Preview

Argumentative Essay On Being Born Blind

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
527 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Argumentative Essay On Being Born Blind
Being born blind means you are unable to see anything, and since being brought into the world, you have no real concept of what anything looks like. Being born deaf means that you have never been able and will never be able to understand or comprehend any form of verbal communication (excluding reading a person's lips), which some believe can set you up poorly later in life. The debate on whether being born deaf or blind is more serious than the other, can be discussed and argued for a long time.
According to Oliver Sacks (1989), “to be born deaf is infinitely more serious than to be born blind” (p. 7). Sacks’ reasoning for stating this, is simple and explained in his book, Seeing Voices. Oliver talks about a South African poet and novelist, named David Wright. Wright was born with the ability to hear, but became deaf around the age of seven. David Wright speaks of illusionary hearing, where he feels that he can still hear his mother’s voice while she mouths words to him, even though he is deaf. Because he was born with the ability to hear, his communication skills did not suffer completely. This relates to Sacks’ reasoning, because he says that “for the prelingually deaf, unable to hear their parents” (p. 7), they are at more risk for being “severely retarded, if not permanently defective” (p. 8). He feels that this causes a loss of many
…show more content…
If you are born blind, you still have the ability to communicate and understand communication more so than if you were born deaf. This does not mean that it is better to be born blind, or that I am saying it is easier to be born blind. Communication is an integral part of life, because it is all around the world, and people who are born deaf are at a major disadvantage from day one when it comes to comprehending proper communication. At the very least, in the young stages of life, I find that being born deaf is potentially more

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Through Deaf Eyes is an insightful documentary detailing the history of both deaf culture and deaf education and describing many of the struggles which were encountered during the deaf communities fight for recognition. There were several points of interest in the film that I feel are crucial to understanding the deaf community; first, is the method used to educate deaf children. The early 19th century was a time of reform, especially in the religious community; it was believed that anyone could be saved as long you chose to believe. Many teachers of deaf students saw their role in the child (rens) life as slightly missionary. They could help save the deaf child from eternal damnation and in the process return the child to the hearing world.…

    • 219 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Finding Fish

    • 2920 Words
    • 12 Pages

    The book, finding fish, is a poignant autobiography of the life of Antwone Quenton Fisher, an African American boy who suffered a tumultuous childhood in a foster care setting. He was born on 8-3-1959 in a Cleveland prison to Eva Mae Fisher. She was incarcerated for the shooting death of his father, her boyfriend at the time, Eddie Elkins. Initially, he spent his first few weeks of his life in a Cleveland orphanage. Then he was fostered by a wonderful woman named Mrs. Nellie Strange. She lovingly cared for him for two years. One 10-11-1961 he was placed in the foster home of the Reverend and Mrs. Pickett, an African American couple who came from southern black heritage. Mr. Pickett was a kind man with a doctorate in medicine and his wife, the abuser, was the matriarch of the family. For the next eighteen years of Antwone’s life, he would suffer terrible physical, verbal and emotional abuse in this home, even though he would have a total of thirteen social workers “monitoring” his case. In the Pickett’s home, Antwone had three foster siblings; Flo, Dwight and Keith. Antwone suffers so much chronic abuse that he never feels confident enough to tell any of his social workers about his abuse. He is even sexually abused by Willenda, a babysitter who cares for the children at times. Antwone is finally kicked out of the home around his sixteenth birthday and he finds himself at George Junior Republic, a reform school for boys. Even though he isn’t a trouble maker, he loves being there because he finds teachers who really mentor him. While he lives there, he is able to take tests and graduate early from high school. Unfortunately now he has “graduated’ from the foster care system since he is eighteen and he is forced to become homeless and sell drugs for money. The best thing that ever happens to him is when he enrolls in the United States Navy. While serving an eleven year term, he develops…

    • 2920 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Answer In Unit 4222 258

    • 1950 Words
    • 7 Pages

    In sensory loss (touch/ mobility, vision, hearing) can have a big impact to an individual like for example in mobility, the person can not feed or dress himself, or can not participate in an activity and worst if he can not attend to his personal daily living. Another is eyesight or vision, the person who suffers from this disability have a very hard time communicating or even to express themselves to what they want to do and wishes without the help of other person. This case is the same with a person who is deaf or can not hear anything. And sometimes when you suffer from this disabilities, people are easily judge you in a way that they try to seclude you or belong you to have a below average intelligence and assume that you can not do or think the same as other people.…

    • 1950 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    As I read in surdam memoriam: Karl Jaekel, it showed me how society during the 1800’s throughout the 1900’s had a very negative view on Deaf people and sign language. Hard of hearing and or deaf-mute people used to be considered as a lower class. For a family to assume that a deaf child became “Deaf and dumb” by accident was not uncommon. American parents of that day were much more comfortable admitting to congenital than to adventitious deafness in their offspring. Uncle Charlie was enrolled in the Pennsylvania Institution for the Deaf and Dumb where he was enrolled in the shoemaking department, one of the three industrial programs open to boys, and the other two were tailoring and printing. They only kept records of the pupils attendance and work instead of academic enrollment and progress. The training programs saved the state of Pennsylvania a great deal of money by putting the pupils to work for the state. Etiology statistics in 1800’s stated that the deaf should be carefully advised in the defect to be transmitted from generation to generation and that the future of their offspring and their own should be prudently considered before entering upon a condition so fraught with possibilities of misfortune and happiness. (Annual Report, 1887-88). The connection between articulation and eugenics is not as transparent today but when Charlie was in school it was widely believed that Deaf people would cease to marry each other if the sign language that they could only communicate with would somehow be wiped out and they were forced to speak. The views are different now in 2011 because the science and generation has grown which has made families more aware as to why certain people are born or become deaf and it is certainly more…

    • 309 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    First, this book allowed me to see the negative way in which deaf people were perceived. This book is not old by any means, and I was taken aback by the way deaf children were perceived by not only others in the community, but often times by their own parents as well. The term “Deaf and Dumb” is one that I had never heard before, yet one that was used far too often. It is appalling to think that this was used for all deaf people, by not only a few of the more ignorant people who did not understand, but by doctors, teachers, and even the parents of deaf children. This term is offensive and just plain wrong. It is very apparent to me that deaf people are well educated and that their inability to hear has no affect on their ability to learn. Before reading this book I would have never guessed that so many people thought differently not so long ago.…

    • 923 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Redefining D.E.A.F

    • 776 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Ryan Commerson, producer and host of the movie “Media, Power & Ideology: Re-Presenting D-E-A-D”, states that all the preconceptions societies have about people being born deaf is because of “ideology”. He uses Valentin Voloshinov’s definition of the word to later explore its significance in more depth. Ideology: “The dimension of social experience in which meanings and values are produced”. Furthermore, he continues exploring the first persons that tried to describe deaf people back in the 18th century. He explains that at first these persons, like author John Conrad Amman, one of the first ones to write about speech and how deaf people could learn how to communicate, had many misinterpretations of how deaf people really is and what are they capable to. Commeron continues saying that even thou they used very degrading terms to describe deaf people they were judging them wrongly since most of deaf people grew up without any education. The fact that all these people wrote about them, Cammeron says, it brings this false ideology to our present.…

    • 776 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    An excerpt from They Say/I Say: The Moves that Matter in Academic Writing” By Gerald Graff…

    • 241 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Deaf Again

    • 1434 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The book, Deaf Again, written by Mark Drolsbaugh, is an autobiography telling his life story which starts with a young boy growing up who goes through the process of losing his hearing and then, as he gets older, he struggles with trying to fit in as a normal child. When Mark was very young, he could hear fairly well then gradually he went hard of hearing until he eventually went completely deaf. Even though he had two deaf parents, the doctors advised speech therapy and hearing aids because they did not understand Deaf Culture and they thought that Mark would be a lot happier if he could hang on to his hearing persona. Throughout the rest of the book, Mark goes through a lot of stages of trying to fit in with everyone and eventually does find himself and realizes that being Deaf is not a disease, but just a part of who he is.…

    • 1434 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Deaf Again

    • 1112 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Born hearing to deaf, signing parents, Mark gradually lost his hearing. Despite the fact that his deaf parents preferred sign communication, Mark was raised and educated without the use of sign language. His parents and grandparents were concerned that sign might interfere with speech and restrict his educational achievement. Although Mark became increasingly hard-of-hearing, he worked hard to "pass" as a hearing person. This ambition, he later discovered, actually constricted his cognitive development and limited the depth of relationships with family and friends. During these long years, he just "didn’t know what (he) was missing." When he later learned American Sign Language (ASL), chose to mix with deaf people, and learned to perceive deafness as something special, his horizons expanded. He came to value communication and relationships above the things that seemed so important to many people, such as image, income, status, skills, religious background, or race.…

    • 1112 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Nowadays, there are many things that distinguish the Hearing world from the Deaf culture. To begin with, the language is essential when communicating. The Hearing world communicates through the English language by speaking and writing to one another to get their message across. As for the Deaf culture, American Sign Language (ASL) is used. ASL can be seen as a language that is capable of expressing abstract ideas. Therefore, the Deaf culture uses not only signing, but also body movement and facial expressions to communicate effectively. The second big difference between the Hearing world and Deaf culture is the participation to their community. For the Hearing world, being involved with the community is not really important like for the Deaf…

    • 357 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Level 5 Sensory Loss

    • 1911 Words
    • 8 Pages

    A working description of deafblindness that has been accepted over many years, is that persons are regarded as deafblind if their combined sight and hearing impairment cause difficulties with communication. It can be found in all age groups including children but the greatest is in older people.…

    • 1911 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    A child may be born with a sight or hearing impairment which affects most areas of the child’s development. If a child is unable to see, they may not have had the opportunity to join in with physical activities, such as running or football, therefore they may be lacking in this area. If a child is deaf, they may not be able to communicate accurately to other people so will have little social skills.…

    • 410 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Some even had the hope of starting their own families in the future (Sutton-Spence). The new schools for the deaf and blind provided so many new chances for these children to grow, develop and feel normal. A current day study revealed that people who are hearing impaired don’t identify themselves, rather, they see themselves as people who see the world visually and use sign language (Sutton-Spence). This can also be assumed about the deaf in the 1800s. Originally there hadn’t been schools for them or ways from them to learn.…

    • 1169 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Essay On Deaf Problems

    • 559 Words
    • 3 Pages

    “The critical age for learning language is around 21 to 36 months old. During this period, much of the cognitive infrastructure in a person’s brain is developed and it is thought, much of it is developed as a result of learning language.” (Hiskey). This shows that a humans thought process is based on language, making language essential in living an interactive, full and healthy life. For hearing children learning a language is very easy since most of their parents speak the same language. However, the majority of deaf children are born into hearing families, and unless a family with a deaf child lives in a developed country where there is access to education and Deaf communities, a normal life for a deaf child may not be…

    • 559 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In this exercise, students form small groups of 3-4 members to handle one assigned topic from the followings:…

    • 312 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays