Preview

A Comparison of Dead Poet's Society and The Outsider

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1171 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
A Comparison of Dead Poet's Society and The Outsider
Danielle Iaboni
Mrs. Arlotto
ENG4U
April 5, 2014
The Outsider and Dead Poet’s Society Comparative Essay “I find that the very things that I get criticized for, which is usually being different and just doing my own thing and just being original, is the very thing that’s making me successful.” Country singer Shania Twain explains that the things she does in her daily life, making her different from everyone else, actually makes her unique, despite the fact that it goes against social norms. A non-conformist person is someone who goes against societal norms because they are an individual who will do what they prefer to do, regardless of what others may think. In the novel The Outsider, Meursault is indifferent and passive to a conventional life that is not worth living. He refuses to be anything but himself, regardless of the price he must pay. In contrast, Keating in Dead Poet’s Society, responds to such a society by actively and passionately trying to make a difference by nurturing each person to be free to reach his or her potential and essence. Unfortunately, the society surrounding that person is responsible for crushing that individual’s essence. Those who refuse to conform to such a society are judged negatively and consequently, feel alienated. Both Keating and Meursault are strangers in a society that wants to dictate their expected behaviour and actions. Society seeks to imprison their individual freedom. In both the novel The Outsider and the movie Dead Poet’s Society, Meursault and Mr. Keating go against what society thinks and by doing so both characters are punished. Meursault from the novel The Outsider was seen as a social outcast from everyone and did not fit the role of a “normal” person in society. Meursault’s reaction to events that happened around him did not change the type of person he was, regardless of the fact that many people in his community were astonished and did not agree with the way he acted towards life. He ignores

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    The only difference is, Meursault’s attempt to integrate himself into European culture is also the action that defined him as an outsider. During an encounter with an ‘Arab’, Meursault “fired four times at the motionless body... and it was like knocking four quick times on the door of unhappiness” (Camus, 59). At that time in Algeria, racial tensions are high among the French and the ‘Arabs’. To try to fit in, Meursault tries to enforce the racial superiority of the French when he shoots the ‘Arab’. In his world, killing the ‘Arab’ would help him fit in, but instead he knew it did not work. He states he ‘knocked’ at the ‘door of unhappiness’ implying that he was now on the outside and his actions would disappoint whoever was inside. The house symbolizes the European divide, with Meursault being on the outside of the house looking in. Although his intentions were to assimilate, Algerian citizens saw his actions as too extreme, casting him as the…

    • 2119 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many people in society can be considered by outsiders by society. These sorts of characters, along with being found in modern day society, are also found in all forms of media such as Scott Pilgrim in Scott Pilgrim Versus the World, Colonel Aureliano Buendia from One Hundred Years of Solitude, and even Doctor Gregory House from acclaimed television series House. These characters provide us with a fascinating viewpoint on how they view society and how they are able to interact with society as a result of this isolation and ostracism from society. Arguably one of the greatest examples of this isolated character challenged by society’s very moral center is the character of Meursault of Albert Camus’ The Stranger. Camus throughout The Stranger…

    • 1333 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Rousseau’s quotation, “Man is born free yet, everywhere he is in chains” implies that a person is gifted with great possibilities and potential. Unfortunately, the society surrounding that person is responsible for crushing that individual’s essence. Those who refuse to conform to such a society are judged negatively and consequently, feel alienated. Both Keating and Meursault are strangers in a society that wants to dictate their expected behaviour and actions. Society seeks to imprison their individual freedom. Meursault is indifferent and passive to this conventional life that is not worth living. He refuses to be anything but himself, regardless of the price he must pay. In contrast, Keating responds to such a society by actively and passionately trying to make a difference by nurturing each person to be free to reach his or her potential and essence. Society seeks to chain these two free individuals into conforming to ways that stifle their individuality and freedom, but the key lies in their choice of response in dealing with such a society, regardless of its negative judgement.…

    • 1336 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Transcendentalism was a time period of free thinking, standing up for what’s right, and an importance of a deeper relationship with nature. These are examples of tenets which are the main ideas of this time period, which took place in the 1800’s. Two tenets of Transcendentalism that are present in Dead Poet’s Society are free thinking and the importance of nature.…

    • 302 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Belonging can forcibly act upon individuals, causing them to feel a loss of identity and relationships. They can feel isolated and segregated because of this force, unable to discover themselves as individuals. When belonging is externally forced upon them, it challenges their lives, causing various negative consequences. These negative consequences, in terms of loss of identity and relationships, are witnessed in the 1989 film “Dead Poet’s Society”, directed by Peter Weir, occurring because of individuals being forced to belong. This concept of belonging can be examined in reference to two primary characters of the film, Neil Perry and Todd Anderson. Both characters are forced to belong to their family structures and high expectations.…

    • 880 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Meursault, the readers’ eyes and ears in ‘The Outsider’ appears unbelievably detached from anything or anyone around him. The opening line of ‘Mother died today. Or maybe yesterday, I don’t know,’ shows how little empathy this character has. There is no sorrow or regret, it is only a statement. The reader will soon realise that Meursault will only deal in the factual and the concrete. Emotions to this character are meaningless. On the day of his mother’s funeral he notices a man with ‘trembling (lips) beneath a nose pitted with blackheads.’ Meursault’s description of this man is cold and quite unforgiving. He goes into great detail when describing the suit the man is wearing, ‘the black tie with a knot that was too small for the large white collar... the pants with a thin white pinstripe...’ Meursault recognises the physical appearance of this man, but he doesn’t register the emotional reason for this reaction. The reader can appreciate that Meursault is only affected by the environment, he is mentally absent from the funeral. It is not the fact his mother is being buried today that Meursault finds depressing, but it’s the ‘whole landscape’ which ‘is flooded in sunshine.’ Meursault offers a unique view on the world because he is so detached from society. This unique protagonist means his thought pattern will lead us down a different path of thought as we follow his internal monologue. This is a key reason why I…

    • 2691 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Meursault's Exile

    • 684 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Albert Camus wrote The Stranger in such a way that enabled the reader to analyze the main character, Meursault, and perceive him in their own way. Meursault is characterized as emotionless and independent. Meursault can connect well to the statement, Through the critical lens of Roethke, “In a dark time the eye begins to see.” —Theodore Roethke, because Camus created a character that enabled the reader to form a changing opinion of Meursault. From the world in which Meursault narrates, the reader can definitely understand why he attempts to find understanding in his life when he is exiled at the end of the novel.…

    • 684 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    It is scorching, fierce, and merciless. During the day, it prowls from country to city. Even a mild encounter may devastate anything it crosses. The sun and natural elements surrounds every creature and has a lasting impact; this is especially true to Meursault. Meursault, the protagonist in the novel, The Stranger, by Albert Camus, is extremely sensitive to the world around him, but he is indifferent to emotional relationships. The physical world around him affects his actions and his state of mind numerous times. His mood is changed during his mother's funeral, while walking on the beach, and during the final encounter with the Arab because of the properties around him.…

    • 891 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    This allows the reader to question whether or not there are links between Nick being an outsider and Meursault in The Outsider. Both Nick and Meursault seem to be detached and simply view and describe what occurs around them from a removed position. Both characters also seem to have a love interest with in the book, Meursault having Marie and Nick having Jordan Baker. Although there are still some differences between the two, Nick is socially accepted, and is more engaged with his own beliefs and views than Meursault. Both Meursault and Nick are outsiders due to the different personalities they have compared to others in the novels. Although there are similarities and links both characters do have various characteristics that position the reader to feel differently about each…

    • 714 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Conformity causes people to be something their not. In the movie “Dead Poets Society” Mr.Keating wants his students to discover their unique identity when he says “seize the day”. This quote clearly states that Mr.Keating wants his students live their lives to the fullest. Mr.Keating wants his students to live their lives not like the past students who failed to discover their identity. Another example of the danger of conformity is in the article “The Sociology of Leopard Man” in the article it states that the Leopard Man lives outside of society. This shows that Leopard Man…

    • 443 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    He is unfairly judged by society because he exhibits no emotions of any kind at his mother's funeral. In a community where the principle belief that emotional displays are the necessary and correct response to traumatic events such as in Meursault's case (his mother's death) means that there is a standard that is applied to all people. But because the protagonist is shown to be a rebel he does not obey the expected behavior of mourning that society wants him to show. Society asks “has [Meursault] uttered a word of regret for his most odious crimes? Not one word, gentlemen. Not once in the course of these proceedings did this man show the least contrition (Camus 126).” Meursault finally understands that he is in a paradoxical situation where he is judged for showing the lack of feelings rather than his murdering of the Arab man. In the courtroom, the jury represents society’s ethics in which Meursault is being judge while the spectators in the courtroom represent society who are there to pass views on him. He eventually is put on the death penalty because of his nonconformist attitude. Another example that shows the protagonist to be a social misfit is that Meursault believes all men are equal in a sense that no one can ever escape death even if they were a Christian or not. He explains that “every man alive was privileged; there [are] only one class of men, the privileged class. All alike would be condemn to die one day; his turn, too, would come like the others (Camus 152).” He even goes on to say that Old Salamano’s dog was worth just as much as Old Salamano's wife in view of the fact that like all humans, dogs will eventually die as well. So the life of a human can’t be more special than that of a dog since both organisms are made equal by death. The protagonist is an absolute rebel because he is passive, detached, and emotionless…

    • 1583 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Stranger

    • 633 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Albert Camus's The Stranger takes place in a society confined with social standards that dictate who everyone is supposed to be and how they're supposed to act. In the middle of this society, Camus introduces the character of Meursault, who is anything but ordinary. Meursault's nonconformist personality causes him to be alienated from the world. However, he isolates himself more with his attitude about not caring about anyone but himself. Throughout the novel, The Stranger, Meursault reveals his selfish character through his actions and by placing his interests over the interests of others and ultimately deserves the death sentence.…

    • 633 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Life of a poet

    • 1507 Words
    • 7 Pages

    “Whose canon is it anyway?” is an article written by Bethan Marshall. In the article, Marshall analyzes a review by Tom Paulin of a book by Anthony Julius about the anti-Semitism and literary works of T. S. Elliot. Despite being a well-known anti-Semite, Elliot and his poetry were studied in schools around the world. Therefore, by questioning his beliefs, we also question our own culture because Elliot’s works are closely related to its foundation. So, Elliot poses the question: Is culture something we can control or deliberately influence? In 1993, the head of the National Curriculum Council, David Pascall, changed the curriculum in an effort to try and answer Elliot’s question. Five years earlier, Brian Cox had tried to implement a similar kind of curriculum as Pascall but did not follow through with it despite feeling the need for a cultural analysis. Edward Said describes culture as being something inevitable that grows on the individual and automatically makes them a little xenophobic. Dr. Nicholas Tate brought up how our culture is based on our interest and the environment in which we are placed in. He believes that someone can be multicultural as it is part of what makes the person core culture. Yet, by trying to alter the culture, we are losing the traditional values that English literature was built on. For example, the works by Elliot that was been studied for decades are the roots for questions about culture, identity and power that are trying to be preserved.…

    • 1507 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the novel The Stranger by Albert Camus, the protagonist Meursault is a man who is indifferent to major events in his life which would deserve a "proper" reaction according to society. Also, the decisions he makes in his life are done carelessly and without a second thought about whether what he is doing is good or bad. As a result, Meursault is a stranger to society because of how differently his view on life is based on how he approaches certain aspects of life. Eventually, death is what connects Meursault to the society he was estranged from.…

    • 540 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Meursault- the protagonist of Camus’ The Outsider is shown as being influenced by nature. His character and actions are indicative of how an individual is affected by the environment in which he dwells and how a change in the surroundings affects his psychology. The character of Meursault also portrays the biological evolutionary notion of adaptability and how a superior species replaces an inferior one. This can be seen, in the novel, in the role Mersault’s natural surroundings plays in determining his actions and how, towards the end, an existentially enlightened Meursault replaces the older one. In the novel we see how the protagonist is continually affected by his surroundings.…

    • 1910 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays