Preview

Women In Anne Carson's Putting Her In Her Place

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
604 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Women In Anne Carson's Putting Her In Her Place
Women in Atienct Greek litetrue are describe in "Putting Her in Her Place: Women, Dirt, and Desire" by Anne Carson, as being wet, polluted, leaky and cold. This is used to describe the fact that many Greek writers such as Aristotle and Hesiod believed women to be more irrational than man, and unbounded to anything as men are, meaning women were more prone to sexual desires, jealousy, and emotions. Carson ties interesting points of his argument to certain Greeks myths, and the cultural norms these myths creates. The first being the myth of Pandora, the first women created by the gods for revenge, being the down fall of man. He ties this back to the use of the word polluted, pollution or other variations of the word used when describing women. Polluted is used to describe a women’s touch upon man will pollute him.The other was the myth of Zeus putting a veil on chaos …show more content…
Penelope is shown to be contsently in emotional termilol over odyessus throughout the Odyssey. For much of the book she is seen to be crying until a god take pity on her and allows her to fall asleep. But while Penelope is seen to be very leaky, she is also shown to be very rational, and very bounded to many things. One of this things is the funeral shroud that she uses to trick the suitors for three years by unraveling it at night. This was a very interseting part, because in some way it reence backs to Zues putting a viel on chaos and giving it form. Rather in this intsence the viel is a shroud, Penople is Zeus, and the chaos she is bounding is her solution to keep her husbands home without remarrying, or having to give it up, and to move back in with her parents. Penelope is and intersecting character because she mirrors Zeus first wife in many ways, such as tricking her suitors for three years, and by rational finding out that is Odysseus was the true Odysseus, and not and

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Penelope seemed like the epitome of a loyal wife in The Odyssey. She waited years for Odysseus to return, only marrying when it became a necessity. Penny however, not only chose to get married, but she told Ulysses’s daughters that he died in a train accident so she could cover up the fact that he was in prison. Even with that discrepancy, Penny and Penelope both chose to marry for their children. Penelope decided she needed to choose a suitor, so the suitors would leave. She believed that her son, Telemakhos, needed to start his own life, and her marrying would allow him to live in peace. Penny needed someone to provide for her seven daughters. When Ulysses incredulously asked about her engagement, she replied “I gotta think of the Wharvey gals! They look to me for answers!” (O…art thou) Similarly, Penny and Penelope both needed convincing before they returned to their husbands. When Odysseus had returned, Penelope believed a suitor disguised as Odysseus . To test him, Penelope asked one of the maids to move their bed into the hallway so Odysseus could sleep in it. Odysseus became enraged because the bed was carved in an oak tree that grew through the bedroom, therefore rendering it immovable. Penny knew that only Odysseus would know this, so she welcomed him back. Ulysses disguised himself as a poor musician, snuck…

    • 1261 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    With Odysseus’s departure twenty years prior, Ithaca has descended into chaos, by a swarm of suitors, who plague the palace, and pursue Odysseus’s wife and queen, Penelope. Odysseus father, Laertes, and Penelope, his wife and queen, are the two individuals who truly test him— he returns the favour—, as personifications of Ithaca, they act as stepping stones in his reinstitution as head of his household and kingdom.…

    • 427 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The engrossing story, The Odyssey, tells the tale of the heroic Odysseus’ journey to reach home after the Trojan War. In the first four books, the reader learns about Odysseus through other characters eyes. They follow the footsteps of Telemakhos, the son of Odysseus, and his awakening to save his father. Telemakhos’s house is being overrun by his mother's’ suitors, however dear Penelope can’t help change that. Telemakhos is then visited by Athena, in which she arouses him and gives him the confidence and steady mind to search for word on his father. Telemakhos and the reader can interpret from the stories told about Odysseus that he was an important warrior and is thought to be dead. Therefore he is held to a higher respect than most Trojan…

    • 264 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Greeks value loyalty very high in women. You can tell throughout the book that its just fine for men to run off and be with whomever they please, but women must be loyal to their husbands. That is just the Greek culture. Right from the start, anyone can tell that Penelope is extremely loyal. As soon as her husband leaves for Troy, she never even sets eyes on another man, not for years, and is struck with grief every moment he is not with her. Then, when he finally does come home, she is the happiest she has ever been in the Odyssey. The more [Penelope] spoke, the more a deep desire for tears welled uphe wept as he held the wife he loved, in his arms at last. Joy (259-262.23). Even though everyone says that her beloved husband is dead, she refuses to believe it. And while he isnt home yet, the suitors try to marry her but she is firm in her position. She even expresses her loyalty verbally: [my] pain [and] my tears have streaked [my bed], year in, year out, from the day Odysseus sailed away to seeDestroyI hate to say its name! (471-473.19) Penelope is always waiting for him to come home from Troy. She never stops believing in Odysseus. This proves she is loyal because if she wasnt, she would have married a suitor years and years before Odysseus finally got home and if she didnt, then when Odysseus came disguised as a beggar, she wouldnt have been nearly as interested.…

    • 660 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Odysseus’s main flaw was hubris, or his excessive pride. His hubris was revealed when he taunted Polyphemus after escaping the island. Odysseus’s yells of triumph gave the monster a final chance to kill the crew with a boulder, which he nearly did. More importantly, though, was the fact that the hero stated his name to the beast, allowing Polyphemus to pray to his father, Poseidon, to make Odysseus’s journey as treacherous as possible. In contrast, Penelope was never illustrated as flawed. While she was deeply saddened by Odysseus’s absence, this never directly resulted to any misfortune. This demonstrates yet again that Penelope simply was not developed as a heroine in the way that Odysseus was a…

    • 684 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In most Greek mythology there is a general hostility towards the female sex, which relays that most poets and writers themselves were sexist. Throughout Hesiod’s Theogony and Works and Days, women are portrayed in a very subservient manner, placing them far below men and are almost despised. However, in more than one instance, manipulation, women’s true power, is shown. They are constantly described as beautiful temptresses, which could be thought of as the weakness of many men. When Theogony and Works and Days are looked at as a whole it is obvious that Hesiod’s opinion of women, most likely shared by the Greeks themselves, is that they are inferior and subordinate to men.…

    • 736 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    him staying with her. Odysseus loves Penelope and is loyal to getting home to her and his…

    • 832 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Odyssey Comparison

    • 794 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Penelope's devotion to Odysseus can be compared to the soldiers' wives devotion to him while he is at war. Penelope's devotion is shown through the shroud that she is weaving. She absolutely refuses to pick a new suitor until she is done with the shroud. Every day she would work on the shroud and every night she would undo the work she did, therefore delaying having to pick a new husband. In comparison, when the soldiers are sent off to war the wives of the soldiers are devoted to them by way of mail. On the other hand, the wives of the soldiers are not forced to pick a new suitor as soon as their husbands are sent off to war. Also Penelope is a Queen, therefore making her a prize to all the flocking suitors who want to become King of Ithaca.…

    • 794 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Obstacles in the Odyssey

    • 540 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In “Penelope”, Odysseus displays decision making. He meets his wife, Penelope, for the first time in twenty years. Even though he has had to wait so long to see her, Odysseus knows that in order for his plan to succeed for killing the suitors, he has to keep his identity a secret. Additionally, Odysseus also avoids telling Penelope about his home by lying and saying that it will cause him too much pain to talk about it. This episode illustrates triumph because Odysseus succeeds at killing all the suitors in the end. Hiding his true identity from Penelope allows Odysseus to have the element of surprise on his side when he attacks the suitors. He also learns of what has become of his kingdom and how Penelope feels about him…

    • 540 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Odysseus Is Selfish

    • 331 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Odysseus is a very Selfish man. In other words, he puts himself before others. When Odysseus and his crew sailed past the Sirens, he made the team put wax in their ears. He tied himself up so he could be the only man alive to hear their song. In addition to that, He cheated on his wife, Penelope. She is sitting at home in Ithaca worried sick sand just wants her husband home. Little does she know Odysseus has cheated on her. If Penelope had cheated on him, she probably would be killed.…

    • 331 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Penelope from the Odyssey adhered closely to the expectations Greek society placed on women. She possessed womanly characteristics prescribed to women such as loyalty and patience, which she displayed when she waited 10 years for Odysseus to return. In the beginning of the epic, Penelope was upset when the bard was singing about the Trojan War. In response, Telemachus told Penelope, “Go therefore back in the house, and take up your own work, the loom and the distaff, and see to it that your handmaidens ply their work also; but the men must see to discussion, all men but I most of all. For mine…

    • 629 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ancient Greek Mythology

    • 755 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The myth states that Penelope was the wife of Odysseus, and in the myth the Odyssey, Odysseus was gone for 20 years and even after that time Penelope was loyal to Odysseus. Penelope is a good role model because she has no negative choices while waiting for Odysseus and there is no myth of selfishness or self-pity of Penelope.…

    • 755 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    After the war of Troy, Odysseus was lost at sea and Penelope gave up most of her hope after years of waiting for her husband to return home. Later on Suitors came to court her in the castle where Penelope and her son Telemachus lived. There are so many ways that Penelope showed her loyalty to her husband while he was away. One way Penelope shows her loyalty is no matter how the suitors courted her and wanted to marry her she never went with a suiter. Another reason is that she never completely gave up hope that her husband was alive. The final reason is that she defended Odysseus's memory. In The Odyssey, Penelope showed her loyalty to her husband multiple times throughout the epic poem.…

    • 847 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Women in The Odyssey

    • 754 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Penelope is the wife of Odysseus who is the king of Ithaca. When Odysseus is called off to the Trojan War Penelope shows great faithfulness and wit. She stays faithful to her husband and waits for him for twenty years. This shows strong internal will and love for only one man, her husband, Odysseus. During this time, many different suitors tried to court her and offered marriage proposals. She shows great wit by prolonging the time needed to find a new suitor. "... she has been deluding the wits of a whole nation. Hopes for all, promises for every man by special messenger- and what she means is quite different." (Homer, 1994-2009) She fools wanting suitors by pretending to weave a burial shroud for Odysseus’s elderly father. She says that she will choose a suitor when she is finished. Every night for three years she undoes part of the shroud. One of the female maids finds this out and tells. The action of the maid showed how bad deeds of women can change the instance of what is going on. When Odysseus came home he posed as a beggar Penelope again shows her strong wits by not falling right to him. She says that she will court with the one who can string Odysseus’s bow and shoot through twelve axe shafts. Obviously, Odysseus is the only one with the skill to do that. She then is still on guard. This again shows that she, as a woman, as intelligence that she still has her guard up, which she should. However, when the bed is ordered to be moved to the wedding chamber and Odysseus says that he knows it cannot be moved. She then has all the information she needs to believe that Odysseus is who he says he is.…

    • 754 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Telemachus challenges him to a fight. Odysseus doesn?t fight back as he is his only son. Before Telemachus kills Odysseus, Odysseus says ?I forgive you?. As soon as he dies, Athene turns his appearance back into the Odysseus with was about to go to troy. Telemachus has a flash back of being in his dad?s arms and he realises that he has killed his dad. He commits suicide with the same sword he killed his dad with. Penelope comes and sees the body. She says it is a joke from the gods which was intended to hurt her on her wedding day. She just mourns for her son. Then Hermes comes and announces that the Gods were unhappy at her disrespect for Odysseus and her blaming the gods. Also she hadn?t kept faithful to Odysseus and as a punishment, she was immortal. Any more offspring would be mortal and now she has to see all of her friends die when she doesn?t. Also this means that she cannot meet up in the underworld with Odysseus and Telemachus. From that day on, the gods made her life a living hell. She made Odysseus? kingdom a ruin and it was a bad place to…

    • 348 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays