much-esteemed Ronald Dworkin. Part I – Adjudication of Hard Cases In his well-regarded works entitled “Taking Rights Seriously” and “A Matter of Principle‚” Dworkin provides an outstanding account of how judges should adjudicate hard cases. In presenting this account‚ he examines the discretion thesis. This thesis serves as the mechanism by which members of the judiciary should decide the most difficult of cases by establishing new law in the exercise of discretion. Dworkin assesses this thesis
Premium Law Jurisprudence Ronald Dworkin
philosophers‚ scientists‚ writers‚ have tried to answer the fundamental question what constitutes a good life. According to Dworkin‚ a good life is not just about living in some pleasurable way; it is about creating a good life in a critical way. It can be argued that living a good life entails treading down a moral path‚ doing all that morality requires us to do; however Dworkin posits that moral principles should be interpreted so that being moral makes us happy. In his
Premium Meaning of life English-language films Life
single fundamental test for law forces us to miss the important standards that are rules.” explains Dworkin on his attack on positivism. It is argued‚ by Dworkin‚ that both legal positivism and natural law theories are in reality searching for an answer to the question ‘what is law?’ a fundamental question and challenge towards the debate and critique of the natural lawyer and positivist. However Dworkin directs towards another issue‚ a more specific question of understanding law‚ gained by asking
Premium Jurisprudence Ronald Dworkin Natural law
embrace. Philosophers Ronald Dworkin and John Stuart Mill have both presented personal thoughts on the rationalization of liberty of expression‚ and why it is imperative that we as a society defend this right. Ronald Dworkin and John Stuart Mill both present similar ideas when focusing on this subject‚ stating that it is a vital aspect to the success of society‚ but also have differing viewpoints on whether these rights should be controlled in certain situations. Ronald Dworkin supports a society where
Premium John Stuart Mill On Liberty Liberty
London: Allen and Unwin. • Bird‚ Colin (1999). The Myth of Liberal Individualism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. • Bosanquet‚ Bernard (2001 [1923]). Philosophical Theory of the State in Philosophical Theory of the State and Related Essays‚ Gerald F. Gaus and William Sweet‚ eds. Indianapolis: St. Augustine Press. • Buchanan James M. and Gordon Tullock (1966). The Calculus of Consent: Logical Foundations of Constitutional Democracy. Ann Arbor‚ MI: The University of Michigan Press. • Chapman
Premium Liberalism Political philosophy Classical liberalism
Critically evaluate Dworkin ’s and Habermas ’s approach to civil disobedience. The following essay will attempt to evaluate the approach taken by Dworkin and Habermas on their views of civil disobedience. The two main pieces of literature referred to will be Dworkin ’s paper on Civil Disobedience and Nuclear Protest ’# and Habermas ’s paper on Civil Disobedience: Litmus Test for the Democratic Constitutional State. ’# An outline of both Dworkin ’s and Habermas ’s approach will be given ‚ further
Premium Civil disobedience Political philosophy Nonviolence
Synopsis Love & Diane tells the epic story of a family over three generations. At its heart lies the highly charged relationship between a mother and daughter‚ desperate for love and forgiveness but caught in a devastating cycle. For Love‚ the world changed forever when she and her siblings were torn from their mother‚ Diane. Separated from her family and thrust into a terrifying world of institutions and foster homes‚ the memory of that moment is more vivid to her than her present life. Ten
Premium Love English-language films Interpersonal relationship
tried over racial discrimination‚ with verdicts of both innocent and guilty. Ronald Dworkin attempts to argue that preferential treatment is socially useful and at the same time does not violate people’s rights. This is wrong for many reasons; here I shall illustrate how preferential treatment hinders racial equality‚ violates people’s rights‚ and can lead to a lower opinion toward a particular race. Dworkin believes that continuing preferential treatment will decrease racial consciousness and
Free Race Racism Black people
both Simone de Beauvoir and Andrea Dworkin felt that the institution of marriage was also a form of prostitution. They both agreed that both marriage and prostitution are extremely oppressive and dangerous for women. In Simon de Beauvoir’s Prostitutes and Hetairas‚ she said‚ "The only difference between prostitution and those who sell themselves into marriage‚ is in the price and length of the contract (de Beavoir‚ pg. 555)." In Feminism: An Agenda‚ Andrea Dworkin said that in marriage women lose rights
Premium Feminism Prostitution Sex industry
1. RONALD DWORKIN: According to Dworkin‚ democracy is an egalitarian perception to political equality (). Dworkin argues for a substantive approach to democratic procedure; in effort to secure an equal distribution of political power to citizens as a whole (9; 117). Dworkin’s consequential approach classifies two types of political decisions: “choice-sensitive” and “choice-insensitive” issues (132). Dworkin defines choice-sensitive issues in terms of justice that: “depends essentially on character
Premium Management Patient Health care