Preview

Whither Indian Democracy Today

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1343 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Whither Indian Democracy Today
When one reads about the bloody scuffle of the legislators of U.P. Assembly or murder of a CPI (M) leader in Bihar or lynching of a District Magistrate in Bihar or the dismissal of the Chief of Naval Staff of India, one gets the feeling of living in a jungle raj and not in a civilized democratic society. It seems as if two of the major organs of the state, the legislature and the executive, have become totally dysfunctional.

Legislators stall the proceedings of assemblies and the parliament instead of debating and enacting the laws or else armtwist the government officials in the matter of postings and transfers. The executive has become so inefficient in controlling accidents due to rash driving that the Judiciary has to interfere and perform the job of the executive by laying down terms and conditions for hiring drivers of school buses.

For months and years Judicial appointments are held up due to differences between the Judiciary and the executive. In short, the governance has reached its nadir in India after 50 years of Independence.

The last decade of the Twentieth Century has unmasked the hypocrisy of the Indian politician. A popular Chief Minister had to spend months in jail. A former Prime Minister had to appear before the court a number of times in connection with bribing of M.Ps. Another former Minister was remanded to judicial custody while facing charges of aiding and abetting smugglers. It seems as if Indian democracy has become a breeding ground for crooks and cheats.

Another disconcerting aspect of many state administrations is an increase in state sponsored bandhs paralysing life and activities in many parts of the country. Thus we have West Bengal, Tripura Bandhs called by CPI (M) led left front to protest against increase in prices or terrorist killings due to failure of the Central Government to contain price or send required strength of security forces to insurgency affected state.

Bihar is sporadically rocked by caste violence

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    George is a 40 year old senior executive in a large company, a position he has only recently taken up. He was referred to counseling by his general practitioner to explore his mood swings. He has been married for nearly 5 years to a ‘warm and wonderful person’. There were no children yet, and the couple was wondering about the right time for having children. This has been an area of disagreement between George and his wife and has led to a number of heated arguments between the two of them.…

    • 4858 Words
    • 20 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    central political authority is not seen as fair and proper, the litigants will seek personal…

    • 461 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    In a country that claims democracy, Indians seem to be confused on the definition of the government style. You can not blame the people however, because it is the duty of the people to have faith in their country to do the right thing. Indira Gandhi manipulated the people of India by legitimizing the repression by calling for order in a chaos that she created. Indira Gandhi has made catastrophic changes to India’s political, social, and religious views that still have negative repercussions today because of the authoritarian precedent that she set for India’s political system.…

    • 2992 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    There are strong arguments both for and against the idea that there is conflict between judges and government minsters. Some of the arguments for this include the increase in number of judicial reviews, the introduction of the Human Rights Act, the arguments over sentencing policy, and the fact that judges are increasingly speaking out against judicial decisions. Some of the arguments against this include the creation of the Supreme Court, the fact that judges are independent and neutral, judges knowledge that they cannot overturn parliamentary legislation and that judges cannot be proactive. This essay will consider both sides of the argument, and conclude that there is conflict to a SMALL/LARGE extent.…

    • 308 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The need of having just, effective and acceptable laws that govern the society has led to the thinking of having a body which makes those laws, the obvious choice has been the creation a body consisting of elected representatives that is parliament, but this does not mean its always perfect in performing the mandate .There are several shortcomings in the making ,interpreting and execution stages . Laws made in parliament require further interpretation by other arms of government of which this is room of bias in interpreting especially by the executive, also the said arms of government may fail to recognize to of recognize the actual intention of the law makers .Moreover . The group that consist of issues concerning them. Parliament may lack enough time pass all laws required which may to its failure to meet its purpose effectively, also this is corrected delegated legislation , the thinking public participation is watered down , the notion behind having parliament as the law making body .laws made in parliament comes at many a times as a result of pressure groups which only advance their interests ,the tendency to believe that what is good for a certain group is good for the majority this is not so as laws which employers would prefer maybe detrimental to employees interests and vice versa .However, there is some hypothetical nature in laws made by parliament that is the are likely going in testing rather than full implementation like in comparison to the judges which are more practical to the facts of the case. They also involve many other players which have different interest which are not beneficial to the public like party politics and ideological differences .The legislative process then is so far from being one in which interests common are protected or promoted we have seen…

    • 567 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The recent Gujarat riots & the government’s inability to control the situation have also led to an increase in the instability of the political arena.…

    • 820 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Judicial Review

    • 2666 Words
    • 11 Pages

    The controversy of judicial review which at extreme points, is called judicial activism, is a concept new to India. Judicial review can be defined as the judiciary, in the exercise of its own independence, checking and cross checking the working of the other organs of the government, while trying to uphold the ideal of ‘the rule of law’. Judicial activism more reformist in character is often confused with judicial review. According to Black’s Law Dictionary, judicial activism is “a philosophy of judicial decision-making whereby judges allow their personal views about public policy, among other factors, to guide their decisions, usually with the suggestion that adherents of this philosophy tend to find constitutional violations and are willing to ignore precedent.”However, due to the frequent misreading of the two terms, this article will only refer to judicial review as a proportionate mixture of the two.…

    • 2666 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Throughout the ages different forms of drama have been performed with the objective of influencing the masses. Bertolt Brecht was, and still is, one of the more influential playwrights in the history of theatre. Brecht was an opinionated Marxist living in Germany in the time of Hitler. He was exiled from Germany as a result of his controversial plays, and moved to America. This is where he wrote his most famous plays: Mother Courage and Her Childern, The Good Woman of Setzuan and The Caucasian Chalk Circle. He developed his own type of drama, Epic Theatre with the purpose of changing human society. His plays were didactic, with the persuasion on educating an audience. Despite the undeniable aims of his work, the techniques used were not quite so affective in reality and as a result the performances often did not have the impact Brecht desired.…

    • 1211 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Facts: The Governor of Karnataka had reported to the President that there were dissensions and defections in the existing ruling party as nineteen letters were sent to him by the council of ministers from withdrawing their support. He also stated that on the withdrawal of the support in the ruling party, the Chief Minister (S.R. Bommai) also failed to call in for majority of assembly, which is inappropriate under the Constitution. And so, the State is to be administered by the Centre. It was seen that seven out of the nineteen legislators have complained about misrepresentation in their respective letters and therefore, the Chief Minister and the Law Minister met the Governor the same day to summon the Assembly to prove the confidence of assembly in his government. The same was forwarded to the President through telex message. But on the very same day, Governor has sent another report stating that the Chief Minister has lost confidence of the majority of the House and requested for President’s Proclamation under Art 356 and eventually the same was granted.…

    • 341 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    With more than a 100 Amendments today India has come to realize that the framers of the Constitution did not lay down some set of hard core rules to follow. Or they did not declare any superior body to rule. Instead those set of intellectual architects left the Indians with a framework which is as dynamic as the air we breathe. It can take any shape it wants but it maintains its core value.......its basic structure.…

    • 3260 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    As a child I was amused at the premonition of the Soothsayer when he predicted the Death of Julius Caesar, who out of sheer vanity not only discarded his advice, but also admonished him for the same. A similar analogy can be drawn to the travesty that now surrounds Uttarakhand, the sole exception being, the vanity and obliviousness of the Government has gravely pulverized the State Exchequer and costed the lives of its own denizens, as against the death of one ruler.…

    • 1706 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    This time is the time of elections, rallies and parades, in the horde of accusations the manifestos vanish, and we are left with the realization that as the citizens of India we have failed to choose our representatives. I am yet to find some one who is confident of winning a seat on the basis of what he has done or what he is…

    • 1028 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    In India anybody can stand for elections and win to became member of legislative assembly of that area. Anybody can become prime minister, chief minister. But is this a good thing? Developed Countries like USA have highly educated people as their leaders. For a developing country like India where proper measures need to be taken for development, uneducated officials are useless for the development of the nation. The future of our country is in the dark as most of the ministers and leaders are less qualified or uneducated. Corruption is in the roots of our system. Most of the money sanctioned for development of the country such as roads, schools l, colleges, etc is consumed by oh our corrupt leaders. Most of the money we pay as taxes is eaten by our leaders. There is no strict measure for verifying or trying these leaders. The five year form of government is a curse for our country. All the ruling partiers enjoy the ruling power for the first four years and In the last year many rules are implemented to lure the voters and gain votes of the people.…

    • 680 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    speedy recovery of cases

    • 10639 Words
    • 43 Pages

    Delay in the dispensation of justice is regarded as a main latch in the judicial system. The unusual delay both in the trial of civil and criminal cases has made justice an imaginary matter. Delay in disposal of cases on the one way makes justice expensive and on the other way long pendency contributes to the material change of the subject matter of the disputes and lack of both oral and documentary evidence resulting in justice being either impossible or valueless which ultimately indulges corruption. Delay in disposal of cases makes room for non-confident attitude of the people towards the judicial system of the country. There is no other alternative to make the judicial system meaningful and trustworthy to the people without…

    • 10639 Words
    • 43 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The adage is quite old but its relevance is ageless. The past week has clearly reflected how the politicians have become absolutely corrupt by virtue of the absolute power bestowed on them through constitution. Every effort to remove this absolutism has been thwarted with complete disdain. Lokpal has not been allowed for so many decades and all the political group has covertly disliked it and colluded to not allow it happen in spite of a free nation together asking for it. Every word is silenced and khemkas and Durgas of this world get their wings clipped if they try to play with the absolute power. The reason is our political system has become close to monarchy in feigned way. The only difference from monarchy is that this system has group of monarchs. If one looks at the demography of politicians, all the new clans are the younger faces of the older generation. There are hardly a new family or individual joining the politics, rather new breeds are not allowed to prosper. Kejriwals are made to meet their own death by the use of this absolute power. The same media which was doing everything to highlight them and earn TRPs is now blocking every bit of news , why? they also have to survive in this absolutism. After all , this is also run by the people who have to survive and feed their family, so bonhomie has to be there with power. All the new generation of politician have the same genes, so how can one expect them to be different? be it congress or RJD or Shiv Sena or DMK or SAD or SP or any one , the replacements are not coming from any where other than the family? how this can be different from monarchy? Even those kins who had taken profession in films and sports, are coming back to politics. Just to keep the absolute power remaining absolute.…

    • 630 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays