Both of the poems are about World War one, and describe the author’s thought on how women fit in the war. Sassoon writes very negatively about women, while Cannan is very positive. There are many reasons for this. Keep in mind that Sassoon is a man, who fought in the war and got wounded and treated in a hospital. Cannan is a woman and was a nurse at Rouen in World War one. Therefore Cannan is much more positive towards women in her poem than Sassoon is in his.
If we first take a look at Sassoon’s poem, we see that it is written in a sarcastic way. He shows the difference between men and women: The women could stay home and do whatever they want, and men were obliged to put their lives at risk to fight in the war. In the first few lines he states that women only care about the men when they are home and are able to brag about them, but as soon as they leave it is like they don’t even exist. ‘You love us when we’re heroes, home on leave, or wounded in a mentionable place.’ We can see this thought throughout the poem. He says women listen to the man’s stories as if they’re unreal: ‘You listen with delight, by tales of dirt and danger fondly thrilled.’ However Sassoon knows that the war is not a fairy tale or exciting story, for him it is very realistic and horrific. The women don’t understand that it might be too much for the soldier and they could ‘retire’. Over all Sassoon tries to tell us that women have absolutely no idea what happens during such a war, they only listen to the heroic stories.
Now, Cannan is much more positive towards women during the war in her poem. She herself was a nurse at Rouen, and saw with her own eyes what happened. She says positive stuff, but also some negative stuff. The first part is an example of a happy view on the war: ‘Early morning over Rouen, hopeful, high, courageous morning, and the laughter of adventure and the steepness of the stair, and the dawn across the river, and the wind across the bridges, and the empty littered station, and the tired people there.’ Another example of this would be the sentence: ‘All the youth and pride of England from the ends of all the earth.’ She seems to loop upon the war very positively. But in her poem she also remember the Aid post and Red cross train: Can I forget the passage from the cool white-bedded Aid Post past the long sun-blistered coaches of the khaki Red Cross train to the truck train full of wounded, and the weariness and laughter and “Good-bye, and thank you, Sister”, and the empty yards again?’ At the very end of the poem she says: ‘My heart goes out to Rouen, Rouen all the world away.’ In this sentence Rouen has a double entendre, when you take a look at the pronunciation. She thinks about Rouen all the time, and about how it will ruin the whole world. She is perfectly aware of the horrors of the story, but does see the positive stuff and helps out the soldiers when they’re wounded instead of just listening to their stories.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
[ 2 ]. Elizabeth De Cacqueray, ‘Introduction: Gender Disturbance; Women and War in 20th Century United Kingdom’, Revue LISA/LISA e-journal, 6/4 (2008).…
- 4291 Words
- 18 Pages
Best Essays -
When one reads a war story, they expect to hear about the hardships of being a soldier. Stories about the rough and tough journey a soldier goes on when going to war. Tim O’Brien writer of many war stories portrays the hardships of being a soldier in Vietnam. While most of the readers are so intrigued with the killings and dead bodies, they will overlook the negative female characteristic labelling anyone who is opposing the soldiers. Lorrie N. Smith author of “The Things Men Do: The Gendered Subtext in Tim O’Brien’s Esquire Stories,” reflects on how O’Brien’s stories are highly representative of its bias against femininity. The story is centered around masculinity, and negatively labels the weak with feminine characteristics. An example from…
- 190 Words
- 1 Page
Good Essays -
Many women saw the suffering and anguish of men as they had not in previous wars and worked side by side with men as comrades and friends. This…
- 359 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
On brisk September mornings, civilian residences often answer the door to a military officer whom bears bad news about their sons. During the reconstruction, the sex ratio is off balance and many women do not have a full grasp on why they are lonely. In “War is Kind” by the famous poet Stephen Crane; he adopts sarcastic diction and syntax to display war as a destructive force.…
- 416 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
While her she had written her most known poem “Rouen” After Volunteering she had begun to write her poetry books. In the year 1917 from her poetry book “In the war” she had wrote a poem called “After the War”. In this poem she talks about the women that wait at home not knowing if their husband or boyfriend will return to them once again. She talks about how the world was happy and beautiful before and how it so empty and barren after the war. May really did show how it was to be a women during these time and not only did the men have to struggle with the war.…
- 874 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Although the tone in the poem is often light-hearted, the author, Anne Bradstreet, is very critical of those who restrict women's roles. This is because women can do much more than sew and cook. The speaker is a writer, an avid reader, and well-educated. She's ready to go to war with those who attack her, but is also gracious enough to let things go once she's made…
- 363 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
I believe that the author did an outstanding job of presenting the information in this book. Many authors would have tried to intertwine these women’s stories in order to make the story more interesting as a whole. Instead she sets aside a chapter to different groups she wants to go into detail discussing. For instance, she doesn’t try to compare and contrast the women who were on the home front to the women who followed the armies. Instead, she helps you realize the importance of both by devoting…
- 578 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
War is presented in various ways in literature with each writer presenting it in their own unique way due to influences in their social and historical background e.g. Owen wrote poems about war as he was experiencing it. One of the factors on whether a piece, be it a poem or a play or a novel, was positive or negative towards war all depended on the writer’s attitude towards war e.g. Jessie Pope’s “Who’s For The Game?” is all about her trying to convince men it was all a bit of fun to join the war and fight for their country, which makes perfect sense for a woman to say as women during the time of world war one often encouraged men to join war as they stayed behind to look after the children ect. But the poems I want to discuss are “Dulce Et Decorum Est” by Wilfred Owen and “Who’s for The Game?” by Jesse Pope. The play i'm going to Discuss is “Macbeth” by William Shakespeare.…
- 2592 Words
- 11 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Analysis: Prior to the war the men only saw them as pure and sweet although the women are able to change. As the women are put into a new lifestyle the women are calmly able to make the needed changes. In this they acknowledge that the women are capable of changing to fit the current situations and how drastically the change was.…
- 1225 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
Sarah Lumb is a working class girl, she's employed in a munitions factory which gives a her stable income that she could never of achieved before the war. Sarah says that she was earning '10 bob a week' before the war and now she's earning '50 bob a week' this is a massive change for women and Sarah says she 'likes the work' because she wouldn’t have the opportunity to earn that amount of money before. Prior is a patient at Craiglockhart hospital due to being sent home from the war with shellshock, Barker describes him as being left feeling 'out of touch' with women as many aspects have changed since the war began and he feels as though he has been sent back to a different world where women are now more powerful than before he left. Prior says that as women have 'expanded' over this period where men have 'shrunk'. By presenting priors feelings this way it shows the reader how the male and female gender roles changed during the war period, women became more superior by filling in the gaps in society that men left behind when they signed up to fight. This had a negative effect on most soldiers because when they came home it was a complete reversal of roles, they were no longer the ones who were depended on to bring in the income therefore this made them lose there sense of masculinity and feel unneeded.…
- 1042 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
*This poem seems to address the oppression of women and/or how women are viewed in society. Past and present. Works such as “Color Purple” relate to same subject matter.…
- 1005 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
In the satire novel, Candide, Voltaire discusses the exploitation of women in the 18th century. Cunegonde, Paquette and the old women suffer through many adversities such as rape and being physically and mentally abused. One could argue that these women should be pitied upon or admired, when in actuality, they should be both pitied and admired.…
- 405 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Once World War I started, the continent of Europe changed drastically, with the men all gone off in service to their nation. As seen in Sandra Gilbert’s Soldiers Heart, Women were often used as the reason the men had to go off and fight, as seen in one of the wartime slogans, “The Women are Watching,” “Women of Britton Say Go!” (Gilbert 433) However, women were still left without the right to vote, many sending off husbands and sons with no say in the matter while husbands and sons felt guilted by women into going off to war to protect women. All of these things, plus a large physical separation from men who were already worry about the growing “issue” of gender identity, meant many men grew bitter and resentful. As seen in a quote from John Kipling in a letter back home, he expresses that the people, “Don’t realize how spoilt you are” (Gilbert 430). According to Ellen Key in “War and the Sexes,” found in Word War I and the Homefront, in a time where there was darkness and insurmountable odds…
- 979 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The first notable characteristic of “Women” is the physical form of the poem itself. The shape of the poem strengthens the ideology of the message Swenson is trying to express. At first glance, the particular image of the poem could be a play on women’s curves. However, once the content is further examined, it is clear that Swenson is using the image of the poem to emphasize what women should be. The poem's structure imitates many different components: the rocking of a rocking horse, the curves of a woman's body, and an unscalable ladder. Through the swaying words and flowing structure, an illusion of rocking is created; thus, creating the vision of a rocking horse. The curvature, also, mimics a woman’s body. With regards to societal obstacles, the ladder imitates a woman’s struggle to prevail over such barricades to success. All aspects directly relate to the importance of a “traditional” woman in the eyes of men.…
- 628 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Life in world war one first of all is nothing that the soldiers expected, whereas they have been lied and led to belief false statements about the war. For example the many propaganda posters manipulated and persuaded the men to sign up to be soldiers. An example of this is the poster on the right side stating “Woman of Britain say -Go!” This poster shows men in world war one being pressured by the public and the government to go, even though they might not want to and may not realise the reality of war. This poster shows the men and uses the fact that they are fighting for women, to protect them and family, so they won’t be hopeless. It also tells them that the women agree that they should go to war, and this lures and is persuasive as the men want to impress the women. This is also shown in the example on the left saying “WHO`S ABSENT? Is it you?” This example again shows the pressure that men were put under even before joining the army. The picture is making is acting upon the soldiers conscience to support their country and creating their patriotism. Putting pressure on men suggesting that every soldier counts, putting them on the spot that they should be here. The tone is assertive and accusing suggesting shame if you’re not there, also the finger pointing at the middle gives the feeling of talking to the person directly, putting them on the spot.…
- 849 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays