There is an ongoing debate on whether torture should be used and if it is ever “ok”. There are many different points of view and both sides have very clear‚ convincing arguments on whether torture should be used as a way to obtain information. One side says that torture is not necessary even in extreme cases. The other side it should be used if it mandatory. Although these sound like a compromise they do have a few conflicting ideas. Even though both essays are trying to sway the reader to one side
Premium Mind Psychology Logic
First published in Newsweek‚ in 1982‚ "The Case for Torture‚" by Michael Levin‚ state that "torture is not merely permissible but morally mandatory" (201). "Michael Levin argues that torture is a mortal necessity in some situations; that torturing a terrorist is the moral thing to do if it prevents "future evils" (201). Levin examines three scenarios to persuade his readers that torture is justified. In the first circumstance‚ a terrorist has hidden an atomic bomb on Manhattan Island‚ and instead
Premium Suffering Morality Torture
In the article entitled “The Case for Torture” published by Newsweek in 1982‚ Michael Levin argues that the use of torture as a means to save lives is justifiable and necessary. Beginning with very general premises‚ Levin draws a series of hyperbolic cases where torture might be justifiable so as to set precedents for the justification of torture in more “realistic cases.” However‚ the author never fully defines the boundaries and conditions behind his premises and suggests that disregarding civil
Premium Emotion United States Constitution Liberal democracy
Justification on the Use of Torture for National Security While the idea may seem contradictory‚ countries around the globe use torture as a form of national security. As noted in the works of an online database‚ Opposing Viewpoints‚ reasons originating from the early 1800s in Jean Larteguy’s novel‚ Les Centurions‚ depicts the opposing justification of why such a method is necessary for safety (7). In his novel‚ Larteguy stresses millions of lives were saved because a French soldier tortured an
Premium Torture
Composition I November 9‚ 2013 Is Torture justified? What is torture? Basically‚ this is the action of physically or psychologically hurting a person without their permission and against their will. The torture has many goals such as obtaining a confession or information of the victim‚ revenge for an act committed by the victim or just for entertainment morbid and sadistic of the torturer. According to the 1984 United Nations Convention against Torture‚ the torture is: “any act by which severe pain or suffering
Premium Torture Human rights Universal Declaration of Human Rights
“The Case for Torture” Torture is a concept that Americans attempt to avoid. If a criminal possesses the opportunity to harm innocent lives‚ the delinquent should be stopped. The idea presides in Michael Levin’s “The Case for Torture”; Levin attempts to portray a point that the act of torturing terrorists in order to save innocent lives is justifiable. Throughout the article‚ Levin fabricates situations to present his argument that torture is not a bad idea. He voices that torture is not established
Free Rhetoric Question Suffering
In the article‚ The Case for Torture‚ Michael Levin sheds light on the complexity of using torture. The author argues that the use of torture is sometimes necessary. He lays out various situations in which torture may be needed and highlights arguments in support of torture. I agree with Michael Levin’s theory that torture is sometimes justified because it is sometimes morally obligatory‚ it helps to maintain order‚ and it prevents evils that may happen in the future. The first reason I agree with
Premium Crime Capital punishment Prison
Torture and Ethics Paper Alfreepha Williams AJS/532 July 21‚ 2013 Patricia DeAngelis Torture and Ethics There are many views or definition of the word “torture”‚ which is often debated by many individuals. According to “International Rehabilitation Council For Torture Victims” (2005-2012)‚ “torture is an act by which severe pain or suffering‚ whether physical or mental‚ is intentionally inflicted on a person for such purposes as obtaining information or a confession‚ punishing him for an
Premium Torture Human rights Amnesty International
Torture Should Not Be Justified The act of torture is a grave violation of human rights that infringes objectives of the United Nations Charter. Since 1984‚ 155 countries have ratified UN Convention against Torture (UNCAT). Between these 155 countries‚ 142 countries were researched by Amnesty International‚ a non-profit organization in the forefront of the campaign against torture and a recipient of the Nobel Peace Prize. In result‚ in 2014 among 142 countries‚ 79 of these are still torturing. (Dolmaci
Premium Torture Human rights
The United States Use of Torture November 19‚ 2013 In the decade following the terrorist attack on September 11‚ 2001‚ the United States has seen a constant struggle with militant terrorist organizations. Groups including the Taliban and primarily Al-Qaeda have been part of an ongoing violent conflict in the Middle East. Throughout these struggles with terrorists‚ the United States have employed various methods of interrogation and intelligence gathering which have included
Premium Torture United States Human rights