To what extent does Gaunilo’s criticism of Anselm’s argument succeed in demonstrating that the argument fails? Gaunilo‚ a Benedictine monk and contemporary of St Anselm was the first to raise objections to Anselm’s idea that God exists by definition‚ claiming within “On behalf of the Fool” that Anselm’s argument was not logical and needed to be discredited. Gaunilo famously claimed that Anselm’s conclusion that the non-existence of God is “unintelligible” cannot show that God necessarily exists
Premium Ontology Existence Metaphysics
Analogical Argument 2. Analogue: doctors and lawyers Primary Subject: travel agents Similarity: jobs that give public service with years of training Property: must also give the most safety and comfort in service Although there are many relevant similarities between the analogue and the primary subject (e.g. jobs that give public service with years of training)‚ they are outweighed by the relevant dissimilarities‚ most important of which is the difference in the level of training and
Premium Law Lawyer Common law
argue that an approach to corporate social responsibility that achieves business benefits is nothing of that sort - THAT’s just good business. So CSR must be only those things that are of no direct benefit to the business - ie. philanthropy. Cue the arguments about how CEOs should not be giving shareholders money away on their personal causes and projects. This is just dumb. Nobody says that marketing is not marketing if it benefits the business‚ or HR is not ’pure’ HR if its priorities align with
Premium Management Corporate social responsibility Social responsibility
Two thumbs up for Hard Incompatabilism Through Perebooms arguments we see how he argues against compatibilism‚ and how he presents to us four cases that will support his rejection against compatibilism. We will see how he delivers a way in which the agents will not be morally responsible for their actions‚ and succeeds in planting that seed of dought in us. Summary: In Pereboom’s argument‚ he discusses that it is because casual determinism is true that we lack this sort of free will that is required
Premium Free will Determinism Libertarianism
The Design Argument Saint Thomas Aquinas was a Catholic Priest in the Dominican Order and a very important medieval philosopher and theologian. He wrote a book‚ SummaTheologiae‚ presenting five proofs of God’s existence. Each of Aquina’s arguments begins with an observation that is supposed to be easily understood by everyone. Aquina’s fifth argument for the existence of God is what has come to be called the Argument from Design. The Design argument is one of three arguments about the
Premium Teleological argument Existence Theology
Strawson’s attempts to break down the Basic Argument into conversational language which‚ while helpful‚ does not lead me to agree with his idea. His adjusted argument goes a bit like this: one does what one does because one is oneself. The only way to adjust oneself is to act‚ but since one acts according to oneself‚ one would have to make infinitely expounding choices about who one is and how to be and how to change. This would lead one to suppose that it’s impossible to create oneself and as such
Premium Morality Philosophy Ethics
Dominic Lowman 11/28/12 Engl 102 sec 018 Academic Argument High school students today are all excited about post-college life‚ which for most means going away to college to further their education. The question is‚ are they truly being provided the necessary tools needed to be successful at the college levels? Are teachers‚ counselors‚ parents and the government both state and federal doing enough to lead these young minds out into the world? We all know how expensive college is and that only a
Premium High school Academic degree College
Many important events in our nation’s history were influenced by persuasive arguments. Many sides have gained support due to the writings or speeches gave by an effective speaker. These arguments take a lot to be effective. There are three key components‚ and if an argument lacks any one of them‚ it is not effective. Organization‚ diction‚ and bias words are all important aspects to any effective argument. Using these three elements‚ Thomas Paine was able to make a triumphant case‚ whereas James
Premium Management Leadership United States
works in perfect harmony with the defense and proof. 2. Reason Is also known as the transcendental argument. This shows that Christianity is the necessary presupposition of meaning and rationality. If that statement is believed to be true than the denial of Christianity denies all meaning and rationality. 3. Argument An apologetic argument is no more neutral than any other human activity. This argument is where one would presuppose the truth of God’s word. It must be of representation of who God is
Premium
Euthanasia: The Argument Euthanasia is defined as; “the intentional killing by act or omission of a dependant human being for his or her alleged benefit. (The key word here is “intentional”. If death is not intended‚ it is not an act of euthanasia.)” Source: www.euthanasia.com/definition The act of euthanasia is a very controversial issue which has many supporters‚ both for and against and has been a topic of the world’s media‚ time and time again. There are arguments both for and against
Premium Logic Euthanasia Human rights