Preview

What roles did religion and nationalism play in the Belgian Revolution of 1830

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1156 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
What roles did religion and nationalism play in the Belgian Revolution of 1830
What roles did religion and nationalism play in the Belgian Revolution of 1830?
Nergiz De Baere
FYE: Legacy of the Mediterranean
Sonam Singh

In world politics, Belgium is not a powerful player. It does not have a major army and its divided government is, at the moment, unable to make important decisions regarding its own country, That being said, its geographical location has made sure that Belgium was not ignored in history, and it now hosts EU and NATO headquarters. Division of cultures and conflict is deep-rooted in Belgian history and culture, leading back to a tug of war between France and the Netherlands where Belgium was caught in the middle. Fundamental differences - such as religion - between the French and the Dutch disgruntled the Belgians, and the indecisive strife between all three countries led to increases in nationalistic sentiment in Belgium. A fateful showing of Daniel Auber’s La Muette de Portici on 25th August 1830 in Brussels led to a revolution, which then caused the establishment of Belgium as an independent state. This paper will demonstrate that in the Belgian Revolution of 1830, Belgians’ motivation to revolt against the Netherlands was unduly influenced by nationalism, and less so by religion.
Events leading up to the Revolution
The tug of war mentioned earlier was not a novel concept for Belgians. The small country was always a part of a larger empire such as the Carolingian Empire in 800 A.D. (Cook 5) or divided up and given to other surrounding countries. Its location in Europe, along with its potent and fertile marshlands ensured that many a conqueror was attracted to the region. It was under the rule of Julius Caesar in 50 B.C. and then went on to become a Roman province. It is safe to say that Belgian rulers have suffered for centuries at the hands of their more powerful and domineering neighbours. Perhaps the most gruesome of the occupations was that of the Spanish Crown, which caused Belgium and other surrounding areas to be

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Chapter 13 covers Europe’s social and political order from 1600-1715. In the early century, inflation was such that prices were four times what they had been between 1525 and 1550. Three great powers contested for dominance – the Ottoman Empire, the Spanish Empire, and France, under Louis XIV and Richelieu. Each had a mass of about 17 million people. In spite of the presence of these great monarchies, there were still areas all over Europe from southern Italy to Scandinavia and from Scotland to Auvergne where primitive social enclaves persisted, with hundreds of dialects and local, semi barbaric, religious cults. Attempted control of these numerous pockets sapped the resources of the great powers, similar to the drain on the Roman Empire when it was ringed with…

    • 585 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In 1564, the Netherlands saw the first fusion of political and religious opposition to Regent Margaret’s government.…

    • 2423 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In contrast to the latter’s long tradition of expansionism and territorialism, the Dutch Republic came into existence in the late 16th century, a loose federation of provinces that had escaped from Spanish domination. What drove the Dutch into overseas ventures was not the prospect of expanding their land holdings and claiming sovereignty in other lands, but the promise of lucrative trade that would allow the Dutch to hold onto their precarious autonomy. With England, trade with the natives was less important than the establishment of territorial claims. This required the subjugation of the natives which was justified by the superior civil-inferior savage belief. In comparison, Dutch economic policy did not require the large-scale conquest of territory; in fact, it may have mollified their claims to superiority so long as a commercial relationship was being…

    • 3780 Words
    • 16 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Dbq Flemings and Walloons

    • 760 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The first controversy between the Flemings and Walloons was political tension. After the Belgian Revolution in 1830, the new nation of Belgium had to come to terms in context of political leaders, but the dispute between the Flemings and Walloons was so strong that no political settlement could be officiated. In Document 2, an American diplomat speaks about the history of Flemings and Walloons, stating that Walloons are impatient politicians and deny tradition, while Flemings feel strong nationality and are better contenders to run the government. This document is supported by Document 4, where a Brussels-based newspaper claims that Walloon control the north, but resist monarchial power, while Flemings are ardent supporters. In Document 8, a French observer discuses the struggle for political power between the Flemings and Walloons, stating that the Catholic Flemings lead a politically dominant party and their leadership demands must be met over those of the Walloon politicians. Through years of battling, Walloons and Flemings still found their selves butting heads in the political arena, but still, all of that fighting came down to one issue: language.…

    • 760 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Dutch Republic Dbq

    • 1517 Words
    • 7 Pages

    From the middle of the Seventeenth Century to the early Eighteenth Century, the Dutch Republic, which in 1648 had it’s independence recognized in the Peace of Westphalia, was an important commercial and military presence in Western Europe which later experienced challenges to its security, unity, and prosperity: in security, the Dutch faced navel challenges from England and land-based invasions from France; the challenges to prosperity came from the cost of wars and fierce competition to it’s trading empire; in turn, the financial stress caused by war and commercial decline threatened the unity of the Republic, as the financial burden of the wars fell disproportionately on the province of Holland.…

    • 1517 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The challenges to the security, unity, and prosperity in the Dutch Republic, otherwise known as the Netherlands, in the seventeenth and eighteenth century were mostly routed in the wars between England, France, and the Dutch Republic (which led to the end of the Dutch’s Golden Age and the start of their economic decline). The challenges varied from one to another; whether it was military conflicts, the shifting of alliances, the decay in oversea trade, or the disunity among the provinces. Despite the immense role these challenges played in the downfall of the Netherlands, the key factor was the disunity of the seven provinces. This disunity was the Netherlands tragic flaw and led to their downfall.…

    • 686 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    AP European History Spring Final Study Guide Table of Contents: Timeline Semester 1 (1300-1850) Timeline Semester 2 (1750-2010) Unit 1: Middle Ages & the Renaissance (Ch. 12-13) Unit 2: The Reformation (Ch. 14) Unit 3: Religious War & the Age of exploration (Ch. 14-15) Unit 4: Absolutism & Constitutionalism in Western Europe (Ch. 16) Unit 5: Age of Absolutism in Eastern Europe (Ch. 17) Unit 6: Expansion & Daily Life (Ch. 19-20) Unit 7: Scientific Revolution & the enlightenment (Ch. 18) Unit 8: French Revolution & Napoleon (Ch. 21) Unit 9: Industrial Revolution (CH. 22) Unit 10: Ideologies and Upheaval (Ch. 23-24) Unit 11: Age of Nationalism (Ch. 25) Unit 12: World War I and Imperialism (Ch. 26-27) Unit 13: Age of Anxiety (Ch. 28) Unit 14: Rise of totalitarianism and World War II Unit 15: Europe During the Cold War and After (Chap 30-31)…

    • 440 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Government scandal is no shocking news, constant new conspiracies and power plays are all too frequently covered by the media for such a thing to be a surprise. The biggest scandal is covering up their own actions. Too much history is covered up by governments around the world. Selfishly, they hide their own shameful history to keep a good name and to stay in good graces with their subjects. In his final chapter of King Leopold’s Ghost, Adam Hochschild conveys how the transgression of the Flemish to the Congolese was erased. How is it that the people of both the Congo and Belgium have completely forgotten the horrors their predecessors endured and committed? For every secret that is uncovered, how many more are…

    • 587 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The intention of colonialism, though cloaked with moral justification, was clear from the beginning: in order to assert oneself as a dominant power, a country must steal, ravish and exploit the land, people and culture belonging to another. The belief that taking of foreign land was justified because a particular country had the power to do so with little genuine resistance was so prevalent during the late Nineteenth, early Twentieth centuries that it significantly, and tragically affected those colonized land. In Adam Hochschild’s novel, King Leopold’s Ghost, he details chronicles that events that shaped King Leopold of Belgium’s rule over the Congo in Africa, but also illustrates that what went on was not aberrant. Rather, it was example of a broader problem that plagued many Europeans countries in the decades leading up to World War One that led to the death of millions.…

    • 779 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Belgium saw them as an easy target with big profits and imperialized. Belgium, as a western nation, also agreed to the ideas of Social Darwinism, the belief that the white European was better than the rest of the people in the world, chiefly based on their physical features. Simply put, they were racist. Most Europeans fell into this belief, but the Belgian people took this to an extreme. They enslaved the native people of Congo in their own country and forced work upon them. Quotas and taxes were created to ensure certain amounts of raw materials were gathered and harsh punishments were put into action for those who didn’t complete or meet their requirements. According to Mark Twain, “The amount of rubber needed to meet the tax requires the men to work for up 25 days each month harvesting the wild rubber vines in the Congo forest” [3]. According to this that would leave only 5 days a month for “regular” life for the Congolese people. They did not have the time or resources to educate themselves, make money, or to develop. In 1908 the Belgian government gave the natives better treatment, by taking away the direct ownership of the nation from Leopold and they made it an official colony of the Belgian government [4]. This decision came through by putting humanitarian pressure put on King Leopold. Conditions improved, schools, hospitals, and roads were built, but the cruelty and racism was still their because of the history they had of it. Also, the punishment, crimes, and cruelty was all that the people understood because they were forced to live in it their entire lives, and it was a hard to shift back. Even in today’s world, this industrialization and these policies have left a scar on the Congos. In both the Republic of Congo and the Democratic Republic Of Congo there is still political unrest and constant violence. On December 17, there were 22…

    • 1768 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In contrast with the days of Westphalia, two world superpowers fighting each other over who could gain more global influence is quite a significant change from the bare-bones delegation of the right to self-determination, and though all the prior laws of world order are supposed to apply to subsequent one, they are slightly twisted and worked-around in this iteration. In an examples such as the ideological fight for Vietnam or Korea, one could consider that the people of these nations had an independent decision to decide which alliance to side with, but it would quickly grow into a much larger conflict that held no regard for the objections to the sovereignless nation’s mutually assured destruction. The people of Vietnam were as much as the victims of the war as were the innocent families of Protestant and Catholic faith during the Thirty Years’ War; Which was agreed upon to never happen again post-Westphalia.…

    • 249 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Nationalism and liberalism spread throughout Europe during the French Revolution and Napoleonic wars. Taking root, it influenced the peoples of Eastern Europe as well as Italy and Germany in Central Europe. Important to Eastern Europeans and peoples of the Balkans, in the southeast, was national independence. This desire by the Slavic peoples for separation from foreign rule would bring about the spread of nationalist ideas. Further destabilizing the already weakening Hapsburg and Ottoman empires were growing nationalist movements and Russia’s involvement in Balkan politics, “posing as the champion of Slavic liberties and nationalism against the Slavs ' Turkish and Austrian masters. This heightened tensions between Austria, Turkey, and Russia and would provide the spark to set off World War I.” (Nationalism, 2007).…

    • 1821 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Within the federal state of Belgium, Wallonia is both a Region and a Community, two terms which reflect different political realities, the former is based on the principle of territoriality with Brussels, Flanders and Wallonia, while the latter was created on the premise of cultural and linguistic solidarity with the Flemish, Walloon and German-speaking Communities (Francard 2013: 29-30). The concept of Community as understood in the Belgian constitution is of particular relevance in the frame of this master thesis as communities are responsible for linguistic, cultural, and educational legislation. Thus, any attempts to revitalize Walloon is to take place…

    • 1079 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    After the Second World War, Belgium encourages massive labour immigrations first from Italy (from 1947 to 1956), then from Spain, Greece, Morocco, Turkey, Tunisia, Algeria and Yugoslavia (Adam 13). But these immigrations are seen as temporary by both the immigrants and the Belgian state (gastarbeiders) (Adam 13). And if some measures are implemented for the immigrant workers, they do not manage their equal participation in Belgian society as full citizens. In 1974, the Belgian state officially closes its borders, shattering the myth of temporary immigrations (Adam 14). Measures of integration are implemented, such as training courses or cultural activities devoted to bring communities together (Adam 14). In 1980, the integration policy changes from ‘the welcome of immigrant workers’ into ‘the welcome and integration of immigrants’ and publically acknowledges the immigrants as permanent residents (Adam 15). Since then, the integration policy has known different trajectories in Flanders and in…

    • 1814 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Our lecture started with well-known demographic facts about Belgium - the population equals to 10,511,000, 15% of which are immigrants (1,570,000). In Belgium, Catholicism is the most widespread religion. There are also Moslems, Jews and Protestants. In general, people are open-minded about other religions and of course different nationalities. The cultural diversity is enriched by international and local immigration. In the last hundred years the most important immigrant groups were Jews who form a sizable community in Antwerp; Poles, who came after the fall of communism; Italians; North Africans and Turks. There are many recent immigrants from other countries in the European Union also.…

    • 1520 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays

Related Topics