Preview

Secretary Chant Essay Example

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
779 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Secretary Chant Essay Example
The Secretary Chant By Marge Piercy
A Feminist Analysis
In the poem The Secretary Chant Marge Piercy’s the speaker portrays the vision of a woman who has lost her humanity to her occupation. The poem tells a story of a woman who has lost touch with herself as a person, and consequently she views her body as a separate entity from who and what she once was.
The tone of the poem is set immediately; she opens with “My hips are a desk (ll 1.)” I found this analogy very interesting that she uses the word are instead of like, by comparing labeling her hips as office furniture Piercy paints a bold image. This woman’s hips are a desk; she has already lost her basic humanity. In the first line she has already portrayed herself as an object. Piercy goes to a great deal of personification to paint a stronger and bolder image. 1. From my ears hang 2. chains of paper clips. 3. Rubber bands form my hair 4. My breasts are wells of mimeograph ink. 5. My feet bear casters. (ll 2-6)
Her body is no longer hers or that of a woman’s. Paper clips adorn her ears and bands form her hair. Not even what makes a woman a woman is left unscathed; her breasts are wells of mimeograph ink. The speaker is clearly a woman doing secretarial work, whose body has become one with her job, which is bluntly obvious as she describes her body parts as different pieces of office equipment. Why does she view herself and her body this way? Is it a self observation or is the result of the way she is viewed as or treated by her male coworkers, who in 1973 would view her as nothing more than a phone call answerer, meeting scheduler, and a coffee fetcher. The speaker’s tone is robotic. Her movements, actions, and tasks are so redundant that there is no thought process needed to do them. Not only is her body dehumanized, but, so is her mind, “My head is a badly organized file. / My head is a switchboard/ where crossed lines crackle” (ll 9-10). There is no creativity

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The poem “The Secretary Chant” uses metaphors to describe how inhuman a secretary feels in the workplace. By comparing their body parts to inanimate objects such as “My hips are a desk” (Piercy 1) and “My head is a badly organized file” (8) the narrator relates themselves to the responsibilities of a secretary. Their job became their identity.…

    • 300 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The poem "homage to my hips" by Lucille Clifton is meant to convey the author's embrace of her femininity and her body. She uses metaphors throughout the poem to convey her acceptance of her own body and to urge other women to do the same. The poem also challenges social norms that apply to women and the beauty ideal. Additionally, Clifton alludes to the need for empowering women. In the opening lines of "Homage to My Hips," Clifton describes how her hips are big and how "they don't fit into little petty places." This line explains how the size and shape of her hips do not fit into the socially accepted beauty ideal of thinness. She then talks about her hips being free and how "these hips have never been enslaved." This line is meant to be…

    • 245 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Dolor Roethke Analysis

    • 589 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The narrator begins the poem with a look into his time in an office. The stiffness is almost visible to the reader in lines such as "I have known the inexorable sadness of pencils,/ Neat in their boxes" (Roethke lines 1-2). The despair can be felt within the poem. As Cynthia Kotana describes, "The persona is buried under the detritus of office life: pencils, pads, folders, paper clips. The sheer weight of inanimate objects is felt as unbearable" (Kotana). Roethke places a heaviness in the poem on each individual object through personification. By giving the inanimate objects these human characteristics, one can imagine them in a deeper sense thus causing the emotion of the poem to stand out. The simplicity of an office is now filled with depth, "sadness of pencils," "misery of manilla folders," and the "Lonely reception room" (Roethke lines 1,3,5).…

    • 589 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The theme of Lucille Clifton’s “Homage to my hips” concentrates on a proud, strong, and powerful woman who is absolutely in love with her hips. Clifton’s tone throughout the poem focuses highly on her big hips. Not once does the she speak negatively about them. She feels absolutely wonderful about her big hips, making her feel so confident and full-bodied all at the same time. She gives off many reasons to why her hips make her modest, but full of pride.…

    • 548 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Although Bordo’s argument is mostly based on philosophy, she uses logos to ground her opinions. Before depicting her thoughts about the impact of an idealized body on women, Bordo defines the basic elements of her argument by providing evidence about “$1.75-billion-a-year industry in the United States” (Bordo). The inclusion…

    • 226 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Homage to My Hips

    • 1017 Words
    • 30 Pages

    Clifton is taking something with a negative connotation, “battleship hips”, and makes them seem sexy, confidant, and something to be proud of. Since hips are associated with childbearing and are a very feminine feature, one can also gather that they are being used as a symbol for women. So, the ideas Clifton is bringing to light can be applied to all women, not just herself specifically, or women who are larger in size. She repeats the word “hip(s)” throughout the poem, showing she is not ashamed of them, and showing the importance of them. “These hips are big hips/they need space to/ move around in./they don’t fit into little petty places”(lines 1-4)—This is one of the more pertinent ideas in the poem. Not only is the author addressing physical figure and how she shouldn’t be expected to fit into spaces that are too small, which is a general expectation in her society (as well as ours still today), but also she is using these ideas to symbolize a bigger picture. The “petty places” she is describing are literally places that larger hips may be looked down upon being in, i.e. on a bus, in a crowded street, and also metaphorically symbolizes places like the kitchen, the home, the bedroom---places that women are expected to be in in her society. Clifton believes women don’t want to be in these places that won’t get them anywhere in the world, they want to go out and do what they want and want to have some sense of fulfillment in their lives, working and being pertinent in society. “They need space to move…

    • 1017 Words
    • 30 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    We Wear the Mask

    • 904 Words
    • 4 Pages

    3. What is the speaker’s tone? Which words reveal this tone? Is the poem perhaps ironic? The speaker describes the different dead-end jobs she has had in a positive way, happily noting, “all / the onion rings I could eat / cleaning houses was fine / liked the donut shop best…” (Laux, 4-5, 12, 29). At the end of the poem, the tone saddens with the description of her telemarketer job. “It wasn’t that I hated calling them… / It was that moment / of expectation, before I answered back / the sound of their held breath / their disappointment when they realized / I wasn’t who they thought I was…” (35, 39-43). I feel sorry for her, as she expresses the sadness she felt.…

    • 904 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Her series of portraits reveal how I have been subjected to feeling uncomfortable with my own body. I wasn’t aware of my views on such things until I was exposed to them. There is nothing wrong with a woman’s body but somehow in society over the centuries there as been standards of what is acceptable for a woman to look like. Cindy Sherman pushes that boundary and criticizes society’s standards. This can be seen in her work titled ‘Untitled No.155’ or ‘Untitled No.222’, both of which show unflattering views of women’s bodies. No.155 shows Cindy Sherman posed on the floor with a fake ass facing directly into the camera. Whereas No. 222 depicts an ancient painting of a woman with her breast exposed, sagging towards the floor. Both crude and uncomfortable as they reveal the true body of a woman even if they are done so in such vulgar…

    • 1129 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    It's the year 1984. As you walk down a crowded New York street, you can't help but stop and stare at the world around you. There's one particular image that stands out to you through. It's a large, black and white poster of a woman looking into a broken mirror. The words "You are not yourself" are written across it in bold cut-out letters. You stop to think to yourself about the possible meanings of this poster. It shows the apparent work of a feminist sowing women's struggle with her own self-image.…

    • 1909 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Alice in the Mirror Image

    • 918 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In the story “Mirror Image” by Lena Coakley, Alice has been in accident which to survive they were only able to save her by performing a brain transplant. She finds herself in the middle of an identity crisis when the doctor was required to exchange her body for someone else’s body. This body had belonged to a girl named Gail. Due to the change in body, she finds herself curious about her new body. Also she is quite sensitive about when is comes to her new body she takes the changes she has gone through quite personally. Alice is also quite unsure when it comes to her new body, and she is has a hard time taking in the changes that she has gone through such at wondering if her soul is really hers. When she recovered and was able to go back home, and she was interested in reading her twin sister Jenny’s diary. Jenny wasn’t comfortable with her reading her diary, but she still feels like there is a stranger in her home. Alice explores her new body in a different way and compares it to her old one: “I feel like I could do anything in this body. Hey, did I show you, I can almost touch my foot to the back of my head” (Coakley 13). The significance of this quote shows her curiosity about her new body and the way she explores how different her new body is and the new things that she is able to do compared to the one she was born with. Along with curiosity, Alice also shows signs sensitivity. The reader comes to realize this when Alice was in the hospital because at first she struggles greatly on recovering her basic cognitive and motor skills:…

    • 918 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Poetry Reading Log

    • 1218 Words
    • 5 Pages

    * “The Secretary Chant” by Marge Piercy was written in 1973. I felt the author was describing how this woman was so engulfed in her work that she felt like she was nothing but a machine, something whose sole purpose was to work and produce. The sentences are very mechanical and choppy and I felt that it helped to emphasize the point of her feeling of being a piece of office equipment. She took the tools of her trade and with humor compared it to her own body. I personally felt sad when I read this, being a working woman I understand the unbearable demands to be perfect in my work, being dehumanized to the point where I feel that is my only purpose and a personal life is non-existent.…

    • 1218 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In ‘’Refiguring bodies” published in 1994 by the Indian University Press, philosophical journal ‘Volatile Bodies: Towards a Corporeal Feminism’, Elizabeth Grosz, examines ‘key features of the received history that we have inherited in our current conceptions of bodies’ (47). The significant term ‘somatophobia’ is used by Grosz to describe the philosophical foundations of our notion of the body, meaning ‘fear of the body’. More importantly it acts as some sort of guide, leading to questions regarding the bodies of both men and women, more specifically the effects ‘mind’ and ‘body’ have on each other. Grosz argues that philosophy has…

    • 611 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Sartre explains the different forms of oppressive objectifications towards females, an example being a moral attack upon a woman’s reproductive rights and agrees with Mackinnon, “that assumed objectivity of thought is oppressive in its intent”. He defines an object as something that can be handled, manipulated and definable, which in turn leads females to question and try to relate why women are identified by being objects. Feminists have responded to Sartre’s claim of women being like objects or holes by describing the ways in which women objectify themselves in response to the objectifications of their bodies by men. Women’s personal bodily changes can include liposuction, implants, hip reduction etc. to configure to a man’s image of a proper woman appearance wise. Thus women feeling threatened in their own environment by men will collaborate in foregoing males rise in society. One of Sartre’s most extreme examples of women is “slime”. Even though slime is not…

    • 866 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The poem begins with the voice of Alvarez’s mother. “Who says a woman’s work isn’t high art?” (J. Alvarez, p. 790) is certainly not the author’s sentiment. In the first few stanzas it is painfully obvious that Alvarez’s answer to this question would be “Me!” According to her mother, scrubbing the bathroom tiles, shining the tines of forks, and cutting lacy lattices for pies is the pinnacle of a woman’s purpose in the world, a way to express her love and devotion to her family: an art. Alvarez sighs in line five, longing to play with her friends and leave behind the oppressive repetition of keeping house. Despite the liberties she takes with the structure and rhyming, and the enjambment (breaking the lines while continuing the idea), in lines four and five, as well as lines six through eight, it is still clear from the rigidness of the chosen form that Alvarez was “kept prisoner in her [mother’s] housebound heart” (p. 790).…

    • 711 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A Work of Artifice

    • 1023 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Marge Piercy’s “A Work of Artifice” is a poem that begins in a simple manner, but unfolds into a more complex statement about the oppression of women. Marge Piercy, a feminist, struggled to have her work published, but at age sixty-three her dreams finally came through in the year 1999. The last word in the title, artifice, is defined as the use of trickery to reach a result. In the poem a bonsai tree is shaped by a male gardener that only allows the plant to grow to his desired measurements. The poem then shifts to include the subordination of women. Both the bonsai tree and the woman are viewed as results of artifice. Piercy’s words may bring anger to women reading this poem, but the truth of her message will inspire those that crave change. Through “A Work of Artifice”, the visually imagery displays male dominance and the roles set for women in society.…

    • 1023 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays