However, the child would have to undergo appropriate proceedings if it was proven that he acted with discernment.Sen. Miriam Defensor-Santiago has strongly opposed the proposal to lower the minimum age for criminal liability for minors from 12 years old to 15 years old. Santiago maintained that young offenders should not be treated as criminals and punished but should be rehabilitated. By Anthony vargas (manila times) number of children committing crime surges
Rehabilitative services for youth offenders, since the 1960s, have been the principal solution of the Philippine government, past and present, to the persistent social problem of juvenile delinquency.The Department of Social Welfare and Development (DSWD) maintains 10 regional rehabilitation centers throughout the country; biggest among these are the National Training School for Boys (NTSB) in Rizal province and the Marillac Hills for girls in Alabang, Metro Manila. There are also other youth centers run by various local government units, church-based institutions and non-government organizations.Several advocacy groups as well as some psychologists and parents are not convinced that NTSB, Marillac Hills and government rehabilitative services could really serve their reformatory purposes.These facilities lack personnel and social workers for the growing number of youth offenders. At Marillac, for example, there are only 25 full time social workers for its average 500 clients; at the NTSB, there are only five social workers for its average 300 clients. Although the NTSB has its share of “success stories,” DSWD admits that these are very few. Some of its discharged clients have since been jailed repeatedly for new crimes.While the DSWD is supposed to provide a post-care service, Gorospe of NTSB admits that it does not have the resources, mechanism and system for out-of-center guidance. Thus, most of its discharged patients are no longer monitored and supervised.Other children NGOs criticize that the country’s juvenile justice system only intensifies the social ties that bind children to misery and criminality.Albert Schweitzer Association, an Australian NGO for children’s rights and welfare based in the Philippines, described the government rehabilitative efforts as “ineffective.” So does the feminist NGO, the ISIS International – Manila.Schweitzer’s social worker Agnes M. Cabauatan explained their group’s analysis that poverty is the condition that breeds “bad boys and girls.” “To bring them (youth offenders) to a center, feed them or educate them for a month to a year then discharge them back to the condition of poverty is a vicious cycle of crime and poverty,” she said.Ma. Victoria C. Belleza of ISIS strongly suggested that government efforts should first address the root of the social problem of juvenile delinquency, which is poverty. She elaborated that the government should make sure that the basic needs of the Filipino family are addressed by the government’s social services.Meanwhile, there are a number of laws in the country that supposedly protect and promote the interests of children. One of them is Republic Act No. 7610.Known as “An Act Providing for Stronger Deterrence and Special Protection against Child Abuse, Exploitation and Discrimination,” this law provides for a more comprehensive mechanism for child protection. But as with other laws that look good on paper, its implementation remains a big problem. (bulatlat.com) when children commit adult crimes
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Q1 The profile said that hes one of a new breed of young sportsman who are a breath of fresh air, and hes hugely exciting. He is a calm person.…
- 274 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
1. According to Ministry Is, chapter 11, "The beings that are closest to God are a special type of angels called “seraphim.” (be able to fill in the blanks)…
- 3196 Words
- 13 Pages
Good Essays -
In this society, there are adolescences that happen to slip through the cracks and stay in the system of justice for criminals all through their existence even if some are bailed out by efficient guidelines during crucial developmental periods. The regulation for juvenile misconduct could be managed on criminals up until 21 years of age when the court considers that the offender is emerging. Some issues related with young crime has to do with living in an insecure family environment and family hostility, deprivation, drugs, negligent peer cliques, frequent contact with violence, media violent behavior, and easy exposure to firearms.…
- 1112 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Standard 1: understanding the principles and values essential for working with children and young people.…
- 14814 Words
- 60 Pages
Better Essays -
Over the past 30 years, behavior in children has worsened. Growing up used to less traumatic just a few decades ago. Children back then worried about things such as a flat tire on their bike and hoped that their teacher wouldn 't give them too much homework. (Anderson, 1) Children and adolescents have among the highest rates of conventional crime victimization and, in addition, suffer from some crimes like sexual abuse and family abduction, specific to childhood. Despite enormous publicity about crime and youth, however, this high vulnerability is seldom mentioned. (Kopiec 1) The innoncence of childhood has been replaced by the very real threat of violence. (Anderson 1)…
- 1517 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
1.1 Explain why working in partnership with others is important for children and young people…
- 904 Words
- 4 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
The youth culture is influenced by many things each and every day. The society, parents, care givers; all of these help influence youth. But the most important factor to help give the a visual of what teenagers are today are in fact films. You are left wondering how films help influence the teenage race? The cinema of adolescence brings an image of youth, Juno (2007), The Breakfast Club (1985) all encounter specific stereotypes which encourage teenagers. The youth culture is influenced by many things each and every day. The society, parents, care givers; all of these help influence youth. But the most important factor to help give the a visual of what teenagers are today are in fact films. You are left wondering how films help influence the teenage race? The cinema of adolescence brings an image of youth, Juno (2007), The Breakfast Club (1985) all encounter specific stereotypes which encourage teenagers. The youth culture is influenced by many things each and every day. The society, parents, care givers; all of these help influence youth. But the most important factor to help give the a visual of what teenagers are today are in fact films. You are left wondering how films help influence the teenage race? The cinema of adolescence brings an image of youth, Juno (2007), The Breakfast Club (1985) all encounter specific stereotypes which encourage teenagers. The youth culture is influenced by many things each and every day. The society, parents, care givers; all of these help influence youth. But the most important factor to help give the a visual of what teenagers are today are in fact films. You are left wondering how films help influence the teenage race? The cinema of adolescence brings an image of youth, Juno (2007), The Breakfast Club (1985) all encounter specific stereotypes which encourage teenagers. The youth culture is influenced by many things each and every day. The society, parents, care givers; all of these help influence youth. But the most important…
- 1480 Words
- 6 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
The law treats young people differently to adults as it aims to prevent children from being exploited or from facing the consequences of making uninformed decisions. The criminal justice system recognizes young people can be less responsible than adults for their offences and this is most evident in the way the law approaches the age of criminal responsibility, known as doli incapax. In 1989, the United Nations established a treaty on children’s rights known as the Convention on the Rights of the child (1989). It included an article 41 which encouraged the establishment of ‘a minimum age below which children shall be presumed…
- 1711 Words
- 7 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Firstly, preferential treatment towards juveniles is justifiable as juveniles are in the process of puberty, the insufficient existence on Earth to understand and accept social norms and rules, resulted in them committing such crimes with passion and no forethought. As juveniles are in the process of puberty, they are sometimes unable to differentiate right from wrong, which results in them committing crimes without thinking of the plausible consequences, and without understanding the consequences of such actions. Puberty will result in juveniles being emotionally unstable and certain provocations may trigger their emotions and cause them to react in a violent manner. This shows that majority of juvenile crimes are not premeditated and therefore a preferential treatment towards juvenile is justifiable.…
- 564 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The criminal justice system is identified as an important aspect of our society and enforcing laws that help develop the well being of our nation. One would say the criminal justice system is not implemented to arrest, prosecute or punish criminals, however it is there to prevent crime and form a peaceful, law abiding society. In doing this there would have to be a balance with criminal justice and the rights of the individual accused with society’s need for order. The extent of the efficiency of the juvenile justice system, media’s influence over juveniles and their impact on society's need for order and the possible solutions to the problems arising from these systems, need to be changed in order to reduce the high rate of youth crime. In…
- 904 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
To some extent the young justice system recognises the vulnerability of the child or young person during the progress through the criminal justice system. This however has been reduced by implementation of the Crime and Disorder Act 1998. This means that the past requirement that the prosecution of a child (under 14yrs old) involved their understanding of their crime is no long required. The child’s right to remain silent was also abolished by the CDA 1998. The prosecution now only has to prove that the child committed the crime as charged.…
- 2443 Words
- 10 Pages
Powerful Essays -
States passed strict new laws allowing juveniles to be tried as an adult. In 47 states they were making their system stricter. The move toward the stricter law was from the spurred partly by the street crimes and from the sale of illegal drugs. 31 states’ the law allowed juveniles courts to expand their options for sentencing juveniles. In the 20th century, anxiety was growing all over the serious juvenile crimes. Many of the people didn’t believe the approach was working well for the youth crime. Many of the young victims were put in the justice system without proper legal rights.…
- 739 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
If a juvenile, over fourteen has the ability and willingness to commit a violent crime they should be tried and punished as an adult. A fourteen year old knows right from wrong. He (or she) is able to tell whether they are committing a crime. If a juvenile is mature enough to commit an adult crime, they should be treated as an adult, and punished justly according to the adult law. The difference in age in two people should not determine their punishment if they have committed the same crime under the same or similar pretenses.…
- 538 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
A person who commits murder, theft, robbery, physical abuse should always be equal in the viewpoint of the law, no matter it is a youngster or an adult. There should be equal punishments for the juveniles and the adults because the wrong that they have done has lead to the breaking of the law and ethics. Therefore, there are a number of ways in which the young criminals can be punished like imprisonment, labor imprisonment, strict fines on them, they should be send to custodians and rehabilitation centers. Nevertheless, the degree of the methods of punishment can be a bit lenient for the people under the age of eighteen, but the method should remain the same as of adults to let them realize that…
- 331 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
In the Philippines, reported cases of women and children victims of rape and incest have reached an alarming level. Today, approximately one woman is beaten by her partner or husband every 43 minutes while one child is battered every hour and 20 minutes. A woman or child is harassed every 4 hours. There are 500,000 victims of prostitution in the Philippines where 100,000 of them are children. Eleven women die every day due to complications in childbirth.…
- 455 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays