Preview

A Comparison Of Boule De Suif 'And Jewelry'

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
485 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
A Comparison Of Boule De Suif 'And Jewelry'
“Boule de Suif” is a short story formed upon a prostitute and her experiences while escaping from her city during the Franco-Prussian war, while “Jewelry” is a story based upon the experiences of a widower as he realizes his dead wife’s misdeed. Both stories take place during the late 19th century in France, resembling the historical aspects of the country during that period. While both short stories take place at a different setting and situation, the common aspect which the author convincingly conveys in both plots are the selfish behavior of human beings. In “Boule de Suif”, the author centralizes his main motif on the real difference between the nobles; considered as a superior being with a prostitute; a profession considered as the lowest of all. In the story, Maupassant clarifies the sacrifices made by the prostitute for the sake of the nobles, while the nobles …show more content…
Through the story, Maupassant emphasizes the theme of illusions versus reality by adequately revealing the true immoral nature of the nobles, while they impersonate themselves as honorable to the common people. The theme of “Boule de Suif” is thoroughly similar to “Jewelry”, where the author exposes the deceptive nature of humans through symbolizing jewelry. In “Jewelry”, Mr. Lantin finds discovers his wife’s jewelry to be exceedingly valuable, while until Madame Lantin’s death, he was under the impression that all her jewelry are imitations. In this case, He falsely believed the jewelry to be fake until he discovered the truth much later. The beauty of Maupassant’s writings is in his ability to surprise readers with his ironic and unexpected endings. In both stories, Maupassant merely uses the characters and elements in the plot in order to convey a much more significant

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Another sign is also how they are divided between men and women. For example in the story “Boule de Suif”, where they spent a night at the hotel, they eat separately men and women. Also, in the story “A Simple Heart” where Felicite’s profession is housekeeper without any real education, but cooking, cleaning and taking care of the children. Another view on the 19th century is also that it is very much based on class. For example in the text “Boule de Suif”, the way the other characters in the text treats the prostitute signals the very little value they add to her. While she shares food with them, they do not share food with her. Additionally, it is also her that is forced to stay a night with the officer so they all can continue their trip. Another view there is not second chance and no idea of rehabilitation. In the story “The Last Day of A Condemned Man”, the main character has been a thief throughout his life and has already been in jail before he got condemned to death. Although he escaped from the first jail, the main character clearly needs help and might have some mental issues. Although it is unclear what the second crime was, the man might just need rehabilitation and then might have been turned into a normal citizen, but at that time, it seems that if a man has debt to the community, then there is no…

    • 1440 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the nineteenth century, money was a symbol of power and wealth, for the amount of money a person has defines their social status. In “The Necklace”, the setting plays an intricate role in the decisions that Mathilde makes, and the consequences that come along with her actions. In “The Necklace”, Guy de Maupassant uses the setting to further display and develop Mathilde’s greed.…

    • 179 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Prostitution, arguably one of the oldest professions in human history, has flourished in every form of society since time immemorial regardless of its legality. Particularly in France, prostitution has had a long and extended socioeconomic influence and is recognised by Nicolas Sarkozy (former French president) as being part of France 's national cultural heritage (Gangoli, G. & Westmarland, N. 2006). In Jean-Luc Godard 's fourth feature film, Vivre Sa Vie (1962), an account of the impact prostitution and its affiliation with criminality in the daily lives of ordinary Parisians is brought to light in the style of a theatrical documentary, using various Brechtian alienation devices to provoke understanding and critical analysis from audience members concerning its underlying message. Just as the chapters one is prone to find in a fictional novel just so Vivre Sa Vie (1962) is filmed in the form of twelve tableaux, done to further distantiate the audience on regular intervals, discouraging any preoccupation with the psyche of the unfortunate heroine Nana. In addition to its novelistic detail in form, the name 'Nana ' carries the legacy of the naturalist film done in 1926 by Jean Renoir (one of Godard 's greatest influences). The striking similarities between the scripting of the two films are perspicuously displayed in the heroines ' shared ambitions to succeed in the entertainment industry, their promiscuity and the tragic end to which they found themselves. Nana, in addition to being Godard 's homage to Renoir, is also an anagram of 'Anna ' Karina ( the then wife of Godard). It is therefore implied that it is not the identity of Nana being examined on the pedestal of this moving picture alone but Karina as seen through the eyes of Godard which begs the question of whether the work of an auteur can be indeed seen as an autobiography of its creator.…

    • 1749 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Girl with a Pearl Earring

    • 949 Words
    • 4 Pages

    For hundreds of years people have wondered who is the girl in the portrait Girl with a Pearl Earring, painted by a Dutch artist Johannes Vermeer in the 17th century and what is the connection between them. This fictional love story by Chevalier explores the sensual relationship between the young lady and the painter. Griet, a seventeen year old girl, narrated the story of her life experiences in the 1600’s, as she transformed from a young girl into a married woman. The narrative structure will appeal to a young adult audience as they will be able to relate to many of Griet’s experiences, especially the encounters she had with men. She was hired as a maid by a rich and famous painter, to help her impoverished family. Vermeer allowed her the privilege of working as his assistant in the studio, which caused much turmoil with his wife. This tension between the characters reads like a modern day soap opera. Vermeer was a gentle and respectful master, and Griet became devoted to him. Her secret admiration of him became increasingly intimate and loving, but not sexual. Vermeer’s friend, Van Ruijven requested him to paint Griet. Van Ruijven had several unwanted sexual encounters with her. Griet had to deal with the nervous emotions of a young girl learning to cope with sexual predators. Meanwhile, Griet met the local butcher, Pieter, and a friendship developed between…

    • 949 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    During this time period, women’s role in society was that of a submissive, powerless position. They often relied solely on their husband for direction, allowing the husband to make decisions and take lead no matter what. In the story of The Necklace, Maupassant illustrates these submissive, almost fearful thoughts of women. “She reflected several seconds, making her calculations and wondering about what sum she could ask without drawing on herself an immediate refusal and a frightened exclamation from the economical clerk” (Maupassant 61). His use of the word “drawing on herself” (61) suggest women often cause their own repression, as if it was their fault. Kate Chopin provides us with an example of women’s powerless position when she writes, “She was beginning to recognize this thing that was approaching to posses her, and she was striving to beat it back with her will- as powerless as her two slender hands would have been.” It was as if it took everything for Mrs. Mallard to “beat back” (Chopin 67) her feelings. She had never had to fight anything so hard before.…

    • 646 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the novel “Girl with a Pearl Earring” by Tracy Chevalier, the limitation of women of 17th century Holland was portrayed by the female protagonist Griet and how she is manipulated as a maid by all adults in her life, which means they place Griet in difficult situations and take advantages of her innocence, her feelings and love with their power and influences on her life to benefit themselves. She is put in the lowliest position which enables some other adults to abuse her, that is, they misuse their position of authorities as well as social rank, leaving her vulnerable and open to accusations as well as sexual assault. However, she managed to maintain her strong characters and show the effort to make positive choices about the future by leaving the Vermeer house and marrying Pieter.…

    • 1121 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    After she is shunned by everyone for doing what they wanted, because she is now “the unclean contact,” which in turn leaves “Boule de Suif still wept, and sometimes a sob she could not restrain” In this confrontation with the ladies and the officer she goes from an independent, strong woman to a crying, disgraced woman. The challenge with Boule de Suif is that I must try and not choose a side while reading. For me to understand and comprehend the message the author is trying to convey, I have to look at both sides objectively. You must look at the story for the time it is written, the country, and how the characters are laid out before we reach the confrontation. As a reader you know more than the character so when looking at it from Boule de Suif’s point of view, they ladies are encouraging her and will still be her friends.…

    • 1164 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    After the party, Madame Loisel loses the necklace, resulting in tireless work, loans, and night jobs for her and her husband in order to pay back the equivalent of the price. The couple finally succeeds when all the money is paid ten years later, only for Mathilde to discover that the necklace was ironically a fake, and worth a very small percentage of what the couple paid. The theme of this story is that an overemphasis on material wealth can shrink the spirit and leave one open to the changeability of fortune. The situational irony highlights this moral because the Loisels would never have had to exhaust themselves if Madame Loisel wasn’t so obsessed with riches and wealth. From the very beginning of the story, she wastes her time dreaming of luxuries such as fine silks, beautiful furniture, and gourmet feasts. Even when she is at Madam Forestier’s house to try on necklaces to borrow, she is never satisfied until she has seen the very best. Madame Loisel’s preoccupation with appearance clouds her judgment as well. As soon as she realizes that she has lost the necklace, she should simply come clean to Madam Forestier. Instead, she is too concerned with how her reputation will be affected, so she keeps quiet. She later pays the price for this when she discovers that the necklace is “false [and]…worth five hundred francs at most.” The life that she gets instead as punishment during the ten years in debt is even more difficult and meager than her life to begin with, which stresses how fame and fortune is so fleeting and unimportant in the scheme of…

    • 1345 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Honor In Old Regime

    • 353 Words
    • 2 Pages

    This excerpt highlights how aristocratic privilege trumped concepts of ‘honor’ in Old Regime France and exasperated class tensions over aristocratic privilege. According to Loyseau, in early modern France, the social hierarchy of the three Estates was “. . . willingly observed through honor, and certainly they are more honorable when they come from a voluntary respect . . .” (Loyseau 17). Without the observance of honor and rank, Loyseau claimed “there would only be confusion among us.” (Loyseau 17). Consequently, the chevalier in the case, a noble, should never have pursued Noailles, the daughter of a merchant. Although Noailles resisted the chevalier’s advances because of the difference in their ranks, the chevalier continued to pursue her, leading to her kidnapping and, to protect her honor in the aftermath of the kidnapping, their…

    • 353 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In the first literal work, “The Necklace” by de Maupassant, the author utilizes a story format in presenting the themes outlined within the literature. In this story, Guy de Maupassant successfully manages to bring out a flavor to all the stories described within the literature work. In this literal piece of work, the author writes about ordinary people through an analytical story that looks quite unforgettable, and paints their lives in different colors that are fully enriched with acts of marriage, adultery, prostitution, war, and murder (Maupassant, & Kelley, 2004).…

    • 2483 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The courtesan, was the highest class of sex worker, not all prostitutes were courtesans. A woman’s ambition to succeed in prostitution was vital in setting her apart as a courtesan rather than a common prostitute, “The essential difference is that the first carries on trade in her pure generality- as woman- with the result that competition keepsher at the level of a miserable existence; whereas the second endeavors to gain recognition for at the level of a miserable existence; whereas the second endeavors to gain recognition for herself —as an individual —and if she succeeds, she can entertain high aspirations. Beauty and charm or sex appeal are necessary here, but are not enough: the woman must be publicly distinguished some how, as a person." Setting themselves apart through high fashion, and polished expressiveness of the upper class, these dazzling women described in Baudelaireian terms as “a perfect image of savagery in the midst of civilization.”…

    • 1014 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Sequel: The Necklace

    • 336 Words
    • 2 Pages

    And she smiled with proud and simple joy. Madame Forestier, quite overcome, clasped her by the hand. “Oh, my poor Mathilde. But mine was only paste. Why, at most it was worth only five hundred francs!” “Only five hundred francs!” Madame Loisel gasped. Lost in thought, she began to feel sick. Thinking that she has just wasted ten years; doing heavy housework, hateful duties of cooking, bargaining with the butcher and many others, along with living the life of a pauper. “Oh darling, are you all right?” Madame Forestier questioned. “You look terribly ill” “I….I’ve got to do!” Madame Loisel mumbled as she ran towards the court yard. By the time she got home, she was out of breath. Madame Loisel yelled for her husband, but he didn’t respond, guessing that he still hasn’t gotten home yet. Thinking whiled she waited for her husband to return from work, about how he is going to react. When Monsieur Loisel came home, Madame Loisel greeted him pleasantly and began to tell him what has just happened. As she explained the situation, she could see her husband slowly become furious. Madame Loisel finished what she needed to say. Monsieur Loisel calmly stood up and told Madame Loisel to get back the necklace. Madame Loisel was confused with her husband’s reaction but went to go see Madame Forestier. Madame Loisel got to Madame Forestier house and asked “May I please have the necklace back. I will buy you the exact one that I’ve misplaced.” “Of course not, you’ve given it to me so now it’s mine!” Madame Forestier fought back. They continued to fight until Madame Forestier became violent. She revealed a dagger that was hidden under a cloth and persisted on stabbing Madame Loisel. Madame Loisel was stocked and blankly stared at the dagger coming towards her. As she stared, every second became slower and quieter. When the dragger touches her flesh, she awakes and notices it was all a dream……

    • 336 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Necklace Greediness

    • 1059 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Guy de Maupassant, born into nobility, wrote “The Necklace,” along with many other literary works, some inspired by his nobility. “The Necklace” is rittled with themes of wealth, and status, all issues Maupassant would have dealt with. The main character, Mathilde deals with these issues as well. When Mathilde deals with these themes her character is revealed, some good, but mostly bad. In “The Necklace” Maupassant represents Mathilde’s character by revealing her greediness, her lies, and her love.…

    • 1059 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    I have chosen to use Story of an Hour, written by Kate Chopin and The Necklace, written by Guy de Maupassant for this compare and contrast paper. My intentions are to show similarities as well as differences between these two pieces and provide comparison of the works to provide a deeper insight into the topic of this paper. The theme I find similar in these two pieces is greed: you should be happy with what you have. In both stories you have women that are not happy in their situations, seeming to always be wanting for more. While the stories are very different, they…

    • 2886 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Comparitve Essay

    • 510 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In the two short stories “The Necklace” by Guy de Maupassant and “The Rocking Horse” by D.H. Lawrence, the authors show that the love for money is the most corruptive love of all. One’s love of money can cause one to hurt what they hold most dear, it can make you forget your love for others, and can cause your loved ones to take desperate measures in order to attain your love. These effects are shown through Hester, the female protagonist in “The Rocking Horse” and through Mathilde, the female protagonist in “The Necklace”.…

    • 510 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays