Preview

WW1 Conscription Persuasive Essay

Satisfactory Essays
Open Document
Open Document
272 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
WW1 Conscription Persuasive Essay
Conscription During World War One

There were more deaths than there were volunteers and the soldiers should not have to die in vain; therefore, conscription was the right course of action for Canada during World War 1.
In the beginning of World War 1, people were excited and more than willing to volunteer to fight as soldiers in the war but as the war progressed, people realized that the war was really extremely antagonizing and muderous. Once people stopped voluteering to be in the war, there were not enough people to replace the dead on the battlefield. In law of conscription had to be enforced. Without the introduction of conscription, Canada would have run out of men much quicker. With the lack of men on the battlefield, Canadian soldiers would not have been able to hold off the German attacks so they would have lost the war. Canada owes it's victory to conscription.
Some people say that conscription was taking away people's free will, and for that reason, it was a mistake for Canada. If conscription was not introduced, than all the hard work, effort and money that the soldiers put into the war would have gone to waste. Canada sent over 500 000 soldiers to fight in the war and spent approximately $1 665 576 000 in food, supplies, weapons and equipment. It would be dishonourable toward the soldiers if they had died for nothing.
Concription was the right course of action for Canada due to the fact that there were more deaths than there were volunteers and the soldiers should not have to die in vain during World War

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Before war, Canada’s “tinpot navy” had 350 sailors and 2 warships (the Niobe and the Rainbow). When Canada first entered the First World War in August 1914. Within two months, Canada sent a contribution of 30,000 men. As the great world war continued, Robert Borden managed to get 100 000 more volunteers. He had Sam Hughes lead the military and Borden provided them with weapons, ammunition, uniforms and food. Although the weapons and the uniforms were not the best, they got the job done and saved Canada money. While some were off the war, Robert had to get the rest of Canada into “war mode”. Since Canada had to provide food for the Canadian and British military, Borden had to make sure food at home was not going to waste. Everyone had to stretch the life of their food and find ways to preserve them so that they are good for a longer period of time and the army would be able to eat. Although war came as a surprise, Robert Borden displayed phenomenal leadership by organizing a strong military and getting Canada into "war mode" quickly. As a result, Canada was a part of the winning side of…

    • 1033 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    David W. Barno writes in “A New Moral Compact,” about the current problem of having a volunteer military. He writes about the current war the United States is in as well as, previous wars like the Vietnam War. Barno’s main issue is that the population has distanced itself from the military and are less skeptical about going to war. He proposes, “. . .that every use of military force over 60 days would automatically trigger an annual draft lottery to call up 10,000 men and women” (20). Barno believes this will draw the population closer to the war effort eventually, becoming hesitant about going to war. Barno states, “It has also effectively lowered our national threshold for decisions to conduct military operations or go to war” (17). As war…

    • 554 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Was King Mackenzie Guilty or innocent for introducing conscription? King Mackenzie was part of the liberal party and he became Prime Minster of Canada in 1921 - 1926 and also in 1935 - 1948. King had won by a majority vote in the federal election and became prime minster. King as the leader the liberal party had promised that he would not introduce conscription but he had lied. A bill had passed to have conscription overseas which the citizens had voted for. King Mackenzie is the one blame for introducing conscription into the world during world war two. He is guilty for introducing conscription because he knew that this was the last thing that Canada needed and the main causes for introducing conscription is Militarism, French and English…

    • 382 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Conscription also known as Australia’s National Service ‘Scheme’ was introduced to Australia by the Menzies Government in 1964. The selection of conscripts was determined by a televised ballot system based on date of birth, 20 year olds were obligated to register for conscription which required them to give two years of national service.…

    • 561 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Imagine. You're a Canadian citizen living through out World War II. As the war ends you're proud to have survived the horrific battle, but over hear someone asking what significant features Canada had with the war. How would you feel? What would you say? No matter who you were during that time frame, you would've had a notable and vital role even if you weren't a solider. Allied victory in World War II was in large part aided by Canadian involvement in the form of the BCATP, Economic Change and Women's Rights.…

    • 582 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Main reasons for conscripting troops were: supporting the mother country Great Britain, equality of sacrifice, and Australian troops had a good reputation that needed defending. Voluntary recruitment had failed to bring in enough troops after the news from the war fronts spread to Australia. Many men were too scared or just couldn’t be bothered saying “What have I got to join for. I have no wife, no children & no parents depending on me so why should I fight. Let those fight that have something to fight for.” Main reasons against conscription were: there wouldn’t be enough people to work, the working class would burden the fight, too many Australians had died already and it would divide Australia even more. Many believed that no one had the right to send someone else to be wounded or killed or to kill or wound someone else. Both sides fought strongly but after two referendums and a whole year of debating the Australian public chose to not go forth with the…

    • 776 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    twerk

    • 2520 Words
    • 11 Pages

    600,000 men and women participated in the war by enlisting as nurses, soldiers and chaplains.[2] In general, non-whites were not welcomed into the military. When blacks from Sydney, Nova Scotia volunteered their services, they were told, "This is not for you fellows, this is a white man's war."[3] Nonetheless, some segregated units were formed. In 1915, Aboriginal Canadians were allowed to enlist and accepted into a 114th battalion as well as others. In total, about 3,500 Aboriginal Canadians would serve with the Canadian Forces, but this figure has been disputed.[4] The Canadian Japanese Association in British Columbia put forward a volunteer reserve force of 227 men, some of whom were later admitted into the military. The No. 2 Construction Battalion included black soldiers from both Canada and the United States, the latter having crossed into Canada in order to participate.[3] The over one thousand Black Canadians who served would continue to be segregated during their tour, both on ships and in camps.[3] The CEF included over 2,000 Black and West Indians who were not segregated or part of No 2 Construction Battalion. Records can be found at Library and Archives Canada.…

    • 2520 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many Americans believed that Canada played no part in the Vietnam war. Through the Canadian government tried its best to remain neutral, Canadians themselves become involved. Some Canadians joined because they could get training in areas not available in Canada, for example helicopter flying and trained mechanics. Some joined because they wanted to fight against communism. Others joined for the adventure of personal reasons. And some people joined military because they saw the military as a place to start a great career.…

    • 484 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Once war was seen as inevitable, recruitment officers were sent out to roundup as many suitable young men as possible. However, the definition of suitable by the Royal Patriarch did not include Aboriginals. Records show that the reasoning for this is stated as “‘while British troops would be proud to be associated with their fellow subjects, Germans might refuse to extend them the privileges of civilized warfare.’ ” (Aboriginal People in Canadian…), This comment was made as a stereotypical portrayal of Aboriginal People was still being used in public media, and as so, Aboriginals were seen as only capable of using techniques such as scalping, and torture. These assumptions were based off of the latest motion picture of the time “Red Indian”, and these method were deemed unacceptable for the rules of war that had been laid out at the Geneva Conference. (Aboriginal People in …), So the enlisting of Aboriginals was strictly prohibited. At least it should have…

    • 679 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Canada Prepares for WWI

    • 986 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Before the war had begun, Canada’s main focus was not on becoming stronger by building the military, but on developing the country in other ways such as promoting immigration. Almost all of Canadian soldiers were volunteers, which illustrates how Canada did not have a real army before the war began. Canada had a regular army of just over 3000 people out of over 600 000 Canadians that served in the war (Swettenham, 1). Canada’s small military power is also demonstrated when compared to other countries. By 1914, Britain had a regular army of almost 245,000 troops (“British...” par. 2); France had an army of 777,000 regular troops in 1914 (“French...” par. 1); Russia, the largest of them all, had 1,400,000 soldiers when they entered the war (“Glossary...” par. 1). Taking a look at these numbers shows just how small Canada’s army of 3000 was. The most significant country to compare to Canada was Germany, as the North German Confederation and the Canadian confederation were both created n 1867 (Swettenham, 1). Compared with Canada’s regular army of just over 3000 soldiers, Germany had a huge 856 000 soldiers only in their regular army (Swettenham, VIII). Germany was much more devoted to building a large army that challenged Britain’s great army, while Canada was not committed to…

    • 986 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Conscription had forced young men to fight away from their home country. Many people saw this as unfair and wrong. This too caused a lot of controversy and many arguments were made against the government for introducing this.…

    • 1002 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The Conscription Crisis of 1917 is that there is a depleting amount of soldiers who are fighting and even less who are enlisting. This year was one of worry and despair. After the recruiting effort in Quebec failed Canada turned to its only unused option; conscription (Wikipedia). Conscription is the horrid act of a government forcing individuals to go to war. After countless years of discrimination Canada is now forcing French Canadian to enlist, although Prime Minister Borden promised not to result to this. To make matters worse they are making conscientious objectors (people whose religious beliefs went against the war) go to war (The History Archive). After countless protests and outcries from the people this so called democracy did not listen (The History Archive). They also did not consider the families that would be torn apart and the men who had not chosen this to be their fate. Although war efforts are looking bad conscription should never be the choice.…

    • 941 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Conscription forced young men to fight away from their home country. Many people saw this as unfair and wrong. One of the main problems with the war was the issue of conscription.…

    • 1198 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    There is a common saying:” Nations are made in war.” According to many, Vimy Ridge was the first time when Canadians really felt a sense of national identity. Just like the famous comment made by Brigadier General Alex Cross "It was Canada from the Atlantic to the Pacific on parade. I thought …that in those few minutes I witnessed the birth of a nation." The Ridge was a key position of the German defence system in northern France. Here the four divisions of the Canadian advanced side by side for the first time. Here the young volunteers from across the nation trained and fought as “Canadians”, not just a part of the Empire. Here the commanders invented the “rolling barrage”. Here a full-scale replica of the battlefield was built and the soldiers trained day and night. At Vimy Ridge, the Canadians captured more ground and prisoners than any previous British attack. However, the battle at Vimy came at a high cost: the 16,000 casualties brought devastation to home while victory was celebrated and the conscription debate shook the fragile unity in the country. Anyway, Vimy Ridge showed that although Canada has never had a huge army or talked about patriotism all the time, her people can fight, and fight well when they need to.…

    • 706 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Sociology

    • 1219 Words
    • 5 Pages

    For the sake of national unity, Prime Minister of Canada Mackenzie King of 1935- 1948 did not want to repeat mistakes that had occurred in the past (Quinlan, 50). As World War 1 unfolded Mackenzie King was forced to change his views on conscription (Quinlan, 50). Canada’s military had let in new troops and prepared them for war, during this time they believed conscription would not be necessary (Nelson, 42). The first military conscription divided the country (The diary of William Lyon Mackenzie King). On September 3rd, 1939, Britain and France declared war on Germany following the invasion of Poland by German troops. Mackenzie King held a special seating of Parliament with a vote directly following the debate in the House of Commons; a referendum was the elite alternative to his dilemma. “Are you in favour of releasing the government from any obligations raising men for military service?” this was what Mackenzie King had come up with. After the vote, 82.3 percent of voters, voted yes in Ontario, In British Columbia 79.49 percent vote yes. In Quebec 72.4 voters said “Non” (Quinlan, 50). This was when Mackenzie King found himself in the same position as Borden during the World War 1. Mackenzie was forced to decide between French and English voters. Firstly, for the first time being, Mackenzie King did not enforce conscription, “Not necessarily conscription, but conscription if necessary.” (Quinlan, 51). Furthermore, Mackenzie King had just made his first general tough decision that did not initialize conscription just yet but had to send men to war under the NRMA draft. Lastly, there was an election and Mackenzie made promises that he could not keep. This tells us a lot about Mackenzie and his contribution to the war.…

    • 1219 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays