Preview

Analysis Of Sudipta Kaviraj's The Imaginary Institution Of India

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
3422 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Analysis Of Sudipta Kaviraj's The Imaginary Institution Of India
The term nation has been envisioned variously by primordialists and modernists and is enmeshed in bewildering contradictions. In this paper it has been used to mean “ . . . not so much a cultural artifact . . . but a web of material relations and practices, which rests on classes, caste structures, gendered systems of production and reproduction, armies, laws, territories and yes, signifying practices as well.” (Ahmad 2007:40) The establishment of India as a nation-state upon Indian sub-continent not only conferred the people living within its political boundary a new overarching national identity of being ‘Indians’ above other ‘fuzzy’ identities based on caste, class, community but also brought in its wake the catastrophe of Partition that made the exclusionist and territorial aspects of nation-state quite evident. Sudipta Kaviraj in “The Imaginary Institution of India” explicates the idea of territorial demarcation of boundaries of the modern- nation state, as an imperative condition for enumerating its subjects in the process of nation formation for the purpose of administration and control. He also purports the …show more content…
The story allegorizes the imperative demand the modern-nation state imposes upon its citizens to adhere to the common political identity or nationality and those who fail to align themselves to it, are labeled as traitors and are exterminated, which becomes evident in the story, in the casual remark made by a soldier that “[n]ow even dogs will have to be either Indian or Pakistani” and that “[l]ike Pakistanis, Pakistani dogs will also be shot.” (Hassan 2007:175) The story also highlights the ‘unnaturalness’ of boarders and the irrationality of conflict by juxtaposing in the narration the description of nature that continues its course unmindful of the warring

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    During periods of chaos and war, extraordinary occurrences happen where least expected. In a land where many religions are accustomed, Afghanistan’s citizens are divided by these religions. However in the case of safety, two religious groups come together, believing in the same idea. The Hazara and Pashtuns are religious groups with conflicting opinions and different leaders. But Qadem, a known Pashtun to Najafs Hazara family knows Najaf would ‘surely be killed’ if he was to remain in his homeland. It is there that the two groups, although nervous, put aside their differences and conflicting beliefs and ‘entrust’ their lives with one another for the safety of their own futures. Qadem helps Najaf seek asylum from Afghanistan and in turn this leads to him becoming a refugee.…

    • 609 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many people believe that in the 1940’s most of India’s problems involving independence was to do with divisions within India rather than British imperialism. In this essay I will be looking at both points of view and finally giving my opinion. I will be using three sources also to help me show both sides of the story. I will also be using my further knowledge to add a wider range of knowledge.…

    • 981 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Leadership in the Royal Navy

    • 5439 Words
    • 22 Pages

    The sea – and the land which surrounds it – is the natural home of the Naval Service. The Royal Navy (RN) operates on it, under it, above it or uses it to manoeuvre, ready to go ashore for a variety of government-directed purposes: from fighting wars, counter piracy, counter narcotics, exclusive economic zone protection, to providing humanitarian aid. It must be able to do this worldwide and largely self-supporting. It is both a challenging and hazardous environment, which from the outset requires both deep professional understanding and the highest qualities of leadership; it aims to be the best and must demand the most from its people. The RN develops its people through experience and training to excel. In particular it develops essential requirements of leadership and teamwork. The RN also has a set of core values and standards that are inculcated into their people. These attributes of Courage, Commitment, Discipline, Respect for Others, Integrity and Loyalty define the Service. They represent a key element of the moral contract to their people, and although only recently articulated, naval people over the generations would recognise them. Taken together, leadership, teamwork and the values and standards drive their people to achieve the exceptional. This has contributed greatly to the success of the RN in over 550 years. Leadership is a critical life…

    • 5439 Words
    • 22 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the book Edward Luce discusses the castes systems and explains the differences and conflicts of this system. Edward Luce discusses how the caste systems are separated by the “dharma” or duty.” But it is the Dharma of caste that perhaps gives us the best insight into how India’s traditional society saw itself” (pg. 105). In India like most other…

    • 480 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The government advertises a civil war, by expressing hatred towards the ethnical minorities in Afghanistan, primarily the Hazara. Pashtuns are taught to hate the Hazara because of the history and slight religious difference the two people have, despite both being Afghans. As Amir’s curiosity about Hazaras grows, he thinks, “School textbooks barely mentioned them… I found one of my mother’s old history books… people called Hazaras mice eating, flat nosed, load carrying donkeys…”(10). The corrupt and biased government has erased the Hazara nation from the school textbooks, and curriculum. Both, Pashtun books and people don’t have pleasant to things to say about the Hazara; who by some aren’t even considered to be humans. When the new government took office in 1996, many people celebrated, but the Hazaras know their fate in Afghanistan. In a letter from Hassan, he writes, “We all celebrated in 1996 when the Taliban rolled in… Hassan in the kitchen. He had a sober look in his eyes… God help the Hazaras now… two years later they massacred the Hazaras in Mazar-I – Sharif”(224). When the Taliban came into power all the Pashtuns celebrated, they had false hope of an end to their problems. The Taliban eventually become the worst thing to have happened to Afghanistan. The Taliban’s hatred for the Hazara is even more severe than the past governments of Afghanistan. They massacre innocent…

    • 1009 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    However, when it was first founded it did not adhere to these principles. In more recent times the country has made significant improvements in terms of religious and pluralism. Benedict Anderson defines the nation as, an imagined political community and imagined as both inherently limited and sovereign. According to Anderson it is imagined because he believes that “the members of even the smallest nation will never know most of their fellow-members, meet them, or even hear of them, yet in the minds of each lives the image of their communion” (Anderson, p.6). An imagined community has limitations, which categorizes people to have certain identities. As a girl who was born in India, I feel as if I am categorized as an Indian, not because where I think I belong but because of my race. Anderson strongly explains that nationalism is not associated with racism; however, it is related to the shared history and values, which identifies who we are. We may not realize this, but everything we do is nationalism, from our careers to what we decide to wear. For example, the status level between nurses and doctors. Nurses are frowned upon because their title isn’t as important as the doctors. But according to the work they do, they should be respected. So based on our career paths were characterized into certain category as well. No matter what part of the world we come, were somehow related to one another…

    • 1375 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Industrial Tycoons

    • 934 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Industrial tycoons of the nineteenth century used whatever they could to get to the top of the economy, by either contributing positively or in some cases even if it meant destroying all the other industries that got in their way. In the nineteenth century, industrial tycoons were known as either a robber baron (Jay Gould) or a Captain of Industry (Henry Ford). Depending on how someone contributed to the growth of businesses, labeled them as one or the other. Some of the contributing factors that played an effect on identifying an industrialist as a robber baron or industry captain are how they came to power of the business industry, how they used their power, and how they gave back to society. These industrial tycoons were some of the wealthiest men in the US.…

    • 934 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    It becomes a question of otherness of the people-as-one. The national subject splits in the ethnographic perspective of culture's contemporaneity and provides ... a narrative authority for marginal voices or minority discourse. 150 “From the liminal movement of the culture of the nation - at once up and held together - minority discourse emerges.” (Bhabha, ——:…

    • 506 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    This time the border is the Indo-Pakistani “geopolitical fault line,” called so because of the “deep hostility and mutual resentment between India and Pakistan.” The border was nicknamed the “Radcliffe line” for the man that was responsible for singlehandedly determining the borders of a state. While the existence of this border is not disputed, as is Transnistria’s, the position of the border is a topic of contention that has caused several wars. Titled “Peacocks at Sunset,” the article recounts a ceremony at a border crossing where both states make a show of force every night as their flags are lowered at the respective border station. If there is a more perfect representation of the function of borders, it is certainly hard to find. Again, the flag being lowered represents an entire place and its people, unifying each side of the border against the other as two distinct identities. Religion is the defining factor in this case, in lieu of the shared set of values in Transnistria’s conflict. As set forth in his introduction to the Borderlines series, this ceremony strongly reflects the “Them and Us” mentality that is pervasive in basic human…

    • 1745 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    To accept this level of human bloodshed as a norm, the grandmother has dehumanized the other side of the border as nothing more than the “enemy-state.” However, her deeply flawed idea of nationhood is bound to crumble. Before her impeding trip to the place of her birth, she becomes uncomfortable at the thought that upon boarding the airplane “she would have to fill in ‘Dhaka’ as her place of birth on that form … and at that moment she had not been able quite to understand how her place of birth had come to be so messily at odds with her nationality,” (286). While, her beliefs regarding nations and nationhood are deeply emotional and rooted in nationalistic sentiment, the fact that she is born in Dhaka causes her discomfort, because it is not an emotion or an…

    • 1663 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Bibliography: 1. Rishikeshav regmi Ph.D , Ethnicity and Identity ,2000. 2. Sambhaji - Patil, Vishwas, Mehta Publishing House, Pune, 2006. 3. Roland J. L. Breton. Atlas of the Languages and Ethnic Communities of South Asia. Sage Publications. 4. Josiah Conder, The Modern Traveller: A Popular Description, Geographical, Historical, and ... v. I, India, (1828).…

    • 3474 Words
    • 14 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    If countries can be defined by their socio-cultural make-up alone it would be a difficult task to define India and its subsequent ‘Indianness’. Given its multi-cultural set-ups, where each culture and its sub-culture is a separate world of its own, it is not only presumptuous but narrow-minded to define national identity in such a manner. It cannot be based on class distinctions either. If on one hand we have the destitute scavenging for food in dust-bins, the…

    • 1071 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Every day the world’s poorer nations are growing into economic powerhouses. The major hegemonies are influencing third world countries through globalization and neoliberalism. These economic movements are liberalizing economies through free markets, privatization, and deregulation. Each of these three pillars are positively affecting the economies directly, but are negatively affecting the social aspects of a country. A country undergoing these major changes is India. This culturally affluent nation is now also becoming a prosperous country. The problem is that India is beginning to lose its culture identity at the price of its growing wealth. The problem comes down to – at what price must a country pay to gain prosperity and recognition? Based on academic research and scholarly opinion, one can conclude that the negative effects of globalization and neoliberalism on India are outweighing the positive effects. India’s economy is growing, but its people are suffering in return.…

    • 980 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    My Son the Fanatic

    • 1034 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The main character in the story is Parvez, who’s a good example of an immigrant being well-integrated. He emigrated from Pakistan, where he was taught the Koran. He underwent indignity during this, and subsequently he avoided all religion; he even prefers jokes to rules. Even though he has a wife and a son, he spends most of his time “living a boy’s life” with his fellow taxi drivers; playing card and avoiding their wives. The narration of the story is 3rd person narrative and is therefore limited, but we see the conflict from Parvez’s point of view, which engenders surprises. “Parvez sprang across the hall and set his ear at Ali’s door. A muttering sound came from within (…) The boy was praying.”(l. 130-134)…

    • 1034 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Nation State

    • 521 Words
    • 2 Pages

    A nation-state is a state, or country, that has defined borders and territory. It is additionally a country in which a nation of principally the same type of people exists, organized by either race or cultural background. In the nation-state, generally, everyone would speak the same language, probably practice the same or similar types of religion, and share a set of cultural, “national,” values. Nowadays can be defined as a political unit based on contiguous territory, usually with a single or dominant language, shared traditions, independent of outside forces. The nation-state works as a unique configuration of territorial space and thus, constitutes a central element of modernity in the international political scheme. The key attribute of the nation-state is the concept of sovereignty. Event history analysis shows that a nation-state is more likely to emerge when a power shift allows nationalists to overthrow or absorb the established regime. Diffusion of the nation-state within an empire…

    • 521 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays