H.J. McCloskey The renowned atheist H.J. McCloskey‚ from the 1960’s and 1970’s contended that God was nonexistent. McCloskey wrote an article in 1968 titled “On Being an Atheist‚” stating reasons why he believes‚ “atheism is a much more comfortable belief than theism” (McCloskey‚ 1968). In the article McCloskey dismisses God’s existence‚ and “because evil exists that we believe God does not exist” (McCloskey‚ 1968). McCloskey argues that without defentive proof there is no God. McCloskey goes
Premium God Atheism Deism
H.J. McCloskey‚ in his article‚ “On Being an Atheist‚” presents a series of arguments to defend and justify his atheist beliefs. He debates arguments for God’s existence including the cosmological argument and the teleological argument; stating that these arguments are false and argues that without “proof‚” the idea of God should be rejected entirely. He is critical of the arguments for God’s existence and offers the problem of evil to be a major concern and reason why one should not believe in the
Premium God Religion Logic
Response Paper McCloskey Article (278.205 Kb) Having completed the unit of philosophy of religion‚ you are now ready to respond to an article written by an actual atheist. This article‚ titled “On Being an Atheist‚” was written by H. J. McCloskey in 1968 for the journal Question. McCloskey is an Australian philosopher who wrote a number of atheistic works in the 1960s and 70s including the book God and Evil (Nijhoff‚ 1974). In this article‚ McCloskey is both critical of the classical arguments
Premium God Theology Cosmological argument
The Problem of Evil: Against the Existence of God. I believe that the following argument is unsound because there is a premise missing. If the addition of this premise was present‚ I believe that the structure of the argument from premise 3 and down would change. This change would allow the argument to be both valid and sound. I feel as though it is missing the point where humans were given free will. In doing so‚ humans would be allowed to choose between doing good or doing evil. Therefore‚ premise
Premium Problem of evil God Philosophy of religion
Does God Allow Evil” Richard Swinburne argues that evil exists in the world because of the existence of a good‚ omnipotent God. His strongest argument is that there is a difference between moral evil and natural evil and each are necessary for the world’s good. Therefore‚ any wrongdoings by an individual is done with intent through negligence‚ rather than an act of God. On the other side‚ in “Karma‚ Rebirth and the Problem of Evil” Whitley R.P. Kaufman‚ contends that the problem of evil is constructed
Premium
1. Which of the fundamentals of planning did the McCloskeys effectively execute? Explain your answer. A.- McCloskey identified clearly their main barrier it had to be successful. It needed to change the perception about big farms. Pivoting around this issue‚ McCloskey developed a mission and vision‚ that described clearly this goal and them linked it with other fundamentals of planning. Their mission was described as “educating the public about modern farming‚ protect the environment‚ care for
Premium
Jamie‚ or Angela? If God is all knowing and he is good‚ why would he allow this child to suffer these traumatic moments? Could the sorrow of these women and the trauma of this child have been circumvented with God’s intervention? These and other questions lead us to arrive at our examination of the logical problem of evil. Evil can be defined as a thing that is “characterized or accompanied by misfortune or suffering.‚ [CITE] The deductive or logical form of the problem of evil maintains that a set
Premium Omnipotence God Problem of evil
Benevolence of God‚ the Free will of man‚ and the Origin of Evil"). Theodicy‚ as defined by Webster’s Dictionary‚ is a “defense of God’s goodness and omnipotence in view of the existence of evil.” David Hume‚ in his Dialogues concerning Natural Religion‚ quotes Epicurus‚ a Greek philosopher‚ as saying the following: “Is [God] willing to prevent evil‚ but not able? Then he is impotent. Is he able‚ but not willing? Then he is malevolent. Is he both able and willing? Whence then is evil? Is he
Premium
A question that is often discussed and debated is “does the existence of evil and suffering in our world prove there is no God?” This question raises attention of many people and is thought about worldwide. God is seen as almighty‚ powerful and worshiped‚ but this raises the question of why would God put our world throughout so much suffrage and heartache? God loves each and every person on earth‚ which causes a lot of confusion when it comes to suffering. Bad things happen to good people and good
Premium Suffering Theodicy Good and evil
Existence of Evil incompatible with the existence of God?" "Without darkness there can be no light (Shestov)." This quote says a lot about our world as we know it. To truly know something we must also know it’s opposite. We would not know silent if there was not sound. There would be no young if we did not know old. So how could we believe that there is a good without an evil? To believe in the existence of a greatest good‚ which we call God‚ there must also be exist a source of evil as it’s opposite
Premium