Preview

Against School John Gatto Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
501 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Against School John Gatto Analysis
Interested in both works, ‘Against School’ and ‘Against Love’ I thought over the two and the connections that could be made between them. In ‘Against School,’ Gatto proclaims his opinion of the education system through years of hands-on experience. He goes on to address how schools do not properly education children, but instead leave them bored with themselves. Gatto allows the reader to understand from his point of view from the use of past experiences that he foretells. However, in Kipnis’s ‘Against Love,’ we are unable to make direct connections with her considering that there are no experiences to relate. She procedures to tell how there are no direct experiences related to her by stating“ the voice isn’t precisely ‘me’...” (Kipnis 661) …show more content…
Kipnis’s perspective on coupledom, although not entirely her point of view, was a different vision than that of my own. I perceive love to be finding yourself in your other half, them making you a better person and contributing to who you are. I believe that love is able to awaken parts of the soul that nothing else can feasibly touch. However, Kipnis has a different spin on the idea of love which can be taken from the title, ‘Against Love’. There were statements on how much work goes into the fundamentals of love. As well as how if there is work put into a relationship than you must be doing it wrong because that then makes you have to work at it. Which can make it sound like a chore so people don’t put as much effort in and this can lead to the thought process about the foundation of love. How can two completely different individuals find a happy medium if there is no work involved or communication? Kipnis does imply that listening and hearing are two completely different things and to truly understand them you must practice what you preach. But there is more to love than ‘working at it’. All relationships need both individuals to understand each other which can be sought out through communication. My current relationship is based around communication and I understand that listening to the other can be a hole where information gets lost. Whereas hearing the other person allows for understanding and

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    After reading the two short stories, Love in L.A by Dagoberto Gilb and What We Talk about When We Talk about Love by Raymond Carver, I have realized that a common feeling like ‘love’ can be painted into so many different pictures. Each one of these short stories is written by two different authors and sees ‘love’ at different angles. The character Jake in Love in L.A. has this vision of love that is more of a mockery. Then, Terri’s ex-husband in What We talk about When We Talk about Love has so much passion, but the kind of passion that can be interoperated as obsession. The lies and misconceptions of ‘love’ that Jake and Terri’s ex-husband display reveal that ‘love’ does not exist in a world filled with nothing but cruelty and evil actions.…

    • 1005 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When it comes to the traditional education, John Taylor Gatto’s “Against School” questions whether we really need the nine month, drawn out, traditional curriculum. Gatto goes on to name several successful people through history that were not products of a contemporary school system. When I think of Gatto’s theory of forced schooling, a friend of mine named John Smith who goes by the alias of Viper comes to mind. Viper is in his late 20’s, lives in South Philadelphia, and has worked as a Roofer for the past 10 years.…

    • 719 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Frederick E. Hoxie, “Arthur C. Parker Argues for college Education for Indians” Talking back to civilization. Bedford,2001.…

    • 398 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In both essays, “Against school: How Public Education Cripples Our Kids, and Why” by John Taylor Gatto and “The Naked Source” written by Linda Simon, the problems with education system and how to reform it is demonstrated. They both declare that how courses curriculum ruins students’ curiosity and imagination by dividing them with test ratings. However, in order to make the best out of each person teachers must support student’s abilities. Talent development is essential in order to satisfy their infinite curiosity. Nowadays, obedient citizens are the product of obligatory schooling. Inevitably, It leads to mental exhaustion. When the reason of children’s boredom was asked by John, the students demanded to do “Something Real” rather than sitting…

    • 334 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The author of “Against School” John Taylor Gatto believes that during his long career in public schools he didn’t realise that schools are playing any major role in modification of “raw” children except making them childish adults. And the key problem behind the outcome is boredom, it occurs because scholars feel confined in 12 years of “imprisonment”. Gatto thinks that schools can increase the chances of success for their students if they let them make own decisions and take risks when necessary.…

    • 459 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    He uses rhetorical questions to introduce new topics to the reader, and subtly suggest the supporting facets of his argument. “Could it be that our schools are designed to make sure not one of them ever really grows up?” These rhetorical questions allow Gatto to dig deep toward the issues at hand, and shape the rhetorical situation of the piece. While these questions suggest dramatizations of certain topics (“Do we really need school?”), he guides the reader to various arguments that justify his skepticism on the educational system. Diction and tone play a particular role in these questions, showing an obvious bias towards one way, because even one carefully chosen word can sway one’s opinion. “Is this deadly routine [of forced schooling] really necessary?” exemplifies this concept because “deadly” and “really” imply that not only is forced schooling unjustifiable, but also harmful to the development of children. Gatto takes advantage of the casual tone he has set by creating contrast and introducing claims of absolutes. By staying away from using too much complex language, these claims stand out and cement themselves clearly in the reader’s mind. Early in the essay, after his anecdote about his grandfather’s lesson on boredom, he recalls that he learned “people who didn’t know [how to entertain themselves] were childish people, to be…

    • 935 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Jeffrey Smart’s work, The New School depicts a young girl standing alone, with dull man-made surroundings. She is standing in what looks like a school, hence the title of the piece. The girl looks sad and lonely, and we instantly assume she is new to the school; this may even be her first day. The young girl stands in the centre of the piece and has been placed in the foreground. Nothing is on either side of her, except in the background. She is standing on what looks to be a basketball court, or some kind of sporting court. In the background there are various buildings. Some are everyday buildings we can recognise; however there is a circular construction, behind the girl just to the left. To the side of this is also a playground, with three figures around it. One playing on the swings. On the other side of this circular construction is more buildings, and some bikes. This depicts a school environment. We also see buildings outside of the school which shows us that this school is in an urban environment. The colours are realistic yet this is a very dark piece. The sky is dark as well as the objects depicted throughout the work. When I view this work I am reminded of my first days at new schools. I am reminded of the fear of making new friends and meeting new teachers. I remember how scary the first day of school always was, and the anxiety caused by school.…

    • 1064 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gatto used personal anecdotes as a mode of development throughout his essay to convey the point of schooling being unnecessary. He started out explaining how in his teaching years, he would often have students complaining about being bored and the work they were forced to do. The students also explained to him how teachers were bored and disinterested with the material they were teaching. Gatto then went on to explain that we are all to blame. “My grandfather taught me that…when I was seven I complained to him of boredom… He told me that I was never to use that term…, that if I was bored it was my fault and no one else’s” (Gatto 148). He then taught the same thing to his students, however he realized that boredom naturally caused…

    • 890 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the essay “Against School” the author John Taylor, Gatto claims boredom has made a big impact in schooling systems all around the United States not only in Manhattan, New York. Gatto believes that boredom affects the capability of ones education and also states that boredom is a common condition not only in students but also in schoolteachers. Gatto is against schools all together, saying that our school system is to blame, a school system not designed by the United States but adapted from the Prussian culture.…

    • 374 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    John Gatto believes that mandatory schooling does wrong by prolonging childhood, and Professor X claims that students are unprepared for college, and questions whether some should be admitted. Gatto uses historical references to support his claim that schools stifle independence. Professor X doesn’t think everyone is qualified for a college level curriculum.…

    • 1173 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    John Gatto’s “Against School” is a persuasive essay arguing both the ineffectiveness and negative outcomes of today’s public school system. Not only does Gatto provide credibility with his experience as a teacher, but he also presents historical evidence that suggests that the public school system is an outdated structure, originally meant to dumb down students as well as program them to be obedient pawns in society. Fact and authority alone do not supplement his argument. Gatto also uses emotional appeals, such as fear and doubt, to tear down the reader’s trust in the schooling system. Although it may seem to be so, Gatto’s argument is not one sided. He also offers suggestions to make the educational system more efficient at the hands of positive reinforcement and the employment of more motivated teachers. Through the effective application of ethos, logos, and pathos, John Gatto provides a well-rounded argument against the public school system that would cause any reader to question the goals of modern schooling.…

    • 1386 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Great Gatsby and On the Road are both similar. They have a lot of different things in common. The time period seems to be the same in both of them by how things are happening in the world, what is going on, and how people are treated. On the Road is about a couple of friends who constantly travel by hitchhiking most of the time. The Great Gatsby is about a rich man who was in love with a girl and he went to the war which caused them to drift apart. The two seem to be nothing alike, but On the Road and The Great Gatsby interpret the same message, they have similar characters, and the women are treated the same.…

    • 798 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    I have spent the past 4 years of my high school career being what Alfie Kohn describes perfectly in his article “How not to Get Into College”: The Preoccupation with Preparation. I would with a shadow of a doubt in my mind consider myself a grade grubber. Aflie Kohn defines a grade grubber has a student who has pressures on them to give up everything they love in life to focus on their grades to get into the college of their dreams, and this definition suits me perfectly. Alfie Kohn argues that students in various levels of education, only focus on grades that they need to achieve, rather than actually learning and retaining the learnt content. I believe this problem is a reality for me: as the pressure of attaining a good grade, and the constant…

    • 187 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    mr pip

    • 1913 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Helps advance knowledge and understanding. Matilda says the story results from their ignorance of outside world…

    • 1913 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    In this poem ‘Country School’, Curnow basks in reminiscence of his old school where he drifts away in recalling his childhood. As this poem reflects childhood reminiscence, the narrator seems to realise that things aren’t as dull and bad as they seemed before, along with the portrayal of the overall issue of ageing. However, the tone of the narrator seems to sway between enthusiastic and apathetic as there are many times when the tones seem to differ between two extremes. The persona is describing a country school that seems to be somewhat dilapidated in condition. The vivid image drawn by the alliterative phrase ‘paint all peeled’ supports the fact that the school is indeed deteriorating. ‘Tufts topping’ enables the reader to visualise a country school architecture, with ‘pinus tufts’ on its ‘roof ridge’, establishing an image of a typical country school. Through the usage of colloquial language, these vivid images hold more detail then one might think they do at first. For instance, the word ‘dunny’ evolves a picture of local Australian toilets enlightening the audience to the smallest of details. Furthermore, ‘girls squeal skipping’ conjures up an auditory image as the little children are playing around him (supported by the sibilance). Several kinds of onomatopoeia help to describe what the persona is experiencing. THe fluid ‘r’ sounds in ‘rank’ and ‘roof-ridge’ help to integrate the ideas, linking them and helping form a wider image of the country school. Also, the ‘b’ sounds in ‘bargeboard, weatherboard’ and ‘gibbet belfry’ calls attention to the detailed observation, helping build up a solid image. Curnow employs parallelism as well as repetition in order to create links in this poem. The parallel comparison, or contrast, of ‘how small; how sad’, draws a link with how he seems to be recalling his days back in school. The passing of time and his ageing is revelaed as the very doors that seemed huge from a…

    • 1347 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays