An Ethical Analysis of the case AIDS and Needles 1. Case fact In the case of AIDS and Needles‚ nurses‚ doctors and other health care workers who use needles and syringes as part of their routine operation are exposed to the risk of infection of blood carried diseases from accidental injury on themselves. This issue is a pressing one as statistics reveal that Needlestick injuries occur frequently in large hospitals and account for about 80 per cent of reported occupational exposures to HIV among health
Premium Occupational safety and health Health care Healthcare
INTRODUCTION……………………………………………………………………. 4 LEGALITY……………………………………………………………………………. STATEMENT OF RELEVANT LEGAL PRINCIPLES AND RULES OF LAW APPLICATION OF LAW TO TOPIC AND LEGAL ANALYSIS LEGAL CONCLUSION 8 ETHICS………………………………………………………………………………. UTILITARIAN ETHICAL ANALYSIS KANTIAN ETHICAL ANALYSIS PSYCHOLOGICAL EGOISM ANALYSIS 11
Premium Video game Video game controversy
Case Summary In 1993‚ Michael D. Eisner of Walt Disney fame received $203 million as executive compensation. Although this award was inflated by Eisner ’s exercise of stock options‚ many examples of compensation in millions and tens of millions raise questions on how CEOs should be paid. Critics dispute that CEOs are deserving of their pay. CEOs downsize companies or perform badly‚ yet continue to draw a substantial salary. Unlike low level managers‚ it seems there is no formula for executive
Premium Corporate governance Ethics Board of directors
argued that despite three justifications of affirmative action‚ the liberal principle of personal autonomy should outweigh diversity motivated discrimination in university admissions. The main theoretical justification to this will be an extension of Kantian philosophy‚ which focuses upon the fact that people should never be used as means to an end but rather an end themselves. This will be extended by Robert Nozick’s principle of the ‘separateness of persons’. Despite acknowledging the importance of
Premium Affirmative action Discrimination John Rawls
The Whitaker family selected a specific embryo so that they knew that once the baby was born he would be a definite match for tissue donation. The family has received support from the public‚ but there has also been many cases of opposition. Kantian ethics can be used both to support and oppose this case. One of the main parts of Kant’s theory is that one should never be used as a means to an end. Even though the end would present good results for Charlie‚ the sick
Premium Ethics Morality Pregnancy
I. The Questions The current ethical debate being discussed focuses on biomedicine’s involvement in quality of life issues. Biomedicine is a branch of medical science that applies biological and other natural-scientific principles to clinical practice. Now these interventions are specifically directed to alter‚ eliminate‚ or correct non-life threatening conditions. Cochlear implants are a technology in the branch of Biomedicine‚ which attempts to cure deafness. When surgically implanted and given
Premium Medicine DNA Health care
An Exposition of Kant’s‚ Arendt’s‚ and Mill’s Moral Philosophy Immanuel Kant adheres to Deontological ethics. His theory offers a view of morality based on the principle of good will and duty. According to him‚ people can perform good actions solely by good intentions without any considerations to consequences. In addition‚ one must follow the laws and the categorical imperative in order to act in accordance with and from duty. Several other philosophers such as Hannah Arendt discuss Kant’s moral
Premium Morality Immanuel Kant Ethics
human beings into account and justifies through excuses. These excuses involve him making a decision on behalf of the homeless on the worth of their life‚ and its purpose‚ and the happiness these people have. Whereas the British doctor uses more of a Kantian ethics system and points out what the doctor has not taken into account.
Premium Utilitarianism Immanuel Kant Human
being referred to as a criminal for being asleep on his post: The clump of laurel in which the criminal lay’ (Pojman‚ Vaughn 356) yet some may argue that a son shooting his father is immoral and criminal no matter in wartime or not. In keeping with Kantian thinking and philosphy‚ I think it is the perfect example of putting aside emotions and basing a decision soley on reason and duty. It’s ironic that the thing that rouses him from his state of crime’ (Pojman‚ Vaughn 358) is the horse that his
Premium Ethics Immanuel Kant Morality
knowledge‚” (CW‚ I.233) or‚ as he also calls it‚ “intuitionism‚” which was espoused in different ways by Kant‚ Reid‚ and their followers in Britain (e.g. Whewell and Hamilton). Though there are many differences among intuitionist thinkers‚ one “grand doctrine” that Mill suggests they all affirm is the view that “the constitution of the mind is the key to the constitution of external nature—that the laws of the human intellect have a necessary correspondence with the objective laws of the universe
Premium