Preview

Why does Virgil make Aeneas enter the underworld

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
2326 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Why does Virgil make Aeneas enter the underworld
Why does Virgil make Aeneas visit the underworld?

In book 6 of the Aeneid Virgil makes Aeneas visit the underworld. There are many reasons that Virgil explains in the book. His visit to the underworld is the turning point of the Aeneid, it ends the description of his journey and starts to lead into the warfare and other events in the second half of the Aeneid. His visit rounds up all the main focus points of the whole epic, Aeneas as a person, piety and homage to Rome’s splendour. Aeneas’ meet with his father demonstrates the piety that Aeneas holds for his family and his homeland. The Pageant of Roman heroes demonstrates the homage to Rome and its future. As Aeneas continues his journey through the underworld meeting other people from his past, he changes and this demonstrates what Aeneas is like as a person.
As a debt to Homer, and to be seen as writing in the Homeric style, Virgil uses many similar scenes and references throughout his epic to those in Homer’s. For example, Odysseus meets his mother in the Underworld, but he didn’t initially know she was dead. He tries to embrace her three times, and three times he wraps his arms around nothing but air and begs her not to leave his grasp. Aeneas meets his father in the Underworld and tries to embrace him three times, and three times wraps his arms round nothing but air and begs him not to leave his grasp. Aeneas cannot meet his mother in the Underworld, as she is a goddess. He also knows that his father is dead and is told to go and visit him in a dream. Odysseus may not be able to meet his father in the Underworld because he is still at home, on his farm. It would be too much for Odysseus to meet both his parents in the Underworld. Thus, Homer has made a conscious choice. He may have picked for Anticleia to die because Laertes, being a man, had more prestige in Homer’s time, and should therefore be alive and well to greet his son when he returns home. However, it may also be ironic that Odysseus meets the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Toll proposes that Virgil’s poem, with Aeneas as the protagonist, was written for the readers who were in need of help when it came to viewing themselves as Roman Italians. Virgil was able to see that Roman-ness and Italian-ness was not the same thing. He believed that amalgamating the two nations should have been mutually decided and formed not authoritatively. Toll argues that he accomplishes this idea by using Aeneas, a Trojan who was referred to as “Pater” (Means father in Latin) in the Aeneid, as the vehicle of the new forming national identity of Roman Italian for two important reasons. Aeneas was Homeric and this offered Virgil the opportunity to write his generation’s origin and history as ancient as the history and origins that the Greeks were given by Homer. The second reason that Toll argues why Virgil picked Aeneas, is that, Rome already had a founding-father story that excluded the Italians. In the Aeneid, Aeneas is used to represent the ancestor of a greater commodity than Rome, which begins the formation of the amalgamation of Romans and Italians as one unit.…

    • 515 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    However, Laertes and Penelope are two of many characters who have known to grieve for Odysseus, which is mentioned frequently throughout the epic. In the underworld, Odysseus’s deceased mother, Anticleia who perished from her “longing”(11.201) for him, informs him…

    • 427 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Virgil’s Aeneid is a quintessentially nationalistic epic, written during a troubled time in Rome’s history and Virgil sought to place Rome’s past in the frame of myth by telling the tale of Aeneas and the founding of Rome. A Greek-centred myth, The Aeneid, brought about a new stage in Roman ideology. Virgil brought the present into the past through locations, people and prophecies, the most important of these being the prophecy of the descendents of Aeneas, the future leaders of Rome in Book Six . Family, therefore, takes centre stage in The Aeneid, the appearance of the dynastic line of Aeneas himself being a central event in the book. The various parent/child relationships found throughout the poem shape and drive forward the action of Aeneas’ story, from his escape from Troy with his own father and son, the numerous interventions by his own mother, Venus to the tragic stories of both Evander, his son Pallas, and that of Lausus and his father, Mezentius, whilst also tying in important themes, such as love for the family, duty to the father and the struggle for glory…

    • 2058 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Virgil, the greatest of all Roman poets, modeled his masterpiece, the Aeneid (30-19 BC) on the ancient Greek epics the Iliad and the Odyssey, written by Homer. Virgil's work also portrayed the battles that the hero of Roman mythology Aeneas fought at Troy and his search for an Italian homeland. Aeneas sacrificed love and human compassion in the name of duty and conquest, and the poet portrayed the power of destiny and the poignancy of…

    • 280 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The Aeneid Vergil Analysis

    • 1245 Words
    • 5 Pages

    First of all, Aeneas and his crew arrive involuntary to the City of Carthage due to a violent storm. Once there, they are welcome by Dido, the queen of Carthage who asks the reason of their presence. Aeneas explains that they were heading to Italy because their city was destroyed. In fact, the city of troy entered in…

    • 1245 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    As a result, Virgil had to show the supremacy of Roman virtues: gravitas, dignitas, and pietas. Among these Aeneas particularly embodies in pietas, and is emblematic of it in book II of the Aeneid when he flees burning Troy bearing his father, who carries the household gods, on his back. Since pietas means to be dutiful to family –specifically to the father which is expanded to the community and to the state in ancient Roman world, Aeneas is not culpable for leaving Dido if we follow the author’s viewpoints. With that said, Virgil seemed to use the love affair between Dido and Aeneas to show superiority of Roman race over Carthage and to provide rightful reason for Roman’s ruling over the world. Dido descends from an ideal leader who 'bore herself joyfully among her people..like Diana'(Bk1,502) to a woman dominated by her passion who 'raged and raved round the whole city like a Bacchant.'(Bk4,307). In contrast, Aeneas is forced to endure his own suffering, to 'fight down the anguish in his heart'(Bk4,580) and to remain 'faithful to his duty much as he longed to sooth her sorrow.'(Bk4,583) His decision to abandon Dido becomes 'a heroic and kingly choice of virtue' (Cairns, 50) an expression of Pietas, an an action worthy of great admiration in the Roman…

    • 1531 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    (462)” with the purpose of hearing the fate of his journey home from Tiresias. The scene that Homer outlines through the mouth of Odysseus is one of absolute sorrow heavily laden with the imagery of blood. This underworld is described as unable to be permeated by light saying “the sun never shines there, never climbs the starry sky to beam down at them, nor bathes them in the glow of its last golden rays; their wretched sky is always racked with night’s gloom. (452).” Beyond the gloomy outlook of sorrow, legitimatizing the mourning of and value place upon death, there is a significant amount of time spent with Odysseus dealing with, and observing the souls that are residing there, whose judgment has been passed down by “Minos, Zeus’ glorious son (465).”…

    • 1708 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Virgil uses a few techniques in order to extract sympathy for Aeneas from the reader. At some different points in Book 12 of the Aeneid, Virgil makes it seem as if Aeneas is the hero, and Turnus the villain, thus creating sympathy for the former. Virgil, for a large part of this book, portrays Aeneas as being wounded by an arrow wound, making the character seem more heroic, and so we feel sympathy towards him because of this. A number of times, Aeneas is unable to catch Turnus because his wounded knees slow him down. Virgil clearly shows the reader the struggle that Aeneas is facing, and this is illustrated in the simile of the Umbrian hunting dog and the deer. Through this simile, Aeneas – the hunting dog – is unable to grab Turnus, having been deceived by an empty bite. Throughout Book 12 of the Aeneid, Virgil hints that it is possible to feel a small amount of sympathy towards Aeneas, however it is clear that this sympathy cannot extend as far as with Turnus.…

    • 930 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “Antinous you might wonder what I’m doing here, I came to Odysseus to avenge your death but before anything was able to get started Laertes,Father of Odysseus, killed me with his spear. Not knowing what I really came to avenge, the men of the underworld have told me you caused hardship among that family the most. As they’ve killed us both we shall understand the law of the land. We shouldn’t have anything against them for they have retaliated.” His words were cringing but they were the words that stood and we all went our…

    • 709 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Not only is the way emotion is represented in contrast in these two epics, but the emotions used and emphasized are also different. The Aeneid is based upon the ideas of empathy and based around a character that represents love and piety while the Odyssey is based around a hero of battle and logic. This helps to symbolize the transition from a culture based around sound ideas of logic to a culture that becomes more open to human nature and its sympathies. The Roman culture was far more empathetic and subjective than their Greek counterparts. This style of narrative creates a much closer bond between the character and the reader than was presented in the Odyssey (Brooks 9). The Romans valued a hero who was inspired by his heart while the Greeks…

    • 1334 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Brutality In The Aeneid

    • 290 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Aeneid has gone through The Fields of Mourning, where he his greeted by his former lover Dido. Once Aeneas sees Dido he begins to break down with emotion expressing, “Did I bring only death to you?” (602). Aeneid goes onto proclaim to Dido that although he was unwilling to leave her, the gods had a mission for him to execute. Continuing on with his expedition he also sees the decease combatants of the Trojan War. A pivotal moment in the walk is when Aeneas sees a dismantled Deiphobus, sadden by his presence, Aeneas is heartbroken, and the two share a heartfelt conversation (660-724). In the middle of the conversation Sibyl forces Aeneas to move on with his expedition, there he witness a “fortress encircled by a triple wall and girdled by a rapid flood of flames”…

    • 290 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The author and narrator of “The Aeneid” is Publius Vergilius Maro (known simply as “Vergil”), though the tale briefly transitions into Aeneas’s narrative at one point. Responding to audiences who are unfamiliar with his tale and motivated by the need to share it, Vergil recounts Aeneas’s story, from his actions during the fall of the city of Troy to his visit to the Underworld and beyond. Scholars have long studied this piece and debated its significance, either as a simple historical tale of fiction or as a medium across which Vergil expressed his thoughts and musings. (Topic) The best way to interpret "The Aeneid" (Argument) is as a study into the character of Aeneas, who exhibits signs of the Roman virtues virtus and disciplina (or the lack…

    • 2165 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    They both had to make a sacrifice before they went down. They both were escorted by a nymph. Also,they also both could not stay for long. On the other hand, The two depictions of the underworld are extremely different to the one another. In The Odyssey there are no sections at all; the sinners are placed with the good and everyone is miserable. Also the dead souls do not know who they are and seem deranged. In The Aeneid, all different types of people are separated into different categories based on how they lives their mortal lives. Their are people who are being punished for being bad people, and others are being rewarded. The two versions differ too because Odysseus could not wait to go back and get out of the underworld; “I rushed back to my ship, commanded all hands to take the decks and cast off ables quickly” (Odyssey, 207). On the other hand, Aeneas did not understand why anyone would want to go back; “What dreadful longing sends them towards the light?”(Aeneid, 138) This is when the spirits are lined up to be sent back onto rather in another body. The difference in the two books are clear and it shows what interpretations is the better one. This reflects on how greeks view their after life then versus…

    • 1327 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Aeneid Vs Beowulf Essay

    • 640 Words
    • 3 Pages

    His home is conquered by the enemy, his wife is left behind during the flee, and by the decision of the gods he must leave dido to go to Italy. Virgil states “But Aeneas is driven by duty now” (Aeneid 496). Virgil sees the emotion of dido however; he refuses his emotions to come in the way of his duty. As a man, Aeneas disregards emotions and feelings for dido. It is similar to the modern day saying that men do not cry. The belief that emotions make men weaker still holds true in the modern day society. If Aeneas stays with dido, his peers would consider him less of a man and he would be unable to achieve glory. Virgil states that “In spite of all he obeys the gods’ commands and back he goes to his ships” (Aeneid 499-500). Virgil describes Aeneas’ decision to leave as a command from the gods and by doing so rationalizes his decision. Aeneas’ decision to follow his fate over his love shows the values of their…

    • 640 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Odyssey

    • 668 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The passage that Homer exquisitely wrote in The Odyssey was in Book 5, lines 309-323. Homer’s techniques established an image that could never be forgotten. In this passage, Odysseus was being dragged down to the sea by Poseidon. The sea god was furious that all the other gods were in his favor. Odysseus talked to himself and wondered out loud, “Rag of man that I am, is this the end of me?” (V, 309) Irony was a method Homer utilized to convey the message of helplessness. Odysseus has used trickery and deception during his journey. The sneaky hero went under disguise as a beggar with rags. The great, humble man categorized himself to the lowest position. It’s intriguing when Odysseus seems to regret and reflect about the past- “...lucky those Danaans were who perished...I should have had a soldier’s burial and praise from the Akhaians-not this choking waiting for me at sea, unmarked and lonely.” (V, 316-323) Odysseus doesn’t seem to be afraid of death. He does not ask for Poseidon’s forgiveness. The only thing he regrets the most is being unable to be recognized for his accomplishments. Usually, Odysseus is the victor of his odyssey. Now, he has lost control to the waters. To exemplify the mood, Homer inserted caesuras. The section “Would God I, too, had died there-met my end” (V, 317) is heart-wrenching. When I read this sentence, I had to hold my breath for the long pause. Odysseus sounded as if he was reflecting what could have been in a different scenario.…

    • 668 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics