To what extent does Gaunilo’s criticism of Anselm’s argument succeed in demonstrating that the argument fails? Gaunilo‚ a Benedictine monk and contemporary of St Anselm was the first to raise objections to Anselm’s idea that God exists by definition‚ claiming within “On behalf of the Fool” that Anselm’s argument was not logical and needed to be discredited. Gaunilo famously claimed that Anselm’s conclusion that the non-existence of God is “unintelligible” cannot show that God necessarily exists
Premium Ontology Existence Metaphysics
Analogical Argument 2. Analogue: doctors and lawyers Primary Subject: travel agents Similarity: jobs that give public service with years of training Property: must also give the most safety and comfort in service Although there are many relevant similarities between the analogue and the primary subject (e.g. jobs that give public service with years of training)‚ they are outweighed by the relevant dissimilarities‚ most important of which is the difference in the level of training and
Premium Law Lawyer Common law
A Family Argument 5W & 1 H: What was it about? Why did the argument start? When did it take place? Who were involved? Where did it happen? How was the problem solved? My family subscribes to the philosophy that family arguments‚ though unpleasant‚ are healthy and even necessary. Like my father says‚ they are like antibodies that fight virus in human body and eventually some good may result. My otherwise close knit family polarized by the fact that I have always been my father’s pet while
Premium Family Mother
Collin Brozek Scott Harber Comp. I April 14th‚ 2013 Argument Essay There are a plethora of reasons why pop and soft-drinks are bad for personal health as well as the environment. Never the less there have been an increase of obesity cases and children with diabetes caused solely by the consumption of sugar filled beverages. The consumption of soft-drinks and other carbonated beverages have multiple negative effects‚ and I want to briefly cover ten or so reason as to why soda is hazardous to
Premium Soft drink Carbonated water Obesity
argue that an approach to corporate social responsibility that achieves business benefits is nothing of that sort - THAT’s just good business. So CSR must be only those things that are of no direct benefit to the business - ie. philanthropy. Cue the arguments about how CEOs should not be giving shareholders money away on their personal causes and projects. This is just dumb. Nobody says that marketing is not marketing if it benefits the business‚ or HR is not ’pure’ HR if its priorities align with
Premium Management Corporate social responsibility Social responsibility
Erykah Black Instructor Carrie Kemmett WRT 104 28 November 2012 African American Stereotyping on Television African Americans on television‚ stereotyping or realism? Definitely negative stereotyping. African American stereotyping on television has been a focus on television shows for centuries. The majority of television shows with African American cast has a stereotypical plots and scenes. These shows on television are not creating laughs and giggles for viewers they are negatively portraying
Premium Stereotype Race Black people
Argument: Audience Analysis In this essay I tried to give more insight as to the reasons why Cigaretts should be illegal and be banned from even being sold. I give examples and true statistics on how cigarettes are harming the air‚ polluting it and the harms it has on your body and the long term affects it can have on not just your body but your mental state. I did research on the amount of people smoking cigarettes and how it affects not only the person smoking but the people or nature around
Premium Tobacco Cigarette
Two thumbs up for Hard Incompatabilism Through Perebooms arguments we see how he argues against compatibilism‚ and how he presents to us four cases that will support his rejection against compatibilism. We will see how he delivers a way in which the agents will not be morally responsible for their actions‚ and succeeds in planting that seed of dought in us. Summary: In Pereboom’s argument‚ he discusses that it is because casual determinism is true that we lack this sort of free will that is required
Premium Free will Determinism Libertarianism
Strawson’s attempts to break down the Basic Argument into conversational language which‚ while helpful‚ does not lead me to agree with his idea. His adjusted argument goes a bit like this: one does what one does because one is oneself. The only way to adjust oneself is to act‚ but since one acts according to oneself‚ one would have to make infinitely expounding choices about who one is and how to be and how to change. This would lead one to suppose that it’s impossible to create oneself and as such
Premium Morality Philosophy Ethics
I believe that this is an argument that will have good arguments for either side and as such I will defend and debate against both sides throughout the course of this essay. I believe that curfew laws are most definately something that many people‚ mostly teenagers since they are the ones affected‚ would be opposed to. It can be seen as unfair to force someone to follow a curfew especially if they want to go hang out with friends or if they wanted to do something that required being out at night
Premium Crime Adolescence Alcoholic beverage