Where Death And Glory Meet Analysis

The memory of Colonel Robert Gould Shaw is a key example of an officer’s memory dwarfing the equally courageous actions of his subordinates. In the book, Where Death and Glory Meet, historian Russell Duncan argues that Shaw became the most important abolitionist hero of the war. Interestingly, Shaw became one of the first white officers to command a colored regiment. Colored troops were a symbolic statement to the Confederacy, that the Union was committed to the emancipation of enslaved African Americans. Therefore, the national perception of black resolve for their freedom and equality, fell onto the shoulders of colored regiments including the 54th Massachusetts. Indeed, there is overwhelming symbolism in a black Union soldier fighting against his pro-slavery counterparts. So how could the memory of the 54th Massachusetts charge on Fort Wagner develop into the memory of a single white officer? More specifically, why is the life of a single white officer more significant than the massive show of courage exhibited by the black soldiers? Was the memory of black soldiers repressed by the inability for whites to see blacks as their equals? Furthermore, was the change in memory affected by rise of the “Lost Cause” ideology and subsequent fall of emancipationist movement?
This paper focuses on the
Therefore, different primary and secondary sources must be consulted, to gain a clearer picture of the impactful memory of Robert Gould Shaw. Historians including Russel Duncan, Ja Saltmarsh, and David Blight have all written about Shaw’s memory. Primary sources will include speeches published by Shaw’s family, the monument dedicated to Shaw and the 54th Massachusetts, and the movie Glory. I will also consult newspapers including The Christian Recorder- a prominent African American newspaper, The Charleston Mercury- a Confederate newspaper, and The New York Herald- a northern