Preview

Xunzi Vs Mencius Analysis

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1577 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Xunzi Vs Mencius Analysis
For centuries, mankind has struggled with the question, "Are we good by nature?" Do we do good deeds only out of selfish desires, or is there a real shred of decency somewhere in our being? Even today, lawyers argue whether a killer's motives for committing atrocious crimes stem from the fact that he has a naturally incompetent tendency, or if outside influences, such as a difficult childhood, turned a naturally innocent person into a murderer. The Chinese philosophers, Mencius and Xunzi, explored this difficulty in their philosophies. While both considered themselves disciples of the philosopher, Confucius, their perspective on humans were different. Mencius had an optimistic view of humans, while Xunzi saw humans as creatures in need of reform. …show more content…
He gives an example that when one is hungry, his natural is to eat without thinking of other people first. It is only because of artificial social convention that he thinks about other people eating before him. Because these tendencies are undesirable, Xunzi believes that they must be transformed rather than developed. He compares moral development to straightening a board or sharpening metal. It must, in effect, be reshaped. The solution, Xunzi writes, is that "one must be transformed by the example of a teacher and guided by the way of ritual and rightness before one will attain modesty and yielding, accord with refinement and ritual, and return to order." He argues that if people were truly innately good, there would be no need for social norms and rituals. People perform these rituals, Xunzi argues, because they desire to be good people, showing that they are not good. Xunzi's view of human nature is fairly accurate to today's society. While I believe that the majority of humans do not belong to the extreme end of immorality, there is a common desire to become good people. The self-improvement section of a bookstore contains resources to better oneself, and good deeds such as donating money to a charity or even attending church can be considered modern "rituals". What ultimately seems to define a person's living testimony is how good of a person he or she was; the activities and situations he or she was in to claim himself as a "good person". The Catholic church even shares Xunzi's view, teaching that the number of good works a person does determines whether they go to heaven, purgatory, or hell. Relating to Xunzi's argument that rituals would be unnecessary had human nature been good, the same goes for the various opportunities to become good in today's society. If we are truly good, then these

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The article “’Bros Before Hos’: The Guy Code” by Michael Kimmel, chronicles the negative perception that men have for the “weaker” man through a list of unwritten rules of men. It stated that this “guy code,” was or is, essentially, what defined masculinity. Many descriptions of weakness include homophobic words like “faggot” and “gay.” Words that pertain more to women, like “pussy” or “mama’s boy,” are also used as an insult to describe a man’s weakness. This is because of the low status that men had been taught throughout the years. Masculinity, Kimmel says, is attributed through peers, male figures in their lives, and a “hard-wired” definition of what being man means. Once a man steps outside of those lines, the risk is looking being emasculated.…

    • 364 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Assignment 5 Price

    • 1866 Words
    • 6 Pages

    To Confucius, good people lived good lives, which in turn caused good societies to be formed from the deeds of these individuals. He believed that education should focus on shaping individuals into good people; people with “virtue and excellence”. One of his ideas, called ren, is directly translated into “human excellence”, “benevolence” and “love”. According to Confucius ren is not something that is inherent in every individual, however, humans are able obtain ren through cognitive thinking and effort. Confucius believes that every person has certain qualities inside of them that can make them good. For instance he believed that every individual possessed wisdom, kindness, respect and piety.…

    • 1866 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Created by Confucius, the Confucian ethical system there are thought to be six different basics known as xi, zhi, li, yi, wen, and ren. Xi is, ‘the original good, evil or nothing’ that man is born with. In Confucianism, xi does not contain any original goodness or badness because of this Confucius believes that people must learn to act ethically since it is not an original part of their nature. Zhi is the natural substance of which a person is made, but it is not naturally received, people is acquire zhi through education.There is an inference that an individual acquiring li has a sense of fairness or equity. Li not only shapes character, but motivates the individual to behave. Yi is the standard by which all acts must be judged, yi represents mortally. Wen is something that one does for fun, such as music, poetry, and art. Ren is considered the highest virtue in Confucianism, a person who acquires ren is mastering the way of virtue, morality, compassion and love. This person is reaching the highest levels of moral perfection in a specific aspect of life.…

    • 449 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mencius proves that people are naturally virtuous by using an illustration of a baby that has fallen into a well. He explains that people will have the urge to assist the baby immediately and will feel concern therefore, humans are good. However, he argues that society can taint one’s inner virtue. If individuals begin to trail after their greed for materialistic objects in the world, then people will succumb to evil. People should cultivate their morals and develop a sense of goodness throughout their…

    • 900 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The collection of dialogues that Confucius had with his students and with statesmen known as ‘Analects’ was highly influential in the philosophy and moral values of Imperial China.[5]In the conversations, Confucius’s thoughts are recorded including his belief in the powers of moral…

    • 2972 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The good and evil of human nature is a controversial problem in the Chinese and foreign history, Majority of ethicists such as Laozi, Mengzi, Xunzi etc. published their own opinions on human nature, good and evil in human nature of the different answer to construct the theory system. The most significant influence about ancient Chinese history theory of human nature of is Mencius’s theory of "goodness" which I believe is the impressed content I learned from ancient Chinese philosophy.…

    • 916 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Didion's on Morality

    • 782 Words
    • 4 Pages

    What is it that forms and drives our “moral behaviors”? Are we born with a basic sense of morality or do we develop a set of moral “social codes” to keep society from falling into chaos and anarchy? In her essay “On Morality,” Joan Didion dissects what lies beneath the surface of humanity’s morality. By recounting several stories and historical events, she shows that morality at its basic “most primitive level” is nothing more than “our loyalties to the ones we love,” everything else is subjective.…

    • 782 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    According to the Analects, or the scripture within the main Confucian book, benevolence is the most principal of the religion's virtues, including empathy, humanity, love and thoughtfulness (ibid, 137, 144). The faith states that men who wish to consider themselves of superior nature should not only carry out these attributes through right actions, but also be properly motivated with the correct mindset while executing them (ibid, 144, 145).…

    • 618 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    To every child, good or bad seemed very clear to mind. If one stole another’s belongings, lie to their parents, or hurt anyone in any way, it would be seen as a wrong doing, as a morally incorrect behavior. But somehow, as life becomes more complicated, everything that has been done might be based on multiple reasons involving both positive and negative elements. Any act of good cannot be explained as simply because of one’s kindness, and this principle can go with an ill-minded act as well.…

    • 1872 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Hsun Tzu's, "Man's Nature is Evil" the author explains why the human characteristics are wicked. The author uses basic illustrations of people's jealousy and envy to prove that human nature is truly evil. Tzu's essay proves through many examples that man's nature is evil, and that everything that is considered good comes from people that go against their "evil nature" to make the concept of morality. Hsun Tzu's "Man's Nature is Evil" is a great analysis of human nature to suppose that in fact, man's nature is truly evil. The writer uses metaphors and history of human kind to support his reasoning. This paper will analyze Tzu's essay and propose with supporting facts that man's nature is justifiably evil.…

    • 1287 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The Warring States period in China (453-221 BCE) presented a time of great confusion and chaos among the people of China. However, it was also a great period for the philosophy of Confucianism, with the teachings of Mencius and Hsun Tzu to lead the way for their lost followers. According to Hsun Tzu and Mencius, human beings give birth to their children with a sense of an inherent reaction to life. Without proper teaching, children would be uncivilized, and ineffective in contributing anything towards society. Young age is important, for it is at this time that their perspectives drastically split. Mencius believed that human beings were born with a rationality of good sense. Hsun Tzu, in opposition, believed that all human beings are born into a state of primitive evil. While both claiming to interpret the philosophy of their teacher, Confucius, with certain contrasting ideas, it is Hsun Tzu's ideas that seemed more logical and realistic to the people of China.…

    • 1645 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    “You’re a liar” said one of Trump’s supporter. Since after Donald J. Trump sworn into the office, many of his supporter are outraged because Trump did not his promises during the campaign. During the 2016 election, Donald Trump’s campaign fought fiercely against Hilary Clinton’s campaign. To win the election Donald Trump promised “to build a great, great wall on our southern border” and “have Mexico pay for that wall.” Because of his strong promise, he gets people in electoral college to vote for him, but soon after he got in the office he disappointed them by making us (the taxpayer) pay for the wall. The second promise that Donald Trump made during his campaign is bring the coal mining jobs back; he said “I’m going to be the greatest jobs…

    • 319 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Hsun Tzu

    • 1232 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Hsun Tzu's philosophy is built from the idea that human beings are by nature inherently evil, and the good they produce will only come through their conscious activity. Hsun Tzu believes that if man follows his nature and indulges in his natural desires, without transforming himself by conscious activity he is doomed to fall victim to his evil nature. "Any man who follows his nature will inevitably become involved in wrangling and strife, will violate the forms and rules of society, and will end as a criminal." Despite the pessimistic tone of Hsun Tzu's message he does propose conscious activity as a solution to man's evil. This paper will examine Hsun Tzu's perspective in light of both Mencius and Lao Tzu, and the path it proposes for man to raise from his evil nature and become good.…

    • 1232 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Confucianism has a core of morality, ethics, and activism. It encourages social harmony and mutual respect. Confucianists sought to perfect their character by living a virtuous life and seeking goodness. They valued ethics, respect for elders, and propriety. Confucius, the originator of Confucian thought, believed political order would be found by the proper ordering of human relationships, and so did not bother himself with the structure of the state. He stressed that a good government must fill their positions with well-educated and conscientious people, called Junzi. Confucius was followed by his disciples Mencius and Xunzi. They also possessed the same optimism that humans could improve themselves to perfection.…

    • 393 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    3. What are the hallmarks of a moral society in Mencius’ way of thinking? How should wealth be distributed? What kinds of lives should people lead? What outward signs indicate that a society is good, and what are the symptoms of emerging social problems?…

    • 408 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays