Preview

Albert Speer: Apolitical Technocrat Or Skilled Manipulator?

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1621 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Albert Speer: Apolitical Technocrat Or Skilled Manipulator?
Albert Speer: Apolitical Technocrat or Skilled Manipulator?
Albert Speer was, arguably, the most complicated personality in the prominent Nazi officials. He began his career after joining the Nazi party as an architect; and his friendship with Hitler propelled his promotion to Reich Minister for Armaments and War Production. When Germany lost the war, Speer was one of the few Nazi officials to evade the death sentence. There are two historical viewpoints as to the role of Speer. The first is that Speer was merely a technocrat, with no political views- and this view is created by Speer in his post-war writings, as well as historian Joachim Fest. The second viewpoint, which is more widely believed than the first, is that Speer was a clever man who manipulated the Nazi party, the Nuremburg War Crimes prosecutors and also the world through his books after
…show more content…
His defence was this: Speer accepted collective responsibility for Nazi war crimes and crimes against humanity, while simultaneously claiming to have had no knowledge of these atrocities or their details. American economist John Galbraith, who was present at the Nuremburg trials, said “Speer’s confession was part of his well-developed strategy of self-vindication and survival”1. Also, historian Wesley Yang writes that Speer “seduced the Allies with his looks, charm and clever strategy”2. Speer was primarily accused of utilising slave labour in his munitions factories. He distanced himself from his advisor, and the ‘official’ recruiter of the slave labour force, Fritz Sauckel. Sauckel became the scapegoat, and their relationship became very futile. As a result, Speer was sentenced to twenty years in prison, a comparatively light sentence. Film director Martin Davidson conveys in his documentary that “Speer gave the judges what they wanted most, penitence”3. But where did this manipulative nature

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Albert Speer’s rise to prominence began through his early work for the Nazi Party, followed by becoming the first architect of the Reich and his contributions to the Germania project where the Nazi power was consolidated. Speer reached his full potential through his appointment as Armaments minister.…

    • 627 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Many historians such as Alan Bullock praise Speer's performance at the Nuremburg Trials and were convinced that Speer had told the truth. They label Speer an 'apolitical technocrat', 'more concerned with the job he had to do than the power it brought him.'(1) American journalist William Shirer reported on his trial at Nuremburg and came to view him favourably (2), whilst British academic Hugh Trevor-Roper interviewed Speer, and in his book The Last Days of Hitler, describes Speer as the 'penitent Nazi'.(3)…

    • 1640 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    After the attempt had failed, “Hitler told German radio listeners a coup by a ‘clique of ambitious, conscienceless, and criminal and stupid officers’ had failed and would be dealt with in true National Socialist fashion” (McDonough). Five thousand people who were against Hitler were executed that day (McDonough). “In an attempt to protect himself, Fromm organized the execution of Stauffenberg along with three other conspirators in the courtyard of the War Ministry” (“Claus von…

    • 606 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Speer's Significance

    • 603 Words
    • 3 Pages

    What is the significance of the role Speer played as Minister of Armaments and Production?…

    • 603 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Albert Speer Characteristics

    • 4463 Words
    • 18 Pages

    Speer’s technical and administrative skills and enthusiasm were what made him Hitler’s ideal choice. Hitler had originally paid very little attention to the detains of organising production and had ordered a reduction in weapon production after the fall of France in 1940. Speer assumed responsibility for a vast enterprise and in solving three key issues that would effectively decide the war effort – how to eliminate the gross inefficiencies of war production, how to increase armaments and munitions production despite the increasing bombing of German factories and other production targets. Speer believed in total mobilisation of the workforce to avoid military…

    • 4463 Words
    • 18 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    There have been historical arguments over the idea of Albert Speer being an apolitical technocrat in regards to his career. Speer wasn’t an apolitical technocrat due to the use of slave labour for the production of armament, his visits to concentration camps such as Mauthausen camp and the horrific conditions he saw at the Dora missile factory, his knowledge of Himmler’s speech at Posen also his defence at the Nuremburg trials in 1945.…

    • 1036 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The early life and career of Albert Speer was shaped by his familial upbringing, his connection to his mentor Professor Heinrich Tessenow and, in later years, his affiliation with the Nazi Party. Born into a wealthy family in March 1905, Albert Speer was the second of three sons. His father, Albert, was a prosperous architect who provided a privileged life for his three sons and wife. Albert's mother, Luise, was also successful in her own right. His parents provided all manner of material conveniences to their sons however with their high…

    • 769 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In my essay I will assess how significant Albert Speer was to the running of the Nazi war machine and the Nazi regime. I will look at how such an intelligent, well-intentioned, principled person like Speer could become such an integral part in the Nazi party, so captivated by Hitler’s charisma and influence that he could ignore all the atrocities, the concentration camps, the slaughter of the fuehrer’s wars and devote all the country’s resources to keeping the regime in power. Albert Speer was appointed as minister for Armaments and munitions in February 1942. Speer played an invaluable role in the Nazi War Machine during the next three years of the Second World War. His effectiveness as minister for armaments and munitions led to phenomenal increases in the production of armaments, and ultimately prolonging the war for another one to two years which greatly impacted on the functioning of the War Machine. Speer’s major accomplishments as minister for armaments and munitions were the standardization of weapons and specialization of factories. Implementing a Total War policy in Germany. The mobilization of the workforce in relation to the armament production.…

    • 1756 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Andersonville Prison

    • 860 Words
    • 4 Pages

    After the war, Wirz was charged for personally murdering 13 of the Union soldiers held captive at the prison camp. It was alleged that Wirz had murdered thirteen Union prisoners of war at Andersonville by shooting, stomping, subjecting such prisoners to the mauling of bloodhounds, and various other mistreatment. However, this is controversial. There were 160 witnesses called to the stand to testify, who all were prisoners. 145 of the witnesses claimed that they had no knowledge that Wirz had murdered anyone at all, and claimed that if he had actually committed these crimes, they most certainly would’ve heard about it. Talking was all that the prisoners could do at the camp, and if these crimes had happened, they would’ve discussed it while in Andersonville. Also, the 13 people who were claimed to be “murdered” were never identified. James Madison Page, an inmate at Andersonville said, “Fictitious men do not need names (Wirz Trial)”. Wirz however, was found guilty on 11 of the 13 charges of murder and for conspiring with high officials. He was sentenced to death and executed on November 10, 1865. Henry Wirz was the only person executed for war crimes during the Civil War.…

    • 860 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Albert Speer’s Role in the Nazi Regime primarily was centred on a couple of areas, his work as the General Building Inspector (GBI), the chief architect of the Reich and his role as Armaments Minister. Speer’s ascendancy within the Nazi hierarchy has been described by Henry King as ‘vertical and ladder like, Speer was an intelligent, affluent and well educated man and there is no doubt that he made a remarkable progression through the ranks of the Nazi Party. In less than ten years Albert Speer no longer was the humble architect but became the master of the German economy and production in Germany.…

    • 3605 Words
    • 15 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    <br>Speer's well structured and thought out defence shaped historical interpretation for years to come. At Nuremberg he presented himself as a pure technician and not involved in the politics or ideology of the party. He also claimed collective responsibility for crimes against Jews but also his ignorance of the Nazi intentions. As he stated at a later time: "I just stood aside and said to myself that as long as I did not personally participate it had nothing to do with me. My toleration for the anti Semitic campaign made me responsible for it." This admission of guilt won a fair amount of sympathy from the court. The reasons he gave for being with the Nazi party was that he was taken by Hitler's personality and also realised that if he was to achieve his dream as an architect he will have to sell his soul to the party. This image of Speer was to be accepted for a while by most historians and was given little attention. This was probably because Speer was a little less ‘spectacular' than Hitler's other henchmen. There were however some suspicions. John Galbraith, a member of the US team that debriefed Speer before the Nuremberg trial, said in Life magazine 1945 that Speer's claims contained "elements of fantasy". He also believed that Speer's confession was a part of his "well developed strategy of self…

    • 928 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Speer - Changing Views

    • 995 Words
    • 4 Pages

    One significant factor that can account for the initial perception of Speer was his performance at the Nuremburg Trials in 1946. This was the breeding ground for Speer’s ‘Good Nazi’ image which was to perpetuate throughout the world. Speer offered the world hope for explaining the atrocities: it validated the idea that not all Germans were ‘Nazis’ and malicious individuals. In the trial, he took an unprecedented line of argument that distinguished him from the other Nazi leaders. Speer admitted at the trial a ‘collective responsibility’ which he argued ‘can only apply to fundamental matters and not to the details’. He focused on the events that portrayed him favourably. Speer spoke at great length regarding how he consistently disobeyed Hitler at ‘great personal risk’. According to K.J. Mason’s book Republic to Reich, most of his accounts were accepted at Nuremburg as ‘there was no evidence to contradict it’.…

    • 995 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    It is questionable whether Speer was at the Posen Meeting in 1943 as the concentration camp was mentioned at the meeting. Speer claimed to have left by then although sources suggest that this was the turning point in his faults to convict him at the Nuremburg trials for knowledge of the concentration camps and the Jewish people. Speer had said in an interview that he had “tolerated” Hitler’s anti-Semitic policies suggesting he did not know about the persecution of the Jewish people. He may not have been supporting this view but his choice to ignore it is viewed as his greatest fault and this adds to why he is counted as an important figure to German history having survived the death penalty for all his convictions at the Nuremburg trials were he pleaded innocent to two counts of murder and persecution and knowledge of the concentration camps that the Jews were involved in. Speer instead received 20 years prison sentence at the Spandau prison. This shows historians as well as others that Albert Speer’s purpose was to get to the top of the pile in the Nazi regime, to get on top of Hitler, although his virtues came along with major faults to stumble his passage. As for his Nuremburg trial convictions historian Ullrich said that “If the judges at Nuremburg had known…

    • 1057 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Rise To Prominence Speer

    • 3495 Words
    • 11 Pages

    Albert Speer was an intelligent, affluent and well-educated man, in many ways he was an atypical Nazi. Albert Speer claimed to be apolitical as a young man; however he himself like many others, were converted to the Nazi Party after attending a rally and hearing Adolf Hitler speak. The following essay will outline Albert Speer’s rise to prominence within the Nazi Party.…

    • 3495 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    How does Social cognitive approach fit with Adolf Hitler? As we know the leader of Nazis he had a rough childhood, mostly blaming his dad. The reason his childhood is a great key to his awful act is because of the different situations that occurred during his young age. He had been whipped and he was helpless only thinking of revenge upon growing up. The situation in which he had been sexually assaulted and also whipped showed the behavior of anger, hatred and the facts that he truly wanted to revenge his dad for making his life a misery one. He responded to this when he grew up, being in politics showed he had the power, he was now in controlled of the situation rather than being weak, he took great advantage of this opportunity and express his hatred of Jews then showed his anger and killed millions by creating a worldwide war. Also because of his father he had severe anxiety problems, several health issues. Being an easy target during his childhood made him unprotected and easily harmed, he still had fear in his adultery because of his personalities disorder, which causes chronic anxiety which then added up to insomnia anxiety. His life turn more misery after he had to take medicine against these anxiety such as chronic and insomnia…

    • 1075 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays

Related Topics