Preview

Montana 1948 Essay Example

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
847 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Montana 1948 Essay Example
Montana 1948 is about the loss of innocence and the painful gain of wisdom. Discuss.
Montana 1948 a series of tragic events were to have a major impact on David and his parents. David’s shocking revelations lead to his painful gaining of wisdom. When David’s story begins, his life is a stable and happy one, and his family are close and loving. It is this stability and respect though, in which the much loved and admired Frank is held by both the townspeople and David, that make the events which occur so shocking, particularly for David.

David must pretend, not just for the remainder of the novel, but for the next forty years, to be ignorant of Frank’s crimes, and much of what is happening because his parents do not realise that he has overheard their discussions.

A loss of David’s innocence appears during his killing of a magpie. This “it can be done in a flick of the finger”. The particular significance about this plays an important part in his as he considers that he also is capable of committing such unfortunate yet immoral things. “Looking in the dead bird’s eye, I realised that these strange, unthought of connections - sex and death, lust and violence, desire and degradation - are there, there, deep in even a good heart’s chambers”.

In David journey has is forced to see life in a more truthful and more painful way. He learns many lessons, but none more disturbing than that which follows Frank’s suicide. “You see, I knew - I knew! - I knew! That Uncle Frank’s suicide had solved all of our problems … I felt something for my uncle in death that I hadn’t felt for him in life. It was gratitude, yes, but it was something more. It was very close to love”.

Maturity may come at any age, but it is an experience that is remembered their whole lives. As the story continues, David matures and grows in order to deal with the situation. Larry Watson suggests that traumatic experiences transform children into adults, and that disturbing experiences lead to

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Montana 1948 is a very good example of what it was like to be part of the fringe of society. The author does an extraordinary job at depicting certain struggles of power between the characters in the book. The reason these struggles are so easy to pick up on is because the narrator describes the characters to full detail. This allows for a further enhancement of the book to which you can become more acquainted with the characters. There for you can predict the struggles between characters. One of the main struggles in this story is between the Fringes of society and those who have power. By power I mean those who are able to speak for themselves and defend themselves. Good examples of power, in the society of Montana 1948, are the white men. Those who would be considered a fringe would be the Native Americans, women, and children.…

    • 775 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In this Novel the growth of David from a small boy to a courageous man is focused. David is a seventeen year old boy from Scotland with the nickname of “Davie.” David is a young boy who tragically lost his father and mother and who is now left alone with no parents. After being left alone, David becomes an orphan. David is then led into a house where his father lived in his childhood. David there meets his uncle Ebenezer ,“Is your father dead?” “I was so much surprised at this, that I could find no voice to answer, but stood staring” (Stevenson 23). Ebenezer first attempts to kill David and then kidnaps him. Uncle Ebenezer was cruel to David and treated him very harshly, David’s uncle strongly disliked David for coming into his life and interrupting him. Ebenezer is a very selfish uncle and envies David for being young and everything he does. In Kidnapped David for the first is exploring the world. Balfour is inexperienced and is frightened about never going out to the “real world.” David’s goal is running away from the torture of his uncle and not having experience of going out to the real world. David is blamed for a murder he did not commit, and his attempt is to escape from all his enemies, since he has become a victim of Captain of Hoseason and his Uncle Ebenezer. As David escapes he meets the other main character Alan Breck Stewart. They both come to meet each…

    • 1380 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Just like in the book Montana 1948, I would like to write to you about how human nature is explained through loyalty and justice. As we have gone to school together for seven years, I would like to show you how the faults of our human nature can be explained through what has happened in Montana 1948. Throughout the book, the faults of human nature are seen as loyalty outweighs justice which as seen through Frank molesting Native American girls. Wes’s loyalty to his brother, Frank, and his prejudice towards Native Americans questions the belief of justice. Wes has received all his power from his parents, so it is nearly impossible for him to go against his family. However, Wes is stuck between his father, a powerful, intimidating man and his…

    • 1544 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The poem “David”, written by Earle Birney is a very emotional and allure piece. The major theme that pursues throughout the whole poem is maturity. Which includes the beginning of such, and all the obstacles that must be overcome. The tone is a very cynical one, especially when David asks Bob to push him off the cliff. Birney also uses figurative language and poetic devices to create an element of tension, complexity and emotion.…

    • 375 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Why The Chrysalids Deviant

    • 4964 Words
    • 20 Pages

    Both she and her family are forced to flee. They are captured and banished to the Fringes. David finds it difficult to reconcile the laws of his society with his own conscience. This problem is intensified when he sees his aunt driven to suicide because she has given birth to a deviant baby.…

    • 4964 Words
    • 20 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    David is the narrator and the main character of the story, and he has to deal with the bombardment of the miss use of power in many different ways at a young age. He first learnt about his father’s racism at the age of seven or eight (said on page 34) and he was attacked with the issue of Frank raping Indian women. Power has dominated David’s life for a long time and has affected him substantially even without the Frank incident, “Instead of attributing this social distress to my own shy and too-serious character I simply blamed life in town and sought to escape it as soon as often I could” (page 23). One of his ways of withdrawing from society, and expressing his frustration from being shut out of the drama revolving around Frank is just being by himself in the wild, shooting wild animals. “Less than 40 yards away, I bought the .22 quickly up to shoulder height and snapped off a shot with no more care than…

    • 1312 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Succeeding the "permeated murder", David becomes trapped by guilt and also loses his sense of self. The conclusion is a contrast between the scene in the lagoon that consisted of a variety of birds flying. surging Birds are generally associated with freedom and they could arguably represent how David felt as he was a part of these birds; as these birds surged, they reflected 'the sun like blown blossom at the foot of the original Brendon' even the sun in this scene contradicts the latter scorching sun. The atmosphere turns from a breezy, light summer's sun to something more 'manly' and scorching that trapped David 'in a dome'. This manhood that he tried to achieve so badly had not only trapped him, but also had turned him into 'an automaton figure on a mechanical clock"- he had lost all sense of self and was now lost and trapped for…

    • 702 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    After David sees Sophie’s foot and understands the repercussions of it, David thinks, “A blasphemy was, as had been impressed upon enough, a frightful thing. Yet there was nothing frightful about Sophie. She was simply an ordinary little girl- if a great deal more sensible and braver than most. Yet, according to the Definition…”(14) At this point, David does not understand why having six toes on each foot can be so life threatening. He has to prove to Mrs. Wender that he is going to protect Sophie whenever he can, and that he is taking her secret extremely seriously. David could report Sophie’s deviation to his father or to the inspector at any time and David would be thought of as the person who did the right thing. He also has to be exceptionally brave because he is forced to go against his father’s wishes to keep Sophie safe. David does not agree with his father’s beliefs, or with what he values, but he knows that he could get in serious trouble if Joseph finds out that David is keeping Sophie’s secret. David is a kind-hearted boy who thinks everyone should be treated fairly regarding his or her…

    • 954 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    David is an immature person. After his father moved away, he was so angry that he refused to talk to his dad and even burnt all the letters from his father. He thinks that he is as same as his neighbour's dog, Monty, a victim of neglect. He even stopped working and got low marks at…

    • 537 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    When young David, witnesses his licentious uncle commit suicide, he unrealistically decides that his death was the answer to all of the hardships faced by the family. ‘Montana 1948’ by Larry Watson, depicts the tale, of deterioration and destruction of one family through heinous crimes committed by certain characters in the novel. The offences carried out by Frank, destroys David family forever. When the emotional twelve year old watches Frank, die, he wants to reverse the adverse effects of his uncle’s crime and death seems like the answer to like the answer to their problems. However David does not realize is that Frank’s death did not solve their problems but merely changed them.…

    • 802 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Character in Montana 1948

    • 614 Words
    • 3 Pages

    An important character in Montana 1948 is Wesley Hayden. He is introduced as a weak and oblivious character, who lives under the shadow of his brother Frank. Throughout the story, it is shown that Wesley is a lawyer who was coerced into being a sheriff due to the pressure put on him by his overpowering father. In this essay I will explore why Wesley Hayden is an important character in the novel Montana 1948 by Larry Watson. He is used to illustrate the theme of loyalty vs. justice, he grows the most as a person in the novel and he has to cope with making difficult decisions so the reader will empathise with him.…

    • 614 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    David sees his Uncle as a friend and a role model rather then just a relative. "…because he was Uncle Axel and my best friend among the…

    • 526 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Point of view plays a pivotal role in influencing the viewers to sympathize with David. By the author choosing to narrate in third person, readers are not given a biased view on the protagonist’s situation and therefore their sympathies are derived from their own response to the text and are not manipulated. For example, if the short story were to be narrated by David himself, certain bias may be accompanied and subsequently the readers may not sympathize with him as they may not be sure to whether he may be over reacting, being that he is a child. Also, without third person narration, Wilding would not have been able to show the readers that parental and societal pressure causes problems for an individual; the reader would have only been exposed to the way David deals with the issues caused by the pressure. David’s parents, being traditional people, in terms of their thinking, are very judgemental towards him, particularly his father. The father talks about ‘family honour’ being…

    • 1003 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    David Lurie Quotes

    • 1066 Words
    • 5 Pages

    However, in the court case against David, David is staright forwrd and honest. He does not linger about protecting himself, but he tells the truth and infact in a way protects Melanie. He takes his consequence without debate and refuses to appologise, on hoesty basis, of his appology being meaningless. "Do you regret what you did," "no, i was enriched by the experience." Davids honesty, is very rare, because he is not contemptible, but is telling the raw truth, when he knows that lieing could save his…

    • 1066 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    I Was There

    • 1172 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The novel Montana 1948, By Larry Watson is about the horrific events that consumed the summer of 1948 in Bentrock, Montana. The events are seen through the viewpoint of a 12 year old boy, David, now 52.Who is looking back 40 years in the past to try understand how and why his life ended shaped the way it is. The events of that cataclysmic summer permanently alter twelve-year-old David's understanding of his family, his father, a small-town sheriff. His remarkably strong mother, the Hayden's…

    • 1172 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays