Preview

Native American Controversy Essay Example

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
838 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Native American Controversy Essay Example
Native American Controversy

“People ask me why I don’t just let this go. It’s all in the past, they say. I tell them that there is no past tense in the Cheyenne language. The past is not gone. As I stand here before you, all of my ancestors stand with me.” ...Suzan Shown Harjo

This controversy of using Native American mascots has been origins that are engrained deeply into Indian and Non-Indian relations. Today, there are many sports that use Indian names (The Atlantic Braves, Golden State Warriors, Chicago Blackhawks, and University of Illinois Fighting Illini) that are the center of this argument. According to The Free Dictionary a mascot is “A person, animal, or object believed to bring good luck, especially one kept as the symbol of an organization such as a sports team.” When it is used as a school symbol it represents their sports teams and its fans with pride. Through decades these teams have rallied team spirit and support.

Even so, in the 1960’s, American Indian students and Indian activists efforts rocketed to persuade these sports teams to discontinue the Indian-related mascots, symbols and names. The National Congress of American Indians also came up in this time. They focused on cartoons and movies; however the effort to remove Indian logos and mascots became very popular.

The use of Native Americans as mascots at public schools and universities has become a growing controversy. Those who advocate for the elimination of Native American mascots argue that these mascots belittle and discriminate against Native Americans. Then to those who counter this say, the prevailing attitude of many supporters of Native American mascots is that the intent is to honor and pay respect to the Native Americans. These caricatures of Indian’s shouldn’t be acceptable to one’s conscious: “these public schools should not be the vehicle of institutional racism.”

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    In Blackhorse v. Pro Football Inc., the Trademark Trial and Appeal Board of the US Patent and Trademark Office invalidated the trademark of the Washington Redskins. Filing in 2006, five plaintiffs, all Native Americans, have finally won a historic trademark cancellation case against one of the National Football League’s (NFL) oldest franchises, the Washington Redskins. The plaintiffs claimed that the football team’s name, “Redskins” was disparaging towards Native Americans and requested the name be changed. The owner, Dan Snyder vowed to never change the name, citing tradition and brand recognition, and the case has since picked up national interest as the case proceeded. Although the NFL hasn’t officially ordered the team to change the name, the…

    • 1787 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the blog Not for Sport by Barbara Munson, the argument is presented that teams should not use “Indian” mascots. Using a statement and response dialogue Munson argues against what she feels are “common misunderstandings on this issue” (Munson 1). Munson uses ethos, pathos and logos with weak results. Munson’s target audience are the general population and more specifically communities with current “Indian” mascots and leaders in those communities.…

    • 733 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The writer Jack Shakley formed the article, "Indian mascot - you're out" which distributed in 2011. Shakley composed the article once the debate of the University of North Dakota attempted to change its mascot from The Fighting Sioux. He uses a modest bunch of solid sources that helps his contention and sentiment on the theme. He started constructing his assurance by utilizing his own associations with the theme.…

    • 735 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the summer of 2005, the NCAA banned the use of mascots that could be considered offensive to American Indians at any of their championship games. In order to understand this, it is important to consider that movies and television programs for years portrayed them as savage warriors that were feared and misunderstood. That is why some schools have chosen to use Indians as their mascot, a role typically played by wild animals or fictional beasts. You would not tolerate derogatory terms for other ethnic groups being used for school mascots. In the NCAA’s new ruling, they ask schools to eliminate mascots that may be hurtful or offensive to America’s Indian…

    • 112 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    “The Redskins”, “The Blackhawks”, “The Cleveland Indians”, and other sport teams/organizations have very offensive derogatory mascots and slurs towards Native Americans. Many Native Americans are very offended by these sports team using their culture in a very racists way. They argue that Native Americans are people not mascots, and they also portray their body features very “savagely”. The redskin, feather in the hair, old wrinkled skin, war paint, etc. all these features are stereotypes and disrespectful.…

    • 136 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    According to Redskins officials, the name refers to the American Indian practice of painting the faces and bodies of warriors with red clay before battle. It also reflects positive attributes of the American Indian, such as dedication, courage and pride. Additionally, the name Redskins was originally chosen to honor the team’s Native American coach, William Dietz, who began coaching in 1933. The trademark of Redskins was registered in 1967, and there was no issue raised about the name at that time. Later, a lawsuit was filed by a few Native Americans against the Redskins organization in 1992. They said the name and its trademark were a racial slur that should be changed. I think these particular Native Americans put too much weight on fighting the name and consequently overlook the merit of applying the name to a beloved institution.…

    • 366 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    National Collegiate Athletic Association mentions that it has been a debate in America at least 30 years about the usage of Native Americans imagery as school or sports teams’ logos, nicknames, or mascots (Native American Mascots, 2008). There are over 3,000 sport teams from high school, college, and even professional…

    • 2430 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    These mascots also help spread and continue stereotypes because “most Americans have no direct or personal experience with contemporary American Indians” (463). The mascots and inaccurate depictions of American Indians are not only harming the psychological well-being of the minority by making it difficult for them to form an individual identity as well as a group identity, but are also keeping the majority from forming well-educated opinions and attitudes towards them. All parties involved are harmed because it further separates them and keeps them from being able to coexist and work together on issues that affect them all. If the minority was not misrepresented and their real issues were not ignored, then the properly educated majority could help raise a voice for their rights (as the voice of the majority is listened to more than the voice of the minority, which is wrong). By allowing these mascots to continue “representing” and “honoring” American Indians, then the stereotypes are also being allowed to continue, and the majority is continuously…

    • 591 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    College Mascots

    • 1405 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The term “Illiniwek” was chosen by Coach Bob Zuppke in the 1920’s, which refers to the complete human being. The costume for this mascot was a traditional costume made by a member of the Ogala Sioux tribe, and the dance is an actual tradition used by the Native Americans. There was controversy surrounding having a Native American tradition and mascot in college athletics since it was first used. At first, the members of the Peoria tribe supported the use and were proud to have their people recognized in such a manner by the University of Illionois, but five years later, “Peoria tribe changed its position on the Chief Illiniwek mascot” (165). Despite the universities statement that they portray the Native Americans in a brave and courageous light, a vote of 3 to 2 requested the cease of use the Chief…

    • 1405 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The material I have selected to analyze is “Bonding Over a Mascot” on page 632. This essay remonstrates that the Florida State University’s mascot, the Seminole, is a derogatory representation of a certain Native Indian tribe called the Seminoles. The school mascot represents the era when the Seminoles and United States were at war. For some this mascot connects the past history of Seminole culture and Florida State’s sports, but for others it creates a disputation of Native American stereotypes.…

    • 354 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Sports Mascots Analysis

    • 757 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Some of those colleges are North Dakota Fighting Sioux, College of William and Mary Tribe, and San Diego State Aztecs just to name a few. What is quite astonishing is that, local legislation is getting involved on the high school and collegiate levels regarding this issue but in regards to the professional sports organizations it seems to be a tough task. For example two of the most controversial and offensive mascots in professional sports today is the Washington Redskins (2nd) and the Cleveland Indians (1st) (Kornhauser, 2014). The Cleveland Indians have a historic franchise but as of 1947 people have been quite upset with their mascot Chief…

    • 757 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Black Americans, segregation, and slavery. Most of the people who have studied American history recognize the inhumane actions towards people of color during the 1960’s and 1980’s. Yet, people often are not aware of the similar acts perpetrated on the Native Americans during the same period of time. The Native Americans had to suffer their past of external shame imposed on their culture and tradition by the White American society, followed by a coercion of White American culture due to the government proposal of the “Indian problem.” Nevertheless, the Native Americans maintained their pride in their identity and culture internally, within their tribes, and carried out such acts as Ghost Dance, valuing their own tradition. While it may seem paradoxical, both shame and pride of culture and identity simultaneously resonate in Native Americans today as a means of letting go of the unpleasant past and moving on to the future with a new hope.…

    • 1263 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Is it believable that Native American children face discrimination during their education because their schools have Native American mascots? Yes. However, are Native American children the only children who face discrimination throughout their education? Do mascots lead to discrimination against other races of children? Do African American and Asian children face discrimination? Do timid children, “nerds” and other various stereotypes face discrimination? Are all of these students not being discriminated against as well? A cultural mascot may lead to some discrimination against Native American children in school, but does it contribute to all discrimination against them? In Barbara E. Munson’s Common Themes and Questions About the Use of “Indian” Logos, Munson attributes all discrimination in school against Native American children as a consequence of the use of Indian logos and Native American mascots. Although it is conceivable that Native American children have faced discrimination throughout their education as a consequence of their school having a Native American mascot, Munson is unable to support her argument. Munson, despite her credibility to speak on the Native American culture, creates a biased argument filled with fallacies and lack of support; consequently, she overuses pathos to distract the reader from the faults of her argument.…

    • 1352 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Thesis: Modern Native American traditions reflect the history of struggle, strife and triumph they experienced in history.…

    • 1021 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Racism

    • 606 Words
    • 3 Pages

    It has been said that mascots for professional sports teams and even college and high school teams are considered offensive to Native American or Indian tribes. Sports teams or even schools should be allowed to use the mascot of their choice not the ones that the activist think they should use. Mascots are in no way meant to be racist or harmful, they are meant to be shown for pride and dignity towards the school so they don’t look like wimps. These team mascots are not racist. Some of these so called racist or offensive sports team names are close to home.…

    • 606 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays