Toulmin Analysis Chad Doctor ENG215 Toulmin Analysis Two college freshmen were recently tasked with preparing an argumentative-type essay on video games violence and their influence on their younger audiences. The two easily accepted the assignment without hesitation; they bore deep-seated skepticism on the “nearly depleted positive influence” games have on kids today. They submitted their paper promptly and were stunned to learn of the essay’s failing grade. The students had invested so
Premium
place. Rebuttal: A rebuttal is implied against the position that standardized testing is an adequate test of student’s knowledge and job skills. A rebuttal establishes what is wrong‚ invalid‚ or unacceptable about an argument and may also present counterarguments or new arguments that
Premium Nuclear power Critical thinking Three Mile Island accident
Augmentative Analysis Against the Toulmin Model The late Stephen Toulmin the creator of the Toulmin Model has constructed and contributed immensely to the analytical study of arguments. The Toulmin Model‚ a dynamic foundation of structured analysis commonly used to analyze any text in which an argumentative statement develops through the essential elements which goes to define the Toulmin process. In a textbook titled‚ Elements of Argument written by Annette Rottenberg and Donna
Premium Education in the United States Rhetoric Argument
The Toulmin method is a method of reasoning that includes a claim‚ ground‚ and a warrant. This method of analysis breaks down the paper into parts in a way that makes the argument more effective overall. The passage‚ “The Locavore Myth‚” goes over the disadvantages of people whose diet consists only of locally produced food. The author goes over several statistics and studies that show the harmful effects of buying from nearby farmers. According to the Toulmin method‚ this argument is very effective
Premium Local food Critical thinking Counterargument
Learning Team Toulmin Analysis Team A Contributors: Allison Cloutier‚ Christopher Etheridge‚ Genevieve Thompson‚ and Dionna Mark ENG/215 October 17‚ 2011 PHILIP SCHUNK Body Paragraphs Crichton makes the claim that environmentalism is becoming one of the most influential religions in the Western world. He presents the idea that environmentalists are religious fanatics who are making extreme predictions for the Earth’s future. Crichton does a minimal job at supporting
Premium Natural environment Environmentalism Environment
MEMORANDUM To: DCCCD President and Board of Directors From: Adrieanne McClelon‚ student Date: July 16‚ 2013 Subject: Smoking should be banned on campus Introduction and Recommendation Second hand smoke affects approximately 126 million nonsmoking Americans per year. 72.2% of students‚ age 18-24‚ enrolled in a single campus are not smokers but are at risk of developing lung cancer and other diseases associated with smoking all because of the 24.8% of students who do. Recent studies
Premium Passive smoking Smoking ban Lung cancer
Gay Marriages Subjective Claim Throughout history‚ a marriage has been a male and female exchanging vows‚ promising their lives to eachother. Never did anyone think‚ that gays had a right to get married‚ it was always considered a sin to be gay. Legal binding marriage between two homosexuals nowadays‚ whether it be a male and male or a female and female relationship‚ should not be legalized after following a long history of marriages. There are too many factors that need to be addressed when
Free Homosexuality Same-sex marriage Marriage
Essay # 1 For corporations‚ sponsoring a school’s sports teams or facilities is a way of community outreach‚ where for a good turn‚ a company’s name and logo are disseminated more freely among the populace. For schools‚ sponsorship is a way to pick up extra cash-to buy books‚ renovate classrooms or make sure the soccer team has up-to-date equipment. In most public school systems‚ the taxpayers can’t provide all that. While cities cry foul for the supposed corporate “brainwashing” that takes place
Premium High school Public school Independent school
Cited: Code of Canon Law (Washington‚ D.C.: The Canon Law Society of America‚ 1984). Canon 277 #1. Gandhi‚ Mohandas K.‚ An Autobiography: The Story of My Experiments With Truth (Boston: Beacon Press‚ 1993). “The Argument of Celibacy.” 123HelpMe.com 01 Apr 2015. https://owls.englich.purdue.edu/owl/resource/588/03/ Driver‚ Helen‚ Natascha Gast‚ and Susan Lowman-Thomas‚ English 102- Effectiveness in Writing .2012 Web. Sipe‚ Richard A.W.‚ Celibacy Today- Mystery‚ Myth
Free Sexual intercourse Human sexuality Human sexual behavior
supports the argument. o Body paragraphs go on to develop the various results of the Thirty Years’ War as alluded to in the thesis. • Essay is well balanced; multiple turning points required by the question are covered at length. • All major assertions in the essay are supported by relevant‚ specific examples. o Examples document major turning points in European history caused by the Thirty Years’ War. • May contain errors or off-topic content that does not detract from the argument. 7–6 Points •
Premium Holy Roman Empire Thirty Years' War