This poem, written by Les Murray, reflects upon all aspects of the human condition, from the fear of change to the need for conformity, uncovering the ultimate truth of the universal desire to belong. Set in a society which significantly resembles today’s world, where feelings and emotions are kept hidden and people are caught up in their busy lives, it explores the realms of acceptance and the ways in which societal norms shape a sense of self. Although not quite an easy read, with obscure meanings, the poem is capable of touching many hearts and evoking self-realisation.
Starting off in an eventful world full of greed and gossip, the poet, through vivid imagery of different people in ‘sheets of numbers’ and streets ‘baked up for almost half a mile’, paints a picture in the readers’ mind of a busy city skidding to a halt at the mere mention of an unconventional occurrence. The sight of a ‘weeping man’ on the streets is unheard of, a strange phenomenon that garners ‘edgy talk’ and ‘pointing’ – depicting the man’s exclusion from society for being different, for pouring out emotion in public. Yet, his weeping attracts attention, at first in a negative way; the people who ‘surround’ him nevertheless keep their distance, warily observing him. The juxtaposition of the ‘crowds’ and the ‘man that no-one approaches’, further highlights his isolation from society. However, in my opinion, this seclusion is not wholly negative; it seems almost desired in a way as he creates a peaceful ‘hollow’ around him by his weeping. In contrast, in Dickinson’s poems is described a sense of sorrow accompanying separation – in Poem 82 the persona craves social ‘wealth’ but is unable to ‘hope’ for it. However, the end of the same poem sees the persona finding peace with not belonging – an idea that Murray’s poem also shares.
As the poem progresses, it can be seen that the weeping man grows to be respected and even admired. Within the ordinary act of crying lies the extraordinary act of standing up to society; he is soon elevated to a high status, seen as possessing supernatural ‘force’ or as a messenger from ‘Paradise’. However, this is juxtaposed with the very next line, ‘there is no such thing’, portraying the ambivalence of the persona as they question the existence of the man.
Nevertheless, the crowd evidently gets drawn in by the man, in my opinion, not solely by emotion but because of their desire to belong with him. While many embrace the ‘gift of weeping’ out of ‘sheer acceptance’, wishing to express their approval of his actions and their desire to blend in, others ‘refuse to weep’, fearing rejection from society. This portrays how people, anxious to be accepted, are afraid to deviate from societal norms and unlock their true nature. The ‘uniforms’ in the crowd who earlier try to stop the man, could be symbolic of conformity – as we all attempt to wear the same ‘uniform’ or be replicas of each other in order to fit in, we lose individuality. According to me, the contagion of crying depicted in the poem portrays the final realisation of internal belonging, a concept that is also present in Dickinson’s poetry. While the persona in Poem 82 discovers satisfaction within themselves after searching for wealth outside, the crowd in Murray’s poem finds it in the free expression of emotion.
In my opinion, as the title suggests, the poem is an extended metaphor, as the weeping man is in fact a rainbow. Although it is ‘ordinary’ knowledge, it is extraordinary in that it succeeds to awe us each time it occurs. The man’s tears are the water droplets that make up a rainbow; though far away from us, it envelops us with ‘amazement’, with the power of the sublime helping us find our place in the world.
On the whole, I feel that this poem is a beautiful representation of the belonging felt from within and the community.
================================================================
Written by Les Murray in 1969.
Published in ‘Selected Poems: The Vernacular Republic’, 1970.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
-Essay: 1300- 1500 words. ‘A sense of belonging is never permanent.’ Discuss in relation to TWO poems and TWO pieces of related texts.…
- 1017 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Belonging can result in both a positive and negative experience. The choice to belong or not belong can be forced upon an individual by society. The most common barriers preventing a person from belonging in society in which are highlighted in Peter Skrzynecki’s poems include culture, language religion. Skrzynecki, straddles a dichotomy; that of identification and disconnection.…
- 907 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Your perception of belonging can be shaped by your surroundings and community which can impact on whether you are isolated to the point of conformity.. This is determined by the individual which either leads them to adapt-which offers them safety, security and feelings of acceptance or to feel outcast and ostracised. In Ray Bradbury The pedestrian and in Peter Skrzynecki’s poem Felik Skrzynecki examine how individuals are pressured to conform to the norms and expectations of society, however a lack of it can also cause alienation.…
- 799 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The need to be accepted and please those who know us is an intrinsic part of human nature. For many, this craving to ‘fit in’ is forever accompanied by the fear of displeasing and in turn being rejected by that which we are a part of, whether that be place, people or groups with shared ideas. So too are the connections we make with people, places, groups, communities or the larger world essential to achieve an individual’s sense of belonging; the sense of acceptance that signifies us as humans and is intrinsic to our growth as individuals. The idea that belonging comes from a series of connections made with the world outside our own self is a theme throughout Romulus, My Father, a memoir written by Raimond Gaita about his immigrant father, and the poem We Are Going by Oodgeroo Noonuccal which illustrates the pain and loss felt by the Australian Aboriginals when their land was taken.…
- 980 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The sense of belonging humans naturally seek in life reflects the feeling of security and being accepted. They struggle with their identity as they make the choice whether to reject the individuality and belong to a community or group. When individuals seek to belong and rigidly follow society’s norms and practices, they must adhere to the strict rules of their society. In doing do, the desire to belong comes into conflict with the need to be an individual. These ideas are powerfully evident in Arthur Miller’s play “The Crucible”, “Catcher in the Rye” by J.D Salinger and the Gurinder Chadha film “Bend it like Beckham.” In each of these texts, most desire to belong but need to restore the balance between the need to belong and the expression of their individuality.…
- 1657 Words
- 7 Pages
Good Essays -
When an individual’s sense of identity is corrupted through prejudicial attitudes they are left exposed and vulnerable allowing a sense of isolation and displacement in society. An individual’s ability to promote change within is largely influenced by the hardships they experience in their struggle to conform and the connectedness of identity that stems from acceptance. Tara June Winch’s novel Swallow the air, adapts the core concept that the perceptions and ideas of belonging are shaped within personal, cultural, historical and social contexts defining who we are resulting in a true understanding and sense of self. This notion resonates in Shaun Tan’s picture book The Red Tree and Armin Greder’s allegorical picture book The Island ,as all three texts explore the potential of the sacrifices an individual makes to belong and the affect the attitudes and perceptions have which can either allow or hinder an individual’s quest to find their place in the world.…
- 1046 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Individual characteristics and traits are what initiate and drive an ever-changing society. Individuality sparks innovation, keeps life captivating, and forces society to continue to grow. However, society also is the first place where individuality is not accepted or misunderstood. The idea of not fitting into society can be viewed as a painful experience. In Susan Musgrave’s poem “You Didn’t Fit,” she aims to show how no one fits into social norms. The poem intends to show how people believe they need to reach certain standards to be accepted and to find love, but in reality, everyone should be trying to stand out.…
- 582 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The concept of belonging is essential. To belong is to form a connection which will allow a sense of identity to manifest, without this we lose our humanity; however, conformity is in a sense a facade of belonging, as it restrains our freedom and forces us to only mimic. My studied texts show how society demands us to conform, yet conformity prevents a sense of true identity being created.…
- 692 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Belonging can be beneficial and disadvantageous depending on the individual’s journey. Conformity is necessary in order to gain acceptance to a certain group or to a certain individual. When one’s experience of belonging is positive it can provide them with new option in the world. This can grant new opportunities but can also result in neglecting one’s true identity. A strong concept that is explored within ‘Great Expectations’ (1861) by Charles Dickens is that self-fulfilment can be enrich one’s life and can cause a shift in social economic status, granting one with new opportunities for a sense of belonging. Another critical concept that is evident in ‘Scar’ (2004) by Missy Higgins is that conformity often leads to the redundancy of one’s identity, causing self-destruction…
- 314 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Howe presents her poems as “meditations on matter and spirit” (801). She intends to explore both “the mysteries of interior life and the weight of the material world” (801). These ideas are similar to Dickinson’s theme of her inner world. However, Howe does not emphasize death and dread to the extent of Dickinson. She embodies the postmodernist rejection of the “Modernist despair and sense of tragic loss”.…
- 263 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
The concept of belonging is essential. To belong is to form a connection which will allow a sense of identity, without this we lose our humanity; however, conformity is in a sense a facade of belonging, as it restrains our freedom and forces us to only mimic. My studied texts show how society demands us to conform, yet conformity prevents a sense of true identity being ever created.…
- 680 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
I enjoy reading “Song of Myself” poem from the book in this assignment. Whitman is a good example of American identity because he has experienced it. America is one of the country consist a lots of different ethnicities like African American, Asian, Hispanic etc. The quote of Whitman “This is the meal equally set this the meat for natural hunger, It is for the wicked just the same as the righteous, I make appointments with all” (The Norton Anthology of American Literature, 1342). This meant for someone like Mr. Whitman he believes that everyone must be free and equal.…
- 502 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Cited: Author’s name omitted by request. “Emily Dickinson Poem Analysis.” Copyright 2001. (Viewed on 12 February 2003)…
- 632 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Thesis of my paper that I am trying to prove to the reader is that Emily Dickinson is a brilliant extraordinary writer. She talks about mortality and death within her life and on paper in her poem works.…
- 865 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
In this poem Dickinson uses a good variety of diction and figurative language that supersedes poets of her time. In all of her stanzas she uses personification such as, “The Lightning-never asked an Eye Wherefore it Shut,” (Aries 1) is one example of attributing human characteristics to non-human entities. Other examples of Dickinson’s figurative language used within her poem are her use of similes. In her first stanza she writes, “The Wind does not require the Grass To answer-Wherefore when He pass She cannot keep Her place,” (Aries 1), which provides a perfect example of comparing the inability to remain still and reserve during physical and emotional pressure metaphorically. By Dickinson writing in this manner, she is able to keep the reader engulfed through imagery provided by her poetic language.…
- 544 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays