Some of the main messages hidden in the song use the lyrics “Frankie kicked a mine that day, the man kicked the moon”. these messages where for the people sitting at home, that the government was trying to cover up the war by diverting their attention on the moon landing to cover up the disgrace and horror of the war, they didn’t want the public of America sitting at home to know about what is really going on in the world. Also, for the soldiers in Vietnam the moon landing is just another memory for horror.
It also mentions about life for the soldiers after the war. Physical and psychological. The physical refers to the lyrics “and what’s this rash that comes and goes”. This refers to the chemicals that were used in the war. This can refer to Agent Orange, a chemical that was used on dense jungle and bush areas to burn the foliage off the trees to find the Vietnamese soldiers tunnels and networks. A side effect of this chemical was that when used in close range could cause serious physical defects to soldiers exposed, such as cancers and genetic damage, also, a recurring rash.
The psychological refers to the lyrics ‘why I still can’t get to sleep? And night time’s just a jungle dark and a barking M16?’ and “why I still can’t get to sleep? And why the Channel 7 chopper chills down to my feet?’ This talks about the fact that soldiers can’t just walk away from their experiences. They still have all the terrible memories, which can be remembered by simple normal life occurrences, such as a plane going overhead or loud noises that sound like gunfire. Also within the name, ‘I was only nineteen’ shows as well, that he still has his whole life to suffer from these memories.
The song clearly goes on about the negative aspects of war, nothing about this song relates to the apparent “glory of war”. The lyrics that express this are “The Anzac legends didn’t mention the mud, blood and tears”. These soldiers weren’t prepared for the pain of war, a war they didn’t even start, that was one of the main reasons for the making of this text. This song has been that affective in the time that it was rereleased by the band “The Herd”, in a bid to help remind people about the war, this time aimed at the Iraq war. The fact that this song has been remade because of the dramatic effect it caused, speaks for itself, that this song is successful in the move towards anti war. It is for this reason and the others I have mentioned before that I believe this to be one of the most persuasive texts about war I have read and heard.
Thank you.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
This song is a very simple one with a very clear message against the war in Vietnam, and against President Nixon. It was not surprising to find that because this was an anti-war song, it was banned from many radio…
- 554 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Perception of the Enemy The everlasting commotion of bombshells, gunshots, ear piercing screams, and the rumble of tanks began with the assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand. To say the least, hell broke loose in 1914, the mental and emotional scars that the soldiers of World War I bare is utterly incomprehensible to the common man. Through all the chaos, the soldiers never quite knew what they were doing, they were drafted, and from that point on for the next four years came the nonstop misery and false hope of the war ending. The soldiers of the war never had a hatred for the opposing side, it was forced murder; they saw each other with pity from time to time which the authors Erich Maria Remarque, August Stramm, and Tim O’ Brien exemplify…
- 961 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The beginning of the poem starts out very depressing, the soldier talks as if they are old men on their death beds. ""Knock-kneed, coughing like hags, we cursed through sludge"(2), this line implies how miserable the soldier 's are, their sick, weak, and enduring unbearable conditions. They are walking toward their camp, which the poem tells us is quite a distance away. But they are so tired they are sleeping as they walk toward the camp. These men don 't even have sufficient clothing, some have lost their boots and most are covered in blood. "Drunk with fatigue; deaf even to the hoots / Of tried, outstripped Five-Nines that dropped behind"(6-7). This line tells us that these men are so exhausted they have become numb to the war and blood-shed around them. The soldier 's have become numb to the 5.9 inch caliber shells flying by their heads, the bombs bursting behind them, and their fallen comrades body 's lying next to them.…
- 569 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
In the book, If I Die in a Combat Zone…, Tim O’Brien, a Vietnam veteran, gives us his raw, personal story on what it was like to be a soldier in a controversial war. O’Brien was/is a conscientious objector to the Vietnam War and yet he completed his one-year service. He does not shy away from his negative opinions about the war and how in a way the government had let him down. O’Brien leads his story from the beginning in 1968 where he is drafted in Minnesota through 1969 with his homecoming. Throughout the book he is keen on the recognition of his comrades’ deaths, the Vietnamese residents, his daily internal/external battles, and the contemplation of what is bravery/courage.…
- 178 Words
- 1 Page
Good Essays -
Then Terry, father diagnosed by a doctor that something is wrong with him. An example from the text found on page 50 when it states,”It’s from the war, his mother had said. The doctors at the veterans’ hospital call it the Vietnam syndrome.”This is important because a doctor had said that he had a syndrome from the war and it’s probable PTSD.…
- 199 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
'I was only 19' is a song written/composed by Redgum, it is about a first-person account of a typical Australian soldiers' experience in the Vietnam War. The poem focuses on the after effects of what happens to the soldiers after war, how they experience PTSD (post- traumatic stress disorder) and that leads us to believe that an internal war is ongoing. In this text, the technique used is imagery. Redgum uses this technique to describe what their experience was like. This prompts the audience to feel sympathy for the soldiers.…
- 174 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
For the duration of “I was only 19” there are many poetic devices which include repetition, colloquialism, rhetorical questions and metaphors. Repetition is used throughout the song to reinforce that the boy was only 19 and yet he was still being exposed to the horrors and brutality of war. Colloquialism is also used through mention of “VB”, “drinking tinnies” and “til the morphine came and killed the bloody row”, this language allows readers to have a greater connection with the song as it is more relaxed and free flowing. Rhetorical questions are used in this song to get the listeners more involved and thinking about the meaning of the song, an example of a rhetorical questions used in the song is ‘and can you tell me doctor, why i still can’t get to sleep?’. the final technique is metaphors an example is ‘it was a war within yourself’ this is suggesting that the feelings and emotions of the soldiers were going through was just as chaotic and horrific as a war however there wasn't actually a literal war in your head it was just figurative…
- 296 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
The emotions that I felt from the song was this is a reflection on time, slavery and all the things associated with them.…
- 350 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
The song is about negative issues that are on a global level. In an interview about the song Butler says “It’s hard not to look around and try to ask the questions, “Does anybody see the insanity that’s going around at the moment? Is it just me, or has anyone else seen this craziness, this madness of destruction, whether through war or killing people through the economy?”” The theme of the song is about standing up for a change and the fact that…
- 1227 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
The film shows the Vietnam experience from the average soldier 's point of view. In the beginning Chris Taylor is very ignorant and his chances of survival are slim. The movie went beyond just showing battles, with the showing of the moral dilemmas that the soldiers faced. The film does not in any way glorify the war in Vietnam. It is a gritty look at what the soldiers endured while serving their country. The men in the platoon come from all walks of life and all over the country. However they all share the same desire to serve their time and get as far away from the fighting as possible. There is not one soldier in the jungle whose mind is not irrevocably warped by the ravages of war. Some critics complain that the character development in the story is weak and there is no plot. J.P. Stern of U S News and World Report states that "The Central Plot tension - the battle for a young private 's soul between a "good" sergeant who has retained humanity and a "bad" sergeant who has become a killing machine is not very tense." However, the introduction of the entire cast in the film is what sets the film apart from others like it. There are no real heroes in this movie and no real villains. There is just a group of frightened men fighting for survival in their own ways and counting the days until they can leave the…
- 995 Words
- 4 Pages
Better Essays -
The war is brought to life by the flashbacks the soldiers experience in their nightmares as well as in their interaction with Dr. Rivers. Barker offers realistic details of many horrible war scenes, dwelling upon the destruction that war wreaks upon men 's minds. Throughout the novel, there is an insistence on physical suffering as well as on mental suffering.…
- 1246 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
Many similar ideas found in this song are also found in the book Fahrenheit 451, and in the short story, “Harrison Bergeron,” that we read in class. Each of these texts share the same idea of being revealed to something, and wanting to pursue it. In Fahrenheit 451 Guy Montag discovers the amazing thoughts and ideas in books that him and his society were deprived of. He does everything he can to fight for the right to have books. Though he did not know much about them he still does not give up until he succeeds. In the short story, “Harrison Bergeron,” they know nothing other than being drained down by weights and having their thought interrupted by government receivers. They cannot think for themselves nor can they do anything themselves. One boy Harrison, decides to go against the government he gets arrested but still fights, though he did not win in the end his brightness, and the idea of him being revealed to the truth will make it easier for others to understand. As well as these examples, this song shares similar ideas, considering it was written as a response to Fahrenheit 451. It talks about being in the dark, not knowing anything, then finally once he sees the light, everything makes sense to him. Everything turns out positive in the end.…
- 632 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
A summary of the first stanza is it describes soldiers who are hunched over carrying their gear through thick sludge. Some of the soldiers walking had lost their boots in battle, so they now have bloody feet, yet they still trudged through. They had been deafened earlier by the sounds of artillery and gas shells, and to add to that they were exhausted. The second stanza tells us the soldiers are bombarded by gas, and they hurry to put their masks on, but some soldiers unfortunately were not able to put them on in time. The narrator (Owen), who is a soldier, lost his comrade right before his own eyes. The third couplet shows us that the narrator is asking himself whether or not this is a dream when he says “In all my dreams before my helpless…
- 724 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
In the second stanza he talks about how the solders are looking like and what is going on behind them. He shows you what they look likes by saying. “Men marched asleep, many had lost their boots, but limped on, blood-shot”. This make you think the solders are so tired from the war and the horrible fighting, that they look like the=y are all asleep with one shoe on and one off. That the war bad they are so tired, to tired to walk. Later in the stanza he goes on to say. “All went lame; all blind; drunk with fatigue; deaf even to the hoots of tired, outstripped five-nines that dropped behind.” In this part of the poem he make it sound like they are all blind and all can’t walk, it make the atmosphere that they are all in a terrible condition and are extremely exhausted.…
- 588 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
While reading the novel one can see they sorrow that Bao felt in participating in this war. Many of the quotes in the book use a poetic phrase that the sorrow of war inside a soldier's mind was in a strange way immense sadness of a world at dusk. War took a lot from the people both of American and Vietnamese decent. You can see the sorrow from the beginning of the book quotes from Kien the main character you can see how much war really did affect them, “It was hard to remember a time when his whole personality and character had been intact, a time before the cruelty and destruction of war had warped his soul.” Soldiers didn’t even want to live during the war because Kien recounts the tale of a soldier, Quang, who is severely wounded during a battle. He begs to be shot and finally, commits suicide by using a grenade. As he is leaving, Kien hears as “Quang’s crazed laughter followed him” (96). Another thing these Vietnamese soldiers’s…
- 1250 Words
- 5 Pages
Powerful Essays