Preview

Welfare and Drug testing; Unconstitutional?

Satisfactory Essays
Open Document
Open Document
471 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Welfare and Drug testing; Unconstitutional?
Jesse Fortiz
Wrt 101

Drug Testing for welfare; unconstitutional?

Should welfare recipients be drug tested in order for them to receive their food stamps or government assisted checks? With hopefully your answer being yes, many people in the United states believe the thought of forcing a drug test on a person applying for welfare to be completely unconstitutional. There are currently 12,800, 000 Americans on welfare in the United States today. The United States of America currently spends 131.9 billion dollars a year annually on welfare recipients. Yes, those are actual numbers based on a study of the department of commerce. With numbers like that, it’s no surprise the government financial system is the way it is today. The question is, should welfare recipients be randomly drug tested on order for them to receive their government assisted checks and food stamps? And is the thought of random drug testing unconstitutional? My answer and my honest opinion about the subject is that I believe it is perfectly fine to drug test welfare recipients in order for them to receive their government assisted checks. Do I believe that this is constitutional? Yes, yes I do. The reason being is that why should any other hard working American go through a drug screening in order to work and receive his or her hard earned check. As of today in 48 states, there is no law stating that welfare recipients should be subject to drug testing. It’s plain and simple, if a person can afford drugs on a regular basis, why should that person get free money? Some people feel that drug testing recipients is unconstitutional, and that is strips people of their rights. I believe in order for people to get help, they should comply with the rules and regulations to get the benefits of welfare. If that’s a problem for some people, there is no one forcing them to apply and get help. Florida and Utah are the first states to actually test recipients to see if those who are

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    The electronic reserve reading that I read was the one about the judge stalling Michigan's drug testing program for welfare applicants. I agree the decision on making people that are applying for welfare take and pass a drug test. The reason why I agree with this decision is because a lot of people that are receiving welfare benefits stop trying to do better once they start getting the benefits. I feel like they get comfortable and start only depending on welfare. A lot of these people probably are doing some kind of drug and cannot pass a drug test so they do not even try to go out and search for a job. I look around and most of the people that…

    • 293 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Whether or not a drug test is required by recipients of welfare has been questioned time and time again by many states. In the article "No drug test, no welfare", Kimberly Yee expands upon on this question by explaining what her stand point is on the many advantages of drug testing for welfare. In this particular article, Ms. Yee does not sufficiently argue her position on the subject of welfare recipients taking drug test to receive benefits.…

    • 527 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Ok, let's all look at this as realistically as we can; if just 1 person failed a drug test for the welfare, that's a whole extra few hundred dollars per month that our government can save, and that's only for 1 person! A typical drug test cost around $10 for the cheaper ones. That's store price too, that's not considering what government contracter bulk…

    • 501 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Florida Governor Rick Scott made plans to test all welfare recipients to see if they are using drugs before they can receive payments is hardly saving the state any money, according to recent reports. At $30 per test, the state paid $28,800 in drug test reimbursements (960 reimbursements at $30 each, since about 2 percent also didn’t finish the application process) for those who did pass, while saving themselves about $66,000 in payments that did not have to be made for the year to those applicants that didn’t make it through for one reason or another (applicants receive $138 a month, or $1,656 per year).…

    • 493 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Isn't it ironic in our society today, that individuals are administered drug testing if they want to bring home a paycheck in efforts to provide a roof over their head, clothes on their back, and food in their mouth? At the same time it's not required by another individual who is requesting government assistance in their efforts to receive the exact same things? You could argue that the individuals applying for those jobs are not personally obligated in any way to subject themselves to undergo any drug-testing. However, those same individuals would likely be overlooked for any consideration of employment due to failure of meeting the companies drug-free policy. So why aren't welfare recipients required to undergo drug-testing in order to receive any government assistance?…

    • 498 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    References: Walterss, J. (2012, March 13) Should Welfare Recipients Be Drug Tested? Governing: The States and Localities. Retrieved from: http://www.governing.com/topics/health-human-services/testing-welfare-recipients-drugs.html…

    • 566 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    There is much debate regarding this issue. Supporters of requiring drug tests for welfare applicants believe that there will be many people deterred from applying due to knowing they will not pass. They also believe that some will fail the drug tests. These supporters believe this number of people will be so large that there will be a significant decrease in welfare spending. Other supporters have said “substance abuse is a prominent barrier preventing people from making the necessary transition from governmental dependence to self-reliance.”(Targeted News Service) Opponents have said this is a direct violation of our constitutional rights as American citizens. Some have even said it is not right to assume that just because people are poor, they drug users. Other opposers of welfare drug testing have argued that it will not save money at…

    • 1822 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    We live in an age of laziness, and by that I mean people take the easy way out more often than they should. Now that being said, finding the easy way to do something is not always a bad thing. The case of Americans fraudulently receiving welfare checks is an example of the laziness I am discussing. As a society, we need to make this accepted practice an unaccepted practice. We need to stand up and make the process of applying and receiving these benefits more stringent than they currently are. I believe through use of mandatory random drug testing, progress monitoring, on- going physical and mental examinations, we can discourage the continued misuse of these funds.…

    • 704 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Drug testing welfare recipients has been a major topic across the United States for a few years now. Many argue that if working class people are subject to a test prior to hire or randomly during the length of employment, why should those that don’t have to work for money not have the same treatment? Invasion of privacy is a huge disadvantage on the government’s part, yes it is free money but that doesn’t entitle anyone, even government, to control every aspect of your life or hold it constantly over a person’s head until they feel guilt or just flat decline assistance. Let’s ask ourselves just one question; if you went to the bank for a car loan, being this is a necessity for everyday living to own, how would you feel if they asked you to take a drug test prior to lending you the money? I feel many peoples’ tune would change drastically.…

    • 1433 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The need for welfare among society today has become increasingly large. Although the need for welfare is rapidly increasing, so is the use of drugs. This is posing as a major problem for the welfare programs. Welfare programs are now trying to put into place a new qualification where any possible recipients of welfare are required to take a drug test. For the most part, welfare recipients respect the requirements of their contract with the agency. The drug testing will just be used to eliminate any persons taking advantage of the welfare program for inappropriate use and to ensure that the welfare will go to the people who are actually in need of it. While many are more than willing to take the drug tests, there are also quite a few who are very reluctant toward this new qualification. In order to decide whether or not drug testing is a logical and fair requirement, all the pros and cons need to be laid out on the table.…

    • 1226 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    United States lawmakers face one of the most pressing issues of our time-welfare reform. New screening processes, often considered a direct violation of constitutional rights, have already been enacted in many states. Strong evidence exists, asserting that the practice of administering drug testing to welfare recipients will cost the U.S. taxpayers more money in the long run, stigmatize applicants and participants, and serve only the purpose of making the pharmaceutical companies more powerful. In order to protect the constitutional rights of potential welfare recipients, United States lawmakers should avoid further criminalizing the poor by submitting them to drug testing and/or a nationwide welfare registry.…

    • 1695 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The uprising of unemployment and welfare is exceeding previous predictions and not many states are keeping up with them. Drug testing for welfare is unconstitutional and unfair because not everyone abuses the system. Not everyone uses the money they get for drugs. Some families really need the money while others use it for their own selfish needs instead of the needs of their families. Drug testing only leads to spending more money than its worth. An editorial in a USA Today article took a hard look at the recent push to drug-test applicants for public assistance across the country. They agreed that, "Until states can come up with a smarter way to ferret out the abusers while protecting children, the testing craze will be just another program that appeals to stereotypes in hard economic times while producing little value in the real world." As USA Today argues, there 's little evidence that programs to drug-test applicants and recipients of benefits are necessary in places where these programs have been implemented, few people have tested positive. And if the goal is to save states money, they fail on that count too states save very little compared to the upfront costs of implementing testing programs. Not to mention, these programs perpetuate the inaccurate notion that poor people use drugs more than others and single them out for unconstitutional privacy violations. Sadly about 20 states have implemented drug testing for welfare but they are gradually realizing how wasteful and unfair it really is so they are starting to take away the tests.…

    • 656 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    No, I do not think that welfare recipients should have to be drug tested in order to receive assistance. People that are for drug testing welfare recipients feel like it is not fair that they have to be drug tested in order to maintain a job but people receiving “free money” don’t have to be tested. I feel like they need to think beyond the fairness and think about more important things. It is unconstitutional, could cause children to suffer, and it will cost tax payers even more money.…

    • 698 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Should people who want welfare be required to take a drug test? People say the fourth amendment protects them because it states “ unreasonable searches and seizures.” Welfare drug testing is a common way to make sure taxpayer dollars are used responsibly. People who have to pay for other people’s welfare because they can go into work disagree with people who even have to think twice about drug testing being required to receive welfare. Taxpayers who pay on welfare think the government is responsible to make sure that their money is being used correctly and to make sure that drug users don’t receive any funds from the state. Why should we support their drug use, if you want drugs you should be able to pay for your own needs. We shouldn’t support basically feeding into their drugs use and letting them slowly kill themselves. Instead we should provide rehabs and hospital treatments. We don’t need to lock the addict up we need to get them help because they’re cable of so much more than what their setting their mindset do. They’re putting a limit to their goals and success in life. You can do…

    • 1019 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In conclusion, welfare drug testing is a waste because millions and billions of dollars are wasted each time they buy an expensive test. Many people are mad because this shouldn’t be happening, and because it isn’t right for lazy people to get away with everything. There is also people who actually do things the right way. It isn’t good for people to do the tests. However it does and does not make a change. It can save us some great money that we all…

    • 723 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics