Preview

Why Grades Should Not Be Used To Measure Intelligence?

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1117 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Why Grades Should Not Be Used To Measure Intelligence?
“Grades are primarily a measure of how good students are at getting good grades, not a measure of how much they learned,” a blog post written by a professor entitled “What do our grades measure? Academic savvy or actual learning?” mentioned. This had me thinking, what is the purpose of our grades? Should we use it as a basis to determine if whether or not we are intelligent? Then I realized: No, academic grades should not be the basis for measuring intelligence since they are based upon standardized tests, they can be influenced, and they do not measure learning. According to an article entitled “What is Standardized Testing? – Definition and Types,” when a particular group of students take a standardized test, they take the exact same set of questions, and will be scored and analyzed in the same way. We, as human beings, are unique. But more than that, it is a psychological fact that we have different intelligences. Howard Gardner, a Doctor of Philosophy and a Professor of Education at Harvard University, brought about the Theory of Multiple Intelligences. The theory expresses that “human beings have all of the intelligences, …show more content…
And no, I am not going to go on and talk about the teacher’s pets. There are many different factors which can influence grades. For one, we have cheating. On an article entitled “Most High-School Students Cheat,” Kenneth Kiewra, a study researcher and a professor of educational psychology at the University of Nebraska-Lincoln said that students are aware of what constitutes cheating, but they do it anyway. And at times, students don’t grasp that some dishonest acts are cheating. (Most High-School Students Cheat, 2010) In this case, a student’s grade is based upon how skillful of a ninja he is and not on his “ability to learn and understand things,” which is the definition of the word intelligent according to the Merriam-Webster

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    What is intelligence? How can it be defined, when it seems to be an individualistic characteristic? These are just a couple of questions in the debate over intelligence. The biggest misconception about intelligence is that it can be measured through an IQ test. While IQ tests are valuable pieces of information to have, they can’t specifically measure intelligence solely. Adam Hampshire, a PhD, psychologist, at the Brain and Mind Institute Natural Sciences Centre, London, Ontario, Canada says, “There are multiple types of intelligence, and It is time to move on to using a more comprehensive set of tests that can measure separate scores for each type of intelligence” (Mann, 2012). His belief is that tests that measure these different types of intelligence should be used in making the determination of intelligence, because in one area of the brain and individual may show intelligence, but in another they may not, so the confusion becomes, are they intelligent or not (Mann, 2012)?…

    • 1293 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    A good GPA has the ability to make students extremely proud. When receiving a high GPA most would not be happy due to their intelligence, but rather their commitment. So why are there still those who see grade point average as a measure…

    • 421 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When someone is called intelligent, people automatically think of how book smart someone is. Book smart relates to how much information about math, science, and english a person knows. In Hidden Intellectualism, Graff brings up the idea that intelligence isn’t all about a scholarly form of thinking. “Everyone knows some young person who is impressively “street smart” but does poorly in school” is the first line of Graff’s essay (Graff 787). Nowadays, it is popular for a person to have the experience and knowledge for an everyday environment but lack knowledge in educational studies. A reasonable answer for this problem could be that schools aren’t tapping into subjects other than the worn out academics that quickly in-interest students.…

    • 523 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Being a student who has taken the ACT and SAT, I agree that standardized testing is a good way to prove a student’s intelligence and that it does not discriminate. By analyzing previous points, we could come to a common ground to make testing more individualized for each student by way of online testing, but at the same time measure a students intelligence. “The Best of Both Worlds,” written by Jack Schneider, Joe Feldman, and Dan French, informs of a way in which teachers pull kids at random times to “amass a body of evidence and experiences so they can develop common and research-based grading practices within and across grade levels, departments, and schools…. ultimately creating consistent expectations of standards performance levels with a grading and reporting system that reliably and accurately reports that performance.” By understanding the beliefs of supporters, it is clear that the main goal is to provide a test that demonstrates how well a kid will do in college.…

    • 937 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    We live in a society that uses grades as a reflection of learning. Grades are supposed to show how well you know a subject, but is that what they really show? In our society it has become more about getting the grade than actually learning the subject. What impact do grades even have on learning? Jerry Farber, a professor at the University of California wrote an article, titled “A Young Person’s Guide,” that discussed grades and the impact, or lack thereof, they have on learning. Farber is correct in saying that our school grading systems are terrible because grades are not an accurate representation of someone's knowledge.…

    • 1006 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    voting

    • 1912 Words
    • 10 Pages

    Grades represent a standard of achievement and understanding, not just a memorization and regurgitation of…

    • 1912 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Some may beg to differ when people say the SAT or ACT are not fair to everyone. Not everyone may test well, so these tests are not an accurate assessment of someone’s intelligence. According to Merriam-Webster Dictionary, the SAT first stood for the Scholastic Aptitude Test, then the Scholastic Assessment Test; now it does not stand for anything. The SAT is a college entrance exam for high school students, and it measures strictly mathematical and verbal reasoning skills. On the other hand, the ACT, which stood for American College Testing, is scored differently and measures English, math, reading, science and an optional writing section. Some people may argue that these standardized tests will determine how well someone will do in college, but then again some people are not good test takers and perform better on tests that they can study for. Therefore, I believe standardized tests do not accurately measure intelligence of people because everyone performs differently on tests.…

    • 913 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Annotated Bibliography

    • 722 Words
    • 3 Pages

    That is another work of Howard Gardner for educational psychology, after set the frame of multiply intelligence in 1983. It focuses in social context’s influence of a person’s IQ, which means IQ tests cannot apply to another society as the cultural background is various. It also criticises the psychometric method of the U.S and compares it to the Japanese one, saying that the American neglect interpersonal experiences and emphasize too much on psychometric instruments.…

    • 722 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Abolishing the SATs

    • 1068 Words
    • 3 Pages

    As soon as we are put into the school system as children we are immediately taught that getting good grades makes you smart, and getting bad grades makes you dumb. We are taught that honor roll students get labeled “gifted” as C or D range students are labeled only “average” or even “slow” or “below average”. Yet, does a simple standardized test with computer calculated answers determine our true intelligence? Is it legitimately fair to say one is not smart if the test is not scored high enough to society’s standards? We are humans. We are fascinating creatures; and the measures we have pushed our brains to is impeccable. In every type of activity and subject, we continue to strive as people. An enormous factor of our future is our education. It is just more likely to live a more comfortable life financially, if you educate yourself and get a degree. But why if there are so many different types on intelligence, does one kind of test deteriorate if people will make it or not?…

    • 1068 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In 1983 a professor of education at Harvard University, Dr. Howard Gardner, developed the theory of multiple intelligences. This theory states that there are eight different ways in which a person is intelligent. These different forms of intelligence are as follows: linguistic, or word smart; logical-mathematic, or reasoning/numbers smart; spatial, or picture smart; bodily-kinesthetic, or body smart; musical, or music smart; intrapersonal, or self-smart; and naturalist, or nature smart (“Multiple Intelligences” para. 1-2). It is not difficult to pinpoint which of these intelligences standardized testing primarily measures. For students who are not linguistically or mathematically gifted, the tests do not accurately show the students’…

    • 581 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    However, others will pull their hair out and bend their mind backwards trying desperately to conjure up another plan for the not-so distant future. ACT, SAT, and other standardized tests ultimately decide every student's educational future. As humans age and mature, we come to realise that tests such as these are becoming over used. However, many schools and colleges use standardised testing to demonstrate how brilliant their students are. Consequently, there are many factors that cause standardized testing to not only show false views on students intelligence, but some of the factors even have shown that they are an inadequate approach to showing true brilliance. The question that arises from this is: are standardized tests necessary for schools and colleges to…

    • 289 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Standardized tests have become a recent controversial topic across the nation. Americans strive for a great education system, but fail to realize that testing is the main issue. They are believed to be a simple way to evaluate students from all different areas. However, there are countless faults that cannot show truly show students’ ability. Standardized tests in the United States do not accurately measure intelligence and should be modified to prevent issues in academics.…

    • 1852 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Kohn (2000) says, “The tests do not capture what is referred to be a well-educated person.” There are those that object the multiple-choice questions because they are not a true reflection of what the student knows. In addition, the condition that the student takes the test can change the score. Standardized tests promote shallow thinking, the tests are written by people with biases, and the tests may not be reliable. The tests change the curriculum in schools, so students are not learning other subjects that are equally as important. I agree with Gardner that there are many unique kinds of intelligence that people can have. Through standardized testing, we are ignoring many people that are very intelligent but in different areas than the tests. Most standardized tests follow the theory of Spearman and only test the g factor (general intelligence) of the person while ignoring the s factor (specific intelligence). When people are recognized for their unique intelligence, they gain confidence in their abilities. Therefore, I believe that in order to test intelligence accurately, the standardized testing system must be…

    • 1595 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Graders and educators seem to emphasize assignments and grading for performance and understanding. The grading system basically labels a student’s image either being a smart/average/”dumb”. Knowing this will run very deep in how a child careers their self around school or when they have to do an assignment. The grading system makes the student more focused on what they can do to get the grade that is Above Standard than actually care about what they’re researching or learning about, this is assessing students and categorizing them basically in groups based on their knowledge and skill in the course. Teachers do try to motivate their students but it doesn’t always work and students begin to chase their grade and become disinterested in the course material. I saw a post the other day on why students cheat on exams to pass and the top reply was this “When students cheat on exams it’s because of our school system values grades more than students…

    • 784 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In nowadays education system, the grades of students in each subject is determined by their achievements. But some students may not agree with this as they think they have worked very hard to finish the works, but since they have low skills , they can’t achieve high grades and this is unfair to them. I think high grades should be given to achievement rather than effort because the grade is given according to the quality of the work but not the quantity.…

    • 252 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays