Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Why Do Shakespeare and Blake Show Love and Conflict in Romeo and Juliet and the Sick Rose. Why?

Good Essays
2129 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Why Do Shakespeare and Blake Show Love and Conflict in Romeo and Juliet and the Sick Rose. Why?
Two Williams. One concept. Love. The two texts are based on love and conflict which relates to the audience. How? The emotions effected by such a delicate topic are felt strongly through the use of linguistic devices such as the sequences of events, dramatic irony, puns, characters themselves as well as the fervour in the language and the sentiment that they instil onto the audience which brings out pivotal sections. The exploration of such artistic measures will reveal the representation and interpretation of love and conflict in the minds of both writers as expressed in the text.
I believe that Blake is very similar to Romeo. How? Easily moved by and consumed with emotion, the first line drips with so much vehemence towards the rose. ‘O Rose, thou art sick!’ Here, I believe that Blake is talking about his love why? And he tries to create a sense of Distress and sorrow by using the word ‘sick’. Expand. He achieves this by using the vocative of the noun and also adding the exclamation mark to the end of the line. The depth of his emotion is clearly conveyed and it has an element of resonance to it that keeps it echoing through the heads of the audience
But why does he use the word rose? Research. This rose who is the embodiment of femininity due to its bittersweet nature is in love with another who is the worm. And this unrequited love is the thorn on the rose that pricks when one tries to hold on. It is the puncture in the vein that cripples the heart when one tries to hold on to love too tightly.L
The audience perceives a hint of sexuality in Blake's poem. This is shown in his references to male genitalia, the ‘worm’ and also female genitalia, her ‘bed of crimson joy’ which I think refers to the hymen. The effect of this image of passion created is the support of the notion that love is the driving force behind everything which was a popular belief during romanticism which was the period in which Blake lived. This brought in the perspective of love as a living fantasy. It is heroic in the way that the rose may have viewed the worm as a caterpillar soon becoming a butterfly or even as a silk worm that creates precious articles so delicate – love, and therefore her hero. But it is also a deadly gothic fantasy. The worm ‘flies in the night’ and it is ‘invisible’ with the disguise of the ‘howling storm’ which I believe could be perceived to be villainous. The villain then infects the rose with its ‘dark secret love’ that ruins her life. This contrasts with the ‘holy’ love in act1 sc5
In this way, I come to think of Blake’s view of love as destructive ‘does thy life destroy’. He, views the worm as a scoundrel who is taking away his beloved and consequently, a pest. With Juliet playing the part of the rose, Romeo’s ‘dark secret love’ could be the house of which he comes from i.e. the Montague’s as it actually does destroy Juliet’s life and she eventually dies because of this. His dark secret love could also be his emotion and passion.Effects
What they view love as ---just slip it in there
Two Williams. One concept. Love – and conflict. Complex word structures, linguistic devices and the like are evident in both pieces of literature as well as different perspectives of love. But what unites them and what distinguishes them? This question can only be answered by exploring both texts and contemplating the motives behind each motif. And by dissecting each piece, a bridge can be built across the sea of ideas they both share but also, the sands of time on both sides can be conflicted and contrasted giving us a deeper idea of the influences on both of the writers ultimately aiding the recognition of the twists both writers put on the constants in life we call love and conflict.
Love is an experience. It is an instinctive journey that we are set to make from conception.
It’s a call and a response. “O Rose, thou art sick!” I believe that the use of the vocative is not only for emphasis but also to show that he is distressed about the situation. I believe this Rose who is the embodiment of femininity due to its bitter-sweet nature is in love with another who is the worm. Also, I believe that Blake views love from sexual aspect which was very common in the romantic era.
Another driving force in his view of love is rebellion. The romantic era was full of revolutions and rebellions against them. This obviously influenced him as the rose rebelled against him, and chose her worm who she may view in terms of a caterpillar soon becoming a butterfly or even a silk worm that makes precious items, a hero. I believe she is madly in love with the worm so much that she does not even care about its ‘dark secret love’. Or maybe she is simply in too deep to be able to do anything about it.
"Two households, both alike in dignity... From forth the fatal loins of these two star-crossed lovers take their life." When Rosaline is first introduced to the audience, one may have though that Rosaline would be the second star-crossed lover. But she didn’t love Romeo and wanted to remain chaste. Personally, I thought that at the party Rosaline would see Romeo and eventually come around but instead Romeo moved on quickly. This sudden change caused a shift in thought and, in my opinion, the plot. I believe Romeo’s love for Rosaline was superficial much like beauty without intelligence which can be linked to the sick rose. Romeo, as the worm was only attracted to the colour of the rose (Rosaline) but when the rose became sick i.e. when Rosaline became sick of Romeo and refused him, he backed off. Thus making his feelings for Juliet seem even stronger
I believe that Shakespeare believes love is that which is light when present but heavy when absent as long as the fire has been ignited which is similar to Blake’s general view of suffering due to unrequited love. I also think that Shakespeare had rebellion as a motif to add to his picture as Romeo and Juliet rebelled against the systems of hatred put in place by their parents
Connecting both texts, after being heartbroken by Rosaline, his view changes. The rose is now Juliet and she is lovesick. After being closed off from love, when Romeo sees Juliet, something happened for the very first time with her. His heart melted and felt something true. ‘Did I ever love till now forswear its sight for I ne’er saw true beauty till this night’ his words burn with intensity He sees her as a light within his world ‘o she doth teach the torches to burn brightly’. This contrasts to the ‘dark secret love’. Shakespeare sees love as light while Blake sees elements of darkness to it.
Engulfed in loves sweet fume, Romeo and Juliet obsess over each other. Drinking in each other’s words which flow like honey only to choke them at the end. This cloud of passion ‘howling storm’ overrides the foreboding that plagued Romeo on the way to the part. The chemistry, first developed from Romeo’s tender language and in hindsight, fuelled by Mercutio’s vulgarity is maintained and influenced by a series of mannerisms consummated by the different characters.
I believe that in Romeo and Juliet, the premonition ‘I fear tonight for my mind misgives, some consequence yet hanging in the stars’ created the aura of impending doom but in the sick rose, the word sick does this and it does this effectively. From the title, we already know that there is something wrong.
Blake views love as a good thing as shown in the clod and the pebble ‘But for another gives its ease, and builds a Heaven in Hells despair’ but also a bad thing ‘Joys in another’s loss of ease, and builds a Hell in Heavens despite’ in the same poem. A lot of his poems talk about unrequited love and I believe that he sees love as a double edged sword. A bitter-sweet experience.
I’ve never been in love. But I am a ‘lover’ as quoted by Mercutio. Love is that which stirs emotions. It overwhelms and I believe it is a tree of emotion with many branches. It means that you are not alone. God is love. God is omniscient and also omnipotent. So is love. Love is supernatural and True love is eternal, infinite and always like its self an ‘ever fixed mark’. Some people say love changes but I disagree. Love doesn’t change, you do. I heard that love is the rose that grows through the concrete. The rose. Beauty, pain, that which arises from conflict. I believe that to love is to suffer. To avoid suffering one must not love. But then one suffers from not loving. Therefore to love is to suffer, not to love is to suffer.
Death is inevitable but we are still never prepared for it. The destruction and events leading up to in both texts are obvious but different twists are put on the same story line. Two Williams, one concept. One love.
Introduction
Romeo only goes to this Capulet party in Act 1 Scene 5 to get his mind off of the fair Rosaline. Rosaline has rejected him and he is heartbroken. Despite all of this, Romeo quickly forgets about Rosaline when he sees Juliet. He first asks about her before deciding to go up to her which i believe shows that he is love struck but also wary due to the fact that Rosaline had only recently broken his heart.
Juliet also asks about Romeo when she is taken away by the nurse. Looking to act 2, Juliet asks her famous question which reinforces the fact that she is madly in love.
Romeo meets Juliet at a Capulet party he crashed. I believe that this shows that their love was written in the stars.
Viewpoint: the play is written in an omniscient point of view which i believe is used to enable the audience develop an opinion of their own, Shakespeare ises this to ensure we feel the emotions of r&j clearly instead of moving through their point of views
Responding to the imagery of the text, i can identify a ‘solar love’ that is idealizing and which reaches beyond time. ‘o she doth teaches the torches to burn bright’ but trapped in time the love also takes refuge in the darkness
Love between the children of enemies is paradoxical; even more so is a love that finds marriage in only death.
What’s in a name? That which we call a rose by any other word would still smell as sweet. What about a sick rose?
It is on seeing Juliet that romeo’s language gains subtlety. He describes ‘beauty too rich for use, for earth too dear’
Featuring 3 murders and 2 suicide R&J has the potential to be both melodramatic as well as sentimental.
Romeo now means a lover,passionate admirer, a seducer and a habitual pursuer of women. Is this the kind of message shakespeare wanted to give.?
Switches between comedy and tragedy, rarefied romance and earthy bawdiness, work with the rucurring figure of the oxymoron to produce a formidable momentum entirely appropriate to the fast pace of the plot.
Elevated language
Juliet's famous question 'what's in a name? Articulates self-consciousness of Romeo and Juliet.
That which we call a rose would still smell as sweet.
What about The Sick rose?

--------------
When we recall that use means 'employment', 'interest' and 'wear and tear' that earth means both 'mortal life' and 'the grave' , that dear can be either 'cherished' or 'costly' and that there may be a play upon beauty and booty, the lines range of meanings becomes very wide.
---------------
Romeo's infatuation with Rosaline is a form of posturing that romeo himself already realises to be foolish
---------------
I also find patterns of light and darkness to be the dominant pattern of Romeo and Juliet. Lying behind this imagery is a suggestion of the transformative power of love. The beauty and ardour of young love are seen by shakespeare as the irradiating glory of sunlight and starlight in a dark word. Romeos first words about juliet : o she doth...ethiops ear
--------------
Pure love is possible because the lovers have not been corrupted by experience: they do not think to a past that teaches them about the failure of love

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Through careful analysis of Shakespeare's language, characterisation and dramatic technique,discuss the nature and development of Romeo and Juliet's relationship.…

    • 1773 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Romeo and Juliet is hailed as a staple of romantic literature, with beautiful prose and loving relationships. However, while its language is eloquent, Romeo and Juliet’s relation is the antithesis of a good relationship. Any relationship which involves both parties ending up dead within a few days of meeting each other is probably not healthy. It’s clear both of them rushed into it based on superficial reasons and stupidity ended it early.…

    • 324 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In this scene Shakespeare presents the relationship between Romeo and Juliet as a tragedy. I can tell this because it says ‘I must be gone and live’. This shows that Romeo knows he might die if he stays but he is choosing to stay to see Juliet. It also shows how much they love each other as Romeo is showing he would die for Juliet. By using the image of death, it shows that the story might become a tragedy. By including hints towards a tragedy, it keeps the audience interested. It also shows how bitter the feud is between the two families.…

    • 386 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Juliet’s perspective of love, marriage and relationships have changed throughout Romeo and Juliet. At the beginning of the play Juliet never thought about love or marriage and never considered love or marriage, for when her parents told her that they want her to marry Paris she asked how can I love someone if I don’t even know him. “I have never dreamed about marriage.” When Juliet’s family had a party Romeo snuck in and when Juliet saw him, she told the nurse that he is cute and she thinks she fell in love with Romeo at first sight. When Romeo started to sneak out and see Juliet the would talk about how they like each other but Juliet is still be cautious because she doesn’t know if they are going to feel about each other overnight, but the…

    • 237 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In My Pretty Rose Tree different manifestations of love are shown as individual plants are personified. The repetition of ‘flower’ instead of the word ‘rose’ in the first stanza acts as a symbol to represent love and experiences and because of the use of a general term instead of the specific rose it can be perceived as the flower depicting love that’s being given to another woman. The speaker is presented with a flower ‘as may never bore’ yet returns it in loyalty, to the rose tree, then looks to ‘tend to her by day and by night’ nevertheless the rose ‘turn[s] away with jealousy’ portraying love with the imagery of experience as the expectations of light romance come forth. For his affection he is returned with ‘thorns’ suggesting the speaker may be willing to pay the price for a continued relationship as the thorns represent the protection he may hold over her from other lovers and therefore he is ‘delighted’ and reckons them as a symbol of love. In addition to this the speaker may find he is compelled to be in delight with the rose despite its thorns, as he has rejected the flower and the pain of the thorns may be infinitely preferable to his fear of the unknown, just as Adam and Eve with the fruit of knowledge, the flower takes the place of the fruit which offers experience yet comes with tempting propositions.…

    • 815 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The act of young love clatters as Rosaline rips Romeo’s heart out of his chest, producing sadness, and depression to overcome his feelings of delight that he once partakes…

    • 624 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Early on in the play, the audience is introduced to Romeo, grief stricken and in pain due to his unrequited love. His friend Benvolio comes to comfort and him and rid him of his troubles yet, Romeo speaks of his pain commenting how, “Love is a smoked raised with the fume of sighs” (1.1.197). Sighs are noises that are often made when one is distressed or sad. The smoke becomes a metaphor to the sighs that are produced by his feelings of love. Smoke is produced by fire, often have the connotation of being…

    • 1195 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Romeo and Juliet, Shakespeare portrays love blossoming in the midst of violent conflict at the centre of the feud. The connection is not coincidental; it is essential. This antithesisbuilds tension, as the Chorus sets up a ‘fearful’, ‘fatal’, ‘death-marked mood’, sowing the seeds of tragedy in the turbulent ground of ‘rage’. The lovers will be destroyed in a catharticmovement that will ‘bury their parents’ strife’. Shakespeare shows the redemptive power of love opposed to destructive hate - and in some ways the feud seems the major cause of the tragedy. But it is not the only cause. Romeo’s violent love echoes Tybalt’s love of violence. Both characters act out the parts they’ve written for themselves, and in both cases, ‘violent delights’ come to ‘violent ends’.…

    • 960 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    During the play Romeo and Juliet, Shakespeare manages to effectively depict the tragedy of Romeo and Juliet’s relationship. One way he achieves this is by creating sympathy for Romeo and Juliet, which consequently affects the reader and audience of the play. Three ways in which Shakespeare is able to create sympathy for them is through the general setting and plot structure, the language used, and also the characterisation of Romeo and Juliet.…

    • 1010 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Romeo is full of disparate emotions across the play, Romeo and Juliet by William Shakespeare, and is a significant character to analyze for his emotional states. In the course of the play, Romeo goes through many different sentiments and the artist captured and displayed it in his artwork. As the story unfolds, Romeo feels conflicted when losing Rosaline, passionate towards Juliet when they first meet, and mournful when seeing Juliet dead. The artist painted a beautiful creation showing Romeo’s three emotional states from the opening of the play, when expressing his love for Juliet, and the closing of the play.…

    • 409 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    One of the play’s most consistent visual motifs is the contrast between light and dark, often in terms of night/day imagery. Need Evidence! This contrast is not given a particular metaphoric meaning—light is not always good, and dark is not always evil. On the contrary, light and dark are generally used to provide a sensory contrast and to hint at opposed alternatives. One of the more important instances of this motif is Romeo’s lengthy meditation on the sun and the moon during the balcony scene, in which Juliet, metaphorically described as the sun, is seen as banishing the “envious moon” and transforming the night into day (2.1.46).…

    • 732 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Despite the fact that Romeo may chose that his affection for Juliet is more vital than his Honor, Romeo is enamored with Juliet whose last name may overcome his honor and Incidentally Romeo understands that his genuine romance is the enemy"oh, this is an overwhelming cost to pay! My life is in the hands of my enemy".…

    • 57 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In this short excerpt from Romeo and Juliet, Romeo expresses his feelings for Juliet, often including body parts such as eyes and hands, and celestial beings to enforce his heartfelt message.…

    • 295 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    With his individual visions William Blake created new symbols and myths in the British literature. The purpose of his poetry was to wake up our imagination and to present the reality between a heavenly place and a dark hell. In his Songs of Innocence and Songs of Experience he manages to do this with simplicity. These two types of poetry were written in two different stages of his life, consequently there could be seen a move from his innocence towards experience.…

    • 2064 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In this poem, Blake uses phrases to portray his view on love through the clod of clay. In lines 1-5 Blake states his view of what love should be "Love seeketh not Itself to please, Nor for itself hath any care, But for another gives its ease, And builds a Heaven in Hell's despair." Meaning that regardless of all the terrible things that occurs in the world love endures and can overcome all obstacles. Blake also expresses that love is not for self - gratification, but to please another, the one they love. In line 3 Blake says, "for another gives its ease." meaning that one will give up the simplicity of taking care of oneself and take up the responsibility of caring for the one they love.…

    • 732 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics