Preview

A Critique of a Critique, Catcher in the Rye

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1279 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
A Critique of a Critique, Catcher in the Rye
Mburke
Mr. Sherman
English III - Period 2
1/8/2013

An Analytical Biography of The Catcher in the Rye

Jonathan Baumbach, “The Saint as a Young Man: A reappraisal of The Catcher in the Rye,” in Modern Language Quarterly, Vol. 35, No. 4, December, 1964, pp. 461-72

Critic Jonathan Baumbach explores the significance of innocence in J.D Salinger’s Catcher in the Rye. He claims that the novel is not only about innocence, but actively for innocence-as if retaining one’s childness were an existing possibility. Not only that, but he states that Holden wishes to be a saint: the protector and savior of innocence by preventing them from falling into the cruel adult world of corruption and fickleness. Although he also wants someone to prevent his own fall since he is in fact still a child himself. Baumbach states that this is Holden’s paradox, saying that he must shed his own innocence to protect innocence. These statements are what send Holden off into the three day soul-searching quest that dooms Holden to sinking into insanity in our novel.
The critic opens with a rather descriptive insight about how others view and critique Salinger’s first and only novel, as well as pointing some of the flaws that Catcher has:
“The novel is sentimental; it loads the deck for Holden and against the adult world, the small but corrupt group that Holden encounters is not representative enough to permit Salinger his inclusive judgments about the species.”
Baumbach claims that Holden does not have enough information to comment on the phoniness of humanity as a whole based on his observations of only a select few. As the critic investigates further, he makes a few interesting points. Some of which regard Mr. Antolini: Holden’s former English teacher. Baumbach claims that Antolini’s kindness to Holden is triggered by a homosexual interest that he has in the protagonist. Pointing out the flaws in his teachers marriage, as well as ambiguous actions that he had done while

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    J.D. Salinger’s book, The Catcher in the Rye, constantly gets debated on whether high school English classes need to read it. Despite the crude language and R-rated stories, every high schooler needs to read this book. After the book gets dissected, the deeper meanings of the story come about and show the importance for reading the book.…

    • 608 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When someone is young, they tend to have innocence about them. As children grow up, they no longer possess this natural innocence. Exposure to all of the hatred in the world causes this loss. Holden Caulfield realizes this simple fact, as he himself grows up, and has a difficult time with the change. He experiences problems with communication as well as his school work. A common theme used throughout The Catcher in the Rye has to do with contradictions Holden makes. In J.D. Salinger’s The Catcher in the Rye, first person point of view is used to highlight contradictions Holden makes throughout the novel.…

    • 747 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the novel The Catcher in the Rye, J. D. Salinger portrays the protagonist, Holden Caulfield, from two very different sides. On one hand, Holden is passionate about the protection of innocence, and he attempts to shelter all kids, especially his younger sister Phoebe, from any knowledge which might compromise their innocence. On the other hand, Holden is repeatedly revealed to be experienced and knowledgeable in society. He constantly swears, drinks, and smokes, sharply criticizes everyone he sees, and generally does not conform to society. Because Holden lost his own innocence so early in his life, he becomes fascinated with the idea of guarding it in others. Salinger shows Holden protecting the innocence of people many times throughout the novel. Some examples include Holden’s anxiety about Jane, Holden’s protection of Phoebe, and Holden’s general frustration…

    • 908 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Ever since its publication in 1951, the quality of J. D. Salinger’s novel, The Catcher in the Rye, has been a controversy. The story has been praised for its enlightening views on society, but criticized for its use of slang and sexual content. Nevertheless, the story is worth both reading and teaching, for the story still relates to the lives of today’s teenagers, introduces a unique writing style to its readers, and teaches its readers an important lesson about phoniness. Throughout the novel, the main character, Holden Caulfield, attempts to catch innocent children before they fall off the cliff and die or before they lose their innocence and become a corrupt and phony adult. While doing so, he suffers isolation…

    • 1244 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    All throughout the novel, Holden digresses about people he finds phony and the degree of hatred he has towards their phoniness. He talks about his older brother, DB, noting that he is a brilliant writer but hates that fact that he becomes a “prostitute” in Hollywood (2). Holden does not like that DB goes around looking like a big shot with his jaguar. He also does not like that DB wastes his talent in writing storylines for movies. This alludes to the next significant concept that Holden hates. Holden strongly dislikes movies in general and the people that love to see movies. He finds that movies are phony because it is just acting; the content of film is far from reality. Holden claims that people who enjoy movies are phony because they are just drawn to the superficial. Again, Holden demonstrates his hatred of phoniness through movies. The last aspect he hates about the phoniness of people is the arrogance and essence of superiority that is evoked. Holden explains that Pencey Prep “molds boys into splendid, clear-thinking young men who play polo” (2). However, he feels it is full of phoniness that Pencey is left with the idea that the school is full of polo players and hot shot students. In reality, no one plays polo and it is a standard school. Evidently, Holden demonstrates his hatred of phoniness through his numerous complaints and criticism of…

    • 1077 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In The Catcher in The Rye, by J.D, the main character, Holden, can be seen as a troubled teenager growing up in a less than perfect society. Throughout the novel Holden struggles with the fact that many young and innocent kids will grow up and see the world from a different perspective. He naturally becomes worried for all future generations who will one day grow, as he did, and loose their innocence. The fixation of youth and innocence can be seen in the title of the book, as well as throughout the novel.…

    • 852 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    These chapters establish the way Holden interacts with his peers. Holden despises “phonies”—people whose surface behavior distorts or disguises their inner feelings. Even his brother D. B. incurs his displeasure by accepting a big paycheck to write for the movies; Holden considers the movies to be the phoniest of the phony and emphasizes throughout the book the loathing he has for Hollywood.…

    • 1902 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Holden Caulfield Controversy

    • 2569 Words
    • 11 Pages

    “Holden acts like a saint or savior of the innocent. It is this sensitive, innocent, and childlike side of Holden that makes him a complex and endearing character, in spite of his vulgarity and immaturity”(Baumbach 25). In agreement with the first part of Baumbach’s claim, Holden displayed many characteristics that held up to these words. In particular, Holden lived up to the statement of protecting innocence by removing the slander off the school and museum walls. This action supplied evidence of contradiction to the second part of Baumbach’s claim, which deemed that Holden possessed “vulgarity and immaturity.” One source says that Holden became a defender of innocence when he erased these words off the walls because he did so in order to shield them from the corruption in the world (Freedmen…

    • 2569 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Holden Caulfield Symbolism

    • 1743 Words
    • 7 Pages

    In the novel The Catcher in the Rye, the author, J.D. Salinger, takes the reader through Holden Caulfield’s struggles with adolescence as he makes his way through New York City in the 1940’s. Salinger shows how Holden attempts to go on an unrealistic quest to save children from a sudden loss of innocence. Holden’s wake-up call comes in the form of his little sister, Phoebe, who unintentionally illustrates to her big brother that reaching for the gold ring isn’t always a scary thing, but a part of life that everyone must go through. The author uses symbolism to create Holden’s idea of becoming “The Catcher in the Rye,” a way of preventing others from the abrupt loss of innocence. Holden’s idea is challenged by his interactions,…

    • 1743 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Catcher in the Rye, the protagonist, Holden Caulfield, is introduced to the readers as a troubled young who desperately wants to protect his youthful innocence. Because Holden constantly faces harsh realities of adulthood and world, he is even more compelled to protect innocence. He wants to protect not only his, but also those around him. Holden feels that childhood is something to be saved and kept, instead of learning the truth of adulthood since the adult world is an impure place that corrupt kids and ruin their perfect perception of the world.…

    • 836 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In J.D. Salinger’s The Catcher in the Rye, the subject matter of Innocence is explored as Holden’s quest throughout New York City unfolds and his views on society develop. The novel is narrated by Holden Caulfield who is telling us the story of how he got to the mental hospital where he is currently a patient. Holden starts off at Pencey Prep, a preparatory school in Pennsylvania but eventually leaves after he is expelled. Holden wanders through New York City where he originally plans to go home after 5 days but continuously ponders the idea of running away after he visits his sister Phoebe. Throughout the novel, Holden’s mental state worsens dramatically and eventually leads to his mental breakdown. In Salinger’s The Catcher in the Rye, Holden’s…

    • 656 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    No matter how much a person strives to remain young and innocent, eventually all children grow up and innocence fades. In The Catcher in the Rye by J.D. Salinger, the main character, Holden, values innocence and does not believe that children should lose it as they become adults. The early death of his younger brother, Allie, causes Holden’s constant need to prevent the loss of innocence in the people he cares about most and in himself.…

    • 570 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Innocence, the theme repeated so many times within the novel. Our hearts all want to hold on to the innocence that we had as children. However, the adult world doesn’t allow for innocence, it only allows blood, sweat, tears, and stress. This spiritual theme of innocence is described perfectly when Holden states "Anyway, I keep picturing all these little kids playing some game in this big field of rye and all. Thousands of little kids, and nobody's around – nobody big, I mean – except me. And I'm standing on the edge of some crazy cliff. What I have to do, I have to catch everybody if they start to go over the cliff.” (Salinger, 191) He is spiritually saying that he would like to be the guardian of innocence stopping children from falling into the terrors of…

    • 510 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    A lonely teenager walks in the empty streets of New York City, and countless thoughts run through his confused mind. His features include grey hair, a long jacket, and a tall presence, making him appear much older than he really is. But do these mature features really resemble this teenager’s inner heart or is he longing for the innocent past, a past he so desperately wants to maintain? In the book Catcher in the Rye by J.D. Salinger, the theme of innocence becomes an important aspect of this teenager’s identity. This particular teenager’s name is Holden Caulfield, and he is a desperate, depressed youth with purely innocent intentions, figuratively and literally. He holds on to the image of innocence and the maintenance of that trait, but his depression causes him to seek for innocence at an extreme level, to where it affects his everyday “adult” interactions. Holden is not a “normal” teen, and this makes his life a very hopeless experience for him, to where he has no actual goals for his future self. With all of…

    • 1473 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many things on the Catcher in the Rye are from Salinger’s early life experience. The Catcher in the Rye published at a time when the developing of the American industrial economy made the nation prosperous and entrenched social rules served as a code of conformity for the younger generation. The book was banned in many areas when it was first released because many people think it was not formal literature. The book is in a casual and informal tone. Also, the book discusses about adult sexuality in an openly. The novel is popular though. It induces many critics and it is a best popular seller. The main character, Holden stands for a symbol of pure individuality in the face of cultural oppression. It is a tale of an individual’s separation from a cold and heartless world. The book is written during the World War II. Salinger participated in the World War II and the experience there cast a shadow over his life. The experience caused this cynical view of adult society.…

    • 1573 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics