at the same time‚" John Hick. Hick starts out providing a definition of theodicy‚ and contrasting both Augustine and Irenaeus’s theodicy. Theodicy has two conditions: one‚ God is real and is limitlessly good and powerful‚ and two: humans are on a religious experience. Augustine and Irenaeus’s theodicies both depict evil way back to human free will. The point that was different is when Augustine thought that evil were against odds with God’s purpose‚ and Irenaeus considered evil has a precious part
Premium God Good and evil Theology
Thomas Aquinas on Transubstantiation Before Thomas Aquinas died he was writing the Summa Theologian‚ which was regarded as one of the greatest works of medieval theology. Although he didn’t finish he made 4 very interesting arguments about Transubstantiation. He asked whether the substance of bread and wine remain in this sacrament after consecration‚ whether the substance of bread or wine is annihilated after the consecration of this sacrament‚ whether bread can be changed into the body of Christ
Premium Eucharist
First Thomas Aquinas argues that our existence in itself is proof that God exists‚ as we would not be “in motion” had God not been the “first mover” and put us in motion. If I correctly understand Aquinas he is saying that life would not exist had there not first been a creator‚ and with out first a creator life would not have come to be. Secondly Aquinas argues that life is a series of events that could not have brought itself in to being. Theretofore God must exist to begin the series‚ he is the
Premium Existence Metaphysics Ontology
Anselm’s argument of God’s existence and Aquinas objection I was in the debate team in high school. And there were times that our team would take the against side of the statement. In his famous work Prologion‚ written in 1077-1078‚ Anselm presents the idea the God exists because God is the greatest thing of all‚ that the idea of thinking of God exists prove its existence. Hundred of years later‚ Thomas Aquinas brings up the account that addresses Anselm’s idea in objection 2 of Question II‚ First
Premium Existence Ontology Metaphysics
Seif Ramy Kodsy ID: 900071874 Philosophy 220 – Philosophical Thinking Spring 2010 Take-home Paper On Free Choice of the Will Question 2 This book by St Augustine contains many philosophical arguments. St Augustine was a Latin speaking philosopher born in what is now modern day Algeria. He was one of the most prolific philosophers with hundreds of surviving works attributed to him (having survived the passage of time). The book On Free choice of the will contains may divine references with
Premium Free will Metaphysics God
Plato vs. Augustine on Memory Assignment: Plato and Augustine use memory in ways that are comparable and incomparable. What is the role or function of memory in their respective psychological writings? What are their differences? If they disagree‚ indicate how they would criticize each other’s work. Augustine begins describing memory as that of a house. He describes it as being a place where images‚ ideas and memories are kept. They can be accesses and stored‚ re-used and deposited as needed
Premium Memory Mind Psychology
to find out if there is a God and who he is. According to Aquinas we will never be able to understand who or what God is. We are finite and so we cannot understand the infinity of God. We can only know He is and always will be because He has instilled that bit of knowledge within us. So when Descartes says we cannot have the idea of finite without the idea of infinite‚ he claims we understand what God is. But I would disagree and take Aquinas’ side because what Descartes is understanding is not who
Premium Theology Metaphysics Ontology
St. Augustine the Roman Philosopher St. Augustine was man of many substances‚ he was scholarly man‚ and he was a person that fought with his temptation as a child growing up. Augustine could have become a lawyer but he chose to follow his faith and become a priest. He is a man of his teaching and he makes you believe or question his teaching but you still come away that he knows what he is talking about. Before he became a Saint‚ Augustine was born in a small city in Northern Africa in the town
Premium Augustine of Hippo God Christianity
Knowledge Aquinas and Descartes have different ideas on how humans gain knowledge in the world. Both philosophers need to define what the human body is composed of in order to determine how we gain knowledge. For Aquinas intellect comes from the soul and the body working in unison. The soul is the substantial form of a living material thing. It is the actuality of a living material substance. Even though the rational soul is what differentiates humans from other living things‚ it does not
Premium Soul Mind Metaphysics
Augustine and the Problem of Evil Introduction When St. Augustine wrote Enchiridion‚ The City of God‚ and On the Free Choice of the Will he certainly had various reasons in mind and multiple arguments he was seeking to prove. One common thread throughout is the problem of reconciling the existence of evil in a world in which God exists as well. This is the problem of evil. I will show that Augustine attempts to solve the problem by denying that evil exists as such and by saying that what we
Premium God Problem of evil Metaphysics