Three years later, the group of friends has grown apart. Jasmine has returned from her two year trip to Iceland. Amanda has totally transformed and is now the most popular girl in school along with the former geek Holly. Kim is going for a swimming scholarship, and Carter has become ultra-competitive with her flawless sister Bethany.
Later in the story Chloe’s body is found, and as horrified as the girls are, they think that their secrets are finally safe. Soon after, they begin to receive messages from a mysterious person known as –M. The threats turn to blackmail as M brings out all their brutal memories and dirty secrets.
Chloe
Each one with a secret, so scandalous and wrong
I think I’ll keep it
But only two can keep a secret if one is dead
You think the truth is this big shiny disco ball of purity
Then go ahead and try it. See what it gets you.
Telling the truth to the wrong person at the wrong time is how I ended up where I did.
Take it from me you're always better off with a really good lie.
Each one with a secret, so scandalous and wrong
I think I’ll keep it
But only two can keep a secret if one is dead.
Holly
I used to be the geek and one with no friends
As I sat here through my tears then we all became close to each other
But it all ended too fast
I look back on all the years
Games we lost