Preview

Analysis Of Judith Thomson's Article, A Defense Of Abortion

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
144 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Analysis Of Judith Thomson's Article, A Defense Of Abortion
In Judith Thomson’s article “A Defense of Abortion”, Thomson proposed an interesting thought experiment. She asked the readers to imagine finding themselves waking up into a situation, where they were kidnapped and have a famous unconscious violinist, who suffered from a fatal kidney, plugged into their body. Later, they found out that they alone have the right blood type to help the violinist and to unplug themselves from him would have killed him. All they need to do is to have the violinist circulatory system plugged into their body for nine months. All for nine months, that’s it.

Suppose that I am the only person in this planet that can save the violinist’s life by plugging his blood circulatory system into my body for nine months. In

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    In submitting this assignment with this cover page, I am hereby stating that: (1) I have voluntarily read, understand, and agree to uphold and abide by the syllabus plagiarism policy for this class; (2) I have neither plagiarized any other author’s written material or unwritten ideas or enabled (intentionally or unwittingly) other students to plagiarize any part of this assignment; (3) I have neither shown or even discussed my assignment with any other student; and (4) I voluntarily accept the consequences stipulated in the syllabus plagiarism policy for this class should my statements in (1), (2), or (3) above prove false.…

    • 1756 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The debate about abortion focuses on two issues; 1.) Whether the human fetus has the right to life, and, if so, 2.) Whether the rights of the mother override the rights of the fetus. The two ethicists who present strong arguments for their position, and who I am further going to discuss are that of Don Marquis and Judith Thomson. Marquis' "Future Like Ours" (FLO) theory represents his main argument, whereas, Thomson uses analogies to influence the reader of her point of view. Each argument contains strengths and weaknesses, and the point of this paper is to show you that Marquis presents a more sound argument against abortion than Thomson presents for it. An in depth overview of both arguments will be presented in the paper, as well as a critique of both the pros and cons that stem out from the question-begging arguments.…

    • 3100 Words
    • 89 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The statement "defense of abortion", gives us an another view to a problem of abortion. Mostly, Judith Jarvis Thompson protects pro-choice side, and she says that abortion is not immoral, and that it is logically correct action. However there are a lot of anti-abortion philosophers who are not agree with it. So Judith Thompson gives an arguments to proof her sides correctness. She says that mother has all rights to do anything with her body and things in her body. Judith Jarvis Thompson also believes that fetuses are not persons, and killing them is not immoral. However she says that there are also situations, when abortion is incorrect. Also she gave 3 main thought experiments to get another point of view to abortion.…

    • 354 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    She justifies this point with the violinist case, which states that a famous violinist is about to die so his fan base nonconsensually kidnaps you and hooks your origins up to his for 9 months until he can get better and live on his own again. As the reader, you can choose to stay hooked up to him or cut the cords, which would kill the violinist, but allow you to live your life as you did previously. Thomson argues that it would be extremely unfair and immoral to you to force you to stay attached to the violinist, as you had nothing to do with him being connected to you in the first place. She goes on to compare this to nonconsensual intercourse that causes pregnancy and states that it is morally acceptable to abort the fetus because, just like being attached to the violinist, a woman did not ask for or do anything to warrant being pregnant. Her next argument was on the topic of abortion when the mother's life is at risk.…

    • 1018 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    After reading “A defense of Abortion” by Judith Jarvis Thomson and what he had to say with his violinist analogy involving the kidney replacement. I agree with what he has to say on not only abortion itself but, whether or not a fetus should have the right to the women’s body. I don’t think that the fetus should be given the right to use the women’s body because what if she does not what to have a baby and ends up getting pregnant anyway. Also, each time a woman engages in sexual intercourse, she is not inviting the fetus to live inside her body. This is why birth control and other contraceptives are not a sure deal when dealing with sexual intercourse. What if the birth control method fails and the women end's up getting pregnant? She did…

    • 404 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Thompson feels that its false. In her first thought experiment, she goes on talk about how one day you just wake up in the hospital with a famous violinist attached to your kidneys, and he needs the use of your kidneys for nine months. You have to keep in mind that every person has a right to life and so the violinist has a right to life so it would be impressionable to unplug the violinist. You also have a right to bodily integrity which trumps a right to life. This example shows us that there are some cases in which abortion is morally permissible. This analogy about a pregnancy that resulted from a…

    • 602 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Abortion has always been a controversial topic in America. People have been separated into “pro life” and “pro choice” groups who support completely opposite topics. In “When Abortion Suddenly Stopped Making Sense”, Frederica Mathewes-Green successfully persuades readers why she is against abortion by utilizing personal anecdotes when switching from pro choice to pro life, alarming statistics and exposing a baby’s humanity using sympathetic language.…

    • 1021 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    7.Poupard. J. Richard, (2007) in 'suffer the violinist: why the pro-abortion argument from bodily autonomy fails ' Christian research journal, http://www.equipresources.org/atf/cf/%7B9C4EE03A-F988-4091-84BD-F8E70A3B0215%7D/JAA025.pdf accessed 30/01/2013…

    • 2254 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Strode, T (2003, October 17) More abortions for Down syndrome may result from new tests The…

    • 2028 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Author Atul Gawande is a surgeon, staff writer for The New Yorker and a professor at the Harvard Medical School. Being Mortal: Medicine and What Matters in the End was an inspiring book that unwrap people’s mind for discussion and question our current practice of medicine and care. It is easy for audiences of all ages to relate to this book even if the young do not think about the process of death. It has a comprehensive coverage of medical sociology, where it deliberates on the evolution, controversial conversation of medicine and issues after medicine becomes impotent to people’s health. Gawande uses recounts of people (patients) and his own reflections on the stories to illustrate the dilemmas of the two facet of medicine: to attempt…

    • 1462 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Abortion Ethics Paper

    • 554 Words
    • 2 Pages

    P1: Whether or not the unborn has a right to life, it does not have a right to…

    • 554 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Pro Life Vs Pro Choice

    • 2228 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Richard Stith presents an analogy in his article “Why Pro-Life Arguments Sound Absurd.” He asks “at what point in the automobile assembly line process can a "car” be said to exist? Most of us would point to some measure of minimum functionality, like having wheels or a motor, but some might insist on the need for windshield wipers or might say it's not fully a car until it rolls out onto the street (Stith 1). Stitch makes a compelling argument towards the unknown factor of when a human is able to function. In “Unstringing the Violinist”, Greg discusses one most debated arguments supporting abortion, which was developed by Judith Jarvis Thompson in 1971. “The Violinist” explains how you wake up one morning in a hospital with tubes attached to a famous violinist; the doctor tells you that you have to be connected for nine months and that you will grow weaker-maybe even die- until he is disconnected from you. If you choose to break the plug, then the violinist will die. Most people would choose to disconnect the plug to save themselves; what most people do not know is that this is a metaphor for an unexpected pregnancy. This analogy has left many speechless and unable to fight the argument with sufficient information and…

    • 2228 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    “Since the legalization of abortion in 1973, over 56 million unborn children have been killed.” Their mothers never gave them chance to be born. Abortion has been a debatable topic for decades, but aborting a human being is morally wrong and medically unsafe.…

    • 1608 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    “Philosophy is defines as the study of the principles underlying conduct thought, and the nature of the universe. A simple explanation of philosophy is that it entails a search for meaning in a universe” (Chitty, & Black, 2007, p. 318).…

    • 559 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    My Files

    • 1122 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In this story, you will read about someone who was misunderstood. Be able to tell how this someone became happy. Tell also in what way this story could apply to people.…

    • 1122 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays