The only poblem with this is that the two had almost opposite ideas although they realized the the Articles of Confederation didn’t have enough power. The main obstacle was how much power should the new government have. The Federalist form of government provided the best government of the two. Alexander Hamilton was unsatisfied with the Articles of Confederation. He feels that the U.S has reached the "last stage of humiliation‚" due to a lac of a military‚ large debts‚ a lack
Premium United States Constitution Articles of Confederation United States
Federalists v. Anti-Federalists Participants in the Debate The debates over ratification of the Constitution represent the most important and intellectually sophisticated public debates in American history. On the one side‚ the supporters of the Constitution‚ or "Federalists‚" argued that the nation desperately needed a stronger national government to bring order‚ stability and unity to its efforts to find its way in an increasingly complicated world. Opponents of the Constitution‚ or "Antifederalists
Premium United States Constitution United States Congress President of the United States
Writing the United States Constitution was a very long very hard process. They needed a new constitution‚ they failed with the Articles of Confederation‚ they couldn’t stay unified in the face of a crisis like Shay’s Rebellion; every state had their own government but they needed to be unified. The problem was that everyone wanted it to be perfect‚ but the debates over what to include were very controversy. Not everyone could decide on one thing‚ with a country filled with a diverse group of people
Premium United States Constitution United States Articles of Confederation
This was a way to get around the Articles of Confederation because the federal government could not tax the people. So the federal government started to tax the states more which then caused the states to have to tax their people. If you could not pay the tax then they would shut you down or foreclose you. This hurt many of the small farmers and also the small stores. Some of the other effects were that the faults of the Articles of Confederation were demonstrated. This made the state leaders
Premium United States Constitution Shays' Rebellion Articles of Confederation
indirectly through economic domination of resources and markets. Part II: Short Response Essay (1) Why did lawmakers replace the Articles of Confederation with the U.S. Constitution? The Constitution placed both internal and external restraints on the powers granted to the central government which the Articles of Confederation did not. The Articles of Confederation left the republic helpless to deal with the threat of foreign encroachments and the problems of
Premium United States Constitution United States American Civil War
meant that the people are the nation. Since most nation- states were home to more than one group of people claiming national status‚ Nationalism is often associated with war or a struggle to national liberation‚ as seen in the case of the German Confederation and the Congress of Vienna. Instead of struggling and competing against other states‚ the European states should focus and concentrate on their common interests and goals. Parallel to the ongoing nationalism in Germany‚ similar movements were
Premium Germany Congress of Vienna Holy Roman Empire
The thesis of the Federalist papers was that the Article of confederation needed to be replaced with a new constitution which would ultimately save the nation from the problems of the United States government having strong state government and a weak national government. The Federalist papers addressed the weakness of the Article of Confederation. The federalist were all in favor for ratifying a new constitution because it did not serve as a firm constitution. The new constitution that was
Premium United States United States Constitution President of the United States
were very fearful of giving them too much power because of the experiences they had with the royal governors. In turn they gave most of the powers to the legislatures leaving the governors with little power of the state. Then‚ the articles of confederations were established giving most of the power to the state government and not the national government. In order to manage the new territory that they wanted to move on they came up with the land ordnance of North West territory 1784. This ordinance
Premium United States Constitution Articles of Confederation Northwest Ordinance
It can be said that in a democracy‚ unity among the many cannot exist without compromise. Following the conclusion of the American Revolutionary War in 1776‚ the Articles of Confederation (the “Articles”) were written to allay fears about‚ and promote liberty‚ for its citizens‚ by legitimizing the rights of individual states. However‚ the Articles provided such restrictive powers for the underfunded national government to counteract deficiencies‚ that the union was at risk of collapse. A series of
Premium United States Constitution Separation of powers United States
brings up a fear of many people‚ that of an oppressive government. Many people feared a powerful government since that is the very thing the United States just fought to gain freedom from. As a result‚ the author suggests that the Articles of Confederation‚ which established a weak central government‚ is a better fit for America. He states‚ “our present Constitution‚ with a few additional powers to Congress‚ seems better calculated to preserve the rights and
Premium United States Constitution American Civil War Slavery in the United States