Analysis Of John In The Painted Door

The short story, The Painted Door, deals with two characters with antithesis traits: John, who is a dedicated farmer and providing husband, and Steven, who is the unmarried, flirtatious neighbor. Ann, the protagonist, struggles with a dilemma between the two men. Although Ann feels conflicted, dramatic irony is present as the reader is well aware that John is the better man. Despite John’s dullness “his devotion [is] baffling” (Ross 51). First, he slaves “away fifteen hours a day to give…” (Ross 51) Ann the life he believes she deserves, full of pretty clothes and endless love. With great intentions, John labors his life away. He repeatedly reminds her that he has never abandoned her and never will. John’s loyalty and dedication confirms his
love for Ann. While her husband is away from the house, Ann receives a visit from a friend. Steven arrives with “his lips drawn in a little smile...” (Ross 57) that is unrelenting for the remainder of the night. The growing tension between Steven and Ann gives a perception of lust rather than love. His compelling body lures her to the bedroom to cave to her fantasies. Steven’s seduction of Ann exposes his poor characteristics and harmful intentions. Subsequently, after discovering Ann in bed with Steven, John commits suicide. Even to his death, he is trying to do what will ultimately makes Ann the happiest. Inevitably, Ann’s dilemma highlights both men’s traits justifying John as the better man.