represented. The feeling of deprivation not only angered the Americans, but may have also opened their eyes to see the need of a revolutionary movement.…

    • 612 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    British treat American unfairly, according to the movie "The Patriot" all three sons died in under deserved death. Ones of them died just because of saving his brother from being capture by the British and he got kill on one shot. Also during the movie they mention that the British brings Colonies to the church and burn them to death. It not fair for them, and everyone have a tolerance. So that the reason why war be a savior of American spirit, save them from suffer, save them from being underestimate, and help being their own country. American Revolution happen to encounter that they are deserve to gain right and freedom to govern their own independent…

    • 390 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    When the American colonies were under British control, many people realized how unfairly they were being treated. Colonists had no say in any of Parliament’s decisions. While some colonists were very upset about this, others simply sat back remained loyal to the king. These people were known as Loyalists. The colonists who became fired up when their rights were taken away were called Patriots. Since they fought for freedom, glory, and the end of colonies’ suffering, colonists should have joined the Patriot side.…

    • 691 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The taxation and regulation added to the resentment that the colonies felt towards Britain due to laws like the Proclamation of 1763. The French and Indian War made soldiers realize that they had less liberty than Englishmen. A Massachusetts soldier wrote, “…and though we be Englishmen born, we are debarred [denied] Englishmen’s liberty.” (Document D) The Americans’ growing resentment helped cause the colonial rebellion that would erupt in a short while.…

    • 488 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The French were important in the American Revolution because they formed alliances with the American, and with great ideas, were those who helped to defeat the British. France and England had their antecedents; therefore the role that I played France was great motivation to fight with those with whom they had been fighting time ago. To say that the Americans could not have been without the French is something uncertain because the facts were others and the only way to know is if it had been without the help of France. I think that the fact of the union in the confrontation was what gave an impulse to the arrival of success. In the Franco-Indian War, France was responsible for helping the American Revolution with the help of the British in the…

    • 136 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The French and Indian War undoubtedly created new tension in the colonies. After the conflict had finished, the colonist’s independent attitudes surfaced. Many had grown tired of British insults and being looked down on by the mother country. After the war, Britain’s debt was immense. The mother country’s solution was to impose taxes upon the colonists to erase the debt, seeing as the war was most beneficial to them. This new responsibility was not welcomed by the colonists who, with their new sense of unity, found a common resentment towards England. Along with the resentment, colonists saw no reason for British occupation to continue because the French threat was no longer present. This was the spark the ignited the fight for independence.…

    • 635 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The French and Indian War was perhaps the first event that cracked the door open to the American Revolution. For the first time, the very different colonies had been forced to work together to defeat a common opponent. In addition, the war was soon entirely under British command and orders were issued to the colonists. When recruitment in the colonies slowed the British commanders begin forcibly enlisting the colonists. Officers seized supplies from local civilians and took shelter in their homes, usually without compensation. The conflict created over these British requisition and impressments policies confirmed for many Americans the British had no place in local affairs. Resentment of the British toward the colonists also began to mount due to the their military incompetence, the selling of food and goods to the French by some colonial merchants, and, most of all, their lack of contribution to the high costs of the war the British felt was largely for colonial benefit. Many English leaders began to think it necessary to tighten the reigns on the colonists and reorganize the empire after the war. The costs of the war were exorbitant; estimated to be around two and a half million pounds. Even after…

    • 1880 Words
    • 54 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The French Revolution and the American Revolution have many similarities and many differences. One important similarity was that they both had an emphasis on Enlightenment ideas such as liberty, freedom, and the rights of citizens. The Enlightenment began in France and identifies with writers such as Voltaire who wrote about inequality, injustice, and superstition, and Rousseau who believed that people are good in their natural state but are corrupted by the evils of society. Such ideas caused those under higher power or monarchies to begin to recognize the inequality that have been given to them. People of all classes, especially those in the middle and lower classes, began to form a resistance and insisted on new measures to be taken that…

    • 173 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The American and the French revolution are similar and different in many ways. The only huge difference between the two revolutions was the outcome of them. The outcome for America was that we were able to gain our independence and was free from their own ruler and was able to make their own choices. While in the French revolution they destroyed the king, they still had another leader to take control and rule them. They still didn’t have their freedom like America did.…

    • 143 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The American and French revolutions both not only affected their own countries, but the whole world. Many other countries and colonies drew inspiration from these revolutions, especially in South America. There were a series of revolutions in South America of different colonies wanting to gain independence from Spain and France. One of these revolutions occurred in Venezuela. The Venezuelan Revolution was very inspired by the events that took place during the American Revolution.…

    • 196 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The American Revolution depending on the viewer can be seen as a revolution or as an accelerated evolution. Compared to the French or Russian Revolution the American Revolution did not radically change much around the colonies. Some parts, of the Revolution though can be considered completely revolutionary while other parts were not so much. Politically, the American government was changed from the British ruling monarchy to a democracy within a totality of about 8 years (1775-1783). Eight years would be considered a swift transformation when looking at the age of the nation. Substantial local control though came into question after this transformation and America for a while had a weak central government under the Articles of Confederation. Independence from Britain led many individuals in the pursuit for equality and it took a totality of 89 years after the Battle of Yorktown until poor white men had a federal right to vote. This was mainly due to the property-holding requirements for voting. Once the proclamation of 1763 was revoked though, white men, rich and poor alike had an opportunity to gain land. Women, having no such opportunity such as this, had to wait 139 years until they obtained a federal right to vote. Looking at it from this aspect the revolution wasn’t very swift politically. Religiously a fight for the separation between church and state resulted in significant gains. The Congregational Church was attached to the state in most New England colonies. The hardest “divorce” of the church from the state was in Virginia, 1786. Jefferson and his co-reformers, the Baptists, fought for this eventually won passing the Virginia Statue of Religious Freedom in 1786. The policy of “free exercise” of religion under the First Amendment was passed soon after, in 1791. This was a slight radical change in that there was no more dominance of the Anglican Church in the colonies, though a lot of colonies were somewhat already religiously tolerant. Economically,…

    • 506 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Revolutions are mainly the product of the people seeking to better their lives. Many governments throughout the world are very corruptive. When it comes to corruption, the power is all in the government and citizens don’t have a voice and choice. In most cases corruption is the main…

    • 391 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The struggle of the French Revolution can be viewed, as any revolution can be, through the many eyes, of the people who are fighting it. They are fighting for reasons that vary according to what they believe as individuals, “Despite occasional appearances or stated war aims, the war became an ideological conflict between new and old –between “democratic” and “aristocratic” forms of society…” The war was a meeting of the minds, yes there was famine, and an unskilled monarchy, but the problems went well beyond this. France had not been living up to its full potential, nor was it using all of its resources to benefit its citizens. By the time Louis XVI came into power, he was ruling an already sinking ship. His circumstances and inexperience…

    • 1300 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The French Revolution is known because of the struggles France has on that time. Injustices they had were not good. King Louis spent half of the budget of federal service and that quickly led them in to bankruptcy. This was not a good year for France so they start to raise the prices of food and people going hungry, so that is one of the reasons they went into a revolution. New traditions were implemented during all that, government change from monarchy, and new economic was crated. Even though there were many up and downs in France definitely the French Revolution was a success because Enlightenment were part of the good changes in…

    • 114 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    ----------------------- Venkateshwar international school Name : …………… …………. Class : ……… …….…

    • 313 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays