War is the worst thing a mankind can face. For me, war is always associated with sadness, loss, grief and people’s bravery. And all these themes are brightly unfolded in the story “In Another Country” by Ernest Hemingway, which is under consideration. Hemingway is an American author of the 20th century, who won the Nobel Prize in Literature in 1954. The ones of his famous works include The Sun Also Rises, A Farewell to Arms, The Old Man and The Sea. The popularity of Hemingway's is based on the themes, which are love, war, wilderness and loss, all of which are strongly evident in the body of work.
The title of the story is puzzling, as it has two meanings: direct and indirect one. At first glance, "In Another Country," refers to the fact that the American narrator is indeed in a foreign land-Italy. But the other side of it is that the main hero is culturally, emotionally in another country. He is at War, the country of the ‘so-called’ sickness and injuring.
Now let me give you the brief reconstruction of the events. It was fall in Milan, a group of soldiers wounded in World War I received treatment at a hospital. There, one of the main characters, the narrator of the story, wounded in his knee, saw three Italian soldiers, but felt a great wall between him and them, because he had received his medal for being an American, and they actually performed feats of bravery to receive theirs. Another main character, the major with the withered hand taught him Italian. One day, the major became angry when Nick mentions about marriage, he burst out, because the major's wife had just died. The major could not resign himself to the loss of his wife. He was crushed, shattered by the news.
While reading the story we can state several key-points, which help us to understand and analyze the context. And the main of them, to my mind are war and bravery. First, let me dwell upon the bravery. The attitude towards bravery is different in terms of the characters of the story. The personality of the narrator is described indirectly, through his thoughts . He wasn’t a brave man during the war. “I was very much afraid to die… and wondering how I would be when I went back to the front again’.
As for the three soldiers, there was no notion of the bravery in the targets of any of these persons. The narrator calls them “hunting hawks”. They were hunting for medals, material values, given by the government, not for the faith.
The attitude of the protagonist and the soldiers are also specific due to attitude towards the war, so was the major. We get to know from the story that they are Italian. They are very patriotic people, and their duty was to protect their country, as the war was on their territory. And the narrator was just an American, Let me quote : “I had been given the medals because I was an American…being wounded, after all, was really an accident.” He didn’t understand why people die, what they fought for. The problem of the ‘lost generation’ arises here. The fact is that Americans were indifferent to the war. Their aim was just to participate and being wounded. As the result, the relationship between the narrator and the soldiers were specific. Let me quote: “I was a friend, but I was never really one of them… they have done different things to get their medals”, “I wasn’t a hawk”.
As for the major, he didn’t believe in bravery at at. And Through his loss we understand that for the narrator the major was the bravest man of all, as he possessed a strong mind and tried to cope with his feelings like a brave soldier.
We are to admit that the author uses different stylistic device, what makes the story more expressive, captivating and interesting to read.
First of all it is the usage of foreign words, for instance “Signor Maggiore”, “A basso gliufficiali!”, which reflect the Italian atmosphere, where the action takes place.
Other stylistic device is symbolism, which, to my mind, prevalent in this story. The recovering machines are the symbol of false promises and hopes. I quote: “… there were large framed photograps around the wall, of all sorts of wounds before and after they had been cured by the machines… I do not know where the doctor got them”, and this symbol also implicate with irony, e.g. “You will be able to play football again better than ever”. Other symbols, “roasted chestnuts”, “charcoal fire”, are the hopes for the better, because they mean light and warmth.
The story makes use of repetition to emphasize the narration “In the fall the war was always there”, “It was cold in the fall in Milan and the dark came very early.” He repeats this idea with a slightly different emphasis at the end of the paragraph: “It was a cold fall and the wind came down from the mountains.” This description of nature here is also rather symbolic. It makes me feel the atmosphere of death and hopelessness. In conclusion I can say that it is smth bloody and sad. But through all these disasters we are to stay humans and bravery ones. The war will finish, but the human nature is eternal.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
This book report discusses the plot, significant characters, setting (e.g., time of the story took place, historical background), problems and resolutions, themes or messages of the story. A reflection of the author’s writing style will be presented followed by a conclusion.…
- 1544 Words
- 7 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Bread and Wine is a timeless story of the struggle of one man in a changing country. The Country is Italy. The time is the 1930 's, however the struggle is against fascism. To understand where the book is coming from, one must first understand where the author himself was coming from. Ignazio Silone can be closely related to the main character in the book; Pietro Spina. He was born early in May in the year 1900. Living in a small village in the region of Abruzzi, something caught the eye of the young Silone. That something, was the promise of a better life. That something, was the hope of a socialist Italy. Since 15 years old Ignazio Silone tried desperately, doing what was in his power to help the cause, and overcome the odds of fascism. It is his life that ignited his writing career, and that career which ignited the beginning of this book.…
- 1286 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
Lina is stuck in a foreign country without knowing any Italian and has no one who truly understands her there, but the journal offers a sense of comfort and strength for her because it feels like her mom is walking right beside her throughout her trip.…
- 547 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Hemingway’s inspiration was war, both as a personal and symbolic experience and as a continuing condition of humankind.…
- 759 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
In Italy, fishermen are punished for helping illegal immigrants from the sea get to shore and let them go because this adds to the illegal immigration problem in Italy. Therefore a young man named Filippo does not let any illegal immigrants on his boat. Later some people die and Filippo changes his mind about the matter. He decides to help a mother, a little boy and a newborn baby.…
- 255 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
Even though to be in conflict with society and especially its values and beliefs isn’t easy for many authors to do, Ernest Hemingway breaks out this idea in order to give the reader a deep and provoking novel, mixed with unusual themes for that time in the way they were depicted, like alcoholism and expatriation.…
- 617 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Through this act, Guido risked everyone’s life because if someone in the cabin had not understood German, the whole cabin would have lost vital information to survive in the camp. Guido lies and goes to extreme lengths to shelter his son from the reality of the Holocaust by turning imminent survival into a playful game. This scene forces the audience to think about childish games and the fragility of life in the camps simultaneously, provoking the audience to think about the life of…
- 2326 Words
- 10 Pages
Better Essays -
Commentary: In order to develop ideas for this paper, I first analyzed the time of the Depression and what Italian Immigrants lives were like typically living in America. Using this background knowledge, I was able to analyze the lifestyles of the working class in each of the stories. Even though the background story of each of the family’s lives differed, they all had a common basis in that they were Italian Immigrant families working a hard lifestyle in order to support the family during economic hardship. I revised this paper by looking to see if my ideas were clearly expressed. I ran into an obstacle of trying to figure out which ideas to express, since the novels are characterized with many examples. In order to overcome this, I decided that I wanted to stick with the main points of the novel to my ideas across. This is where I think my strength came in. However, I think my weakness lies in organization of my ideas within each story.…
- 2790 Words
- 12 Pages
Powerful Essays -
As Michele learns more about Filippo Carducci, Michele’s nightmares shift into reality. Michele’s discovery of the boy in the hole and what to do is the most severe test of his moral character. Even when Michele knows he is right to be afraid, he is compelled to act by his sense of moral obligation. He knows he “must go” to see Filippo after he hears Filippo’s mothers declaration of love on the television, even though he “was scared”. His loss of innocence and world of betrayal are distressing and difficult lessons for him. “Papa was the bogeyman. By day he…
- 778 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
While scarcely a sentence, Hemingway's work of Flash Fiction “For sale: baby shoes, never worn.” is indeed a story. It contains the expected attributes of a story, neatly wrapped up in a super compact form. After showing said work has a beginning, middle, end, setting, an array of characters and conflict, it becomes hard to deny its place among other stories.…
- 279 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Ernest Miller Hemingway was born on July 21, 1899, in Oak Park, Illinois at his family's Victorian home. He is known as one of the greatest writers of American literature in the twentieth century. Even today, Hemingway's mythological character fascinates and at times bewilders literary critics and readers. Frequently, his writings recreated the events of his life, some of which caused him much distress. He was married four times during his sixty-one years, but the first two marriages appear to have had the greatest fundamental impact on his life. In "Hills Like White Elephants," Hemingway re-evaluates his own experiences in terms of relationships and his decision to father children.…
- 598 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Both War by Luigi Pirandello and Family History by Jacques Prévert demonstrate that people may avoid the reality of tragedies that result from war in order to help themselves cope with the emotional impact. As “Human kind cannot bear very much reality,” (T.S. Elliot) one must face the harsh truths in life for one to truly understand and feel the tragic impact of war and death, no matter how devastating the situation may be. If one does not face the realities of life it can cause ones values or moral beliefs to become askew. Readers are given two different view points on this by the different characters of each story/poem. In War, the character referred to as the ‘fat man’ discusses the loss of a son at war and social responsibility versus personal sacrifice. In Family History, the characters’ values and morals are completely askew as the realities of a tragedy are never faced.…
- 799 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
In 1924, commonly accepted as the earliest specimen of Hemingway’s male protagonists, Nick Adams appears as the protagonist in Indian Camp. Nick is a boy just approaching manhood, who’s old enough for his father to be thinking about Nick’s future career yet still young enough to need some nurturing. Hemingway’s earlier writings show this code hero’s sensitivity more openly. Early in this brief story the line, “Nick lay back with his father's arm around him” (E. Hemingway 69), indicates ease with demonstrating a young man can have a warm, comforting relationship with his father.…
- 417 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
This short story is one of the stories in Men Without Women, written by Ernest Hemingway, an American writer. I started to love every Hemingway’s short story since I reached this semester especially this short story, which is tells about boxing that is one of my favorite sport. I think Hemingway was a man’s man. He wrote everything covered both things that happened in World War I and World War II, he had deep-sea stories, he liked to tell about himself, every journey he had done and using I which is refered to his main character of his stories that could make people who never read his stories would think that I, refered to Hemingway itself. He removes himself from the role of narrator. The stories are almost wholly composed of dialogue. One must engage him or herself in the narratives and ignite his or her imagination to understand the emotional core of each of these stories. Hemingway expects us to.…
- 2383 Words
- 10 Pages
Better Essays -
Ernest Hemingway once said, "As you get older, it is harder to have heroes, but it is sort of necessary." Hemingway knew this because he actually invented his famous code hero. The Hemingway code hero was a macho man that indulged in liquor, women, and food, and usually did not fear God. In almost all of Hemingway’s stories and books such as: “Indian Camp”, “The Short Happy Life of Francis Macomber”, his Inter Chapters, and all of his other stories and books. However, while reading “The Old Man and the Sea”, the reader is not exposed to the usual Hemingway code hero. Hemingway creates an aging hero that proves to be the opposite of the normal code hero by his disinterest in physical pleasures, the presence of religion, and the presence of a companion.…
- 692 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays