Since the mother is talking about her daughter's history, it makes the story more personal, because she witnessed all of her history. The story shows how the mother viewed her child, and how her child grew up. The point of view comes from a person who truly and unconditionally loves her child, and would do anything for them. She mentions all of the grief, anger, and sadness her daughter Emily went through. The theme of the story is the bond between a mother and daughter, and it is more personal and loving because the mother explains their lives.
The narrative structure of the story is based on certain flashbacks to Emily's childhood, as her mother remembers them. This shows just how great of a love Emily's mother had for her daughter, who despite everything, still tried to do the best thing for her daughter, given the circumstances. Flashbacks give a personal view into events that happened, through a person who was there. The mother explains her anger and despair for some flashbacks, such as when her child was away at the asylum and when she was with her paternal family. The flashback of when Emily became a comedian was a happy one for her mother, who remembers the joy and excitement in her daughter during that time.
If the point of view had been different, the whole story would have been affected. If Emily's point of view had been given, then it would have been more bleak and dismal, because she was not a happy child. She would, of course, have shown even more joy than her mother when she became a comedian. If the social worker had given her point of view, it would have been impersonal and of course from an outsider, so not warm or loving at all.
The point of view and narrative structure of this story are very crucial to the comprehension of the theme and the thoughts and feelings meant to be felt by the reader. The theme is the bond of a mother and daughter, and is shown throughout the story, through flashbacks and certain areas of point of view. Change in the point of view would have ruined the affect given by this author.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
In “I Stand Here Ironing” by Tillie Olsen, the narrator is absent for many important moments of her daughter Emily’s life. This absence causes many issues for the narrator in regards to knowing her daughter and to creating a bond with her. The narrator describes Emily’s growth throughout life in the story while also describing her own issues as a parent trying to provide for her family with relatively no help financially. There are many key times in the story where Emily is absent from the narrator’s life and an important moment happens. Emily misses these moments due to her absences that are decided by her mother. These absences have caused Emily great difficulty in finding herself as a person throughout life. By…
- 1976 Words
- 8 Pages
Better Essays -
This gives the story sort of mysterious sort of view. We don't read Emily's thoughts or reasoning but of her actions. This gives the audience outside looking in point of view. The story teller also gives us the town's people reactions to the main character deeds. The story teller recounts the events in Ms. Emily's life: how her father force her first love away, trying to kept her father's dead body, and the mysterious departure of her latest beau. Not knowing all the detail grabs our attention until the end of the story. Then it let us draws our own conclusion. This not only where the stories contrast, the personalities of the main characters are vastly…
- 718 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
For my paper, I chose to write about the short story, “I Stand Here Ironing,” by Tillie Olsen. In the story, a mother of a nineteen-year-old girl named Emily is ironing some clothes, as she is pondering a recent message she received from one of Emily’s counselors or teachers; a message of concerns with wanting to help her daughter. The mother begins to think back to the very beginning of Emily’s life. She starts stating all the various events that took place in Emily’s life that could have played a role in why Emily is the way she is now. These events had to do with Emily’s father walking out on them, Emily having to go to daycare in her early years, and also self esteem issues from not looking like the other girls in school.…
- 569 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Upon reflection, Emily appears to achieve a greater wisdom than nearly any of the living. A wisdom that according to the stage manager is only possessed by “saints and poets maybe”. She realizes how special every moment of life is, and she is shocked at how people just let their life fly by. All too often people take things for granted, they become complacent in their everyday life. Emily is struck by the tragedy that she only truly appreciated what she had after it was gone. She sees every second of her life as extraordinarily precious, even a seemingly irrelevant moment. She realizes that the living are so busy with the small things in life that they don’t take the time to appreciate the important things. Looking back, Emily wants nothing but to talk to her…
- 1039 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
The story begins with a woman ironing her daughters dress. It causes her to recount the life she as provided for her daughter Emily. As she considers her actions she wishes that she had done some things differently. Unfortunately, the depression era had left her with very few choices if any at all. So to survive and provide for her children the mother, abandoned by her husband, had unintentionally, not protected nor not made the best choices for Emily. Several times, during the course of Emily childhood the mother would leave her to the care of other, a few of these times for extended stays. The mother knew that some to these situations were not to Emily’s best interest but she would leave her just the same. The outcome would mold Emily into emotionally, mentally, and physically deprivation. It also caused Emily to lose the beauty she was born with which resulted in self-esteem issues. This might have been the reason for the conflict she had with her siblings, the siblings that she helped to care for who were younger than her. Even thought Emily had a low self-esteem and grow to be frail, sickly, and nonchalant, she discovered that she had talent as a comedian after winning a talent show at school. Emily became a comedian and preformed at other schools, colleges, and community fairs. With new confidence and growing in maturity Emily’s acquired a beauty all her own. The mother observed this as she completed her ironing and prepared for bed, than she wondered why she even worried at all. She figured out that even though she helplessly made mistakes along the way raising Emily, causing for many imperfections in her child whom was now nineteen, that she still had the power to reassure Emily of herself worth. She still had time to be a better mother.…
- 478 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
The different methods of characterization Olsen used to describe her characters also influenced the mood of the story. Emily was described as a dark-haired, thin girl who was reserved and almost never smiled. The mom feels like this is her fault and if she had given the girl more reassurance she would have smiled more and not felt so bad about how she looked. “Months later she told me how she had taken pennies from my purse to buy him candy. ‘Licorice was his favorite and I brought him some every day, but he still liked Jennifer better’n me. Why Mommy” (Olsen 213). The mom felt guilty that she hadn’t encouraged Emily’s talents instead of frowning upon her faults. Most of all, she just wishes she had followed her own maternal instinct instead of…
- 679 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Tillie Olsen's I Stand Here Ironing addresses the issue of a mother's guilt over how her child turns out and develops into a grown woman. Although she blames herself for the daughter's problems, is it really her fault? While this short story is obviously about the mousy daughter, the mother often mentions how she feels guilty for the way her daughter Emily is, for the things she (the mother) did and did not do. The ideal mother-daughter relationship is not like the one we find in this short story. This is neither the fault of the mother or the daughter.…
- 788 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Throughout the story “I Stand Here Ironing” author Tillie Olsen places readers into the eye of a mother as she evaluates the relationship dynamics between her and her oldest daughter. Using tools such as first person point of view Olsen immerses readers into the lives of The Mother and her daughter Emily and narrates the many misfortunes that occurred in both of their lives. I believe that because of this perspective Emily and her mother are portrayed as “victims” of circumstance. Olsen explains to readers that the Mother’s circumstance snowballed into unhappiness for Emily. Along with her feelings of unhappiness Emily struggled with many trials by herself. Ultimately the interaction between Emily and her mother may be the biggest factor that defines these two characters as “victims…
- 1363 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
In "A Rose for Emily" Faulkner begins the story with the death of Miss Emily Grierson, giving the reader the first glimpse into the main character of the story. By using an objective point of view an author turns the reader into a jury, so that the reader is able to interpret the story, and draw conclusions when given enough information. An Objective point of view is when the narrator assumes the position of an observer, detached from the narrative. Faulkner decidedly chose this point of view to intimately show how gossips think. Only from this view could we hear their negative thoughts they have of Emily. The town gives the reader an impression of our main character. “When miss Emily Grierson died, our whole town went to her funeral: the men through a sort of respectful affection for a fallen monument”(21). Emily coming from a well known popular family the town was always concerned with the family’s actions. After many generations the town began to lose hope in the family because of their attitude. With the town losing hope in the family it gives…
- 1295 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
First, Emily is stubborn and unbalanced mentally, physically, and emotionally because of the obstacles she has undergone within her lifespan. Emily wanted to convert her per-civil war self, which was a traditional one, practiced slavery, lived in a wonderful mansion, and cared for money; as such corresponded with her father. All her life it seems that she was raised at a standard that was above the rest. By living such a secluded and controlled life it set her up for the happenings in her future.…
- 469 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
2) What does the title of the story suggest about the townspeople’s feelings toward Miss Emily? Why do they feel this way about her? (Or: What does she represent to them?) Is there anything ironic about their feelings?…
- 1029 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
It is through Emily’s reflection and review of her life that allows us to see how age has not withered Emily. No matter what events have happened over the years, may it be the death of her son or the death of her husband, Emily stands strong and is undefeated by them. She tells herself bravely, “It’s all over now. It’s all past, it can’t be changed…” and still continues to look forward to living. The death of these two people in her life did not make her cling incessantly to the people around her, in fear of losing them. Instead, age and experience has taught her to let go of some things in life, one of which is her daughter, Doris, who was supposed to stay with her at Emerald Hill. This time, Emily’s willingness to let go and allow the children to make their own choices paid off. She was able to maintain a good relationship with her only daughter and is satisfied to know that Doris is living happily in America. Her willingness to let go also brought her closer to her remaining 3 children, who are willing to come back to Emerald Hill to visit her frequently with her grandchildren even though all of them moved away. Towards the end of the…
- 1803 Words
- 8 Pages
Powerful Essays -
2. What does the title of the story suggest about the townspeople’s feelings toward Miss Emily? Why do they feel this way about her? (Or: What does she represent to them?) Is there anything ironic about their feelings?…
- 349 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Right from the start of the story the narration gives us a sense of how the townspeople think of Miss Emily. The setting is Emily’s funeral with the entire town in attendance “the men through a sort of respectful affection for a fallen monument, the women mostly out of curiosity to see the inside of her house”. (Faulkner 128) The story then goes back to the beginning starting with the death of Emily’s father. When Miss Emily’s father dies the narrator says, “At least they could pity Miss Emily.” (Faulkner 130). The people thought that Miss Emily was living such a perfect life that this had finally “humanized” her. After the death of Emily’s father she became more of a source of entertainment among the town. When people went to offer condolences they were met at the door by Miss Emily denying her father’s death. Finally the body was disposed of and now she was left with nothing because her father had always driven away anyone who tried to get close to her.…
- 1519 Words
- 7 Pages
Better Essays -
Miss Emily finds herself to be very alone after the death of her father and is willing to do what she has to do to keep someone she loves in her life. In the beginning of the story Faulkner writes that after Miss Emily loses the two sweethearts of her life she is seen very rarely. This showing that Miss Emily was lost because her two loves were gone. After her fathers death the women and minister call the house to send their condolences and Miss Emily refuses to believe that her father has past away. She kept claiming that " her father was not dead (104)." Three days after Miss Emily's father passes on she finally broke down and let them dispose of the body. Miss Emily didn't want to accept the fact that her father had past on because she was so close to him and he was all she had.…
- 857 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays