‘Dystopia Is Merely a Utopia from a Different Point of View’. Discuss This Statement in Relation to Two Pertinent Literary or Filmic Examples
‘Dystopia is merely a utopia from a different point of view’. Discuss this statement in relation to two pertinent literary or filmic examples.
The following essay proposes to consider the concepts of dystopia and utopia, analysing the ways in which they can be deemed to constitute the same phenomenon understood from a different point of view. For the purpose of perspective, we intend to consider the problem from the standpoint of H.G. Wells’ A Modern Utopia (1905) and Aldous Huxley’s A Brave New World (1932). This, quite clearly, represents an especially complex issue to attempt to tackle with paradigms pertaining to both dystopia and utopia being intrinsically linked to political ideology. It is, for instance, impossible to critically analyse Wells’ work, especially his early fiction, without reference to the dominant political ideologies of the epoch, particularly socialism . Likewise, when considering A Brave New World and A Modern Utopia we have to do so with the historical context in which the novels were written firmly in mind. In the final analysis, fictional ideals relating to dystopia and utopia as they appear in these two books are rooted in the great social, economic and political upheavals of the late nineteenth century and the early twentieth century. As a consequence, it is prudent to begin our discussion by undertaking a critical exploration of the meanings of dystopia and utopia as they are understood in modern literature in order to manufacture a conceptual framework in which the remainder of the discussion can take place.
Although utopianism is a concept that is most commonly associated with modern literature, the origins of the notion of utopia has long been an important feature of fiction writing. In the Classical Era, for example, Plato’s Utopia was conceived of as an attempt to fictionally portray a perfect, idealised version of his Republic. Likewise, Thomas More’s Utopia (1516) concocts a fictional island society with ideal social,
The following essay proposes to consider the concepts of dystopia and utopia, analysing the ways in which they can be deemed to constitute the same phenomenon understood from a different point of view. For the purpose of perspective, we intend to consider the problem from the standpoint of H.G. Wells’ A Modern Utopia (1905) and Aldous Huxley’s A Brave New World (1932). This, quite clearly, represents an especially complex issue to attempt to tackle with paradigms pertaining to both dystopia and utopia being intrinsically linked to political ideology. It is, for instance, impossible to critically analyse Wells’ work, especially his early fiction, without reference to the dominant political ideologies of the epoch, particularly socialism . Likewise, when considering A Brave New World and A Modern Utopia we have to do so with the historical context in which the novels were written firmly in mind. In the final analysis, fictional ideals relating to dystopia and utopia as they appear in these two books are rooted in the great social, economic and political upheavals of the late nineteenth century and the early twentieth century. As a consequence, it is prudent to begin our discussion by undertaking a critical exploration of the meanings of dystopia and utopia as they are understood in modern literature in order to manufacture a conceptual framework in which the remainder of the discussion can take place.
Although utopianism is a concept that is most commonly associated with modern literature, the origins of the notion of utopia has long been an important feature of fiction writing. In the Classical Era, for example, Plato’s Utopia was conceived of as an attempt to fictionally portray a perfect, idealised version of his Republic. Likewise, Thomas More’s Utopia (1516) concocts a fictional island society with ideal social,
Bibliography: Appelbaum, R. (2002) Literature and Utopian Politics in Seventeenth Century England Cambridge: Cambridge University Press Baccolini, R Darwin, C. (Edited by Gillian Beer) (2008) On the Origin of Species Oxford: Oxford World Classics Davis, J.C Engels, F. (2008) Socialism: Utopian and Scientific New York: Cosimo Inc. Fitting, P Huxley, A. (1959) A Brave New World Revisited London: Chatto & Windus Huxley, A James, E. (2003) Utopias and Anti-Utopias, in, James, E. and Mendlesohn, F. (Eds.) The Cambridge Companion to Science Fiction Cambridge: Cambridge University Press Jameson, F Jameson, F. (2010) Utopia as Method, or the Uses of the Future, in, Gordin, M., Prakash, G. and Tilley, H. (Eds.) Utopia/Dystopia: Conditions of Historical Possibility Princeton: Princeton University Press Kumar, K Nate, R. (2001) Scientific Utopianism in Francis Bacon and H.G. Wells: From Salomon’s House to The Open Conspiracy, in, Goodwin, B. (Ed.) The Philosophy of Utopia London: Routledge Parrinder, P Partingdon, J.S. (2002) The Time Machine and a Modern Utopia: The Static and Kinetic Utopias of the Early H.G. Wells, in, Utopian Studies Journal, 13 (1): 57-68 Vieira, F Vint, S. (2006) Learning from the Little Engines that Couldn’t: Transported by Gernsback, Wells and Latour, in, Science Fiction Studies, 33 (1): 129-148 Wells, H.G Williams, R. (1978) Utopia and Science Fiction, in, Science Fiction Studies, 5 (3): 203-214