Darren Jenkins
Class-3
February 5, 2013
The Dispossessed Response
I’m not going to lie, while reading The Dispossessed I found myself very confused. This is partially due to the fact that I do not know anything about politics. William Deresiewicz studied the working class and the stigmas it holds. In The Dispossessed he illustrates his observations and talks about how the working class is viewed by society today. Deresiewicz highlights on some observations that I would have never noticed. The first is that T.V. shows today are not revolved around working class families. Personally, I think that since 80% of the U.S. workforce is considered working class, people do not want to watch a show about what they are experiencing in their everyday lives. They want to see the extravagant lifestyle that they could have had if they were given the resources and opportunities. The working class hasn’t been taught to believe that they’re entitled to do the best of everything, and they will take what life brings to them. Deresiewicz mentions that, “working class people care more about their families and their friends and the places they’re from than they do about their careers.” I agree with Deresiewicz and believe that most working class people worry more about the things that are going on around them such as friends and the place they’re from rather than worrying about making the right steps in order to get to the middle class and have a good career.
Deresiewicz also highlights that race is starting to become a surrogate for class. He suggests, “When we are shown a working class black we see a poor person-when we are shown a working class white, we don’t see anything at all.” I am not a racist whatsoever, but I don’t blame Deresiewicz for making this assumption. I have hung around people that automatically assume a black person is homeless just because he is walking down the street with plastic bags. I would like to bring up the point that racism is still a very common thing today. It seems like even if we do see a successful black person we associate them with being a very “white” black. I am actually guilty of this premise as well. Whenever I meet a black individual that dresses nice or talks proper, I immediately assume that they grew up around a white neighborhood. It is terrible to think this way, but I am sure that there are other people that feel the same way.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
In the three essays that we were assigned to read have connections. In “Serving in Florida” by Barbara Ehrenreich, she decided to work in low paying jobs that pay minimum wage. An example of this is when it states “the multinational mélange of cooks; the dishwashers, who are all Czechs here” (364). This example relates to Diana Kendall when it states, “The working class and the working poor do not fare much better than the poor and homeless in media representations” (428). These quotes express how the working class can be. An example from Gregory Mantsios that corresponds with these when it states “From cradle to grave, class position has a significant [...] economic success” (391).…
- 474 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
To begin with, the media portrays false images of how poor the lower class is, how lazy they are as a result of their own life choices.We see similar portrays of false images in Bell Hooks essay “Seeing And Making Culture: Representing The Poor” . For instance, Bell Hooks describes how the lower class is portrayed incorrectly through social media based on personal experience when she states the comments of her peers and professors, “they almost always portrayed the poor as shiftless, mindless, lazy, dishonest, and unworthy” (Hooks 484). This quote is a prime example of how the lower class are expected not strive and work as hard as other people and are seen as not good enough.…
- 120 Words
- 1 Page
Good Essays -
Life happens in ways you cannot control. People have hard times to achieve an education due conflicts they have no control over. Many statistics show the many ways of what will most likely happen to people that are born into a certain class. In the articles, “Homeless on Campus” by Eleanor J. Bador, “Fremont High School” by Jonathan Kozol, and “Of the 1%, by the 1%, for the 1%” by Joseph E. Stiglitz, show many ways of how society forms one person’s life in a way they cannot control. America displays their citizens as equal, but these reports published by the authors suggest otherwise by explaining the unequal lifestyles of the high, middle, and low class of America.…
- 1542 Words
- 7 Pages
Better Essays -
The sociological imagination is something that I think a lot of people can’t and don’t want to understand. Most lower middle class families are only focused on one thing, and that is there…
- 553 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
The Glasgow university media group found that the working class were often portrayed on TV news as ‘trouble’ – either involved in ‘strikes’ or involved in jostling or fighting with the police, for example the London riots in 2011. From a Neo-Marxists perspective this is no surprise because the media are simply acting against anti-capitalist groups in order to maintain ruling class ideological control. Also Skeggs (2004) felt that TV representations of the working class show them being low in value in comparison to the middle classes – for example shows such as Jeremy Kylie and Wife swap. This shows that the mass media can have a negative impact on creating and reinforcing identities of the working class in the contemporary…
- 641 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
E. Franklin Frazier’s Black Bourgeoisie was more prophetic than many realized. Frazier, who addressed the burgeoning black middle class, expressed concern about the intra-class conflict vis-a-vis socioeconomic status of black folks. Frazier notes that the black middle class was in a rush by the 1960s to assimilate. During the Harlem Renaissance, even W.E.B. Du Bois “strategically included white judges on panels for their black literary competitions, in hopes that white approval would add luster to black achievements.” This shift that occurred was not a mass or universal one. The black middle class was still small and would not be catapulted until after the advent of Affirmative Action.…
- 485 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
For social mobility its is keeping it the way it has been the lower class aren’t able to move up when these prices are so high.…
- 1307 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
Poverty can be defined by the necessities and amenities that one does not have in their life. Due to the expectations created by our society, we have a tendency to judge others based on the clothes they wear or the cars they drive, and we automatically assume that those who cannot afford these luxuries are either uneducated, unskilled or a combination of both. We completely disregard the fact that not all people have control of their financial stability and that anything can damage their current state of wealth. Even the wealthiest of families can find themselves making their way to the bottom due to an unfortunate tragedy such as a death in the family or being laid off from a job, both of which are aspects that cannot be predicted or prevented, and the only thing families can do is accept it. The American Myth claims that someone from the humblest of beginnings can achieve success, but this statement could not be more false. Although a major cause of poverty is financial trouble, a key component that factors in is how the past affects the future. Those who come from troubled beginnings often lead a life of poor behavior and bad decision making skills. Some even work their lives away and still continue to struggle financially, mainly because they had no foundation to build upon due to the fact that they had to start from the absolute bottom.…
- 712 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
"Nearly 36 million Americans one in eight now live in poverty and tens of millions more are considered working poor" (Melvin Claxton & Ronald J. Hansen). This quote shows that a large part of the population fit into the lower class. They make a nice target, but aren't the only class that is effected by the American work ethic. The American work ethic is a job standard created as an expectation put on the shoulders of the lower, middle, and upper class in many different ways. One class might be effected more than another, but in the end we are all created equal.…
- 892 Words
- 4 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Richard Butsch’s essay “Five Decades and Three Hundred Sitcoms about Class and Gender” had me thinking about what we are watching on television. He brought up amazing points saying that characters depicting working class men are shown to be dumb, irresponsible, messy, and unreliable (Butsch, 2005, p. 459). Those in the middle class are shown as sensible, intelligent, and mature. One great example that comes to mind is the show Yes Dear. It has two sets of parents living together because one of them cannot afford rent. The dad of the working class family is overweight. His wife constantly has to tell him how to take care of the kids. His children outsmart him and are shown to be out of control at times. On the other hand, the middle class family has a calm, brilliant child. He constantly has to give the working class dad guidance in his day to day decision making. The working class dad is represented as a failure at life, at supporting his family, and the main element highlighted in his role is how stupid he is. The middle class dad is always the calmer one, he takes care of everything whenever a crisis arises, he teaches his kids manners, and is shown as a loving husband. I cannot find any examples of middle class men that are portrayed in the same demeaning way as working class men.…
- 831 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
A child’s imagination runs wild when they are young. They want to be an astronaut, a police officer, a fire fighter, etc. They want to be all these things all at once just because they probably heard a fairytale story or seen an animated show about them. So they would start to pretend and act like they are these people. I think parents should allow their child to express their imagination. This will build their creativity and expand their career choices. This will lead children down the right path and allow them to know right from wrong at a young age. For example, the author, Bruno Bettelheim, wrote in paragraph 2 in the story, The Child’s Need for Magic that “fairy tales proceeds in a manner which conforms to the way a child thins and experiences the world. A child can gain much better solace from a fairy tale than he can from an effort to comfort him based on adult reasoning and viewpoints. A child trusts what the fairy story tells because its world view accords with his own.” All the stories will be true to a child because their thinking is animistic.…
- 593 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Thesis Statement: Advising Canada on the people out there that are working poor and on the poverty that is happening around our country.…
- 2146 Words
- 9 Pages
Powerful Essays -
However, Miller (1962) argues that the lower working class have their own subculture with different values of the mainstream society which doesn’t value success and thus the members are not frustrated by their status and deviance occurs when people try to achieve their own goals.…
- 510 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Once one receives this title of the working class as their social status, it is very difficult to come back up on top. This is illustrated in Ehrenreich’s “Serving in Florida.” Once Ehrenreich immersed herself in the flurry of her routine of work, sleep, and eat, she realized that there was little to no room for advancement in society (Ehrenreich, p. 290-303). This is because of what one calls subsistent wages, meaning that what one is paid is only enough for survival; the individual MUST work so that they may afford the very basic of necessities, and their work is the only thing they can afford to focus on or else they will not survive.…
- 709 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
I would consider myself now at the moment a lower middle class individual because I have an 8 am - 5 pm job as simulator technician at oil based company. But sometimes I would like to consider myself a upper middle class individual just by the way I carry myself around people but I am still a lower middle class. My life consists of working a job of required skills of which not just any person can fill. I had to go to numerous classes and pass the exams in order to be certified a simulator technician. But honestly after reading this chapter and understanding the six social classes in the United States identified by Lloyd Warner, I really want to achieve more in my job and move myself up the success later. I really did not know that there was anything close to this type of description of social classes. I can appreciate this and realize where I am in life and give myself a reality check and see if I want to settle where I am or strive to the top and put out 100 % of my ability to work harder for an exceptional lifestyle that I would enjoy to the fullest. By labeling myself lower-middle class I can see where I am in life and continue to strive for better and hopefully enjoy some conspicuous consumption because I feel intended for that I keep telling myself I want to achieve more as in education and income wise. Now I as far as some of my friends I would have to consider them the same category or upper lower class. Some of my friends settle for their position in society and never really consider really trying to improve or better their lifestyle. I guess some of my friends haven’t had a reality check or taken “sociology” in order to comprehend the situation a person lives in like I did. I honestly thought I lived in middle class society but society differs from place to place. I thought of myself as a middle class individual before taking this sociology class. Then I came to a sudden realization of the six different social classes and gave me motivation and desire to…
- 523 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays