Quotation: “In case of dissension‚ never dare to judge till you’ve heard the other side.” ― Euripides this quote is saying don’t be so quick to assume that just because the word torture is in the resolution that it is unjustifiable With these words in mind‚ I stand in firm affirmation of the resolution that: the torture of inmates in Guantanamo bay is justified based on the crimes they committed. My value for this debate is justice My value criterion is punish the guilty because it is the
Premium World Trade Center Al-Qaeda United States
Imagine‚ you have a terrorist in custody‚ and this terrorist knows the location of a bomb that will detonate and end thousands of American lives‚ is it ethically justified to torture this terrorist in order to obtain the critical intelligence needed to locate and disarm the bomb‚ saving thousands of lives? This is a scenario called the ticking time bomb scenario‚ it may be an extreme scenario‚ but none the less‚ it is possible‚ would you let ethics get in the way of saving those people’s lives?
Premium Torture
Hollywood has given society the impression that torture is the effective last resort for interrogators to get crucial information. There is a cliché scenario in which a bomb is ticking somewhere and the villain will not tell the interrogator how to stop it. Reluctantly the interrogator starts using brutal torture methods until he gets the confession and saves the day. The “ticking time bomb” scenario is unrealistic and it gives a false perception to society of how interrogations really work. The
Premium Torture Central Intelligence Agency Interrogation
Medieval torture was used by people of the Medieval ages like William the Conqueror and his Norman allies when he was crowned king of England in 1066. They used torture to extract gold from Anglo Saxons in the new kings kingdom. Higher class people would practice torture to get gold and silver from peasants. Punishments would vary depending on the social status of the person and the crime they committed. Criminals who were already sentenced to death were sometimes tortured to give up the names of
Premium Capital punishment Torture Middle Ages
Convention against Torture Around the world and around the clock‚ human rights violations seem to never cease. In particular‚ torture violations are still rampant all over the world. One regime‚ the Convention against Torture and other Cruel‚ Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment‚ establishes a strong elaboration of norms against torture. Despite its efforts‚ many countries still outright reject its policies against torture while other countries openly accept them‚ but surreptitiously still
Premium Human rights Torture Amnesty International
To most‚ torture is seen as action with a single definition that defines it‚ but in fact there are different types of torture that Henry Shue discusses in one of his articles. According to Shue there are rare conditions under which torture could be morally justified‚ but he does not endorse neither the interrogational torture not the terroristic torture. Although Shue agrees with illegality and morally wrongness of torture‚ he explains how one may go about defending torture and how it could possibly
Premium Abuse Torture Government
Should Torture Be Allowed or Not The issue of torture is being very current and it arouses debate between those who are totally against it; those who think that it sometimes can be used for good; and those who are in between. The idea of torture was seen only as something that happened far away in time‚ and it should not even be considered as an issue of the modern society. Furthermore‚ torture was seen as a violation of the fundamental human rights‚ which were protected by different human rights
Premium Human rights Torture
Daniela West Mr. Sandarg English 1102 23 March 2012 Torture Imagine being taken by someone you do not know‚ and questioned ferociously about events that you are not aware of. You are questioned of these things because of who an acquaintance of yours is or by the location you just happened to be in at that moment. When you do not know anything that you are questioned of‚ these same people that took you are now using “enhanced interrogation techniques” upon you. These “enhanced interrogation techniques”
Premium Torture
September 11th 2001‚ the laws on torture have been at dispute in democracy. If there was a way to prevent the September 11th attacks then America should do anything in their power to get the information to save innocent lives of their citizens. Furthermore‚ intelligence is needed to find out who is responsible for these attacks. To get the needed intelligence we must have somebody that knows what happened and a way to extract the information. This is where torture would come into play. There are various
Premium United States Torture Violence
Introduction 1. Torture is on the most extreme forms of human violence‚ resulting in both physical and psychological consequences. It has been used for thousands of years‚ dating back to medieval times 530 AD. Even though numerous laws have been made to stop torture‚ it is without thought of the consequences that occur. Torture has been proven as an ineffective tool for gathering concealed information and running the reputations of the country that use it. Nobody deserves to be tortured‚ as it is
Premium Torture Amnesty International Violence