Preview

Academic Review: Pricing Beauty, by Ashley Mears

Satisfactory Essays
Open Document
Open Document
843 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Academic Review: Pricing Beauty, by Ashley Mears
Ashley Mears
Pricing Beauty: The Making of a Fashion Model
University of California Press, Berkeley and Los Angeles, 2011
(ISBN-978-0-520-27076-3), 261 pp.

Reviewed by: Paige Ross, Hamline University, USA

In Pricing Beauty: The Making of a Fashion Model, Ashley Mears investigates and critiques the inequalities present in the modern-day fashion industry, focusing on the experiences of models in the industry, and the challenges they face in navigating the fashion world, managing their own physical and emotional appearances as social capital, and encountering certain roadblocks or special treatment depending on their race, appearance, and gender. Mears begins her novel by relating her second entry at twenty-three into the modeling industry, and her intent to conduct a firsthand study of the internal workings of the industry, infiltrating the structure from within–as a model. As a whole, Pricing Beauty concentrates on unveiling certain “backstage” ambiguities and inequalities within the fashion industry regarding race, gender roles and performance, sexuality, class, and bodily autonomy in order to address the issues of systemic racism, sexism, and classism inherent in both the fashion industry and in society in general. Mears uses a lot of direct quotations from personal interviews, and her insider perspective to vivisect the underpinnings the industry. Her position as a model grants her additional access to the various players in the industry, and gives her more authority than if this study was conducted by an outside perspective. The book is divided into seven chapters, including the “Entry” and “Exit” chapters. Chapter 1 goes over the “economics of the catwalk,” examining the differences between “symbolic” and “economic” capital, how “prestige” functions in the industry, and the division of these dimensions within the “editorial” and “commercial” sectors, as well as how the industry has changed economically over the years. Chapter 2 delves into the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    The first thing Jill says in this article is attacking the media for what they are doing. She is fed up with emaciated models pushing the readers to be thin, sexy and silent; However now the girls a fighting back. With the use of the visual of the founder of the new trend and there cover girl it shows that you don’t need the perfect thin body and hot clothes to make you beautiful. This shows that these magazines are ‘glossy’ with only information about how to get ‘thin and sexy’. But with Jill praising the new publication trend which shows realistic images of young women is targeting women to think that they don’t need to only look at super models in the media, but of people who they can relate to. This persuades the reader that media now is only thinking of super models is how they will sell it, but another ‘real’ women magazine is going fine. Also you don’t need to think you need to be thin to be beautiful, all you need to be is a real girl.…

    • 583 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In a positive view of social media, I plan to analyze the make up company Covergirl’s newest model who is making headlines for being the first Covergirl model to be a boy. The selection of the model, James Charles, as the newest model for the company brings up the question of traditional gender boundaries in fashion and beauty. In addition, it provides a role model for men who prefer to explore outside of these gender boundaries, and in so promoting their own self-image and acceptance. Furthermore supporting the facts that while there are some negative effects of social media, it can be used as a tool to help us grow as a society.…

    • 363 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Discrimination can take many forms and exist every aspect of society. After many years the fight against discrimination is still an ongoing process and for many it’s a daily struggle for many. The short documentary “The Color of beauty” examines the “blatant racism”(00:20) and discrimination that occurs within the fashion industry. The film revolves around Renee Thompson, an ethnic model trying to overcome the racism that exists in the fashion industry in order to make it on top. In today’s modernizing fashion has become a powerful driving force. The film, argues issue that Caucasian models are preferred over colored models, which is evident with the ratio of colored model to Caucasian models in most fashion choice. The film also points out that the difficulty colored models face due to a biased standard that the fashion industry has on beauty. It argues that more often or not, if a colored model is chosen, it’s due to his/her “unique” future. These so called “unique”(02:33) feature is common feature that many Caucasians. Elizabeth St. Philip, the director of the film, utilized a combination of logic, credibility, and emotional devices, in arguing and persuading an audience on the issue presented.…

    • 1193 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Through deconstructing The Devil Wears Prada the goal of this study is to prove that fashion in relation to a woman’s appearance is inherent to society’s definition of femininity and perceived professional competency. As mentioned earlier the heroines of makeover films are often depicted as independent women that make a conscious choice not to conform to society’s standard of femininity, because they put their emphasis on their intellect rather than their appearance. In The Devil Wears Prada the protagonist Andy Sachs fits the academic and dowdy female protagonist archetype that makeover films typically perpetuate. Andy Sachs follows the makeover film formula in the sense that she starts out the film as an intellectual with a blatant disregard for her appearance and performance of femininity. When Andy realizes how feminine performance or lack there of effects her perceived ability to do her job efficiently she adjusts her appearance to fit societally accepted…

    • 1673 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Pat Cleveland

    • 462 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In the seventies, the demand for black models within the fashion industry was scarce as fashion designers and modeling agencies preferred a particular mainstream image during this era. While the Civil Rights Movement was expanding, the same could not be said for the recognition of women of color in the racially-exclusive popular fashion publications and runway shows. Eventually, the racial boundaries slowly began to dissipate while black models were given the opportunity to demonstrate that the appearance of beauty, elegance and style in the world of fashion did not exclusively belong to only one culture defined by its skin tone.…

    • 462 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Going for the Look

    • 599 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In today’s younger, trendy, fashion stores, people are being hired for their looks and less because of their brains. Marshal Cohen, a senior industry analyst, argues about why hiring better looking people helps a store’s environment. Making a certain brand more desirable to buy, meaning the company shall make more money. Stores such as Abercrombie and Fitch have already set their image using this technique and have become quite successful. Hiring attractive people is not illegal, but it is indeed useful and profitable.…

    • 599 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    By stating the various ways in which teens pursue their fashion and how the industries target certain groups and ultimately how they want to fit in. While returning to the introduction’s hook in the conclusion is a frequently-used strategy, the authors throughout the article start slow by giving us an image in which to picture and feel, then they give info and quotes on how the industry targets certain groups and or body types. they then flow into how teens feel about fashion and even their own fashion by doing this she implies that young teens should not care about fashion but of their own happiness. Returning to their quotes and facts, the authors make their appeal to ethos, pathos, and logos which help establish their article firmly. The magazine articles the author tells us about help show how they target and ultimately persuade which we all have seen, and the quotes from professionals help shine light on the authors purpose of the article which is that happiness is key to a young females life and that the cultural standards are not what matter but…

    • 1304 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    It’s men who are in control of model’s contracts and bodies, as they continually hold positions of power in the industry. The unequal gender dynamic of the modeling industry not only result in economic control but also sexual harassment. Sexual harassment and assault run rampant in the industry because it is so widely accepted. Sadly, sexual assault is under-reported in the industry for fear of repercussion. Additionally, models are subjected to train to high levels and work for no remuneration. According to Jenny Brown the writer of “Fashion Models Shatter Stereotypes, Demand Labor Rights” says that because a model is an independent contractor to an agency, they are not covered by minimum wage laws. Brown writes that many models are paid in trade, and work for prestige. Many models continue to accept little pay because of the prestige that comes from being a model. The ability to become be “part of the fiction that sells these products” is rewarded in our society. While there is prestige in modeling is evident to everyone, the real struggles and abuses faced by the average model, particularly those who are young or undocumented, is kept under…

    • 907 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The first article, written by Aine F. Lorie, looks into four themes in the movie Sex and the City which best depicts the show’s attempt in reversal of the female gender in portraying female empowerment. This includes fashion, homo-socialization, hetero-socialization and female sexuality. It is understood that all the female characters in this series are obsessed and not afraid to splurge when it comes to fashion. One example on how fashion assists in female empowerment is when the female protagonist, Carrie Bradshaw jokingly told her friend “I like my money where I can see it, in my closet”. This statement suggests that items such as shoes (fashion) is used to measure socio-economic status and owning such items boosts the confidence of a…

    • 248 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Rodriguez was a victim of this definition of beauty and went through extreme measures to be like women on television. In her short story “Breaking the Model” she explains the influences that led a young Hispanic girl to become anorexic and bulimic trying to be something that she was not. “As a young teen, I shared the dream of many girls: I wanted to be a model and an actress” (189). These dreams did not conjure up in a girl’s head; they came from the images girls are constantly exposed to. Rodriguez continues, “I felt the media’s and society’s images of women were more responsible” (191). Her modeling agency even suggested that she “study the models in Teen and Seventeen and watch Beverly Hills 90210 to ‘get an idea of what real models look like’” (190). Since cultural ideas and norms are directly reflected in portrayals of women in the media, the Western culture has a deep influence on young girls trying to find their own…

    • 904 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Steve Madden Stereotypes

    • 515 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The model’s big head conveys self-esteem and self-pride and she challenges the consumer to look as good as she does. The young woman wears a face of apprehension and is running away from her old self to start her new confident life with Steve Madden products. The sleek black leather jacket on top of a sexy white shirt, short enough to reveal her stomach and curvaceous hips together with her tight low rider blue jeans, black pointy high boots, and trendy black bag complete her fashionable outfit. The embellished woman’s physique is aimed to appeal to women and girls between the ages of 16 through 25 in search of funky, hip, sexy…

    • 515 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The feature article “Sexed up tween advertising shows fashion needs to grow up”, by Emma Rush and Caroline Norma, is an extremely effective protest text against the sexual exploitation of young girls in the fashion industry. Its textual form allows it to strategically target influential audiences and the article itself is written so that the composer’s disapproval of sexed-up, young models is clearly seen. As a protest text, it also manages to maintain its reader’s interest and motivation for action throughout viewing which heightens its effectiveness.…

    • 610 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    paper

    • 632 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Throughout the history of women’s fashion it is known that each decade creates its own symbolic fashion statement within that time frame. The change in women’s fashion advertising is hard to go un-noticed once looked upon. In the 1940’s women’s fashion seemed to be relatively tolerable and not very difficult to strive for when it came to a women’s perspective. As opposed to today’s fashion advertisement for women; the image that “defines” beauty is what some would describe as unreachable without drastic sacrifice. The women in the image of a 1940s women’s advertisement compared to women in an image of today’s fashion could almost be described as a women that failed to make the cut in strive of todays “beauty”. If you ask me, women’s fashion advertisement has snowballed downhill since the 1940s.…

    • 632 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Beauty pageants, fashion shows, the Internet, and movies have swamped the public with two-dimensional pictures of beautiful icons and celebrities. America significantly relies on mass media to play a role in molding. This nations view of the definition to beauty and remodeling the culture in the same time frame. In present-day society with the consent changing idea that portrays images beauty, the public relies on the media to assist them to discover the most up-to-date trends on how to look and what to wear to stay ‘in fashion’. According to David Hume, “Beauty is in the eye of the beholder,” (1742). Perhaps a more modern-day accurate definition would be, “Beauty is in the eye of the media.” The effect one may have based upon the media could be as simple as the type of clothes a person buys and…

    • 490 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Additionally, Andy was a fish out of water at Runway. She found herself in an industry where she thought beauty was overstated and superfluous, even though Runway was one of the most influential magazines in fashion, a multibillion-dollar industry. Andy made fun of her coworkers by calling them “clackers” for the sounds their stilettos made on the marble lobby; regarded clothes and accessories as “stuff”; was surrounded by women obsessed with their looks and coveted designer handbags that were at least twice as much as their monthly salaries. But because of Andy’s devotion to her career, she stuck it out with Miranda and her condescending colleagues, and left herself no time for family and friends and found herself questioning her own ethical tolerance of the abuse of power and privilege; workplace mobbing, followership and socialization; stealing; as well as contextual pressures, unhealthy motivations and loyalties.…

    • 1549 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays