Preview

Why Is Athens Better Than Sparta

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
528 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Why Is Athens Better Than Sparta
“Where they differed was that the while the Spartans had militaristic values, Athenian were democratic.” States Mr. Duckworth in the passage, “Athens and Sparta.” People argue based on which place which would have been the better place to be in the past, most people choose Sparta; but a majority have chosen Athens, the better place. Both Athens and Sparta had their own inequalities to make them unique, and wanting people to choose there to live. Athens would have been a better place to live because the families there relied on each other and the men were chosen to be the warriors. Though boys did not have to be a warrior if they didn't chose to be, Young children go the education they needed, and wa not taken from their families to be a warrior, alike Sparta. For instance in the passage it states, “Family ties in Athens stronger where women were legally the dependents of their husbands or their fathers.” This proves the …show more content…
The women did the household chores like cleaning, cooking, and taking care of the people at their home. In Sparta they did have rights and equality with men, “In Sparta Women were stronger and they formed friendships with men as they choose,” stated in “Athens and Sparta.” Therefore rights to talk with men, and women as they wanted to. So yes, they did have more women rights, but helots did their work leaving the women to do nothing at all, and helots to do chores. However, Athens women had power as well, just not as much; “As an Athenian one could get a good education and could pursue several kinds of sciences.” Stated by Mr. Duckworth. As a result, people were chose to be a warrior or get an education, this shows citizenship because their opinion mattered in Athens which as in Sparta it did not. If you were a male child you were forced to be a warrior when you turned 18, and had to train until

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Athenians and Spartans were rulers in their own right and developed different political systems. Athens is the capital and largest city of Greece, the birthplace of democracy. Athenians were patrons that support, protects, and believed in living and dying as a champion. Their foundation was primarily focused on economic growth. Spartans believed in being resilient and self-disciplined. Sparta was extremely powerful after defeating rival city-state Athens in the Peloponnesian War. Sparta was dedicated to the military and to the state. Spartans believed in education and military training.…

    • 88 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The cities of Athens and Sparta were both advanced for their time, but differed in their idea of appropriate women’s roles. While Spartan women were relatively important to the social and political spheres, women in Athens were considered nothing more than breeding machines to produce men for the society’s powerful army. Aside from the fact that both groups of women were married for the sole purpose of bearing children, there are hardly any similarities between the treatment of women in Sparta and Athens.…

    • 429 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    All cities, Empires, and River Valley Civilizations treated women like the lesser of the two sexes. Why was Sparta the first to give women rights? In this article, we will compare Athens to Sparta. Sparta, however, was the first to give women a sufficient amount of their own rights. But why did Sparta finally decide to give women rights? Researchers say that it was their giant win over their rival city-state Messenia. Athens did not have a giant slave population 3 times the size of them, but with Sparta having that big of a slave population, it caused them to need to give women more rights so they could help out around the town.…

    • 2059 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Athens and Sparta in the ancient Greece world are both revered by many modern civilizations as being foundry influences on modern democracy. The two city states, however, were polar opposites in how they viewed democracy and ran their government. Sparta was known for its military prowess and power, while Athens has always been famed for its progress in the arts and sciences. While both being developmentally different and butting heads sometimes, they both were integral voices on how similar democratic societies ran their governments up until today. The defining differences between the two is that Athens was a heavily class based Democracy, compared to Sparta which was more definable as being an Oligarchy.…

    • 668 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Athens was a democracy city-state that elected archons annually (124). Whereas Sparta was ruled by two kings that ruled for life or were forced out of office, and were advised by a Council of Elders (123). Sparta was a war centered society, but Athens focused more on academics and philosophy. Spartan values were centered around being brave, self-disciplined, and honoring and fighting for Sparta, even if it meant death. Trade and agriculture were very important to the Athenian economy (137). Both government styles had elections and voting involved, but it was limited to some based on gender and…

    • 551 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Athens and Sparta were two different political parties, Athens was a democracy, and Sparta was an oligarchy. Even though they were different they were still very alike. The power in Athens was held by the people, and in Sparta there were two kings and 5 Ephors who made laws. However, Athens and Sparta both went to Assembly where citizens could vote for laws and talk about fixing problems. In Athens not many people got to vote though because you had to be an upper class man and had to be over the age of 30. In Sparta very rarely did citizens get a say in anything that was being done. In reality, both places citizens didn’t play a big role in politics. The Athenian democracy wasn’t very fair. The oligarchy did a better role of sticking to the ways an oligarchy actually works.…

    • 624 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Women's Role In Sparta

    • 808 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In Sparta, women were well respected and had multiple roles within society. They were given more freedom than in most other Greek societies. The main reason for this was the fact that Sparta had a warrior culture and the men were away either at war or training for war. while the men were away the women had multiple roles. The most important of which was to give birth to healthy Spartan children to become warriors. Some of the other roles women had included; participating in religious festivals, and managing the kleros.…

    • 808 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Athens vs Sparta

    • 1337 Words
    • 6 Pages

    If you had the choice between living in ancient Athens or ancient Sparta which, would you choose? While one stands for democracy, the other stands for war. Surely having been raised in America, one is more likely to side immediately with the most democratic one. However, not everyone was equal in Athens. Also, although Sparta was almost entirely focused on war, one half of the population was not completely alienated by the other. Athens and Sparta had completely opposite ways of living.…

    • 1337 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Sparta, as a girl I could help with farming. I don’t like slavery, but as a Spartan I could support the conquering of other people to become slaves. The slaves did the hard work and were treated harshly, but if they worked hard enough they could buy their freedom. In Athens, the slaves could have lots of jobs like tutors, but could never be free. Also in Athens they used the sea harbors to trade to make money. Athenians’ land was not that good, so they could not farm as much. Athens had huge marketplaces called Agora, where they used coins to trade. Spartans like life to be simpler. They did not like to trade. They made their money from conquering people and farming. In Sparta the government was ruled by two kings and twenty-eight other men for their entire lives. They were nobles with power to stop and make laws. I like the fact you know who is in charge. In Athens, citizens were randomly chosen to serve for one year. The citizens could suggest laws. I don’t think I would like to serve in government. I rather do what I want to do. Also in Athens everyone has to vote on each…

    • 502 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Athens and Sparta were two of the most powerful and recognizable ancient city-states in Greek history. These two civilizations showed a majority of differences over similarities, although some similarities showed such as gender relations and slavery. Athenian women had little to no rights in the society, staying mostly indoors and only being referred to as someone’s…

    • 881 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Athens and Sparta had lots of things in common, but Athens had and did stuff better than Sparta. Like Athens geography, they were able to develop a strong naval fleet because they were close to the Aegean sea, and geographic features helped influence the development of society. Also, it was easier for Athens to trade because they were close to the Aegean sea. They also had better cultural achievements. Athens had the Olympic games when people come and watch people fight and do tons of activities.…

    • 227 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    The Greek Philosopher Aristotle said regarding Spartan women “…nearly two-fifths of the whole country is in the hands of women…”4 and Plutarch said “…For he exercised the girls’ bodies with races and wrestling and discus and javelin throwing, so that the embryos formed in them would have a strong start in strong bodies and develop better…and would cope well and easily with childbirth.” The way that the women of Sparta are described paints a very different picture of women in Greece. Spartan women had many freedoms and are loosely compared in rights to that of modern women. Since Sparta was a military society the women were expected to produce perfect babies and develop their intellect.5 Since the Spartan men were always away the women were in charge of running everything that didn’t involve the army. Women were also allowed to participate in sporting events and feats of strength just like the men, and were actually encouraged to. Women were also very strict and if a son came home from battle and he wasn’t on his aspis (shield), then he would be forever in shame. This is evident in Plutarch’s Sayings of Spartan Women which depicts accounts of women in normal Spartan society. Examples are “Damatria heard that her son had been a coward and unworthy of her, and when he arrived, she made away with him.” “Another Spartan woman made away with…

    • 1211 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Women In Sparta

    • 1726 Words
    • 7 Pages

    According to many historians such as Powell “The citizen women of Sparta were believed to lead unusual lives by Greek standards.” As stated by Lycurgus in the Great Rhetra women of Sparta were aware of their role in society in regards to staying healthy and fit to produce healthy offspring as well as partaking in the running of the economy. Women in Sparta were treated with the utmost respect, as they were an essential element in the ancient warrior society. Spartan women enjoyed much more freedom then women from the other polis (Greek city states). Spartan women were given great privileges as they involved their prominent positions in society in regards to education, family, religion and the economy, which soon became desired by women all…

    • 1726 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Sparta's Rights

    • 1284 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The men of Sparta are the ones who wrote the constitution of Sparta. When they invaded and conquered the land of Messenia, the Messenians became their slaves, also known as helots, which meant things had to change with the way they ruled their land. The ratio of helots to Spartans was one to seven. The helots were consistently revolting. If the Spartans wanted to win, they needed military training. The need for military training lead to the men of Sparta being sent to live in the military barracks at the age of seven, until they were sixty-five years of age,occasionally being allowed to come home, get married and have kids. With that being said, who was going to rule Sparta? They surely were not going to give the helots the power to own their land, and work in their houses; they made them work in the fields. Their only other option was to allow the women to have rights. The women of Sparta owned up to forty percent of Sparta’s agricultural land; they were publically educated, able to move about freely, and they were outspoken. When they were first given their rights, the women did not want to work or control land that they were not earning anything from. The men had high expectations of the women; eventually, work needed to be done causing the men to give the women incentives to do their jobs properly and efficiently. For example, the women begun gaining some profit off the land they owned. Due to the men being at war, they could not be there to monitor the women doing their jobs, and they needed a way to make sure they did it right. The men had to learn to trust them. This worked for a while until the opportunity cost of women having children skyrocketed; women stopped having children as frequently; the women were allowed to go out and have children with other men if they were stronger and…

    • 1284 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    f I had a choice to live in Athens or Sparta, I would rather live in Athens than Sparta. I know that many people may ask why would you want to leave there where women had no rights. One of the reasons why I would rather live in Athens than Sparta is because I have two sons who are four years old and I would not want them to be taken away from me when they are seven years old. According to Andrews (2013), at the age of seven, Spartan boys were removed from the homes of their parents and were placed in a military-style education program designed to mold them into skilled warriors and moral citizens. Spartans believed that the purpose of education was to produce men and women to protect the city-state and if they baby did not appear to be strong,…

    • 305 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays