Preview

A Poor Cousin Reflection

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
652 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
A Poor Cousin Reflection
A Poor Cousin of the Middle Class Reflection 1

A Poor Cousin the Middle Class
David K. Shipler

A Poor Cousin of the Middle Class Reflection 2
In “A Poor Cousin of the Middle Class,” it is about a woman named Caroline Payne who was a hard worker and had a lot of motivation to work and better herself. She was not viewed from a whole person perspective. She was a typical American citizen, fifty year-old, Caucasian woman. She has a two-year associate’s degree, who works at the local Wal-Mart in Muncie, Indiana. Caroline has not lived what you call the “American Dream.” She has had a challenge trying to find ways to survive for her and daughter just be fed for dinner and clothed. Caroline has been married twice and both marriages have failed. She did not grow up with her biological father and her step-father abused her. She has four kids, three boys that live with their father and one daughter, named Amber, who is disabled. Amber has a clubfoot and mild retardation because of Caroline’s emotional assaults, not eating nutritiously, and smoking cigarettes. Caroline only got a few benefits of assistance; she got Medicaid for fix her teeth that had been damaged and social security to live off of with her daughter. Caroline has been in and out of jobs like you couldn’t believe. She would get laid off here and there, not get the pay she needed to get by, moved from state to state, city to city, and she thought her decayed teeth had to do something with her not being able to get a better job. Because her teeth were so bad, anytime she would try applying for a higher position job or a higher paying professional job, she knew she wouldn’t get the job but she would still try. There was nothing that she could do about her teeth because they had just decayed and succumbed to poverty. Caroline couldn’t do anything about her teeth; she didn’t have the money for a dentist to get them fixed. Even when she lived on welfare in Florida she couldn’t afford to get them fixed so

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    For each, she had to master new skills, learn the social environment of each job, and work laboriously for hours on end. She further analyzes and evaluates the rising problem of poverty. A single, educated woman – with the ability to rely on conveniences such as emergency cash, a car, and a credit card; a woman who was without children or a family to support – struggled to make ends meet working one or more jobs demonstrates the inadequacy of the minimum wage and its fail to sufficiently supply an individual or family with the means necessary to support the “working poor.” Companies are reluctant to raise the pay of their employees and can punish and/or fire employees who step out of line. “When you enter the low-wage workplace, you check your civil liberties at the door…We can hardly pride ourselves on being the world’s preeminent democracy if large numbers of citizens spend half of their waking hours in what amounts to a dictatorship.” (Ehrenreich 210) The calculated $30,000 “living wage” for a family of three comes to $14 an hour, and 60 percent of Americans earns less than that. The lifestyles of the poor are tainted with low self-esteem and the need to “work through” fatigue, injury, illness, etc. “They are [the lifestyles] emergency situations. And that is how we should see the poverty of so many millions of low-wage Americans – as a state of emergency.” (Ehrenreich…

    • 691 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    “No one ever said that you could work hard—harder even than you ever thought possible—and still find yourself sinking even deeper into poverty and debt.” This is a quote by Barbara Ehrenreich who wrote “Nickel and Dimed,” she is a journalist with a PHD in biology and writes about her own story as she chooses to change her entire lifestyle, face the hardships of being a part of the working poor class just to see if she can survive. Throughout the book she illustrated the different jobs she endured and the struggles that came along with the jobs. Her story highlights the social inequality she experienced based on her status, working poor class, routine lifestyle, her experience living on the edge and the stagnant pay she received. There was a lot of social inequality in her journey that many Americans seem to overlook on the poor working class.…

    • 3042 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Not being in the lower class is a privilege to the people who witness how difficult it is to live in those conditions and imagine what it would be like to live off of lower class jobs. Barbara Ehrenreich saw this and decided that she wanted to experience what it would be like and experience the hardship that they push through. Barbara discusses the difficulty of living in the lower class with the use of her first point of view/ honesty and her use of figurative language. In the novel, “Nickel and Dimed”, Barbara Ehrenreich uses a sarcastic, dramatic tone to support her argument that people who live in the lower class have a difficult time getting by with the present American economy.…

    • 910 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    I have never lived in poverty but I have also never lived a considerably wealthy life. From reading this book, my perceptions of poverty and prosperity have pretty much stayed the same. Many times I associate fast food workers with poverty, or when I see an elderly woman working at WalMart I also associate that with poverty. I cannot recall a time that I ever thought that the sixty year old checker at WalMart could possibly be rich. As horrible as it may sound, I usually, unconsciously think that anyone that works in any low wage job must be in some state of poverty. I do appreciate what these people do for society, but at the same time, I am not going to feel sorry for these people either. I do not think that low wage workers should in any way be disrespected but at the same time, as much as people will argue this point, everyone has a choice in what they do with their life. Low wage jobs are a pain in the butt and they are not always fair and they are hard, but someone has got to do it. I believe that if someone does not want to live that lifestyle, they do not have to. I would not say this if I did not have proof from personal experience. My mom never went to college and because of that if she…

    • 1248 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the film Raising Arizona, the scene where HI and Ed are sitting outside with Dot discussing the needs of Nathan Jr. is one that relates to our studies of America on Film. The concepts of Class and Gender roles are evident in this scene. HI and Ed can be considered part of the lower-middle class. Glen and Dot are part of the upper-middle class. One of the ways that the film distinguishes between them is that Glen’s job as supervisor shows that he has a more respectable job with higher income. Also, Glen and Dot have many children that they adopted. They are able to support all those children and are actually looking for another one to adopt. This concept of Class also relates to how each couple fits into their gender roles. Prior to marrying HI, Ed had somewhat of a career as a policewoman. She was providing for herself. HI on the other hand, was constantly in and out of prison for robbing the same convenience store. After the marriage, and having obtained Nathan Jr., they each assimilated into their perspective gender roles. HI left his life of crime behind and got a job to support the family. Ed left her job behind and became a housewife. It was important to mention this before discussing the scene at the lunch table with Dot. The way that HI and Ed fit into their gender roles, and the fact that they are in a lower class than Glen and Dot, shapes the way the conversation takes place. During this conversation, Dot is telling Ed about all the things that they must do for Nathan Jr. Every time Dot mentions something to Ed, Ed looks to HI for answers. At this point, Ed playing the role of the housewife looks to her husband, the provider and man of the house, for all the answers. Class also comes into play at this moment. HI has no clue what the woman are talking about. Since we don’t know much of HI’s past, we can only presume that since he was constantly robbing that store, he has been part of the lower class. HI has no experience in these kinds of things like flu…

    • 495 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the book, “Absolutely True Diary of a Part Time Indian” Junior, the main character, writes: “Poverty doesn’t give you strength or teach you lessons about perseverance. No, poverty only teaches you how to be poor.” When it comes to being poor, Junior does nothing to justify poverty that is he doesn’t say that it makes him a stronger or better person. Instead, Junior views poverty as something incredible difficult to overcome, a condition that simply reinforces itself. To Junior, poverty is generational, it is an inherited condition, and it is not a choice. Poverty is something that he is born into.…

    • 494 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The author also makes his point by observing the differences between social classes that can widen the rift between said classes as well as families. Lubrano states that “middle-class…

    • 577 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Still Hungry in America

    • 466 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Her objective in this particular writing is to show how important government assistance programs are too many Americans. She made it very clear in her writing, that although America is the richest nation in the world, many Americans still suffer from or is on the verge of starvation. She also made it very clear that it is important to fight for these programs whenever necessary because although these programs have proven to be helpful to the American people, there are some people out there who fill they are a waste of government spending. It is easy to draw this conclusion because Edelman had to fight back at several groups in the past who tried to defund state and government programs. She also attempted to persuade readers to see her point-of-view by elaborated on the struggles she encountered and overcame in the past. In addition, she had to fight for more programs that would help less-fortunate American on a…

    • 466 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Chasing the Red, White, and Blue is an omnipotent observation of the lives of Americans in modern society. The author, David Cohen, followed the footsteps of Alex De Tocqueville, to explore if Tocqueville major aggregation “equality of opportunity “pursuit of wealth” still exist modern-day American society. Cohen also wanted to figure out what had changed over the years. He found out such thoughts as freedom and liberty remain as the national character of the United States. However, “equality” and “American Dream” which were the main characteristics of America in Tocqueville eyes was indirect or mistaken. Cohen explains this concept in the book, “ What you see depends on the angle in which you look” (Cohen 3) To Further explain, Tocqueville essentially only met white male upper class Americans, Cohen interrogated every American in society including bus drivers, preachers, Washington lobbyists, high-powered real estate brokers, and illegal immigrants. He saw the widening economic gap between the rich and the poor in American society in which minimum wage workers cannot even support themselves. “If you don’t have money, you are none and nobody will care about you,” (Cohen 43) this text of the passage explains how poor Americans are viewed upon throughout the book.…

    • 949 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The romantic formulation we all dream about a home where we can provide for our families and everyone wants to have the equivalent of picket fences, front yards, and two-car garages. We 've known for some time that the degree of social mobility in the US is much less than people believe. The American dream myth is a false perception that there is equal opportunity that allows us to be more accepting of unequal outcomes than we would be if we knew how stagnant social outcomes actually are. The evidence that rebuts this belief is worth repeating. In the story A Raisin in The Sun the Youngers family are about to receive an insurance check for $10,000. This money comes from the deceased Mr. Younger’s life insurance policy. Each of the adult members of the family has an idea as to what he or she would like to do with this money., Mama, wants to buy a house to fulfill a dream she shared with her husband. Mama’s son, Walter Lee, would rather use the money to invest in a liquor store . He believes that the investment will solve the family’s financial problems. Walter’s wife, Ruth, hopes that she and Walter can provide more space and opportunity for their son, Travis. Finally, Beneatha, Walter’s sister and Mama’s daughter, wants to use the money for her medical school tuition. Each person…

    • 819 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In the story “The Necklace,” Mathilde is a lower class woman who has a fine house, kind husband, and enough to make one happy. However, she is not content with her life and continually wants more: “She had no clothes, no jewels, nothing. And these were the only things she loved; she felt that she was made for them. She longed so eagerly to charm, to be desired, to be wildly attractive and sought after” (Maupassant 1). The American Dream reminds people not to settle. When people like Mathilde are unhappy with a good life situation, they expect too much from the American Dream, taking the idea of not settling almost too far. It is impossible to be satisfied when the desire for more is always in your sights. For almost all Americans, this flaw has become a part of their identity, as it coincides with the American Dream. LeAlan and Lloyd notice this flaw as well, though they see it from a slightly different perspective. When LeAlan talks about the privileged suburban kids and struggling ghetto kids, relating to how their identities differ because of their upbringings, he says, “But then sometimes the suburban kid doesn’t have to work and gets everything he wants. That’s why you see a lot more suicides in the suburban area-because the kid doesn’t have to work for nothing and he just goes crazy” (Jones and Newman 43). This quote holds truth, people with different backgrounds and experiences may have opposing identities and views on the American Dream. Yet in disagreement, whether a suburban kid or a ghetto kid, as LeAlan calls them, has an easy or hard upbringing, they will all have to work in order to reach their goals. In the case of both texts, once these goals are reached, especially for those who did not need to work as hard to reach them, an unsatisfied part of their identity will ask for more.…

    • 1559 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    For this assignment I observed two families, one was an upper middle classed family that I encountered in Target. I also observed a seemingly lower middle classed family I encountered them in a local grocery store. Both these families were white they also had many similarities as well as differences the differences they had were like night and day. Going into this assignment I thought that all middle classed families were like the ones that are portrayed on television the snobby, privileged, and stiff people who didn’t care about anyone but themselves, I chose an upper middle classed family and a lower middle classed family just to compare how they acted with their family and how they interacted with others in the stores, or wherever they are outside of the home.…

    • 998 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In today’s society, there seem to be many people dependent on the welfare system. In many instances, these families are made up of young unwed Teen Mothers lots of them working minimum wage jobs just to make ends meet. This being their only means of survival at times and the only way they can afford to feed their Children. These are people we pass by every day, not even realizing or even knowing that they might not be able to feed themselves or their Children. Believe it or not In the United States there is millions who are forced to get help providing for themselves and their families. The economy being what it is now, people losing their jobs, forecloses…

    • 2591 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Diversity Assignment

    • 465 Words
    • 2 Pages

    I grew up in what society would term as a ‘‘poor socioeconomic class.'' My parents got divorced when I was five years old. My Mother was a single Mother, and a hard worker. I do not enjoy being termed, ‘‘poor’’ because though my family did not have a lot money, we were rich in love and affection.…

    • 465 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    This movie portrays how a family, who has a member with a disability, encountered and overcame adversities from within triggered by several environmental factors. The protagonist, Carla Tate, who has an intellectual disability, seeks freedom from her mother, acceptance from others, and attention/love from opposite sex. Eventually she got those as the story developed. This only means that a disability should never serve as a hindrance in achieving your dreams.…

    • 616 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics