Preview

White Power Structures In The United States

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
2313 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
White Power Structures In The United States
The United States strives for unbiased instruction but encounters influential individuals and groups who hold significant control over decision-making, resource allocation, and direction within education. These power structures separate people based on race, creating a barrier that shapes their experiences and opportunities in society. White Power structures are perpetuated, particularly in the context of privilege and supremacy. Many people who are white are taught to ignore their privilege and social standings, see their worldview as normal, and attribute racial issues to individuals rather than systemic structures. Ideas of individual choices and agency over their social standings are modes in which white power structures attempt to distance …show more content…
White people usually divert the blame through the reasoning of having agency and individual choice over deciding how successful they are. Individual choice refers to the belief that academic success and access to quality education are primarily determined by an individual's effort, motivation, and the choices made by their families. This belief suggests that students and their families who prioritize education, work hard, and invest financially in schooling will achieve better outcomes. Agency refers to the right or ability of individuals to make their own choices and decisions without external influence or coercion. White people exercise their agency to perpetuate racism by using abstract liberal principles such as equal opportunity, meritocracy, and individualism to justify racially discriminatory beliefs and actions. However, the idea of individual choice and agency does not apply equally to people of colour, particularly those from economically disadvantaged backgrounds because they fail to acknowledge the structural inequalities that disadvantage people of colour and instead attribute disparities to individual effort or cultural deficiencies, thereby maintaining the status quo of racial …show more content…
Bonilla-Silva argues colour-blind racism operates subtly, masking the continued existence of racial inequality through various frames that justify the status quo of racial hierarchy. Through this, Bonilla-Silva demonstrates how white supremacy gives white people agency over where they decide to live. “I don't have a problem with all-white and all-black neighborhoods if that's the choice of the people, the individuals. But, if it's forced either way, if I'm a black person and I've come into the neighborhood and I want to live here and selectively denied that option, that's wrong. But, again, there still has to be some type of social interaction for growth and if the social interaction takes place then, the cross-integration will take place, I think [— Lynn]” (Bonilla-Silva, Eduardo, 35). Lynn uses the frame of abstract liberalism, a framework individuals use to maintain a liberal facade while disregarding systemic causes of racial injustice. Lynn demonstrates how white supremacy grants white individuals agency over their residential choices while perpetuating unequal power dynamics and inhibiting true integration. Residential segregation is a physical representation of Du Bois’s colour line.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    Lisa Delpit brings the phrase “culture of power” to our attention; she suggests that schools across America are caught in this tug of war of not knowing how to educate children from various cultural and linguistic backgrounds. Delpit goes on to say that a “culture of power “exists in our school system which tunes it out or what she refers to as the “silenced dialogue”. She states in her book that educators are only concerned how white teachers can educate children of color more specifically Black and Native Americans (Delpit, pg 23) and not on how they can educate all students to create a utopian society where everyone belongs.…

    • 1557 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Summary Of The South Side

    • 627 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Natalie Moore’s The South Side: A Portrait of Chicago and American Segregation, puts into perspective the historical and cultural prevalence of black segregation and subsequent discrimination and social adaptations that have spawned where politics has continually failed. The struggle of the blacks and minorities to create sustaining communities to reinvest in and bolster future generations with have faced racial based political stonewalling and “redlining” since the Northern migrations (p. 7) of the early 20th century. Employing a combination of personal rhetoric and historical precedents Moore investigates and analyzes how continued failure from the Chicago Housing Authority coincides with the societal exclusion of the poor or less fortunate…

    • 627 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    White Privilege Analysis

    • 390 Words
    • 2 Pages

    These White Privilege readings engage popular culture by defining white privilege through concrete evidence. Texts such as “White Privilege: Unpacking the Knapsack” ask the reader is to view a list of items that define white privilege. The reader is then asked to confirm whether or not the privileges are applicable to how he or she lives. As most white people realize just how applicable white privileges are to them, they can see that the problem is not just skin deep. The privileges white people have today are because of the white privileges available throughout history. In “The History of White People” the author unveils that most of what we study is a white man’s version of history, and therefore discredits other race’s contribution to history.…

    • 390 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Silva’s Frames of Color-Blind Racism provide the logic used by governmental leaders to explain the place dominance has in a society. In addition, the frames demonstrate how dominance is managed and maintained in a society. Abstract Liberalism, Naturalization, Cultural Racism, and Minimization of Racism are the four frames that Silva introduces. Since Anti-racialism, as defined by Goldberg is opposing the categorizing of people according to their outward characteristics, Goldberg’s frames Naturalization and Cultural Racism do not support anti-racialism. Naturalization makes it possible to deny racism by attributing racist behavior to occurrences that are said to happen naturally e.g. white and blacks do not live in integrated neighborhoods because…

    • 429 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In this lecture the speaker, Eduardo Bonilla- Silvia, talked about how racism has progressed over the years. He started off by talking about how color-blind racism is the new ideology in America. Eduardo explained that color-blind racism is a way of discriminating colored individuals without being “racist”. It has come to the extent that white people are unlikely to experience disadvantages and overlook racism as a whole. He said that most of the time people don’t even acknowledge that they are being racist because of the new civilized version of racism.…

    • 650 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Eng 100 Paper 1 Review

    • 334 Words
    • 1 Page

    Conclusively, the mythology of safety and racial coding needs our utmost attention as a marker of change for the insidious gentrification violence of American cities. Since, the American traditions of racism and capitalism is power played by mechanics of culture, politics, economic and racial disparity. To forge ahead, we require an outrageousness that sees beyond the tired tropes and easy outs that mass media provides which demands organization with clarity about privilege and the…

    • 334 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    McIntosh (1990) asserts how many individuals of the white race an unaware that they attain “white privilege.” As white individuals are taught to not recognize their “conferred dominance,” many of these individuals believe that…

    • 723 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    First, he uses a lot of instances in daily life to illustrate that nowadays in the United States most whites claim that race is no longer a problem (2), but in fact blacks and other minorities, who receive impolite treatment both economically and politically, are “at the bottom of the well” and suffering from racial inequality (2). Instead of Jim Crow racism, which enforced racial inequality by overt means such as calling blacks “niggers” (3), today color-blind racism behaves in a covert way, “subtle institutional and apparently nonracial”, in order to keep minorities in a subordinate position and maintain “white privilege” (3). For example real estate agents do not show all the available units to minorities in the housing market to “maintain separate communities” (3). Second, Bonilla-Silva compares the four ways in which the “survey community and commentators” explained about changes in whites’ racial attitudes in the post-Civil rights era (4), and demonstrates his arguments by expressing his agreements and disagreements with their thoughts. He argues like them that color-blind racism is characterized by “traditional liberalism”, which criticizes blacks for not working hard (7), and explanations of blacks’ position in terms of culture (7). But in addition he also expresses “one central theoretical disagreement” with others because his model is based on “a…

    • 627 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    To illustrate, he uses the history of New York and how it still “bear[s] the scars of redlining, blockbusting and urban renewal” (para 6). He points out past arrangements and how we have shaped the city in such a way that racism is embedded in society. Why do we still segregate by color and wealth in New York City? We have similar races and classes living in the same area because that is the only possible option they have. They are either poor or, due to their race, they have limited options available to them. Manhattan is a great example of the segregation we still have today, where the larger part of residents are white upper middle class citizens. Bronx and Queens have a larger population of low income of Hispanics and Blacks. We then associate that coming from these poor neighborhoods automatically makes residents poor as well. The amount of funding that goes into these neighborhoods is less compared to the neighborhoods of higher classes. What we create is a scene where normal occurrences are really the results of building for the middle class, essentially blinding us from seeing the injustice. How can we expect to stop racist acts if we, as a city, can’t even see the segregation of our neighborhoods? Racism can be connected to many different aspects, one being how we view ourselves and others based on classes, races and at other times on our…

    • 1382 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Analyzing White America

    • 437 Words
    • 2 Pages

    After viewing "Analyzing White America" by Paul Mooney, I was initially taken aback by the content. I never expected the rawness that Mooney brought to the stage and he hit the ground running with such a tone without looking back. A lot of the material made me laugh or at the very least smile because i found it to be identifiable with my own life and some of the surroundings that I was brought up in. The part that I found most amusing was Mooney's suggestion that white people were happier before slavery was abolished. I believe racism is very much present in today's world. When I was growing up, I can recall plenty of neighborhoods in my hometown that were considered "white" or even "black" for that matter. In these neighborhoods, if you were not from that part of town, you were not considered welcomed there. Any parts of the film that I did not laugh at, there was no particular reason other than I simply was not amused by the material because there were not any parts that I found personally offensive. I feel as though the word "nigger" is so controversial solely because of it's history and the origin of it's meaning. This word was meant to degrade and disparage African Americans when it was originated.Today, people use the term in a different context. The new meaning is one of affection but with it's use comes this unwritten rule that white people are prohibited from saying it. I never could wrap my mind fully around the idea that I can say the word "nigga" in reference to a friend of mine but a white kid was not allowed to use it, in the same context, all because we are of different races. In my opinion, it's not right for either myself or a white person to use the word in any context. In today's society, everything is just as much about race as it was in the days of slavery. The only difference between now and then is that openly addressing the issues that we, as a culture, all have with race is socially unacceptable. Mooney's antics on stage were…

    • 437 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Yet, there continues to be a slew of prominent individuals who employ cultural racism when discussing the opportunities and success of blacks and Hispanics. Inciting visions of the American Dream, claiming with hard work and perseverance, anyone can be successful in America (Bonilla-Silva 2003). The problem with this is that the United States has managed to convince people that an individual’s hard work is the only determinant of accomplishment in this country. This ideology denies the power of oppression or privilege on any person’s chances for success, and feigns that every individual, regardless of their race has the same access to the opportunities of America. This sort of rise of color-blind thinking in the past few decades implies that…

    • 1553 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In The New Jim Crow, Michelle Alexander’s argument that Mass Incarceration is, metaphorically, the new Jim Crow is extremely useful because it sheds light on the difficult problem a system of racial and social control that is prevalent in the United States today. Although I agree with Alexander generally, I cannot accept her overriding assumption that Mass Incarceration is the only system of oppression contributing to the new system of oppression that has been emerging since the so-called end of the Jim Crow Era. I believe that the topic of Racial Housing Segregation and Discrimination is of equal importance to the issue of systematic racism as Mass Incarceration. While the Legal Segregation has been abolished, Racial Housing Segregation still…

    • 1378 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    I argue that privileged whites can chose to rise above these created moral hierarchies that wrongly exploit and harm nonwhite people in order to move toward real equality rather than continuing to ignore the fact that our privilege comes at the expense of nonwhites. First, I am in agreement with Hobbes that human morality is relative and based on human ‘desires’ and ‘aversions’ rather than on objective truths (B). From this point, we are responsible for creating our own morality as individuals and as societies. I also agree with Rousseau that humans have free agency and therefore have the ability to override their desires and aversions, for better or worse ends (E). Regardless of whether humans are inherently selfish (Hobbes) or become selfish as a result of conflicts inherent in societies (Rousseau), humans can use their free agency to rise above their selfish inclinations.…

    • 1049 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Living in a neighborhood of color wherein there is no preference for people with low income, represents a socio-historic process where rising housing costs, public policy, persistent segregation, and racial animus facilitates the influx of violence between black and white menace as a results of residential displacement which is otherwise refer to as gentrification. This has however deprived many citizens of the United States, a good quality of life as it boils down to an argumentative issue between the rich and the poor balance of standard of living. American’s extinction is not necessarily the amount or kind of violence that characterizes our history,” Richard Slotkin writes, “but the…

    • 1820 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    I was so struck by Dr. Brown’s statement, that I use it as an academic compass to examine the ways in which I study black geographies, while articulating their significance. Especially with the rise of recent academic discourse that concentrates on the intersectionality of black identity. Often, when scholars investigate the complexities of identity, the focus is directed towards race, gender, sexual orientation, class, age, mental or physical illness, religion or disability. Each of these aspects of social identity, help to better understand individual experiences of oppression and dominance-hierarchy in society, over collective assumptions that structural discrimination is universal and felt in the same ways by all people of color. Although this framework is a momentous paradigm in academic contexts, it neglects to incorporate the significance of placed-based identity. Particularly, how space constructs social identity and the ways in which local dominate systems impact black individual and collective selves. When scholars attempt to understand structural racism and individual agency, “the where” can alter how we cognize environmental influences on social interaction. Further, space acts as a social construct in tandem with other social constructions that have been used against the black body. Therefore, “the where” becomes crucial to recognizing how space exists within societal hierarchies, perpetuating inequality across various…

    • 1038 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays