Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

A Comparison Between Home and Public Schooling

Good Essays
1115 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
A Comparison Between Home and Public Schooling
A comparison between home and public schooling

A comparison between home and public schooling University of Phoenix Leona Stewart COM/170 March 4, 2012 Dr. George Williams

In this essay, the writer will make a comparison between home schooling and public schooling. Whereas similarities do exist, there also will be dissimilarities. Although there is a lack of diversity, both home schooling and public schooling are effective forms of education. According to research several similarities and dissimilarities exist between home schooling and public schooling. However, for the purpose of this essay, the writer will investigate the following: (1) courses taught; (2) required credentials of teachers; (3) class structure, and (4) peer relationships. By comparing the two types of schooling, parents will be able to make an informed decision in regard to their children’s education. In both home and public schooling the curriculum is very similar. Both types of education must contain lessons that include reading, language, social studies, science, and mathematics. While in public schools the school district can dictate the curriculum, in home schooling the parents have the right to make choices. As long as the student completes four and one-half hours daily the parent may decide how much time to devote to a specific subject. This allows more flexibility to work with a child’s specific needs. As long as the student achieves a mastery of a specific subject more time may be spent on the weaker subjects. In both types of education specific goals must be achieved. In public school Criterion-Referenced Competency Tests, known, as CRCT`s are the basis used in the classroom to assess the mastery of subjects. Home schooled students must take a nationally recognized assessment every third year in the third, sixth, ninth, and twelfth grades. An acceptable test would be the Stanford Achievement test. Upon completion the records for this test must be kept on file for three years (Carnes, 2012). There is a vast difference in credentials for the teacher in regard to home schooling and public schooling. To obtain certification to be a teacher in a public school system, the teacher must have a Bachelor’s degree at the minimum. Some states also require undergraduate credit for certification in a specific area. However, Georgia, is not a state that has this requirement. In contrast for a parent to home school his or her child the only requirement is to have a high school diploma or a General Equivalency Diploma commonly called a GED. With home schooling parents have the option to teach the student theirself or to hire a tutor to do the teaching. If the parent decides to hire a tutor the tutor must also possess the same credentials to qualify for home schooling. A Bachelor’s degree is not a requirement of either the parent or the tutor. Class structure varies tremendously between home schooling and public school. With home schooling children of every age will be in the same class. Elementary students will not be put into a separate classroom apart from students who are older. The students will not study the same level of class assignments, but they will be in the same class with the same teacher. In public school students in a class are approximately the same age. There may be a difference of months in student’s ages, but there will not be a difference of years in age. Generally in a public environment an instructor only teaches one subject and the teacher stays in one room. Classes follow a strict schedule in regard to a specific time frame with a break between classes for the students to change rooms. In a home school environment the student does not have to change classrooms, but has the mobility to attend class in a place of the parent’s choosing. This could include a specific room or place in the home, at a library, or even outside weather permitting if the parent chooses to do so. Also there is no specific time schedule. The parent has the leeway to change the schedule in regard to when the classes will be held. For example today mathematics could be the first subject covered, but the next day science could be first and mathematics could be the last. No specific time frame must be adhered to with home schooling. Many differences exist between home schooling and public schools in regard to relationships with peers. In home schooling the only classmates a student will have are likely to be family members. This is in contrast to a public school in which students are from other families, religions, and races. Extracurricular activities will be different for the home schooled student then for the public school student. There will be no after-school clubs, sporting events, or dances to attend. Whereas, the home schooled student may have the opportunity to attend extracurricular activities it will not be in a group with other classmates in attendance. Lack of diversity may be the biggest difference between home schooling and public schooling. The home school student will not have other classmates to collaborate with. Input into a conversation will be strictly between the student and the parent therefore eliminating many perspectives that are available with a group of students who come from different environments and cultures. In conclusion, there are similarities between home schooling and public schooling in regard to mandatory classes the student must take and demonstrate the mastery of. Dissimilarities exist between home and public schooling in regard to requirements for a teacher to qualify to teach the student, class structure, and relationships with peers. While taking the lack of diversity into consideration it appears that both home schooling and public schooling are acceptable forms of education as long as specific requirements are adhered to. In the writer’s opinion whereas there are differences, the most important issue is the similarity between both types of schooling that the same subjects must be taught and verification must be provided to show mastery of the subject. Students in both types of schooling have the ability to achieve the same level of education. The appropriate choice would be strictly a matter of opinion in making the decision whether to home school a student or to enroll the student in a public school. By doing careful research a parent would be able to make an informed decision whether home schooling or public schooling would be the best choice for his or her children. Also a decision could be made based on whether the differences would have an impact on the quality of education in the parents opinion.

References
Carnes, S. (2012). About.com.Atlanta. Retrieved from http://atlanta.about.com/od/governmenteducation/a/homeschooling-in-georgia.htm

References: Carnes, S. (2012). About.com.Atlanta. Retrieved from http://atlanta.about.com/od/governmenteducation/a/homeschooling-in-georgia.htm

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Today’s parents have many options for their children’s education. The pros and cons of homeschooling add up in so many directions. In my research, one of the biggest questions was can homeschooling curriculum match up with examinations and accreditation of public or private schools? The issue is can a parent be qualified enough to train their children on their own without being a professional teacher. Children deserve the best schooling possible because school prepares children for their in life and education is needed to succeed in the life of the world of work. The stress for parents could end up harming their children more because they have to prepare lessons for every subject and if the child starts to struggle, they could end up putting…

    • 225 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Homeschooling is a method of teaching that has grown within the past decade. It has been reported, “In 1999 the percentage of school-age children who were being homeschooled increased from 1.7 percent to 2.9 percent in 2007” (National Center for Education Statistics). Deciding to home school your child can be a rewarding experience. Some of the benefits of being homeschooled are, one-on-one instruction, setting your own schedule, healthier food choices, safety, good morals, freedom of religion, and a lower risk of peer pressure.…

    • 2112 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Benefits Of Homeschooling

    • 906 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Families who choose homeschooling enjoy more time together and quite flexible schedules for various activities. Homeschooling also allows parents to get one-on-one with their children to teach them in an understandable and comfortable way, providing a top notch education and great opportunities for developing social skills. Granted, this method of schooling may not work for families where both parents must work, but in most favorable cases, this manner of learning provides the best benefits and therefore should be chosen above the rest. Whether learning, spending time together, playing, or doing any number of other things, homeschooling families enjoy endless delights of their difficult, yet satisfying, life. The choice shines as clearly as the sun on a clear day: choose…

    • 906 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    COM 155 final paper

    • 927 Words
    • 4 Pages

    While most kids attend public schools to receive an education, there are some people who choose to have their kids home schooled. There are many reasons for parents to choose either way for their children to receive their education. In my essay, I will show that there are similarities and differences between the two methods I will show how either option equally as good as the other.…

    • 927 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    We 're all familiar with the popular images of homeschoolers in America: Extreme fundamentalist families shutting out all other points of view. These stereotypes are touted freely by the popular media and conventional schooling experts alike. But they have little to do with the realities of homeschooling for most families today, and are rarely backed by factual data. The average home-schooled student scored “81 points higher on the Scholastic Aptitude Test (SAT) than did the general population in 2000”. (Winters) At the National Spelling Bee in 2000, the top three winners were home-schooled. Studies show that, “home-schooled children also tend to score higher on basic skills testing than do public school children”. (Winters) According to the Wall Street Journal, “Evidence is mounting that homeschooling, once confined to the political and religious fringe, has achieved results not only on par with public education, but in some ways surpassing it.” (Reider) However, one subject continues to surface whenever the issue of home schooling arises. Public school administrators, teachers, and parents are all concerned about whether home schooling can be considered a good process of education. Therefore, I intend to prove that home-schooled children are properly socialized, fully educated and college admissions increasing acceptance rates of home schooled applicants prove that they’re prepared for the next level of education.…

    • 1447 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ray, B. (2000). Home-schooling for individuals ' gain and society 's common good. Peabody Journal of Education. 75 (1/2) 272-93. Retrieved on 2003 March 11 from http://vnweb.hwwilsonweb.eom/hww/results/results_single.jhtml?nn=29…

    • 703 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Homeschooling has historically been the primary method for educating the average citizen. Before Western civilization began to emphasize the need for education of the general populace, children were most often taught by their parents, grandparents, or relatives with useful knowledge. In fact, the modern idea of formal education was usually reserved for the elite members of society who could pay the hefty price for a private tutor. Now, quality education is readily available to nearly every member of Western society. However, some parents have turned back to the practice of educating their children out of the comfort of their own home. This practice is known as “homeschooling.”…

    • 1704 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In just seven years, the number of kids who are being home schooled increased from 340,000 kids to 1.7 million kids. But what about the 47.2 million other kids that are enrolled in public schools? Public schools offer kids opportunities to cooperate and communicate with each other and become ready for the real world. Some home schooled kids are even sent to a public high school for the last few years of their K-12 education so that they accommodate to the class lifestyle they would experience in college and further. Public schooling is critical and demanding, which is necessary to experience in the real world; home schooling is easy going and less intense because of its environment and this will be unfavorable to the kids¡¯ future.…

    • 703 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Although homeschool education may have its advantages, public school education offers a more well-organized and effective setting for a student to learn and prosper. The famous philosopher named Plato once stated, “Do not train children to learning by force and harshness, but direct them to it by what amuses their minds, so that you may be better able to discover with accuracy the peculiar bent of the genius of each.” This quotation is highly influential. It is imperative to consider the different educational necessities of children when deciding whether homeschooling or public education is the best academic choice. It is a blessing to live in a country where parents can take a step back and find the education choice that best suits our children.…

    • 962 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    "Parents of 136 homeschooled elementary children completed questionnaires assessing constructs derived from the parental involvement literature and personal beliefs identified in the homeschooling literature as important to parents’ decisions to home school. Results suggest that home-schooling parents appear to be motivated by an active role construction, strong sense of efficacy for helping the child learn, and positive perceptions of life context"(1). This shows that parents who choose to home school are very motivated to allow their children to succeed as best they can, also that they would want their children to learn every lesson possible, contrary to the belief that they want to shelter them.…

    • 1420 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Deciding which is better between public education and home schooling may often cause a debate. There are similarities between them, such as both being a good source of education for students. However, there are a few differences. For instance, home schooled students may graduate earlier than public schooled students while public school has more to offer. Even though home schooling has an advantage, public education is a better educational experience because of the opportunity, social skill development, and the things a student can learn from being in a class size of more than one.…

    • 1070 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Annotated Bibliography

    • 339 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The source is a former city school superintendent. This is fitting to my reach paper because the author has experienced both sides of the subject matter. The author created a learning tool for parents who home school their children. The author curriculum has been proven to help children achieve full scholarships to the college of their choice.…

    • 339 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    This article by the Washington Times, by an unknown author, it goes over the a recent study conducted by Dr. Brian Ray and his findings. In his study conducted in 2009, Dr. Ray found that out of 12,000 children from all over the United States when given 3 well known standard tests: the California Achievement Test, the Iowa Basic Skills, and The Stanford Achievement Test. The result separated into 5 sections including: Math, Social Studies, Science, Reading, and Language. Public school students scored within the 50th percentile in each subject, whereas homeschooled students scored between the 85-90th percentile.…

    • 1147 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    For many years it has been a statistical fact that homeschoolers score above public schooled students. A recent study ,” Homeschool Progress Report 2009” ,which was done by Brian Ray showed that home-schoolers scored an average of 37 percentile points higher than public schooled students on achievement tests(Smith ,2009). Homeschool graduates exceeded public school graduates in 42 out of 63 indicators of college success in research shared at the National Christian Home Educators Leadership Conference (CBN News,May,2007). Studies such as this have muted the concern that parents could not provide an adequate education at home.While no one can argue that most homeschoolers are normally intelligent , successful students the argument that remains is that of socialization. Outsiders wonder how these students can maintain a life without their parents by their side no matter how intelligent they may be. The general feeling is that a parent should begin to let go of a child once he or she reaches school age.…

    • 1505 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Thesis: Homeschooling environment is an effective approach in education due to evidence of higher achievement on placement tests, success through college, engaged socially with activities outside homes, and students becoming active members of society.…

    • 853 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays

Related Topics